Earnings Labs

Bio-Techne Corporation (TECH)

Q3 2024 Earnings Call· Wed, May 1, 2024

$53.58

-2.78%

Key Takeaways · AI generated
AI summary not yet generated for this transcript. Generation in progress for older transcripts; check back soon, or browse the full transcript below.

Same-Day

+2.91%

1 Week

+10.14%

1 Month

+5.68%

vs S&P

-1.18%

Transcript

Operator

Operator

Good morning, and welcome to the Bio-Techne Earnings Conference Call for the Third Quarter of Fiscal Year 2024. At this time, all participants have been placed in a listen-only mode and the call will be open for questions following management’s prepared remarks. During our Q&A session, please limit yourself to one question and one follow-up. I would now like to turn the call over to David Clair, Bio-Techne’s Vice President, Investor Relations. Please go ahead.

David Clair

Management

Good morning and thank you for joining us. On the call with me this morning are Kim Kelderman, President and Chief Executive Officer; and Jim Hippel, Chief Financial Officer of Bio-Techne. Before we begin, let me briefly cover our safe harbor statement. Some of the comments made during this conference call may be considered forward-looking statements, including beliefs and expectations about the company’s future results. The company’s 10-K for fiscal year 2023 identifies certain factors that could cause the company’s actual results to differ materially from those projected in the forward-looking statements made during this call. The company does not undertake to update any forward-looking statements because of any new information or future events or developments. The 10-K as well as the company’s other SEC filings are available on the company’s website within its Investor Relations section. During the call, non-GAAP financial measures may be used to provide pertinent to ongoing business performance. Tables reconciling these measures to the most comparable GAAP measures are available in the company’s press release issued earlier this morning on the Investor Relations section of our Bio-Techne Corporation website at www.bio-techne.com. Separately, we will be presenting at the Bank of America, Benchmark, Leerink, William Blair, Jefferies and Scotiabank conferences in the coming weeks. We look forward to connecting with many of you at these upcoming events. I will now turn the call over to Kim.

Kim Kelderman

Management

Thanks, Dave, and good morning, everyone. Thank you for joining us for our third quarter conference call. I’m pleased to report that our third quarter outperformed our initial expectations as several of the green shoots we’ve discussed during our last earnings call continue to sprout and combined with excellent execution by our Bio-Techne team contributed to delivering 2% year-over-year organic revenue growth. We’re looking forward to seeing these green shoots further develop as the headwinds we have faced, namely the biotech funding and the macroeconomic challenges in China continue to stabilize and eventually improve. Our team demonstrated that our product portfolio can show relative strong performance in the stabilizing but still challenging end markets. And therefore, we are confident that we can perform extremely well when our end markets fully recover. Additionally, we delivered this quarter’s growth while we continue to focus on profitability. The recent initiatives to drive efficiencies across the organization while investing to position the business for future growth are taking hold. And this shows by our adjusted operating margin increasing sequentially by 290 basis points to 33%. Our growth pillars within our portfolio continue to lead to our strong performance with a new quarterly record for our GMP reagents business, a continued increase in adoption of our ExoDx Prostate test, robust utilization trends across our proteomic analytical tools portfolio and strong demand for Comet, a fully automated special biology instrument. I will double-click on these highlights and encouraging trends later in the call. First, I’d like to bring to your attention. The Bio-Techne’s recent recognition by CiteAb, a reagent search and data services company. Bio-Techne did not receive just one, but two awards. The first award I would like to mention was received for being the ELISA Kit Supplier of the Year. This important designation is…

Jim Hippel

Management

Thank you, Kim. I’ll start with some additional detail on our Q3 financial performance and then give some thoughts on the financial outlook for the remainder of the fiscal year. Starting with the overall third quarter financial performance. Adjusted EPS was $0.48 compared to $0.53 in the prior year quarter, with foreign exchange having a material impact on EPS. GAAP EPS for the quarter was $0.31 compared to $0.43 in the prior year. Q3 revenue was $303.4 million, an increase of 2% year-over-year on an organic basis and a 3% increase on a reported basis. Acquisitions contributed 1% to reported growth. Looking at our organic growth by region and end market in Q3. North America increased low single digits year-over-year, while Europe and China decreased mid-single digits. As Kim mentioned, we noticed an improvement in demand from our biopharma customers, which benefited growth in both our North American and European regions. Overall, Europe had a challenging year-over-year comp as both academic and biopharma increased mid-teens last year. APAC outside of China decreased low single digits overall, with government funding and macro constraints in Japan and South Korea, partially offset by growth in India. For China, the soft government funding environment continued to impact the region. Although the stabilization we experienced in our run rate business in December continued in Q3. This stabilization led to year-over-year growth in our core reagents as well as our spatial biology business in the region. It appears as though the worst of the China slowdown is behind us at this point. And over the long-term, we remain confident that China will still be the fastest-growing major region in the world for life science tools. However, the path back to accelerated growth, we think will take longer than previous down cycles. By end market in Q3,…

