Gregory Garrabrants
Analyst · Bob Ramsey with FBR
Thank you, Johnny. Good afternoon, everyone, and thank you for joining us. I'd like to welcome everyone to BofI Holdings Conference Call for the first quarter of fiscal year 2017 ended September 30, 2016. I thank you for your interest in BofI Holding and BofI Federal Bank.
BofI announced net income for its first quarter ended September 30, 2016, of $28,897,000, up 13.3% when compared to the $25,501,000 earned in the first quarter ended September 30, 2015.
Earnings attributable to Bofl's common stockholders were $28,820,000 or $0.45 per diluted share for the quarter ended September 30, 2016, compared to $0.40 per diluted share for the quarter ended September 30, 2015, and $0.46 per diluted share for the quarter ended June 30, 2016.
Excluding the after-tax impact of net gains related to investment securities, adjusted earnings for the first quarter ended September 30, 2016, increased $2.8 million or 11% when compared to the quarter ended September 30, 2015.
Other highlights for the first quarter include total assets reached $7.86 billion of September 30, 2016, up $254 million compared to June 30, 2016, and up $1.6 billion from the first quarter in 2016.
Total deposits increased $1.57 billion from $4.76 billion at September 30, 2015 to $6.32 billion. Return on equity was 16.59% for the first quarter above our long-term target of 15% or better. Our efficiency ratio was 38.9% for the first quarter of fiscal 2017, compared to 38.28% in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2016, and 33.25% for the first quarter of fiscal 2016.
Net interest margin was 3.78%, an increase of 6 basis points over the fourth fiscal quarter of 2016. Noninterest income increased by 50.5% as a result of strong mortgage banking fee income, higher prepayment fees and a 66% increase in banking service fees and other income.
The primary drivers of our loan production this quarter consisted of: $122 million of single-family agency eligible gain on sale production; $383 million of single-family jumbo portfolio production; $43 million of single-family non-agency eligible gain on sale production; $104 million of multifamily and other small balance commercial real estate portfolio production; $27 million of auto production; and a net increase in loan balances outstanding at the end of the quarter in C&I lending, factoring and warehouse lending of approximately $105 million in the quarter.
We experienced the higher rate of prepayment in our single-family mortgage, multifamily and single-family lender finance loans this quarter compared with last quarter. We believe part of the acceleration of these prepayments was a byproduct of a reduction in interest rates in the quarter. Prepayments on loans held for investment in the portfolio this quarter were approximately $130 million higher than the fourth quarter of 2016. And we sold approximately $20 million more single-family jumbo loans than in the fourth quarter of 2016. As a result, held for investment balances grew by $203 million, and net loan balances grew this quarter by $195 million over the fourth quarter of 2016.
Despite the higher-than-expected headwinds from higher loan prepayments, we ended the quarter with $6.5 billion of net loans outstanding, a 25.3% increase over the September 30, 2015 quarter balance of loans outstanding. This quarter's results demonstrate the diversity of our lending businesses with broad growth in C&I, warehouse, auto and small balance CRE lending.
Our outlook for loan growth remains positive with a loan pipeline of approximately $970 million consisting of: $545 million of single-family jumbo loans; $132 million of single-family agency mortgages; $113 million of income property loans; and $180 million of C&I loans.
Net interest margins was 3.78, up from 3.72 last quarter and down from 4.02 in the first quarter of 2016. We had higher average cash balances, which resulted in us holding more excess liquidity during the quarter ended September 30, 2016, that we initially anticipated, which reduced net interest income margin by 3 -- 6 basis points.
The increased cost of our subordinated debt offering, which has not been either contributed to the bank as capital or utilized for share repurchases as of today, also resulted in a reduction of our net interest margin by 4 basis points.
Excluding the impact of H&R Block-related excess liquidity and the impact of the subordinated debt, our net interest margin was 3.88% in the first quarter of 2017 within our target 3.8 to 4.0 annual range.
Average loan yields for the first quarter of 2017 were 4.98%, essentially unchanged from 5.02% in the prior quarter and 5.02% in the first quarter of 2016. Our loan yields in our largest business single-family jumbo lending and multifamily lending are stable and impacted only slightly by changes in prepayment speed.
Our C&I lending businesses, including equipment leasing, generated higher-than-average loan yields. Our auto and warehouse lending loans carry a lower-than-average yield relative to other portfolio loans. In this current quarter we will, as we did last year, originate loans to H&R Block franchise owners as well as start originating Emerald Advance loans. Both the franchise loans and the Emerald Advance loans carry a higher yields than our average loan yield. Other than a similar seasonal increase in our loan yields to that which occurred last year from the H&R Block loan products, the overall loan yield at the bank will be determined by the mix of our incremental C&I loan balances vis-à-vis our auto or warehouse lending business.
