Michael Lucareli
Analyst · JPMorgan
Thanks, Tom, and good morning to everybody. I’m going to apologize in advance if I have to cough during my presentation. I’m coming off of a cold and I have all my water and everything lined up, but I seem to periodically have a coughing attack, so I apologize in advance.
Turning to Slide 9, I will walk through the year-over-year income statement comparison. As Tom mentioned, fourth quarter sales decreased 8 million or 2%. Excluding the impact of foreign currency, sales increased 900,000 or 0.2%. All 4 of our vehicular segments experienced flat to down revenues due to several macro themes. First, we are seeing weakness in most markets outside of North America and lower foreign exchange rates are converting our non-U.S. sales to fewer dollars. In fact, nearly 60% of our sales are outside of the U.S. In addition, the wind-down of certain automotive programs is impacting our year-over-year comparables.
On a brighter note, revenue in our commercial product segment was up 9%. Gross margin improved 160 basis points to 16.8%. This was driven primarily by our operations in North America and Europe. The combined improvement in gross margin and lower SG&A resulted in stronger operating income, which improved by $10.6 million or 136%. Please note that during both periods, Modine received a tax credit. During the most recent quarter, we received a $4.4 million tax credit in Hungary. A year ago, a similar tax credit was $3.4 million higher for $7.8 million in total. Excluding these incentives, our effective tax rate would have been in the range of 24% to 28% for the comparative fourth quarter.
Overall, we are very pleased with the operating performance despite the market challenges, and I need to point out that during the quarter we discovered that we had not been properly applying value-added tax, or VAT, on certain complex cross-border transactions in Europe over the past several years. This discovery has resulted in our recognizing an estimated cumulative liability of $10 million, however, this is spread over the past 8 years, therefore we have revised our prior period financials to correct for these errors and we are also taking actions to ensure that VAT is properly assessed on all future cross-border transactions.
Please turn to Slide 10 and let’s take a quick look at our key cash flow and balance sheet items. You can see that we have continued our trend in operating cash flow improvements throughout the year. As a reminder, our first quarter is usually a drag on free cash flow and we would expect that to continue going forward. This is driven primarily by the timing of several employee benefit payments and contributions that we see each year. The balance sheet remains strong with net debt to capital at 29% and $31 million of cash on hand. This past year represents the third consecutive year of CAPEX spending below $65 million.
Moving on to Slide 11, I’ll review our segment results for the quarter. For North America, sales were up 1% due to several factors. First, OEM sales as a whole were up 7 million. This consisted of 16 million increase in commercial vehicle and off-highway sales and was offset by 9 million decrease in automotive and military truck sales as certain programs are winding down. The increase in OE sales was also offset by a $5 million drop in tooling sales versus a year ago. As you can see, although sales as a whole are relatively flat, we are achieving growth in our targeted markets.
Gross margin improvement reflects improved plant performance and lower material costs. Also, I want to point out that last year’s results included $2.7 million unfavorable inventory adjustment in North America. SG&A was lower due to pension expense plus higher prototype and testing recoveries. Overall operating income improved by about $8 million or 104%.
Our calendar 2012 market outlook is for growth in all targeted markets, however, we are starting to see indications that the level of growth, particularly in the Class 8 [ph] market, may be lower than originally anticipated. In addition, we are expecting the remaining wind-down of automotive programs and continued reductions in military spending will negatively impact next year’s revenue by approximately $15 million.
Turning to Slide 12, we have a look at our South American business segment. As expected, sales declined in the fourth quarter as compared to the prior year due to the impact of the pre-buy of commercial vehicles ahead of the January 1 change in emission standards. In addition, the weakening of the Brazilian real had a significant impact on sales. On a constant currency basis, sales would have been down 10.5% rather than the 16% as reported.
Gross margin and operating income were both down on lower volume and costs associated with the launch activities as this region coverts to new aluminum product. As for the 2012 outlook, we see the volumes in the commercial vehicle market remaining down and do not expect them to see a recovery until later this year. That said, we do expect modest growth in agricultural equipment and in the aftermarket business.
Moving on to Slide 13, we have our European segment. Fourth quarter sales were down 4% over the prior year, also reflecting the negative impact of foreign currency. Excluding the foreign currency impact, the sales actually would have been up slightly. We continue to see the weakness in the commercial vehicle market, especially on the engine side, and our sales in this market were down 4% versus the prior year despite higher launch activity. Also, automotive sales were down 10% and this includes the $13 million impact from the wind-down of BMW in the quarter. However, these sales declines were largely offset by an increase in off-highway business, which was up 20% year-over-year.
SG&A benefited from higher customer reimbursement and development cost in the current year and also the impact of an asset impairment charge taken in the fourth quarter last year. The overall impact was a significant improvement in operating income in Europe despite flat revenues, and looking ahead we anticipate the continuation of weak markets for autos and commercial vehicles given the economic situation in Europe. Our outlook also reflects the EUR 45 million reduction in BMW module business as that program takes its largest step down this year. After that and after this year, we are left with approximately EUR 45 million in sales, which will decline over the following 4 years.
