Talya Nevo-Hacohen
Analyst · Scotiabank. Your line is open
Thank you, Rick. In the fourth quarter of 2020, our senior housing managed portfolio continue to experience occupancy pressures as a result of the pandemic and the surge that followed the Thanksgiving and Christmas holiday season. While government funding provided some mitigation from the financial pressures adoption of the vaccine is the linchpin to getting the senior housing industry on the road to recovery. All our operators have been intent on implementing vaccine clinics at their buildings, educating and incentivizing both residents and staff to maximize participation and using their clinics and documented safety record to demonstrate the potential residents with the fastest path to a normal lifestyle as to move into a senior housing community. CMS data compiled by Nick shows that COVID cases in skilled nursing closely tracked cases in the general population from June 2020 until the launch of the Pfizer and then the Moderna vaccine in December 2020. In January 2021, this changed dramatically. Cases in skilled nursing began to decline just as cases in the U.S. spiked from the post holiday surge. By early February, new cases in skilled nursing fell by 83% and cases in the general population fell 47% compared to late December when the Pfizer vaccine was launched. After the launch of the vaccines, deaths in skilled nursing began to decline and have continued to do so dramatically while deaths in the general population spiked and have plateaued since. With skilled nursing as a leading indicator of the impact of the vaccine and congregate living, we have reason to be optimistic. As of the end of the fourth quarter of 2020, approximately 14% of Sabra's annual cash net operating income was generated by our senior housing managed portfolio, approximately 49% of that relates to the communities that are managed by Enlivant and 37% relates to our holiday managed communities. The balance includes our Canadian portfolio and five assisted living and memory care communities in the U.S. To start I will provide highlights of the operating results of the managed portfolio, which includes both the wholly-owned portfolio and Sabra's share of the unconsolidated joint venture on a same-store sequential quarter basis to illustrate the trends in the industry. These results will exclude two recent acquisitions and one transition community and our wholly owned portfolio consistent with a presentation and the supplemental information package. Occupancy declined 280 basis points to 76.4% in the fourth quarter of 2020 in line with the 270 basis point decline experienced in the third quarter over the prior quarter. Revenue per occupied room, REVPOR, excluding government grants received rose 1.6% this quarter compared with an increase of 1.7% in the previous quarter. Revenues decreased 5.8% in the fourth quarter of 2020, compared to the third quarter, inclusive of $1.1 million and $4 million respectively of government funds received by eligible assisted living facilities. If we exclude the grant revenue then same-store revenue declined 1.9%. Cash net operating income for the quarter decreased sequentially by 24.9% to $14.8 million from $19.7 million. Excluding the government grants cash net operating income would have declined by 12.5% on a sequential basis. Cash NOI margin decreased to 21.3% from 26.8% in the preceding quarter, excluding government grants cash NOI margin would have been 20.1% in the fourth quarter and 22.5% in the preceding quarter. In the fourth quarter, we saw the same occupancy and rate dynamic as we saw in the third quarter, rising rates and continued decline in occupancy resulting in a decline in revenue and in business with high operating leverage government funds received by eligible operators have had a disproportionate impact on cash net operating income depending on the amount and the timing of receipt. The Enlivant joint venture portfolio of which Sabra owned 49% had a challenging fourth quarter as a result of lower occupancy and operating revenue that was only slightly offset by the receipt of approximately $484,000 in government grants. Average occupancy for the quarter was 71.6% reflecting a 4.2% decline on a same store sequential quarter basis, and a 10.6% decline on a same store basis compared with the fourth quarter of 2019. REVPOR excluding government funding was 4,576 compared with 4,411 or 3.8% higher on a same store sequential basis, and 3.6% higher on a same store basis compared with the fourth quarter of 2019. Revenue was 8.6% lower on a same store sequential quarter basis and 8.5% lower on a same store basis compared with the fourth quarter of 2019. Excluding government funds, revenue decreased by 1.9% on a same store sequential basis and 9.8% on a same store basis compared to the fourth quarter of 2019. Same store cash net operating income was $5.2 million, a 43% decrease on a sequential quarter basis driven by lower government