Our credit quality remains strong. The bank had 1 basis point of net charge-offs in the first quarter of fiscal 2017, compared to 3 basis points of net recoveries in the corresponding year-ago period, which reflects a favorable credit cycle and our strong underwriting and monitoring.
Nonperforming loans were a modest 64 basis points of total loans and leases, compared to 57 basis points in the first quarter of fiscal 2016. We believe that our strong collateral position protects and limits the severity of our losses in the event of default because the borrower can either sell the property or will recover substantially all our principle in the event we ultimately have to foreclose on the property. The primary drivers of the increase in nonperforming loans was $6.8 million of single-family jumbo mortgages and a $3.5 million multifamily loan.
The 4 loans with the current LTVs between 62 and 65 -- 75% account for $6.1 million in single-family jumbo delinquencies over the prior quarter. 2 of these 4 single-family mortgages that went delinquent this quarter are under contract to be sold at prices above our loan amount. One, $3 million loan for the multifamily property located in Laguna Beach has a 55% LTV and accounts for the bulk of the increase in the multifamily delinquencies. The cause of the delinquency in each of these instances is unique to the family's circumstances of the borrower. Because these borrowers have significant equity and their properties are located in attractive locations, we believe our risk of loss is minimal.
For the first fiscal quarter's originations, the average FICO for single-family agency eligible production was 758, with an average loan-to-value ratio of 67%. The average FICO score for the single-family jumbo production was 709 with an average loan-to-value ratio of 61.5%. The average loan-to-value ratio of the originated multifamily loans was 55.3%, and the debt service coverage ratio was 1.44%. The average loan-to-value ratio of the originated small balance commercial real estate loans was 45.5%, and the debt service coverage ratio was 1.35%. The average FICO of the auto production was 768.
At September 30, 2016, the weighted average loan-to-value ratio of our entire portfolio of real estate loans is 57%. These loan-to-value ratios use historic origination date appraisals over current amortized balances, making these historic loan-to-value ratios even more conservative when you consider that real estate values have generally risen in the markets in which we lend. In single family jumbo mortgages representing 56% of our gross loans outstanding at September 30, 2016, the average loan-to-value ratio is 58%.
As of the September 30, 2016 quarter, 55% of the single family loans have loan-to-value ratios at or below 60%; 37% have loan-to-value ratios between 61% and 70%; 6% of single-family loans have loan-to-value ratios between 71% and 75%; and approximately 1% have loan-to-value ratios between 75% and 80%, and approximately 1% have loan-to-value ratios greater than 80%. We have approximately $1.4 billion in multifamily loans outstanding at September 30, 2016, representing approximately 21% of the total loan book.
We have maintained our low loan-to-value and strong debt service coverage across all our markets. The average loan-to-value ratio on a weighted basis in the multifamily book is 55%, based on the appraised value at the time of the origination. We do not have risks hidden in the tails of our multifamily portfolio. Approximately 61% of our multifamily loans are under 60% loan-to-value; 33% are between 60% and 70%; only 5% are between 70% and 75%; and less than 1% of our multifamily loans have a loan-to-value ratio above 75%.
Our C&I lending group, which include lender finance, real estate secured bridge lending, equipment finance and other asset-based lending, continues to generate good risk-adjusted returns for the bank with no delinquencies and no credit losses.
We have a seasoned C&I team focused on finding good credits, creating favorable structures with significant collateral protection and monitoring our borrowing base and underlying collateral values. Our borrowers' concentration and industry exposures are well managed, and the majority of our approximately $1 billion of C&I loan portfolio are backed by hard assets with readily ascertainable market values.
We see good opportunities to grow our C&I loan portfolio in existing niches and new verticals without compromising credit standards, yields or structure. Our C&I lending group continues to have strong pipelines.
Our equipment leasing group, based on Salt Lake, was formally and individually selected and purchased approximately $140 million of loans and leases and hired a team of 25 seasoned members from the Pac West Equipment Leasing Financing Group in March of this year. Our opportunistic asset purchase and lift out provided us with an accelerated point of entry into a new C&I lending business with accretive yields and good growth potential.
Based on the first 2 quarters of operation, we feel more confident that we'll be able to execute upon our leasing business plan. The group has a nationwide focus with the commitment to grow the business over the next few years as a result of both the bank's expertise and recent investments in lead generation resources, alternative marketing strategies, a transition to a more robust customer relationship management system, expanding product offerings and interbank cross-sell initiatives, all of which we believe will accelerate production over time.
