Jon Bortz
Analyst · Barclays. Please go ahead
Thanks, Ray. The third quarter exhibited the same positive underlying trends as the second quarter, but with a lot of noise perhaps obscuring those trends due to holiday calendar shifts and hurricane impacts this year and year-over-year. Demand trends from business travel both group and transient and leisure travel, including international inbound travel remained healthy and stable in the quarter. And I'll be spending a little more time this morning trying to put all of the industry statistics in perspective in order to help everyone understand the positive trends. On the supply side, over the last 15 to 21 months now, we've seen a flattening of not only net deliveries, which seem to be running pretty consistently in the 2% range, but industry wide construction starts, which importantly have now been running slightly below deliveries for the last year or so. With construction starts slowing, the industry is in the process of topping out its rate of supply growth. With development costs continuing to increase at rates 2 to 5 times the rate of inflation depending on the market and construction financing terms becoming increasingly restrictive and demanding and with interest rates climbing, we're very encouraged that the rate of growth and supply is topping out at a level below this year's accelerated rate of demand growth. This means industry occupancy should grow this year by another 50 basis points or so, on top of already record occupancy levels overall. Supply growth in various urban markets will continue to be a challenge through next year, particularly with deliveries stretching out due to even longer construction delays. So what happened to demand growth and RevPAR growth in the third quarter. As we and others have been indicating all year, the third quarter was expected to and did suffer from both negative holiday shifts, including in both July and particularly in September due to the demand that was enhanced following the two hurricanes that made direct hits in Houston in late August and Southwest Florida in early September. If we look at industry numbers on a year-over-year basis for September, without Texas and Florida in an effort to isolate as much as possible the impact of the post hurricanes demand growth to September's RevPAR growth rate last year, we see that demand was 127 basis points higher and RevPAR was 141 basis points higher. So we're moving those two states leaves us industry demand growth of 1.1% this year instead of minus 0.1% as reported and industry RevPAR growth of 1.1% instead of the reported minus 0.3% for September. But there were also significant negative impact from the shift of holidays in the third quarter that impacted the industry numbers. First, July 4th moved from a Tuesday last year to a Wednesday this year, smack in the middle of the week and the worst possible day for both leisure travel and business travel. That week saw RevPAR decline by 2% on a year-over-year basis, negatively impacting July's RevPAR growth rate this year. But the shift in the Jewish holidays also was a significant negative this year. While both of the high holidays remained in September Yom Kippur moved from a Friday-Saturday to a Tuesday-Wednesday. These shifts were certainly a big negative for September's performance. Though the numbers are bit harder to isolate overall given the multi-week shift. Nevertheless you can see the impact in September on business travel as businesses have become sensitive to scheduling meetings during the Jewish holidays. Industry wide weekday demand declined 0.4% as compared to an increase of 1.7% for weekend demand. If we use August as a reasonable proxy for the ongoing trends in the quarter even though it’s not a big business travel month, nevertheless when we look at the year-over-year comparison for a month in the quarter that was not impacted by either hurricanes or holiday shifts, we see that overall demand grew a strong 3.2% in the month and weekday industry demand grew 2.8%. So we see the clear presence of healthy business travel. These favorable trends, particularly with business travel have been benefiting the urban markets. At the beginning of the year we were forecasting urban RevPAR growth to run between 150 and 200 basis points lower for the year, primarily due to substantially higher supply growth in the urban markets. In Q2 with industry RevPAR growth of 4%, RevPAR for the star defined urban markets grew 3.9% or just 10 basis points below the industry’s performance. In the third quarter the urban markets grew RevPAR 2.4%, better than the 1.7% for the industry, which to be fair was probably impacted more so by the difficult post hurricanes comparison than were the urban markets. We have to go back to the first quarter of 2017 to find a quarter where urban outperformed the overall industry’s performance. And we have to go all the way back to the third quarter of 2014 before that quarter. We wouldn’t be surprised to see the urban markets outperform the industry on a go forward basis or at the very least perform in line with the industry given the ongoing strength of business travel, both group and transient and the strong economic trends and forecasts. The urban markets have also been benefiting from an improvement in overseas international inbound, which according to Tourism Economics has risen 2.4% year-to-date through August. Thought the growth rate has weakened as the year has progressed. These numbers are consistent with the Department of Commerce in down travel data that is once again being published albeit several months behind Tourism Economics. These numbers are also seem consistent with what the brands have been communicating. As it relates to demand at our hotels we continue to see increases in short-term group bookings, as well as short-term pickup in our corporate transient business. In the quarter, for the year group bookings were up 23.3% in room nights, with ADR flat. So group revenues booked in the quarter for the year were up 23.3%. In addition for the third quarter in a row we’re seeing improvement in group bookings a