Operator

Operator

Thank you. [Operator Instructions] The first question comes from the line of Puneet Souda with Leerink Partners. Please go ahead.

Puneet Souda

Analyst

Hi Kim, Jim, thanks for taking my questions. So first of all, look, congrats on the quarter, and it’s really good to see some recovery here in the core business. But based on what you’re seeing today, I know it’s still a bit nascent, but wondering if, Jim, if we can start to get to potentially sort of high single-digit, if not 10% plus organic growth in fiscal year 2025 as we – as you turn the chapter here for the next year and comps do get easier as well. So just wondering, when you look at the accounts, what would you like to see in order to potentially see a line of sight to that high single-digit or maybe 10% plus?

Jim Hippel

Management

Yes, Puneet, thanks for the question. Like as we said before, you look at our track record, both during the COVID era upswing, but also during last almost a couple of years, what we call the COVID hangover, our organic growth rates have been consistently between 500 basis points to 1,000 basis points better than the overall market when you combine it. And this quarter appears to be no different. And so that gives us confidence in our portfolio, positioning gives us confidence in our team’s execution. And bottom line is that when market returns back to its historical growth rates of mid-single digit, we expect that gap in our performance relative to the market to be at least the same, if not better. So the real question is when do the markets get that mid-single-digit growth? And when they do, we believe we’ll be if not high single-digit, will be well in double-digit kind of growth territory. And that’s an open question. And the analysts and our peers, and we all debate that. But the good news is that there’s green shoots ahead of us as opposed to perceived headwinds. And so that’s exactly why we’ll be monitoring that very closely here as we prepare our own operating plans to prepare for that. But I’m not going to sit here and try to predict exactly when the markets come back to their kind of normal rate. But the sentiment is definitely going to be improving. And at least from the analyst reports that are out there, the dollars seem to be behind it as well.

Puneet Souda

Analyst

Okay. That’s helpful. And then maybe, Kim, when you look at the biopharma customers, just wondering, I mean, obviously, there’s some excitement with funding in the first quarter. As you look at the early-stage customers as you had the conversations, wondering how much of those dollars could potentially come to the discovery stage where you are more stronger versus the developmental stages of therapeutics. And then on the cell and gene therapy side, could you elaborate a bit more on the 40% growth that you’re seeing in GMP, how sustainable is that, just given the sort of the environment we’re in currently?

Kim Kelderman

Management

Yes. Thank you, Puneet. Regarding pharma and the early funding, thank you, you and I have discussed in earlier this quarter, I do believe that funding would be seen to flow through earliest for the consumables part, right? So we do believe that CapEx, larger events will have a little bit longer of a lead time before their fundings flow through. We also do know like we mentioned earlier, that there is a couple of months that we now have seen good funding for the pharma, biopharma areas. And we do know that there’s usually two quarters or so of a delay before that funding flows into the business. I think that overall, this looks very good right now. But as I also mentioned, those are only trends for three months, and we had some disastrous months at the end of the calendar year. So yes, good indication. It looks like a green shoot, looks like things are going up, but it’s early days, and therefore, we want to be careful that prognosis. The cell and gene therapy, it has been outpacing our overall company’s growth for a long time. I think it’s a very strong product line as are all four of our verticals. And I think that we are having a great opportunity there. We have the best reagents to place in that space. And as you know, we have a real good opportunity to consolidate all our reagents into the GRx [ph] for the cell and gene therapy space. So we’re very bullish on it. We do know that some of these quarters can be very – can be a little bit lumpy because of the larger orders from the companies that are food in their pipeline and that really can make a quarter swing. However, we saw really strong growth in the earlier-stage companies. And that will give us a better foundation because if more of these 400 customers or so that we have started ordering earlier in their pipelines that will give us a more stable foundation to continue to put up great numbers. But for now, we are, of course, very encouraged with our play in cell and gene therapy and are very glad to see here some momentum building in that end market.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Mr. Souda please rejoin the queue for more questions. Next question comes from the line of Jacob Johnson with Stephens Inc. Please go ahead.