We continue to expect the leasing group to originate between $80 million and $100 million in new leases in the first year. While we are focusing on implementing our management framework of process improvement and workflow integration on the first 2 quarters to build the business for future success, the equipment leasing team has successfully increased the pipeline in the equipment leasing business during the quarter ended September 30, 2016.
The equipment finance business typically experienced its highest leased production in the fourth calendar quarter. We have no nonperforming assets either that we purchased or that we originated in the equipment leasing book.
We had another strong quarter of deposit funding growth. Total deposits increased by $1.6 billion or 33% year-over-year, with growth across a variety of consumer and business deposit categories.
Checking and savings deposits increased by $1.3 billion compared to September 30, 2015, representing year-over-year growth of 33.5%. Checking and saving deposits represent 83% of total deposits.
We have a diversified deposit base, comprised of: approximately 41% business and consumer checking accounts; 27% money market accounts; 5% IRA accounts; 6% savings accounts; and 4% prepaid accounts.
Our small business and specialty deposit groups generated strong growth this quarter. We continue to focus on improving our marketing efforts to attract small business customers and improve the effect of this, of our inside sales team.
Since the launch of our more sophisticated cash management platform last year, our commercial banking group continues to grow and gain traction, focusing on attracting more sophisticated treasury management customers and expanding into new specialty deposit verticals.
On the consumer side, we are pleased that to be recently recognized by MONEY Magazine as the Best Consumer Online Bank because of our easy-to-use web and mobile tools and our strong consumer value proposition.
We are having success cross-selling deposit products to our mortgage customers and utilizing the Virtus brand for those jumbo mortgage customers.
We're excited to expand the product set that we're offering through H&R Block during this upcoming tax season. This year, Bofl will be the provider of individual retirement accounts offered to H&R Block tax clients through blocks approximately 10,000 company-owned and franchised retail locations in the United States. Additionally, we announced in our press release yesterday that we are working with H&R Block, MetaBank and SCS to perform certain disbursement and repayment services and provide $700 million of funding for H&R Block's interest-free refund advance product.
The 2 new H&R Block branded products, IRAs and the refund advance will be offered for the 2017 tax season in addition to the 3 existing financial services products: Emerald Prepaid MasterCards, Refund Transfer and Emerald Advance, all offered by us during the 2016 tax season. We hope that the Refund Advance product will drive incremental tax return volume to H&R Block, and as a result increase usage of BofI's current H&R Block-branded product suite.
We will receive revenue from fees earned funding the Refund Advance product and from potential incremental volume derived from usage of the bank's Refund Transfer and Emerald Card products. As we have previously stated, the revenue we receive from our H&R Block relationship is primarily dependent upon the volume of BofI products sold through H&R Block channels.
With respect to our funding commitments for the Refund Advance product, we believe that this funding commitment is very well secured from a credit risk perspective with sufficient fee income earned to offset the relatively low-level of projected credit loss.
In order to protect from principle loss above the projected credit loss, H&R Block has provided BofI with limited guarantees up to $34 million in the aggregate. Bofl expects that only an immaterial amount of the guarantees will be called upon under anticipated loss scenarios.
After a smooth acquisition and integration of H&R Block Bank, and the first tax season with H&R Block, we believe we're well prepared for a second tax season with H&R Block. We have completed the software integration with H&R Block using our account enrollment API capability that enables our bank to offer individual retirement accounts through Block's approximately 10,000 tax offices and through Block's digital channel for this upcoming tax season.
I'm pleased with the progress we're making across the dozens of strategic and operational initiatives we are currently undertaking.
In auto lending, we've methodically grown originations from approximately $10 million in the first quarter of 2016 to over $25 million in the first quarter of 2017. We focused on prime borrowers with an average FICO of 760 for purchase transactions.
Our direct auto lending platform, which will target high-quality borrowers nationwide through direct and wholesale channels, and will be a component of the product we offer through the universal digital bank, is slated for a soft launch in the second half of 2017. We intend to expand our auto lending business methodically while we perfect our data analytics and marketing capabilities to generate new customers and allow us to cross-sell our products to our existing customers, particularly with our online platform.
We continue to make good progress in our next-generation digital banking infrastructure initiative, the universal digital bank. With the consumer online banking platform prototype, the consumer online opening software completed, we are focusing our efforts on building the production-ready consumer online banking platform and expanding our API toolkit and microservices architecture to allow us to seamlessly integrate with third parties and offer new financial services developed by us or third parties to our clients through our core consumer banking platform.