funds in the fourth quarter. Without those funds, same store cash NOI would have declined 22.3%. Subsequent to the end of the quarter, January 2021 occupancy was 68.9%, 140 basis points lower than December 2020 occupancy. Since the pandemic began nearly all of our Enlivant Joint Venture communities have had a resident or staff member test positive for COVID-19. By late February, only 10 communities had a resident or staff member with a positive test compared with 35 at the end of January, it's a 70% decline. All the communities in the joint venture have completed their first vaccine clinic and 50% have had their second clinic. Data so far shows that 94% of residents and 64% of staff received the vaccine in significantly higher rate than industry average. January 2021 saw a rise in move-ins compared to the prior month, while move-outs remained at a reduced level similar to move-out before the holiday surge. The gap between move-in and move-out started to narrow in January and that momentum has continued into this month. The fourth quarter operating results for Sabra's wholly owned Enlivant portfolio of 11 communities had similar themes in its performance. Fourth quarter occupancy was 77%, a 4.2% decline compared to the prior quarter and a 12.5% decline compared with the fourth quarter of 2019. REVPOR in the fourth quarter excluding government funding of $549,000 was $6,029, 4.7% higher than the prior quarter, and 3.8% higher compared with the fourth quarter of 2019. Revenue was 3.3% lower on a sequential quarter basis and 5.1% lower compared with the fourth quarter of 2019. Excluding government funds, revenue was nearly flat on a sequential quarter basis and 10.7% lower compared with the fourth quarter of 2019. Cash net operating income was $1.9 million; a 32.2% decrease on a sequential quarter basis helps slightly by the government grants. Without those funds, same store cash NOI would have decreased 32.6% for the same period. More recently, January occupancy was 68.4%, 510 basis points below the prior month, while only two of our wholly-owned Enlivant communities currently have a resident or staff member who was positive for COVID-19 that's down from 6 at the end of January, all 11 communities were touched by COVID during a post holiday surge. The combination of an increase in resident deaths and move-in restrictions resulting from the surge had an outsized impact on occupancy. Enlivant also incurred higher costs associated with the surge, including labor costs as well as increased PPE needs. By mid-February all these communities have their first vaccine clinic and have had already completed their second clinic with 94% of residents and 64% of employees receiving vaccine. While it will take time to rebuild occupancy back to the pre pandemic levels of 90 plus percent. In January, we saw a reduction of about 25% in move out in tandem with an increase in move-ins of about 150% compared with the prior month. This momentum along with vaccine clinics, driving a rapid reduction in infection lays the groundwork for occupancy to rebuild. Holiday retirement operates 22 independent living communities for Sabra, one of which was transitioned to holiday in the fourth quarter of 2019. Note that these properties were not eligible to receive government support distributed to assisted living providers. All the following operating results are presented on a same-store basis and excludes the transition property. Holiday portfolio occupancy was 80.8% in the quarter, 1.7% lower on a sequential basis and 7% lower compared with the fourth quarter of 2019. REVPOR with $2,518 flat to the prior quarter, and 1.3% higher compared with fourth quarter 2019. Revenue declined 2.2% compared to the prior quarter and 6.9% compared with the fourth quarter of 2019 and cash net operating income was $6.1 million, a 3.4% increase on a sequential basis, and 10.1% decline compared with fourth quarter of 2019. Subsequent to the end of the quarter, excluding the one transition community, January occupancy was 79.8% compared to 80.7% in December 2020, a 90 basis point decline. Over the last year, all 22 properties that Holiday manages for Sabra have had a resident staff member or private home health aid test positive for COVID-19. As of mid-February, 17 communities have recovered and are in various stages of lifting restrictions, such as dining or reduced capacity, limited visitors and reopening of the beauty salon. Independent living communities were not eligible for government aid and prioritized on premises, vaccine clinics in order to continue to keep its residents safe, Holiday is needed to be creative in organizing and negotiating vaccination strategies. Holiday currently has 13 of our communities with confirmed vaccination partners. Five of those communities have already held five initial clinics for residents and associates with 78% and 37% vaccinated respectively. In the fourth quarter of 2020 Holiday saw a rebound in sales activity