Randall C. Stuewe
Analyst · Stephens
Yes, and I think it's probably a question here that will answer many of it for the rest of the analyst on the call. As you look at the earnings number versus what you guys were trying to model out there, there's a couple, probably 3 or 4, salient points that need to flow through and help you understand here. The first thing is, is that if you look at -- remember, a portion, mid-20%, 25% of our tonnage comes out of the poultry industry. And if you look at the feed grade, pet food spread on poultry in Q1 versus Q2, you would see that in Q1, on the upgraded or value-added ingredients per the Jacobsen sheet, we got about $272 a ton. And in second quarter, we only received $225-a-ton premium. So you got about a -- almost a $50-a-ton discount that happened quarter-over-quarter there that flows straight through the P&L. On the meat and bone meal side, as long as we're staying on proteins, yes, while we did see the Illinois Midwest values improve and, to a degree, track soybean meal, what didn't flow through or what did -- you didn't pickup in it was the substantial discounts that happened and the disruption of trade flows when the Indonesian market closed on us. And if you go back and saw what we added into the Q was there was the -- not only the Illinois meat and bone meal price, but the California meat and bone meal price. And if you look at that, you would see that in first quarter, California was actually a premium to Illinois; and in second quarter, it actually became a discount of $73 a ton. So it became full freight off, if you will, the freight from the West Coast back to the Midwest consumers of that product because of the export restrictions that happened. On the fats and greases, I think for the most part, they were pretty much unchanged on average over first quarter. They are lagging their equivalency of caloric value against corn. But most importantly, they peaked in May and came off fairly substantially here in June. Most of that is driven off of -- primarily off of just very, very slow exports for that product today. As we've said, the hot weather -- I mean, you got a smaller herd size out there year-over-year, whether you're talking cattle or you're talking chickens. And so those 2 combinations really put a little pressure on it. At the same time, as we've said all along, yellow grease or cooking oil yellow grease, tallow cooking oil blends have a real issue in standard biodiesel processes. And so we just did not see the biofuel demand that probably most anticipated there, all the more good reason for Diamond Green Diesel to be able to take that product. So really, at the end of the day, if you take those 3 bullet points there: the pet food feed grade spread; the fat demand driven by lower exports; and then the meat and bone meal discounts, it becomes pretty easy to reconcile for the quarter. Now the question you had, Farha, is: Do you see it improving? I think the answer is we think so because, fundamentally, it should. It's too cheap, all of our ingredients are. We're seeing here in July and August, we're seeing improvements in the meat and bone meal markets, the poultry markets. The fat side, we have yet to see much improvement yet. In fact, it's even staying at a discount today. So I mean, on a corn basis equivalent from calories, if you're only serving the feed market, the fats and greases should be priced somewhere between $0.45 and $0.47. And then we're receiving in FOB plant in the Midwest today somewhere between $0.35 and $0.39. So there's a pretty significant historical lag here that needs to probably improve, we hope.