These investments have already started to pay dividends as evidenced by the API integration into our custom consumer enrollment system we have completed with H&R Block for new IRA accounts this tax season, and the custom integration with a large commercial banking client to significantly streamline their payment processing functions, resulting in dramatic cost savings for the client and significant deposit balances and recurring fee income for the bank.
Once the universal digital bank is fully developed, we'll be able to provide more personalized and targeted products and services delivered in a more seamless way across the channels by which we interact with our clients.
We are making significant progress and implementation of our next-generation retail mortgage origination platform that will automate and streamline the mortgage origination process for the retail client. We believe this software will allow us to automate time-consuming paper-based interactions with customers by integrating with third-party providers of tax returns, pay stubs and bank statements, thereby improving the customer experience and further reducing our closing times.
We believe that one key to realizing our long-term growth plan is to geographically diversify where we attract our future team members. In order to expand the geographies from which we can attract talent, we will significantly expand our existing operations in Nevada by the end of calendar year 2016.
We are having continuous success and making progress in our data-driven compliance initiatives. Our data-driven compliance initiative works to digitize the inputs to the compliance process and automate compliance rules in real time, rather than rely on after-the-fact sample testing.
We believe this reg tech approach to compliance is not only more efficient but it is also more effective. As we roll out more modules available through RSA Archer, our enterprise risk management system, we are focusing on continuing our success in meeting the enhanced regulatory requirements that will accrue as we grow.
Our unsecured lending platform is currently being used to originate loans to H&R Block franchisees, and we're going to log the software platform in the third fiscal quarter of 2017. The speed and efficiency achieved in building this platform is another indication of how our investment in software development and user experience will be monetized in the future. We expect to start this business slowly and conservatively, so we can ensure we originate loans that perform in accordance with our loss expectations.
Our 38% efficiency ratio is higher than the annual efficiency ratio that we expect to achieve in the fiscal year because of the seasonality of our tax-related revenue. Our efficiency ratio will be significantly lower in quarters when we receive the bulk of our seasonal tax-related fee income streams, specifically, our fiscal third quarter of 2017.
We will continue to invest in new businesses and new technologies that will help us sustain diverse and profitable growth. These investments have included expanding our software development team, user experience team and project management group to approximately 70 people.
We also have staff dedicated to better linking our CRM systems across the enterprise to improve cross-sell, the launch of retail auto and consumer installment lending, new systems and software in risk and compliance group to support organic growth and other new incubator businesses.
While our future in -- investment in the future is significant, we believe these long-term strategic investments are controlled, reasonably sized and will augment our organic growth and future competitive position. I believe the company is better positioned from a financial, operational, personnel and leadership perspective than we've ever been in the past. The investments we are making are well-controlled with clear and measurable risk and return initiatives. As we've proven in the past, we are methodically developing new businesses and scaling them in a cost effective and controlled manner. After we perfected the operational, regulatory and system functions, we can further diversify our funding and fee income streams without taking undue credit risk.
Before I turn the call over to Andy to discuss our financial results, I wanted to comment briefly on another rambling and absurd short seller hit piece that was published 2 days ago. As this amateurish, short-seller hit piece rambled through its laughably silly innuendo, it appeared to allege that BofI has a financial interest or some sort of economic and legal exposure to a loan either to or guaranteed by Jason Galanis. I wanted to clarify BofI has no interest, credit exposure or ownership of any loan, any kind of loan to Jason Galanis or any loan in which Jason Galanis is a guarantor including the $7 million loan mentioned in this hit piece.
I'll provide a brief update on our litigation. As I said last quarter, I'll not be spending much time on this because these law suits are old news. The events alleged by disgruntled former junior employee, Erhart, happened almost 1 year and 9 months ago by his account. One of the world's largest law firms has conducted an independent investigation of his allegation and found his allegations to be without factual basis and cleared management of any alleged wrong doing.
Subsequently, the bank has completed 2 record-setting fiscal years; closed 2 acquisitions that both required regulatory approval; successfully completed 2 full annual examinations, 2 mid-cycle examinations and multiple Federal Reserve regulatory examinations.
The bank remains in strong regulatory standing with no enforcement actions; has not been fined a single dollar by any regulatory agency; has not been required to modify its products or business practices. Additionally, we do not foresee any future impact to the underlying business as a result of the frivolous lawsuits and short-seller hit pieces.
Our management team and employees remain focused on running the business. Due to the nature of the ongoing litigation, I'll not answer any question regarding our legal matters on this call in the question-and-answer session.
With that, I'll turn the call over to Andy.