John Fawcett
Analyst · Credit Suisse. Please go ahead
Thank you Ellen and good morning everyone. We had another solid quarter with net income available to common shareholders of $128 million or $1.33 per common share as we continue to execute on strategy and progress toward our 11% return on tangible common equity target for the fourth quarter of this year. We grew average loans and leases in our core portfolio by 1% in the prior quarter and 8% from the year ago quarter, which was driven by continued strong origination activity across all of our businesses. We stay disciplined in our underwriting, credit metrics remain stable, and we reduced non-accrual loans. Our net efficiency ratio improved as operating expenses came down from elevated seasonal levels last quarter. And we further optimized our balance sheet. We reduce our Federal Home Loan Bank debt repurchased $158 million of common stock below tangible book value, which contributed to the 3.6% tangible book value per share growth this quarter. Once again, there were no noteworthy items and I will now go into further detail on our financial results for the quarter. Turning to Slide 6 of the presentation, net finance revenue declined from the prior quarter, driven by higher deposit costs, which were partially offset by lower borrowing costs on secured debt. Interest income was relatively constant. Higher interest on loans was essentially offset by approximately $6 million from the accelerated amortization of the premium on our mortgage backed securities investments. The acceleration was driven by the reduction in long-term interest rates, which resulted in higher actual and forecast prepayments. Slide 7 is our net finance margin walk, net finance margin was 3.13%, down seven basis points from the prior quarter. The reduction was driven by higher deposit costs resulting from the full quarter impact of last quarter strong deposit growth partially offset by lower borrowing costs. The margin was also negatively impacted by approximately five basis points from the acceleration of the premium amortization on our mortgage backed securities investment portfolio. As I discussed last quarter, we ended the first quarter with a higher than normal percentage of cash in investments, which was driven by the strong performance in our savings builder deposit product. We redeployed excess cash by repaying about $2 billion or Federal Home Loan Bank debt since the end of February at an average rate of about 2.7%. We reduced our savings builder non-maturity deposit rate by five basis points on May 1st, and then 10 basis points more on July 1st, which will further benefit the third quarter and we will continue to opportunistically look at options to further reduce rates as the Fed moves. Loan yields improved modestly from an increase in day count, but the benefit was more than offset by lower yields on our mortgage backed securities book described above. The margin benefited from a higher level of interest recoveries and prepayment benefits this quarter, which was mostly offset by the reduction in interest on the indemnification asset which was related to a law share agreement that expired on March 31st. Net operating lease yields in rail were relatively constant as lower gross yields were offset by lower maintenance expense, reflecting some of our productivity initiatives. Turning to Slide 8, other non-interest income increased $9 million compared to the prior quarter. The increase was primarily in commercial finance and included a gain on the sale of a loan that was previously written off. Capital markets fees were down this quarter reflecting the weaker sponsor driven middle-market M&A environment but the decline was more than offset by higher customer derivative income in commercial finance. Turning to Slide 9. Operating expenses, excluding intangible asset amortization decreased $8 million from the prior quarter. $5 million of the decrease related to compensation and benefit cost, which are down from seasonally elevated levels. We significantly reduced our advertising and marketing costs this quarter related to deposits, as our deposit growth in the first quarter was ahead of our expectations and exceeded the amount needed to offset this quarter’s CD maturities. Other expenses increased $6 million resulting from a combination of several smaller items, we estimate that approximately $8 million of operating expenses resulted from the adoption of the new lease accounting standard this quarter, including $6 million for property tax that was offset in other non-interest income. The quarter included $9 million and the full-year benefit of 2019, we continue to estimate that the new lease accounting standard will increase operating expenses by $40 million to $50 million with a $25 million to $30 million offsetting increase in other non-interest income. The net efficiency ratio improved to 56% from 58% last quarter, resulting from the reduction in operating expenses and reflects the aforementioned lease accounting changes which we estimate increased the rate by little more than 100 basis points. We remain committed to further reducing operating costs while also investing in our businesses and we are on-track to achieve our target operating cost reductions of at least $50 million through 2020 when compared to the 2018 level. Slide 10 shows our consolidated average balance sheet. Average earning assets were essentially unchanged from the prior