little further out. In the third quarter, group revenues booked in the quarter for 2019 were 8.1% higher than group bookings a year ago for 2018. While we booked 1.4% fewer room nights for 2019 in the quarter, we did it at rates that were 9.6% higher. This of course is very positive and with very strong growth in our group pace for 2019 at this time, it is clearly an important indicator for our potential performance for next year. In the third quarter we continue to see better attendance from groups, both in-house and convention related groups and less attrition and fewer no shows, and more spend per group customer. We saw no change in corporate travel policies or behavior in the third quarter or for that matter in October. So we continue to see healthy business travel that correlates with the strong economic trends. As Ray said earlier, our overall operating performance was better than we forecasted, led by our hotels in San Francisco. But in addition to San Francisco Minneapolis, Philadelphia, Boston and Buckhead performed better than expected. As a market San Diego also performed better than expected in the quarter, but our properties didn't participate, given the Marriott reorganization and Embassy renovation impacts previously discussed. Weaker than expected markets in the third quarter included Portland, Washington DC, Nashville and West LA. I'd like to move on to an update on the performance of our recently redeveloped hotels. We're very pleased with the way our three transformative redevelopments, from 2017 are performing so far this year. In the first half, EBITDA on a combined basis from Palomar Beverly Hills, Revere Boston Common and Zoe Fisherman's Wharf grew by $5.5 million. As a result, you'll recall the increased our growth forecast for the year for the second time this year for these three properties from $6.5 million of EBITDA in 2018 to $7.5 million. In the third quarter, these transformed properties grew EBITDA by another $2.8 million, which again was a greater increase than we were forecasting. Given year-to-date EBITDA growth of $8.3 million, we now expect EBITDA growth to total $8.5 million for the full year. Let's spend a few minutes talking about 2019, before discussing the remainder of 2018. As we've mentioned previously 2019 is setting up to be a very good year for both the industry and more importantly for Pebblebrook. As has been discussed at length both by us and many others, San Francisco, which represents roughly 25% of our forecasted portfolio wide EBITDA for 2018, currently has a spectacular convention calendar next year following the completion of the renovation and expansion of the Moscone Convention Center, which we're told continues to be on track for completion before the end of this year. Convention room nights on the books for the city for next year were up by 74% as of September. With a number of days with compression as represented by days with 5,000 or more rooms on the books, increasing a whopping 131% going from 39 days in 2018 to 90 days in 2019, which is an improvement of two more days of compression, since we reported last quarter. These are obviously huge increases and are consistent with both our booking phase for 2019 as well as our increasingly confident expectations for at least a high single-digit increase in RevPAR in San Francisco for 2019. In addition to the strength in San Francisco, we’ll have easy comparisons with our legacy Starwood managed hotels and our Kimpton Hotels due to the significant negative impact in 2018 from the integrations and reorganizations, as well as from the significant growth we expect at LaPlaya due to easy comparisons and the benefit from the comprehensive property wide renovations we've undertaken in the last two years. We also have a significant number of properties that we've completely transformed that will continue to ramp up in 2019 towards stabilization, including the eight properties in the last two years. At the same time, economic growth is generally forecasted to continue at a healthy level in 2019. Coming off what is likely to be record corporate profit growth in 2017 and 2018, which should drive further growth in business travel and leisure travel. When we look at our pace for 2019, we're particularly encouraged. Group revenues for 2019 are up a robust 22.3% over same time last year for 2018. Group room nights are up by 15.4% and for what is a very positive sign for 2019. Group ADR is currently up 6%. And we currently have 41% of the number of group room nights on the books as compared to our forecast for where we'll end up for 2018. Our pace is also very positive for transient. Room nights for 2019 are up 1.5% transient ADR is ahead by 10.8% and total transient revenue is 12.5% over same time last year for 2018. So 2019 is shaping up so far as a very good year. For the remainder of 2018, meaning the fourth quarter, while our outlook for Pebblebrook same property RevPAR growth is negative. We have a significant amount of disruption from both renovations as well as other onetime events. As Ray mentioned, we commenced a guestroom and guest bathroom renovation at Sir Francis Drake in early September and a more extensive rooms renovation at both Hotel Zelos in San Francisco, as well as Mondrian LA, both of which commenced in October. A complete rooms renovation at W Boston will also commence before the end of November. These renovations will have a substantial impact on our performance in the fourth quarter. We estimate that total negative impact to RevPAR from these renovations alone to equal roughly 320 basis points in the quarter, with most of it at the two properties in San Francisco. We also continue to anticipate a negative impact from the Marriott Starwood and IHG Kimpton integrations. In addition, the major union in two of our Starwood managed legacy hotels is currently striking Marriott, while those contracts are being negotiated. And those two hotels are being negatively impacted as a result. We're forecasting the integrations and the strikes in the fourth quarter will have a combined impact of 100 basis points on our RevPAR growth. So