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst · Stephens Inc. Please go ahead.

Good morning. This is Mac on for Jacob. Just a few quick ones for me. I appreciate the commentary around biopharma in China. There’s been some muted commentary from most of your peers recently, but also the prospect around the stimulus that you mentioned earlier. So I’m curious as to what you’re watching for to signal an improved backdrop in that country at this point in time?

Kim Kelderman

Management

Yes. Thanks, Mac. As you know, we are big believers of the situation in China improving over time and that this will be as it used to be a true growth driver for the business. As you know, we also had three real tough quarters in China right now, and that’s mainly paced by the lack of funding. We do hear there also some green shoots of funding efforts. And yes, we are keeping our eye to the floor there that the momentum will continue build, specifically for instrumentation. We know that the $70 billion funding that’s laid out or the loan that the government is laying out is aimed at improving and innovating the instrumentation base. And we think we can benefit from that funding. And in the meantime, we hear positive – positivity from our sales force. They talk to their customers and the customers are getting more interested about hearing the benefits our automation brings. And our automation brings consistency, it’s very efficient and it’s got fast results. So that value proposition fits really, really well with the new funding potentially flowing through into China.

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst · Stephens Inc. Please go ahead.

And then just quickly, is there anything that you think you need to change or could change to better capitalize on opportunities in the current environment? Or as it relates to your go-to-market strategy? Or do you think a reacceleration in growth largely depends on the macro environment?

Kim Kelderman

Management

Yes, I think it’s the latter. The – it’s clear that we have a very efficient sales force in China. We’ve always done really well in the region. We feel we have the right coverage, direct versus indirect. And I think that we’ve got the right product positioning. In addition to that, we are, as you know, investing in China for China GMP plant, which will also come in line over the coming quarters. And with that, I think we have the right portfolio, the right value proposition as well as the right go-to-market channels. So I’m very happy with the situation that we currently have there.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Mr. Johnson [ph], please rejoin the queue for more questions. Next question comes from the line of Patrick Donnelly with Citi. Please go ahead.

Patrick Donnelly

Analyst · Citi. Please go ahead.

Hey guys. Thanks for taking the questions. Maybe just one for you, Jim, just on the guidance piece. Can you talk about the margin side? It sounds like up sequentially, maybe in that mid-30s range for 4Q. Is that the right number to build off of as you think about next year? And then I just wanted to clarify on the revenue side? Is it the dollars are up sequentially in 4Q and the growth rate is similar to this 2% organic. I just want to make sure I have that right.

Jim Hippel

Management

Yes, sure. Thanks, Patrick. So first on the margin question. We talked about for a couple of quarters now that our goal was to get that to mid-30s type margin by the time we exit this fiscal year. It’s not a slam dunk to do that. We still got a ways to go to get from 33 [ph] to that point, but it’s not out of reach at this point. So I think, honestly, where the consensus has us right now feels about right for Q4, which gives us a nice launching pad into fiscal year 2025. And it’s really going to depend on the revenue where the markets are and what – I’ve already talked about our expectation of growth above and beyond the market growth. So as you saw from Q2 to Q3, the amount of margin expansion we had on the increased volume and much of that is seasonal. We have amazing pull-through, amazing gross margins in our products. So when you get that volume it contributes tremendously to the bottom line. And of course, we continue to invest because we’re investing for the long term. We’ve got these amazing growth pillars that we have to continue to kind of feed those bees so they can reach their full potential five years, 10 years down the road. So we’ll be balancing that as we go through our operating plan this year and look forward to providing you some more insight to that next call. With regards to the revenue question, to be clear, have clarity on that. As I mentioned, we do believe that revenues will be slightly higher in Q4 than Q3. But the organic growth percentage year-over-year might be a bit challenged, mainly because of the tough comp we have in China. If you think about China last year, we had mid-teens growth versus where it’s running right now, being 8% to 10% of our business, that’s up 1.5 points of headwind just in itself. So that’s kind of where we’re at right now in terms of the range of organic growth.