quarter. During the quarter, we deployed excess cash to repay Federal Home Loan Bank debt and fund investment securities. We grew average loans and leases by 1%, which includes the impact from the runoff of the legacy consumer mortgage portfolio. Average interest-bearing cash and investments remained higher than our typical run rate at about 21% of average earning assets resulting from our strong deposit growth in the first quarter, but declined to 19% at quarter end. The average duration of our investment securities book remains at around two years, reflecting the higher level of liquidity in the flatness of the yield curve. We slowed deposit growth this quarter, on a period end basis, deposits increased 1%, but on average basis, deposits increased 6% reflecting the full quarter impact from last quarter’s strong growth. Slide 11, provides more detail on average loans and leases by division. Strong origination volume across all of our businesses drove growth in our core portfolios. Commercial Finance grew 2% from the prior quarter. Given the diversity of our commercial finance business, we continue to see gorgeous collateral based lending opportunities, which contributed to about 60% of origination volume. Prepayments have also remained low which contributed to the growth. In business capital, continued strong new business volume drove growth across our equipment financing portfolios, which was mostly offset by a reduction in the factoring business. We also experienced an improvement in yields this quarter driven by pricing increases in the second half of last year in the technology driven businesses with an equipment finance and small business solutions. That said, we are starting to see some pricing pressure in certain areas given the decline in swap rates and from competitors looking to aggressively add assets. In Real Estate Finance origination activity increased from last quarter, but a continued to high prepayment level resulted in a net reduction in average loans. Our rail portfolio increased modestly this quarter as new deliveries mostly offsets depreciation and our portfolio management activity. Utilization declined slightly to just below 97% as leases repriced down 15% on average of this quarter. We continue to see strength in tank car lease rates driven by the chemical and petroleum markets. However, many industrial sectors are exhibiting slower growth, which is translating into weak rail industry loadings such as in non-metallic minerals or sand, coal and grain. In this environment, we expect some pressure on our fleet utilization and repricing within these freight markets. As we have mentioned in the past, our market position, strong portfolio management expertise, customer service and young fleet are key strengths as we continue to navigate through the various market cycles. We continue to expect lease renewals on the total fleet to reprice down 15% to 20% in 2019, but will vary quarter-to-quarter based on the amount and type of cars renewing. In Commercial Banking we grew average loans by 2% despite the continued runoff of the legacy consumer mortgage portfolio. We have seen an increase in prepayment levels driven by the current interest rate environment, but it is also driving stronger origination activity in our retail and correspondent lending channels. 85% of our new retail mortgage origination came through our digital channel and total new origination continue to have LTVs below 80% and FICO scores in the 750 area. As Ellen indicated, as part of our continued efforts to further improve our risk profile, last week, we sold approximately $200 million in book value of non-performing loans within the LCM portfolio. We received proceeds in excess carrying value. However, given most of the loans were PCI loans, where interest income was recognized on a level yield basis. Based on the cash flows of the pools they reside in, the excess proceeds or what would typically be characterized as a gain will be recognized over the remaining life of the pool. Slice 12 highlights our average funding mix, which reflects the trends I mentioned earlier. We continue to look for ways to optimize our funding mix, including shrinking our bank holding company and increasing our mix of assets funded with deposits. Slide 13 illustrates the deposit mix by type and channel. Average deposits increased $2 billion from the prior quarter to $35.3 billion, reflecting strong growth in our online savings account deposits throughout last quarter and continue albeit at a slower growth in the second quarter. The cost of deposits increased as the cumulative beta since the first hike of the current tightening cycle in December 2015, increased to 36% from 31% last quarter consistent with our expectations. We are focusing on optimizing deposit costs by increasing the proportion of non-maturity deposits, which we think will perform better, especially as rates declined. We have also reduced our savings rate builder rate by 15 basis points since the beginning of May and have not seen any meaningful levels of attrition as a result of these moves. Notwithstanding any rate reductions from Fed, we are likely to continue to test the elasticity of our deposit rates, balancing or need to fund growth and our continuing effort to optimize our funding costs. Turning to capital on Slide 14. During the quarter, we repurchased approximately $158 million in common shares, consisting of 3.2 million shares at an average