Albert L. Lord
Analyst · Mahmood Reza from Omega Advisers
Thanks, Jon. Good morning, everyone. Jon's given you a pretty complete financial picture, and I just want to give you a little bit of my take on what's going on. Obviously, quarterly numbers tell us about our recent past. Today also, I think, most of us are looking at quarterly results to try to get a sense of what that means for the future. But look, this was an okay quarter. It's $0.58 with some debt repurchases and a higher provision and a few other moving parts, not a bad quarter. Before I get too far into this, just let me say that we, of course, remain okay with our $2.15 projection for this year and $2.30 for next year, notwithstanding whatever else I may say. I think it's important to know that notwithstanding the variability in our quarter-to-quarter numbers, that the company is growing and it's growing its earnings per share. The largest variable, of course, is the provision and, of course, it's variable because we're in a variable economy, with agonizingly slow employment growth. On the positive side, I'm very happy with our volume. We're up another 25% this year, and we're up with the same, if not better, credit quality. This is the third consecutive year of growth. Maybe, 3 years makes a trend. And I'm going to talk to you about the fourth year, which also, we expect will grow pretty significantly. And so instead of starting with the 3, we expect next year's originations to start with a 4. Let me also just say that, that is actually very good news. Sallie Mae has a modestly growing private credit business that's earning more each quarter. It's got a tall task to do because it's trying to outrun -- wind revenues from our wind down FFELP business. But not so far behind the scenes is a very nice growing private credit business. I'm very satisfied with the productivity gains that I think we sometimes fail to recognize. Our operating expenses are at a 10-year -- roughly at 10-year-ago levels. We're under $1 billion, as you know. But behind the scenes, this company is processing more than double the volume that it processed 10 years ago with its -- under the direct loan contract and a variety of other businesses that we're doing. Our productivity will continue to improve. Otherwise, we'll lose margins. And so we will continue to push on productivity. I can't confess to being particularly happy about the recent or maybe even the near-term credit picture. Our numbers, as you can tell, have shown some backups on the delinquency and charge-off fronts. Jon talked to you about our forbearance policies. We squeezed harder on our forbearance policies, going from -- we're down nearly 30% from a year ago. We think that's appropriate, but it caused us some pain. It's also may be worth looking at a little -- slightly larger picture. We've actually taken -- in the last 4 years, we've taken our forbearance rate in certainly the worse market than any of us can remember. We've taken it down from some 16% to 3.2%. That's quite a move. But there are other reasons for the backup in our delinquencies. And the fact is the economy remains very slow. We hear, whether it's in the debates or elsewhere, that it's a tough job market for graduates. It's a tough economy, and some of the slowdown is real. It's certainly real versus just 6 months ago in the second -- first and second quarters when we were showing very dramatic improvement. While it's a tough market for graduates, it's an intolerable market and much, much tougher for non-college graduates. Our overall credit picture, as Jon said, continues to improve. And we're hoping that the near-term increase in our delinquency and charge-off statistics goes away. And we very much expect that it will. But this quarter and next quarter are going to show larger numbers in charge-off statistics. 2013 will be better than 2012. And let me just reiterate that notwithstanding the current economic trajectory, it does not put our 2013 estimates at risk. I understand and have heard from some of my colleagues that there's been some skepticism, I guess, as we reported our earnings about our commitment to share repurchase. Let me just try to discuss it a little more fully than normal. You should know that management believes its responsibility is to buy the stock when it's trading at significant discounts to its intrinsic value. Now when we talk about intrinsic value around here, and there are any number of ways to do this, but I'll just look at what's pure liquidation value and we're trading at 30% below that number. That doesn't -- and that doesn't allocate any value for our private credit franchise or our fee franchise. Obviously, when one buys stock, you benefit earnings per share. That's the immediate benefit, and it's worth something. In this marketplace, I believe the more significant value is that it increases the intrinsic value per share. I've talked in recent conversations about a low 20s number. I would say that number is now mid-20s. And that's mid-20s after the company has distributed over $3 in cash over the last 18 months. Share repurchases and dividends, I believe, will total something in excess of $1 billion in the year 2012. That actually is either equal to or roughly equal to our earnings for the year. It's also important to understand and I -- and maybe, we didn't make this -- or maybe, I've not made it as clear as I should. The company has committed to distributing its capital in excess of its conservative guidelines, in share repurchase and dividends, so long, again, as they're above our capital guidelines. Sallie Mae, over the last several years, has been building its reserves and its capital. It intends to continue to have strong reserves and capital. Right now, we're managing to something like a 13-plus percentage capital level for our risk assets. We have a strong and strengthening balance sheet. As I say, we intend to maintain that. We sometimes think here that the rating agencies have given up on us, but we've not given up on them. We intend to get our rating back. You'll also notice, if you're to do the calculations, that we ended the third quarter right about on the nose with our capital levels that we -- that -- and we're scraping close to our minimum capital levels. The fact is that I think we've got some $160 million or $170 million of share repurchase authority left. It's likely we'll use that in Q4. And then, we'll look at valuations as we move into the future. This is an exercise that the management and the board are involved in and watch very closely. There's no question that our philosophy is that excess capital -- all capitals to shareholders, but excess capital is the shareholders on a much more immediate basis. With that monologue, I will take questions. Thanks.