Earnings Labs

MFA Financial, Inc. (MFA)

Q4 2021 Earnings Call· Wed, Feb 23, 2022

$10.25

-0.44%

Key Takeaways · AI generated
AI summary not yet generated for this transcript. Generation in progress for older transcripts; check back soon, or browse the full transcript below.
Transcript

Operator

Operator

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for standing by, and welcome to the MFA Financial, Inc. Fourth Quarter 2021 Earnings Call. [Operator Instructions] And as a reminder, today's conference call is being recorded. I would now like to turn the conference over to Mr. Hal Schwartz. Please go ahead.

Hal Schwartz

Analyst

Thank you, operator, and good morning, everyone. The information discussed on this conference call today may contain or refer to forward-looking statements regarding MFA Financial, Inc., which reflect management's beliefs, expectations and assumptions as to MFA's future performance and operations. When used, statements that are not historical in nature, including those containing words such as will, believe, expect, anticipate, estimate, should, could, would or similar expressions are intended to identify forward-looking statements. All forward-looking statements speak only as of the date on which they are made. These types of statements are subject to various known and unknown risks, uncertainties, assumptions and other factors including those described in MFA's annual report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2020, and other reports that it may file from time to time with the Securities and Exchange Commission. These risks, uncertainties and other factors could cause MFA's actual results to differ materially from those projected, expressed or implied in any forward-looking statements it makes. For additional information regarding MFA's use of forward-looking statements, please see the relevant disclosure in the press release announcing MFA's fourth quarter 2021 financial results. Thank you for your time. I would now like to turn this call over to MFA's CEO and President, Craig Knutson.

Craig Knutson

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

Thank you, Hal. Good morning, everyone. I'd like to thank you for your interest in and welcome you to MFA Financial's Fourth Quarter 2021 Financial Results Webcast. Also with me today are Steve Yarad, our CFO; Gudmundur Kristjansson; and Bryan Wulfsohn, our Co-Chief Investment Officers and other members of senior management. The fourth quarter of 2021 was a stark wake-up call for the fixed income market. After languishing in a 15- to 25-basis-point range for nearly 18 months since late March of 2020, 2-year treasuries rose 50 basis points from the end of September to the end of December, and the curve flattened significantly as 10 years ended the quarter essentially unchanged from September 30. The first 6 weeks of 2022 have been even more volatile with 2s higher by 75 basis points, 5s by 55 and 10s by 40. The rate environment had an inevitable negative impact on our fair value assets, but MFA nevertheless, turned into a respectable fourth quarter and a very strong 2021. We added SOFR interest rate swaps in the fourth quarter and have continued to manage our duration exposure into this year. We are certainly not immune to interest rate risk. We're still waiting for that vaccine. But between our relatively short duration assets, our successful execution of $2.6 billion of securitizations last year and our nimble hedging response to dramatic rate moves more recently, we think we've weathered the storm reasonably well. That said, this is no time for complacency with inflation seemingly raging, the Fed on the move, and a very tensed geopolitical environment, making it impossible to predict interest rate movements, particularly in the short term. Away from rates, MFA's focus on residential mortgage credit serves as a terrific offset to interest rate risk as continued very strong housing trends bolster…

Steve Yarad

Analyst

Thank you, Craig. Please turn to Slide 9 for an overview of our fourth quarter 2021 financial results. MFA's results for the fourth quarter were solid overall, particularly given the challenging rate environment. We continue to see the impact of the successful execution of our asset aggregation strategy and financing initiatives with another quarter of loan portfolio and net interest income growth. In addition, a second consecutive record quarter for originations at Lima One resulted in another meaningful contribution to our overall results. Earnings of $0.08 per common share were impacted by valuation changes on loans partially offset by gains on hedges and securitized debt held at fair value as well as a significant gain on a minority investment. After removing the impact of these items from the quarterly results, the residual net income of $47.3 million or $0.08 per common share is in line with our fourth quarter dividend of $0.11 per common share. I will now provide some additional details of the key components of our Q4 results, which include net interest income of $70.1 million was $8.3 million or 13% higher sequentially. Residential whole loan net interest income again increased this quarter by 7%, again reflecting portfolio growth and the ongoing impact of securitizations, which has lowered the cost of financing. Our net interest spread came in at 2.98%, unchanged from the prior quarter. Our overall CECL allowance in our carrying value loans decreased for the seventh quarter in a row, and at December 31 was $39.5 million, down from $44.1 million at September 30 and less than half where it began the year. The decrease reflects continued runoff of our carrying value loan portfolio and adjustments to macroeconomic and loan prepayment speed assumptions used in our credit loss modeling. This reversal and other net adjustments to…