price of $49.64. Below tangible book value and in the quarter with just under 95 million shares. Our CET1 ratio at the end of the quarter decline to 11.6%, reflecting the expiration of the loss share agreement with the FDIC, which increased RWA by approximately $800 million. If you recall, last quarter, we had a net increase in the common equity Tier 1 ratio related to the change in the regulatory definition of HVCRE loans. Partially offset by the adoption of the new lease accounting standard. In aggregate, the net impact on our capital ratios from both of these changes was minimal. We have reduced the common equity Tier 1 ratio from 12% at the beginning of the year to 11.6% and continue to target 11% by the end of this year. Slide 15 highlights our credit trends. The credit provision this quarter was $29 million, modestly below our guidance range and net charge-offs was $31 million or 40 basis points within our guidance range. Net charge-offs declined from $34 million in the prior quarter and continue to be primarily driven by commercial finance, most of which were previously reserved for at small business solutions within business capital. Non-accrual loans declined this quarter by $26 million or 9% and approximately 60% of the remaining non-accrual loans are current. About half of the reduction was due to charge-offs that had been previously reserved and we received slightly above book value on the other exited non-accruals. Our credit metrics and the broad credit environment remains stable and new business originations continue to come in at better risk ratings than the overall risk rating of the performing portfolio. Our reserves remain stable and strong at 1.56% of total loans and up slightly to 1.89% for commercial banking, and continue to reflect more than four times in the last 12 months net charge-offs. Slide 16 highlights our key performance metrics reflecting the trends we just discussed. Our effective tax rate was 20% and benefited from debts to fleet items of $9 million, which was driven by audit settlements with several state and local tax authorities in the ordinary course of business. Excluding those discrete items, the effective tax rate would have been 25% in-line with our guidance. Our return on tangible common equity from continuing operations was 10.3%. If you normalize to the semiannual preferred dividend that is paid in the second and fourth quarters, our return on tangible common equity would have been 10.7%, up from 9.3% in the prior quarter reflecting lower operating expenses and a lower effective tax rate. We remain committed to continuing to improve our returns and are focused on achieving an ROTCE of 11% in the fourth quarter of 2019, and targeting at least 12% by the fourth quarter of 2020. When we set our initial outlook back in January, we assumed no rate increases or decreases and assumed GDP growth of 2.5% to 3%. As Ellen mentioned, we are starting to see customer sentiment shift a little in some of our commercial businesses, primarily resulting from the uncertainty related to trade and tariff discussions. In addition, the rate environment obviously continues to evolve and is now reflecting multiple rate cuts in 2019 and 2020. While the 25 basis point interest rate cut next week and another later this year would pressure our net finance revenue, we believe we would still be able to achieve our 4Q 2019 return on tangible common equity target of 11%. And we remain focused on continuous improvement. The uncertain environment is making 2020 more challenging to predict, but achieving at least a 12% return on tangible common equity in the fourth quarter of 2020 remains our target. We will keep you posted on our progress as we navigate through the current environment and plan to update our 2020 guidance on our fourth quarter earnings call. Page 17 highlights or outlook for the third quarter. We continue to expect low-single-digit quarterly growth in our core portfolio and slightly lower growth in the total portfolio, reflecting the sales of the non-performing legacy consumer mortgage assets and continued runoff of that portfolio. We think our margin for 2019 will now be at the low end of our target range reflecting a 25 basis point cut in the third quarter and another one in the fourth quarter. For the third quarter net finance margin is expected to continue to trend down to the bottom end of the target range and could be pressured further, depending on the environment for rates and deposits as well as other factors. We expect deposit rates to be relatively flat as continued migration of our CD depositors into higher rate products is offset by a reduction in our savings builder rate. We think - yields will continue to reprice down but will be mostly offset by lower maintenance costs. And as I have mentioned earlier we had a higher level of interest recoveries in prepayment benefits this quarter, which are difficult to predict and a potential hand to next quarter. We expect operating expenses to be flat to slightly higher next quarter related to marketing costs. As deposit activities normalize. The net efficiency ratio is expected to remain in the mid 50% area next quarter reflecting the trends I just mentioned, and includes the impact of the lease accounting changes. Credit metrics and effective tax rate absent any discrete tax items are expected to be consistent with our full-year outlook. And with that, I will turn the call back over to Ellen.