Patrick Donnelly

Analyst · Citi. Please go ahead.

Okay. Understood. And then, Kim, maybe just on – I think it was last week, you guys announced the expanded Fisher agreement into Europe. Can you just talk about the opportunity there, how impactful that could be as we work our way to 2025 for you guys? Just trying to wrap my head around that agree.

Kim Kelderman

Management

Yes. Thank you, Patrick. Thermo Fisher Scientific has a ton of capabilities, but one of the big ones is the Fisher Scientific channels, and that channel provides great reach and ease of use for transactions for our customers. As you might know, we’ve had a distribution agreement, a very similar one in the U.S. since 2014, so for about 10 years now. And we’re very, very comfortable and used to collaborating with the Fisher channel. I can expect a similar trend and a similar setup in Europe, where our European customers can benefit from the commercial footprint, the reach and also the ease of transactions that come with dealing with the Fisher Scientific channel. And of course, this convenience and this reach is very important for us as well. And therefore, we can – we hope that we can serve our customers better. Nonetheless, of course, Bio-Techne will maintain and grow our direct channels as we have done in the U.S.A. as well. And we will make sure that we fine-tune and work really well together with the Fisher channel and collaborate to eventually optimize our customers’ convenience and the reach we have as a company.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Mr. Donnelly, please rejoin the queue for more questions. Next question comes from the line of Justin Bowers with Deutsche Bank. Please go ahead.

Justin Bowers

Analyst · Deutsche Bank. Please go ahead.

Hi. Good morning. I just want to pivot back to the cell and gene end market and the strength there. Can you talk about sort of what you’re seeing in that customer cohort? And is the durability of that growth over the next couple of quarters, supported by existing programs and customers? Or do you need to see sort of new customer activity? Or is that just sort of like greenfield for you on the go forward?

Kim Kelderman

Management

Yes. Thank you, Justin, for the question. As I mentioned earlier, I think our cell and gene therapy play is just very strong because of the different products we sell into it, right? As you know, we have a 20% stake in Wilson Wolf, and Wilson Wolf have this GRx, which is a container that makes it really easy and efficient to grow – to grow T cells. To grow these T cells, you would need our core products. So we have our GMP proteins, cytokines, chemokines to make sure that you can fine-tune the growth of these T cells. And these are all very high-value ingredients to the cell and gene therapy market. We do know that, for example, the GRx is in about half let’s say, 45% of all the clinical trials that are going on in this space, we know that we are obviously very keen on making sure that all our ingredients are being used in that setup just as well. So we create the pull-through. We’ve seen fantastic growth in our GMP proteins and that are now on basing at an annualized revenue of about $60 million. And yes, we’re very proud that we had a record quarter. As I mentioned earlier, it can be a little lumpy because they are the larger customers that are in the back end of their clinicals where volumes go higher, and that will create some variation of results quarter-over-quarter. But overall, we have seen consistent very high growth within this space. And we know that more and more companies are entering the race because cell and gene therapy has been shown to be able to cure diseases we previously not have been able to find any solutions for us, so we’re very excited about this space.

Justin Bowers

Analyst · Deutsche Bank. Please go ahead.

Okay. So it sounds like increased pull-through and scaling up? And then on Wilson Wolf what are trends like there? Is that still stable? Or is it starting to grow again? Any commentary there would be helpful?

Kim Kelderman

Management

Yes, Wilson Wolf, as I mentioned, participate in 45% of all the clinicals. There are several of these companies that we collaborate with that have now reached the finish line and are commercializing, which is a very good indication, and we’re over half of those. And then last but not least, overall, the company started growing again in double digits, it’s – it’s sitting this quarter in around 14%, and it has a fantastic run rate. And as you can imagine, really, really high margins north of 72%, and yes, we’re very, very happy to see that Wilson Wolf is having such traction in this important market, specifically because we know that Bio-Techne will definitely benefit from it with our reagent. But also over time, we will own the company, and we will then have the data benefit as well.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Mr. Bowers, please rejoin the queue for more questions. Next question comes from the line of Dan Arias with Stifel. Please go ahead.

Dan Arias

Analyst · Stifel. Please go ahead.

Hey, good morning guys. Thanks. Kim, on the spatial business, what do you see as the time line for getting production on Comet? Where it needs to be in order to meet demand? And then it’s firming up the manufacturing plan and you’re getting ready to pay ACD and Lunaphore. Can you just maybe refresh the view on what you think the spatial portfolio should grow at going forward?