Bryan Wulfsohn

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

Thank you, Steve. Turning to Page 10. 2021 was one of the hardest years for home prices in over 2 decades. Prices increased at a year-over-year rate of almost 20%, fueled by historically low rates coupled with limited supply. In recent months, we have seen rates move higher with a 30-year conforming mortgage rate hovering around 4%. Increased mortgage rates should have a dampening effect on home prices. However, the severe lack of supply may still continue to push prices higher, albeit at a reduced rate. Labor market is strong. Unemployment is at 4%, and wages are rising at some of the fastest levels in recent history. MFA's focus on mortgage credit continues to perform well and benefit from the current economic tailwinds. Turning to Page 11. MFA was active in the fourth quarter, adding $950 million of Non-QM loans to the portfolio. We grew our base of originators over the quarter and strengthened existing relationships. We are currently in the market with securitization and although we have seen a widening in spreads, we expect to continue to be a programmatic issuer of securitizations as it is still the most efficient form of non-mark-to-market term financing. The credit on our portfolio has improved significantly from the onset of COVID in 2020. 60-plus day delinquencies are now down to 3.5%, and we have yet to suffer a credit loss on our Non-QM portfolio as a few loans taken to REO were subsequently sold for gains. Many loans that experienced delinquencies end up being paid in full as our borrowers have equity in the property to sell their properties themselves. The weighted average original LTV for borrowers that are 90-plus days delinquent to 65 and that does not account for any potential home price appreciation to post origination. Turning to Page 12.…

Gudmundur Kristjansson

Analyst · Doug Harter with Credit Suisse

Thanks, Bryan. Turning to Page 15. We closed the acquisition of Lima One on July 1, 2021, and realized an immediate impact on MFA's results in the second half of the year as Lima One originated approximately $1 billion of high-yielding business purpose loans in the second half of 2021, all of which were absorbed onto MFA's balance sheet. Fourth quarter activity was particularly robust with over $600 million originated in the fourth quarter, a 50% increase over third quarter originations and a record quarter for the company. First quarter is usually the slowest month in the BPL space, where we have maintained strong momentum into 2022 with approximately $200 million originated in January. A key benefit of the acquisition is Lima's ability to provide MFA with a reliable flow of high-quality, high-yielding assets that are difficult to source in the marketplace. When we announced the transaction in May, we mentioned that we believe that Lima has the potential to grow substantially beyond the run rate at the time of $1.2 billion in annual origination. That has played out faster than we expected as Lima originated over $1.6 billion in 2021, about 33% more than we expected at the time of acquisition. This tremendous result is in many ways due to the time and energy we spent around the deal closing to develop a clear strategic plan for the Lima One business, including short- and long-term goals for the management team as well as exceptional execution by the management team throughout the second half. We have improved financing costs and expanded financing options by adding multiple new warehouse lines and issuing securitizations. We passed some of those efficiencies on to Lima's borrowers in more competitive pricing across most of Lima's product offerings. This has allowed Lima to be more competitive…

Craig Knutson

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

Thank you, Gudmundur. We believe that we produced solid results in a difficult fourth quarter of 2021, and we're very pleased with our results and the successful execution of our strategic initiatives for the year. Our portfolio growth coupled with securitization financing, should enable us to continue to produce consistent net interest income. A thriving Lima One will continue to provide us with a means to generate high-quality assets at attractive yields. And MFA's focus on residential mortgage credit should position us well as we enter a year that will surely challenge investment strategies that are dependent solely on rates. Cynthia, would you please open up the line for questions.