we're forecasting RevPAR to decline between 1.5% and 3.5%, with 420 basis points of total impact in the fourth quarter. Finally, I'd like to make a few comments about the status of our efforts to strategically combine with LaSalle Hotel Properties. As you know, in September, we were pleased to report that we executed a merger agreement with LaSalle, and we continue to be very excited about the value we expect to be able to create over the long-term by putting these two companies together. This combination will create the largest owner of high-quality independent and collection branded hotels in the United States. Since that time, we've been working thoughtfully and expeditiously and cooperatively to integrate the two companies and make the major initial decisions necessary to put the company in the best financial and operating conditions to outperform in 2019 and beyond. In the eight weeks since we executed the merger agreement, we've toured every property in the portfolio and met with every property team. We've reviewed all recent, current and planned renovations and we've identified the hotels we plan to offer for sale in order to reposition the portfolio, including hotels that we've already put on the market through investment brokers or those that we've already entered into contract negotiations to sell. We're pleased to report we also now have one additional property under a separate hard money contract for $38.75 million that is planned to close concurrently with the merger closing. Currently we have hotels representing over $750 million of value on the market listed with brokers, who are actively marketing these properties. As you can see, we're moving rapidly and we're making very good progress. So far we're extremely encouraged by the very positive market reception to the LaSalle properties that we’ve put on the market for sale. The buyer market for these types of hotels remains relatively deep and robust. Based on our thorough review of the portfolio, we now expect to sell between $750 million and $1.25 billion of properties in total, with the vast majority of these sales over the next six to nine months. Proceeds from these sales would initially be used to reduce debt to quickly achieve our long-term leverage targets. And then utilize additional proceeds for either further reductions in debt, repurchasing our stock, calling preferred shares or additional acquisitions, all depending on market conditions and possible public private market arbitrage opportunities. Finally, I thought it would be worthwhile to provide a little bit of color on what we think a portfolio will look like following our planned dispositions. The criteria that we're using to determine what we are or will be offering for sale include factors such as the size of the property, either too big or too small, the uniqueness of the hotel or its potential to be unique, our intermediate to long-term view on our market, anticipated necessary capital investment and the expected return on that capital, and whether a hotel is branded or independent. Of course, we've been using the same criteria since Pebblebrook was created. At the end of the day, following our current targeted sales, we think our repositioned portfolio will look a lot like our portfolio today with a few exceptions. So of course it will be substantially larger. We expect to continue to have terrific individual property diversification. We also expect the portfolio to have a similar West Coast bias. At closing, based on our estimates of 2018 EBITDA and following the sale of the four hotels with hard-money contracts, we expect the West Coast to continue to represent our highest concentration at roughly 54%. Following the disposition of the properties we've now targeted for sale, we expect our West Coast EBITDA to represent between 60% and 65% of our portfolio wide EBITDA, based on our current 2019 estimates. San Francisco, which is our highest rated market with the best long-term supply demand fundamentals will remain the single market with our highest concentration. Following the sale of our targeted dispositions, we expect San Francisco to represent between 23% and 25% of our portfolio wide EBITDA based on our rough 2019 estimates. The one major difference between our current portfolio and the repositioned portfolio following the merger and the targeted asset sales is we expect our resort concentration to represent roughly 20% of our EBITDA, which is substantially higher than today. Given the very high quality nature of this portfolio and the market diversification of these assets, we're extremely pleased with this exception or difference between our current and future portfolio. As a result of our efforts so far, we've also identified numerous opportunities within the portfolio to add value, including experientially driven or design driven redevelopments and renovations. Overall, following and tours and reviews, we believe there is more long-term opportunity and value in the portfolio than we thought when we entered into the merger agreement. We're also very excited about the cross implementation of best practices from both companies as well as portfolio wide initiatives to take advantage of our combined size to lower cost and increase efficiencies. We've also finalized all the necessary decisions related to organizational structure, responsibilities and people, including making offers to the vast majority of the team at LaSalle. All of our offers have been accepted and everyone is very excited about joining the Pebblebrook family. We also continue to feel comfortable with the range of $18 million to $20 million of annual corporate G&A synergies related to the combined company, recognizing that an estimated $10 million of Proposition 13 related property tax increases will offset some of those savings. And finally and importantly, LaSalle’s portfolio is performing at least in line with if not better than the underwriting for 2018 we've been utilizing since the beginning of the year. So overall, so far so good. We’d now be happy to answer any questions that you might have. Operator, Donna, you may proceed.