with leads, move-in and move-outs tracking between 95% and 99% of the fourth quarter of 2019. We are now seeing a gap between move-outs and move-ins narrow significantly on the heels of vaccine distribution, reflecting the same trend that we spoke about an Enlivant. Sienna Senior Living manages eight retirement homes in Ontario and British Columbia for Sabra. In the fourth quarter, the Sienna portfolio had 79.5% occupancy flat on a sequential basis, and 8.8% lower compared with the fourth quarter of 2019. REVPOR was $2,488, 2.5% lower than the prior quarter and 2.2% lower compared with fourth quarter 2019. Fourth quarter revenue was $4.5 million, 2.5% lower than the prior quarter and 11.9% lower compared with fourth quarter 2019 driven by occupancy declines. In the fourth quarter, cash net operating income was just over $1 million, a 1.3% decline on a sequential basis and a 44% decline compared with fourth quarter 2019. More recently January occupancy was 78.5%, a 30 basis point decline compared with the prior month. Only one of our retirement homes have had a confirmed case of COVID-19, and while Canada experience a surge in COVID cases after Canadian Thanksgiving in October, the impact on our portfolio has remained minimal. Both British Columbia and Ontario are in the early stages of rolling out vaccine clinics to retirement homes after having prioritized – I'm sorry, after prioritizing long-term care residents and staff. It is not yet clear when retirement homes will be receiving vaccines, although at least one of our Sienna homes in Ontario has already had 80% of staff vaccinated. Leads have ramped up to nearly double what they were on the fall, even without the catalyst of vaccine distribution move-in are increasing to match move-out, which remain driven by death and the need for higher level of care. We have noted in prior quarters that senior housing rates appear in elastic. Our operators have consistently maintained rates because the perspective resident's decision to move in has being driven by qualitative, rather than quantitative factors. They're seeking a change in lifestyle, whether out of need or desire. While we speak about pent-up demand and higher lead volumes, the fact is that converting leads to move-in is more challenging when potential residents are concerned about the lifestyle that they will have when they move-in. Between February 2020 and January 2021, our Senior Housing Managed portfolio, inclusive of non-stabilized assets lost 10.1 percentage points in occupancy. Occupancy remains the largest variable driving operating results of our Senior Housing Managed portfolio. But what our results in the fourth quarter 0.2 is that the Holiday surgeon COVID cases has not had a uniform effect on our managed portfolio. The largest occupancy declines were in assisted living, particularly in December 2020 and January 2021. Lower move-in rates during the holidays and higher death rates among more vulnerable residents drove that outcome. COVID infections that surged in the general community impacted our assisted living communities and the people who work there resulting in increased labor, PPE and related costs particularly in those months. While our assisted living operators did receive some government support, it was significantly lower in the fourth quarter and didn't offset the simultaneous higher costs and lower revenue experienced in December 2020. Cash net operating income margins, which are lower in assistance versus independent living, were even further compressed. The first step in reversing this trend is to maximize vaccinations, which is underway. Both our portfolio as well as broader statistics indicate that residents are eager adopters, a skilled nursing is a reasonable precedent we have visibility on stemming occupancy losses. COVID cases should decline within a month following the vaccine clinics and in fact, we have shared that we're seeing a steep decline in cases. With fewer cases, we'll come fewer move-outs. Again, something we had discussed, which will begin the return to pre-pandemic levels and extend length of stay. Achieving high vaccine adoption rates among staff will help reduce labor costs, which spiked during an outbreak. These along with normalized PPE expenditures will help stabilize expenses and support net operating income. Rebuilding occupancy will take more time. It requires converting leads to leases and convincing potential residents of the value that senior housing brings to their life. A vaccinated population will allow for fewer and fewer restrictions within the community, which will allow residents to gradually resume the lifestyle that brought them to independent or assisted living in the first place. Operators will now have evidence to show that living in their community is not only enjoyable, but also safer whether it is in the face of a pandemic or a natural disaster. I will now turn over the call to Harold Andrews, Sabra's Chief Financial Officer.