Kim Kelderman

Management

Yes. Thank you, Dan. The production constraints are really, really facing the output right now. We are really happy, first and foremost, that we see the demand that we would like, right, and then actually exceeding expectations. So that’s the most important fundamental. We do believe that during this quarter, the quarter we’re currently in that we will get very close to what our book is. But the real status quo where we can produce as many Comets as that get ordered will be in our first fiscal year quarter. So the third calendar quarter and then we will continue to reel in the backlog in the first half of our fiscal year. You asked about my enthusiasm in spatial, it’s huge. Obviously, it’s a very fast-growing market, and you’ve been – you’ve gotten used to ACD being a real winner in the reagent space, with all the benefits that we know about it. And then Comet, it’s early days. But if we compare the system to other peer systems in the field, we know that Comet is the only instrument that has a full workflow automation, right? So there’s no manual interference or manual steps in the workflow. The Comet you can use any antibodies that you’ve used to utilize in your workflow. We have 50,000 RNA targets, a truly multiomic machine. So you can see your protein and your RNA targets sanely in the same slide. As you know, Bio-Techne has 400,000 antibodies. So there’s plenty of choice to pick from in order to boost our pull-through on the instrument. And as you know, we can run four slides in parallel, and there we have the highest throughput in the market. So I’m extremely pleased with our positioning from a reagent as well as from an automation point of view, and we will continue to work to make our reagents, our antibodies as what the system seamlessly working together from some preparation [ph] all the way to image analysis to eventually make it most convenient for our customers to perform their special biology test.

Dan Arias

Analyst · Stifel. Please go ahead.

Okay. And then, Jim, just maybe to round out your comments related to the finish to the fiscal year here. You touched on margins. I just wanted to ask about the top line. It sounds like you’re expecting similar conditions, but you have the slightly tougher comp overall, China notably hard. Does that translate to some modest growth in 4Q? What’s the outlook there?

Jim Hippel

Management

Yes, we’re absolutely – we absolutely are helping on – stay in the black for sure, so in terms of growth.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Mr. Arias, please rejoin the queue for more questions. Next question comes from the line of Matt Larew with William Blair. Please go ahead.

Matt Larew

Analyst · William Blair. Please go ahead.

Hi. Good morning. I wanted to follow-up on Lunaphore. And the investments you’re making today to scale up manufacturing, would you say that generally they’re within the bounds of what you expected to make just perhaps they’re pulled forward? Or I guess the flip side of that would be; do you have different or worse expectations about the long-term margin potential. So just trying to get a sense for whether this is scale up to meet accelerated demand or perhaps something you discovered once you did the deal?

Kim Kelderman

Management

That was a very good question, Matt. No, fortunately, it’s not something we discovered. It’s truly an outpacing of the orders versus our initial projections. And we had lofty projections but the traction in the market is just overwhelming. And that means that we have to increase our in-house capacity, which, of course, is something that we’re very used to do. We have a fantastic operations team in Switzerland that gets supported by operations teams from the U.S. just as well and from across other businesses such as the ProteinSimple business, very much used to producing high-volume instrumentation. So I’m very confident we can increase that capacity. But as you can imagine, the pull-through also hit some of the vendors. So also there, we have to make sure that we help out with the upscaling of certain critical parts that the vendors are having to get used to these new volumes, right? So overall, we just have to beef up the capacity. It’s a great thing. By now, it’s a good problem to have, and we’re very confident that we can resolve this and there is no other underlying constrained or issue that we are aware of.

Matt Larew

Analyst · William Blair. Please go ahead.

Okay. That’s great to hear. The next question is about ScaleReady and the components of that. So your own GMP protein business, partnership and Wilson Wolf; just curious now that it’s been out there for a little while. What kind of feedback you’ve been getting if there’s any way to talk about how that’s translated to win rates? Is that a driver of some of the pickup in GMP proteins? And obviously, Wilson Wolf has been some market leading technology. I think there probably is some looming competition out there. Beyond just integration to offer a more full and automated solution like you’re trying to do already, are there also additional areas for platform improvement with GRx or that broader suite as well?

