Rich Kramer
Analyst · Deutsche Bank. Please go ahead, your line is open
Ryan I’ll, no that’s really not an issue. As I try to articulate in my remarks. I think if you look at our commercial business we really sort of had these three elements that impacted us in the quarter. You know one was frankly we had a weakness in consumer or in commercial OE volume new trucks, we saw trucks down I think 29% in the quarter and just to be – add a little bit of clarity and transparency on it, we tend to - when we see those we manage our inventory, we take production out. As we took that production out, what happened to us is, when we go through our unabsorbed overhead calculations as part of our accounting policy, as you take that volume out, we can trip a number, which was again very candidly unexpected where instead of that unabsorbed overhead or lower factory utilization turning up as a product cost and then being released is cost of sale when the tire is sold, it effectively gets recorded in the period that we take the production cut in this case in September. So that was an issue that hit us in the quarter. Then we had a specific customer issue, where we are again, I won’t elaborate on, but we’ll say we’re sticking to our value proposition as we go. And then we had frankly just lower volumes. This one is very hard to predict, but we had significant increases in the pre-buys ahead of the tariff and commercial truck tires. I think we had non-RMA members in the U.S. were up, I think 35% in Q1, I think 74% in Q2, and down 23% in Q3. And frankly that’s really hard to predict those pre-volume numbers as we go. And remember that’s in an industry where sort of ton miles and the way to measure freight is, let’s just say relatively flat and not up. So, dealing with that also had an impact in the quarter. Again, little bit harder to predict, but this is something we’ve seen before. Dealers have loaded up on truck tires that means there is a little shelf space, but that will work its way through. Our products are leading in the industry. Our fleet solutions model continues to be very strong. That will work its way through, it will take care of itself as we go forward and we’re working through a distortion. Unfortunately and again just to be very transparent about it; that did have an impact on us in the quarter. So that was one of the things I would say. The OTR did hit us, but that was a little bit more of the cyclicality of the mining industry, it wouldn’t be what you’re referring to which I do remember about a year or so ago.