Turning to Slide 14, we have a look at our Asia business. Sales were relatively flat as order rates in the China excavator market are not improving from the sharp decline we saw in the third quarter. Tom discussed this, but while we’re continuing to launch some new programs, the new volumes cannot offset the weakness in the excavator market, which declined 48% year-over-year in Q4. In addition, we experienced the loss of some vehicular HVAC sales that we anticipated would wind down after we sold Modine Korea. The gross margin decreased slightly as we converted our Shanghai plant to a new engine facility – new engine products facility, also increasing our manufacturing capacity in that region.
We are anticipating modest growth in India in 2012, however, the largest challenge will be our heavy reliance on excavator sales in China given the current market expectations. As a reminder, for the Asia segment excavators currently make up 60% to 70% of that segment’s entire revenue.
Looking to Slide 15, last but not least is our commercial products segment. This segment continues to grow at a much faster pace than the overall market, driven by new product launches particularly in the U.K. The gross margin improvement coupled with flat SG&A led to a significant improvement in our operating income margin to 6.5%. In calendar 2012, we expect to see growth 2.5 – 2% to 5% I should say, for North America, and with regards to the U.K. and the slowing economic environment, we are lowering our expectations for growth in the server market there.
Last, we are very pleased to announce the small acquisition of Geofinity, a technology leader in residential and commercial heat pump systems. This expands Modine’s product offering into a market that is growing nearly 15% per year. Current sales are quite small for this start-up company, but we will quickly leverage Modine’s brand and distribution system throughout North America. The earnings impact will be immaterial to this fiscal year and slightly accretive next year, but I’ll provide more and update once the deal officially closes.
Moving on to fiscal ’12, before I move to guidance, I’d actually like to comment on the slide on the European restructuring that Tom keyed up at the beginning of the call. As you know, we are in the process of shifting our European focus away from high volume automotive modules towards a better balance of heavy duty programs, especially commercial vehicles. This is similar to the work we recently completed in North America. We have some aggressive financial targets, and in order to achieve them we need to address a number of areas.
First, we need to align our manufacturing strategy with our product strategy for long-term success. Next, we have to attain a more efficient operating structure and reduce SG&A spending. In addition, we need to improve our asset efficiency by reducing the assets employed in this business segment. Over the next 24 months, our team will implement the necessary actions and we should start seeing some benefits next year. From there, we want to have a run rate that will achieve our financial targets of the following: gross margin of 15% to 17%, SG&A savings of EUR 5 million to EUR 7 million, and operating margin of 8% to 10% and ultimately a return on capital employed at or above 15%.
At this point, we believe the net cash costs of implementing the program will be in the range of EUR 10 million to EUR 20 million. The ultimate cash cost can obviously vary significantly based on the potential proceeds from any asset sales. In addition to the cash costs, we may incur some non-cash charges during this process. This is the right thing to do and at the right time for Modine. The team in Europe is diligently working on finalizing these plans and is looking forward to the challenges ahead.
Now let’s turn to the guidance for fiscal ’13 on Slide 15. From a revenue standpoint, we and many other companies faced some macroeconomic challenges this fiscal year. Also as mentioned several times, we have some non-strategic programs winding down, including BMW in Europe and certain automotive and military programs in North America. In total, this represents approximately 80 million in sales declines this year. We are also seeing some year-over-year declines in some of our key end markets which Tom and I walked you through, in Europe, South America and Asia. In addition, we are anticipating a fairly significant impact on our revenues from foreign exchange which could have a full-year impact of approximately 80 million.
Given our current market and foreign exchange assumptions, we expect our revenue in fiscal ’13 to be down about 5% to 10%. Certainly things could improve, but given the current economic and foreign exchange situation, we prefer to take a cautious stance. We expect the decline in volume will result in a slightly lower operating margin, therefore we anticipate the operating margin will be between 3.5% and 4%. As a result, we are forecasting fiscal ’13 earnings per share in the $0.60 to $0.70 range. Please note that a portion of the EPS impact is due to an increase in our effective tax rate from this year. This is one of the more challenging areas to predict because we still don’t pay taxes in certain jurisdictions. The overall mix of our earnings plays a key role in the final effective tax rate. So while our EPS is expected to be down, the pretax earnings range is actually fairly close to fiscal ’12 results.
In looking at the quarterly spread of our earnings projections, we expect the second half of the year to be stronger than the first half. Overall sales will be lower than the prior year in quarters 1 and 2. In fact, our most difficult comparison will be Q1 due to the volume and foreign exchange impact year-over-year. From there, we anticipate that revenue will grow sequentially as we move throughout the year, in line with launches in markets.
So just to summarize before I turn the call back to Tom from my standpoint, Modine’s repositioning strategy is working. We are gaining share in all of our targeted markets. We just completed the third consecutive year of return on capital improvement. We’ve gone from a negative return in fiscal 2009 to more than 9% this fiscal year, but we have 2 remaining challenges to overcome. First, we must fully utilize our capacity in Asia and we are confident that our order book will do just that. Second, we must complete the restructuring in Europe and we have an excellent plan to get that done in a very timely manner. The current economic and market obstacles are just temporary. With the approximately $250 million of net new business ahead of us, we are highly confident in our future earnings potential.
With that, Tom, let me turn it back to you.