Kim Kelderman

Management

Yes. Thank you for the question. I just have to say that when I talk to our customers in the cell and gene therapy space, ScaleReady has a real good reputation. So it’s truly a brand now in that particular space. And of course, it has a full solution for cell and gene therapy customers. And that’s why I believe that you see such traction in not only the volume of the G-Rex and the revenue associated with it, but also in the pull-through of proteins the cytokines and chemokines that we – customers end up using in that setup. It’s a complete solution. It’s scalable, and it’s relatively easy to implement compared to some of the competitive workflows. And yes, I think that is a chicken and the egg, right? ScaleReady is doing really well because that’s a fantastic solution. And the other way around, the customers do get to enjoy the solution because the ScaleReady team is really efficient in bringing it to market and educating our customers about the benefit of the solution we have.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Mr. Larew, please rejoin the queue for more questions. Next question comes from the line of Catherine Schulte with Baird. Please go ahead

Catherine Schulte

Analyst · Baird. Please go ahead

Hey guys, thanks for the questions. Organic growth came in about four points better than what you’ve guided. You talked about China stabilizing, but that sounded like it played out as you expected. So can you just talk through what drove that upside versus your expectations? Was it really broad-based? Or was there a particular product category or end market that’s surprised?

Jim Hippel

Management

Yes. Hi, Catherine, this is Jim. Thanks for the question. Yes. I mean, I think generally speaking, the broad-based market performed as we expected. As you mentioned, China overall those as we expected as well. I think there is – if you look within the Protein Sciences, it gets back to our growth pillars and how resilient they are even in this down cycle we’ve been in. So a two point I’d call out would be one was cell and gene therapy. So we always said that when biotech funding came back, we believe that cell and gene therapy will be one of the first places you’d see it. And I’m not saying there’s a direct correlation there, but definitely a positive sign. And it was a bit of a surprise for us how quickly cell and therapy rebounded for us here in the third quarter. And again, we saw the same thing over, as Kim mentioned, in Wilson Wolf as well. So that was very encouraging. It was not necessarily in our outlook a quarter ago. The other growth pillar within Protein Sciences was within our instrument, proteomics instrument portfolio and even more specifically, Simple Western. Simple Western performed extremely well and actually grew double digit in instruments as well as consumables. So also a very good sign because we always figured that when the instrument market came back, that would be the first part of our portfolio that we would see it given it’s a broad base of applications. It’s also very used widely in cell and gene therapy, and it’s very the most underpenetrated of our three platforms. So that was not necessarily in our outlook a quarter ago, and it was very nice to see that come back so strong here this quarter. And then if I turn over to our diagnostics and genomics business, there is, I’d call out the surgeon business. As we talked about the growth rates there, we’re pretty much nearing our EPI test with Exosome. And – so very – one of the highest growth rates we’ve seen with the surgeon since we’ve owned the company and they got some new product launches out there are performing extremely well, and we think that momentum will continue. So that was also very nice to see.

Catherine Schulte

Analyst · Baird. Please go ahead

All right, great. Thank you. And then was there any stocking contribution from the European Fisher deal in the quarter? Or will there be any in the fiscal fourth quarter just given the timing of when you signed – just curious if there’s any stocking related to that partnership.

Kim Kelderman

Management

Catherine, thank you for the question. No, there were no such influences in this past quarter and don’t expect them in the next quarter either, specifically because the setup is that Fisher will bring in the leads, and we will ship directly from our warehouse. So you will not see any of those dynamics, if that makes sense.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Ms. Schulte, please rejoin the queue for more questions. Next question comes from the line of Sung Ji Nam with Scotia Bank. Please go ahead

Sung Ji Nam

Analyst · Scotia Bank. Please go ahead

Hi, thanks for taking the question and congratulations on the quarter. Maybe just on the academic end market perspective at this juncture. Just kind of curious, if you guys have visibility into that market, especially in the U.S. and Europe. Obviously, you’re seeing continued stable growth there, but potentially more difficult comps ahead. So just kind of curious what your outlook might be for the coming quarters.

Kim Kelderman

Management

Yes. I think that academic markets have – we’ve done pretty well in there. And overall, I must say we see a relatively stable environment, right, with the Horizon funding in Europe as well as in the U.S. So it’s a stable market. Of course, with the lull in the biotech industry, some of our innovative sales reps have found their way into some of the academic accounts as well and have started refocusing there. So there is a nice bump up for us by just having the right focus and the connections further developing between the customers in academic as well as the sales rep. So at the end of the day, I think this is not a something that is just for one quarter or two quarters. I think as long as the academic funding stays as it is or gets better, we will continue to see a benefit from that end market, and we will continue to be good or even better at serving it. So – and that’s what I expect for the coming quarters.