Operator

Operator

[Operator Instructions] We will take our first question from the line of Bose George with KBW.

Mike Smyth

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

[Technical Difficulty]

Craig Knutson

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

Bose, we have a hard time hearing you. I don't know if it's your phone.

Mike Smyth

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

Sorry, is that better?

Craig Knutson

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

Much better.

Mike Smyth

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

This is actually Mike Smyth on for Bose. I was just wondering if you could provide some color on the volatility in the securitization markets. Have you seen some of the older inventory cleared? And how long do you think the volatility could persist for?

Craig Knutson

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

Sure. Bryan, do you want to talk about Non-QM?

Bryan Wulfsohn

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

Yes, sure. Yes. I mean we've seen significant amount of supply come to market over the past several months, and that's continued through the beginning of the year. We've seen spreads move around approximately 50 to 60 basis points at the AAA level. And really, the only thing that sort of assures that is time. We think that due to this rate move and what we've seen on the origination side of things in the Non-QM space, things have been slowing down. So if that continues sort of that supply-demand imbalance will correct itself. But that's sort of the only way we sort of see that happening is through the passage of time. There's not really a catalyst that we see that's going to snap spread back or anything like that.

Mike Smyth

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

Got you. That's helpful color. And then have you seen any changes in loan prices to reflect the wider spreads in the securitization market?

Bryan Wulfsohn

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

We've seen some movement in loan pricing, but not to the extent of spread movement that we've seen on the securitization side, and this is historically what we've seen in loan pricing whenever we see movement in spreads and securitization, it's sort of there is some move, but it's not the full extent of the move. So if you were thinking that spreads might have moved to securitization 50 to 60 basis points, it might be 20 to 25 basis points on loan pricing.

Mike Smyth

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

That's helpful color. And then just one more for me. What do incremental returns on new investments look like? And how do you view this versus potentially buying back the stock at a 10-plus percent dividend yield.

Craig Knutson

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

So I think we always look at -- we always look at the stock price. We bought back stock consistently through the year at discounts to book. I don't think it's an either or type of proposition that either we make investments or we buy back stock. We bought back 20 million shares. But at the end of the day, it's not a liquidity constrained decision. I think on the asset side, we're still looking probably worst case at high single-digit, low double-digit returns. And on business purpose loans or some of the fix and flip loans where those securitizations, even though those are again more expensive these days those are probably closer to 20% type ROE. So there is still attractive ROEs to be had. As Bryan said, we haven't seen loan prices completely adjust to current market levels. And so that probably puts a little bit of a damper on enthusiasm to purchase loans until the prices do correct to reflect securitization executions now. But I think that will certainly happen in time.

Bryan Wulfsohn

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

Yes, if you think in terms of attractive of investments and returns that we're making and 2021, it was an unusually attractive year, given the fact that rates were so low and securitization execution is so efficient. So as we now move into Q1 of 2022, I think we're seeing more of a normalization of the environment where there's a better balance between the yields taking out on the asset versus the cost of funds. So we view the current environment as continue to be attractive to execute securitization. Go forward is different what happens to rates. Here we've got to be mindful of how we manage from interest rates and so on and so forth, but we continue to find good opportunities.

Operator

Operator

Next, we will go to the line of Eric Hagen with BTIG.

Eric Hagen

Analyst

Maybe a couple for me. Can you say how much stock you've repurchased to date, what's your book value is? Number two, what would you say is the yield on newly issued Non-QM loans? Like how does it compare to the $385 million that you show for the existing portfolio?

Craig Knutson

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

Sure, Steve, do you want to take this --

Steve Yarad

Analyst

So Eric, thanks for the questions there. So we -- if you look at our press release, you could see that on Page 2, we give an update as to what the stock repurchases have been through the 18th of February. And you just -- you can read that for yourself. But we've got about $45 million left on the current authorization for stock repurchases. And we've been actively repurchasing stock so far since the end of the year. In terms of book value, for January, we've closed the books for January. Obviously, we haven't really started closing the books for February yet. We've been very pleased with the way the portfolio has held up through January. We've added swaps in January. And as a result of that and the other hedging activities that we had in place, we started in the fourth quarter. We haven't seen any meaningful decline in book value through the end of January. It's sort of flattish to just marginally down just even taking into account an accrual of the dividend, which we don't record the dividend until it's declared. So very pleased with that performance through January and into February, we've added more swaps as well to date. So I think in the press release, we talked about our duration being 1.3. Right now, it's closer to 1, given the additional hedging that we've done.

Craig Knutson

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

Bryan, do you want to talk about yield levels on Non-QM?

Bryan Wulfsohn

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

Yes, sure. On new investments today, I would say the yields are somewhere in the order of plus or minus 4%, where you can -- after this rate move.

Eric Hagen

Analyst

Got it. And then within the rehab portfolio, can you say how many loans make up that portfolio? And then should we expect the unfunded commitments, I think it's like $285 million to be had over the course of the year? Or is the timeline something -- can you just describe the timeline for those unfunded commitments?

Bryan Wulfsohn

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

Yes. So let me -- I'll deal with the unfunded commitments first. I mean, on average, fix and flip loans are outstanding anywhere from 6 to 12 months and probably the average life, the payout for our loans tends to be around 10 to 11 months. So as you think about that, usually, like this is -- like if you just focus on a single loan, and it's drawn down over time. So it probably would take it until 9 to 10 months to be fully drawn, then it's marketed and sold in underlying property, I think that's the right way to think about that, the undrawn commitment amount to be drawn down over the course of anywhere from 9 to 10 months. In terms of the number of loans, I do not have that in front of me, but the average loan size is in the context of think about $300,000, something like that. And so if you use that as a proxy, you can get to the loan count. We can also follow up with you, if that's important to you.

Operator

Operator

Our next question comes from the line of Doug Harter with Credit Suisse.

Joshua Bolton

Analyst · Doug Harter with Credit Suisse

This is Josh Bolton on for Doug. Curious, just your kind of high-level thoughts around aggregation risk as you're putting -- getting these loans in the door and then planning on securitizing. Just how much -- how much risk is there? How long does it take in the different buckets to get the size to securitize? And how do you manage through that risk of holding those loans until the pricing of a deal can happen?

Craig Knutson

Analyst · Doug Harter with Credit Suisse

Sure. So thanks for the question. I think it varies by product. So Non-QM is probably the largest size or most prolific. And until the fourth quarter of last year, managing that accumulation period was not really all that difficult because interest rates and spreads didn't really change very much. I think you can see what we did hedging the portfolio in the fourth quarter. And then as Steve said, into January and February, and look at our book value, which Steve basically said, was flat in January. So I think we are managing that risk. And the securitization market, as Bryan said, was a little bit crowded at the end of the year. So we're -- and Bryan did mention before, we're out with the securitization. So we're not waiting to securitize to wait for spreads to come back in. It still makes sense to do. Is it as attractive as it was early last year? No. But in all honesty, every time we sold AAA bonds at less than a 1% yield, we pinched ourselves to make sure that we were awake. So I mean we recognize it for what it was. It was a great opportunity last year. But that's probably not the norm going forward.

Gudmundur Kristjansson

Analyst · Doug Harter with Credit Suisse

Well, as Steve pointed out earlier, I mean we -- coming at the end of last year and into Q1, we have significantly increased interest rate hedges because rates have become more volatile, then the outlook for rate is more uncertain. So we are mindful of that gap between acquisition and securitization. And we expect to continue to hedge that efficiently. And Bryan had alluded to before in terms of the agency investor deals to utilize TBA shorts because those price more closer to agency products versus rates in general. And so that's an important mix of how we manage that. But we are in the market with deals every single quarter, and it's part of our business model to execute those.

Operator

Operator

[Operator Instructions] And allowing a few moments, I'm showing no further questions in queue.

Craig Knutson

Analyst · Bose George with KBW

Okay. Well, we want to thank everyone for your interest in MFA Financial. And we look forward to our next update when we announce first quarter results in May.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, that does conclude your conference call for today. Thank you for your participation and for using AT&T Executive Teleconference Service. You may now disconnect.