Sung Ji Nam

Analyst · Scotia Bank. Please go ahead

Got it. And then I also have a follow-up on Lunaphore and spatial bio. Just kind of curious, it may be early, but are you seeing competitive wins on Lunaphore currently? And just for the spatial bio addressable market in general, just kind of curious what’s driving the – other than your performance there, just from an end market standpoint, are there a disproportional funding going towards your addressable market, current environment, do you think? Or – just kind of any color would be great. Thank you.

Kim Kelderman

Management

Yes. Thanks for your question around spatial biology end markets. I do believe that end market is under less pressure than other end markets. It’s just such an important tool into determining which biomarker you’re going after. It’s just a new way of doing your research and validating your results. So it’s here to stay, and that market will continue to grow significantly, and we believe that it will grow double digits for the foreseeable future. Yes, we see competitive wins, as I mentioned earlier, when Dan asked the question, there are tremendous benefits from a Comet automation system over other systems that are in the market are reagents, their antibodies are also in the lead and very unique in that market. So that combination is just very strong. And if I look at some of the trends in the market, yes, we have been able to sell Comets into accounts that have experience with other systems. But an even stronger signal is the moment we found that customers want a second Comet, right? And then now we have several larger pharma companies that have ordered the third one. So that means it’s not only a good value proposition at the moment you buy it, but it’s still a really good value proposition the moment you use it, and that gives them real first-hand experience, and that gives me confidence that, that workflow is indeed a real strong value position compared to the other solutions in the market.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Ms. Ji Nam [ph], please rejoin the queue for more questions. Next question comes from the line of Paul Knight with KeyBanc Capital Markets. Please go ahead

Paul Knight

Analyst · KeyBanc Capital Markets. Please go ahead

Hi, yes Kim, thanks for the time and Jim as well. The Protein Simple business, could you kind of highlight one of the fastest-growing portions of the product line. How large is Protein Simple now as well? And just a refresh there would be great.

Jim Hippel

Management

Yes. Paul, this is Jim. So thanks for the question. Good to hear from you. Not given the size of so much on the by product line anymore. We try to avoid that from a competitive perspective. But as I highlighted in earlier – as an answer to earlier question, I think the Simple Western platform specifically was a highlight of that portfolio this quarter with double-digit growth overall and double-digit growth in both instrument placements as well as consumables. That being said, our entire instrument portfolio has been very resilient through this downturn. Despite struggles with the instrument placements the last several quarters, the consumables on all three platforms continue to offset that to keep those product lines in a very stable state overall. So we’re very pleased with how those – our instrument portfolio has performed and gives us that kind of great confidence that when the market normal, as no [ph] markets normalize, we’ll see accelerated growth in that portfolio once again.

Paul Knight

Analyst · KeyBanc Capital Markets. Please go ahead

And then you mentioned in the past potential revenue, the GMP facility or maybe expressed as capacity and dollar revenue. Where are you – where is your thinking now on capacity of your GMP business?

Jim Hippel

Management

Capacity is not – yes, capacity is no longer an issue. We’re probably stop talking about it because I think we have capacity could last as a decade or more, to be honest with you at least as it pertains to our GMP proteins for the CAR-T for the immunotherapy market. We still have some capacity that we need to build out for our regenerative medicine side of our – the GMP protein business. But as it pertains to what that facility was specifically built for, which is the immunotherapy side of cell therapy market. Capacity will not be an issue for a decade or more to come.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, we have reached the end of question-and-answer session. I would now like to turn the floor over to Kim Kelderman for closing comments.

Kim Kelderman

Management

Yes. Thank you, and thank you, everybody, for joining the call today and for the insightful questions. I’m extremely proud of the Bio-Techne team’s accomplishments in this dynamic environment, and I’m also proud of the results we’ve been able to deliver in this quarter. Our differentiated portfolio addresses some of the highest growth markets in life sciences and is positioned to deliver best-in-class performance, for all our stakeholders going forward. Thank you very much for joining the call.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. This concludes today’s teleconference. You may disconnect your lines at this time. Thank you for your participation.