Paul Manning
Analyst · Robert W. Baird & Co. Please go ahead
Yeah. I think with that volume, as I just gave you for 2025, those expectations and low single-digit pricing, we expect to continue to get this nice operating leverage, maybe not to the levels you're seeing right now. This is in part recovery from last year's weaker Q3, weaker Q4. But yeah, I think -- as you think about 2025, what's going to feed into that. First and foremost, it's always new wins. That is the fundamentally most important metric we track as a company. That is the true barometer of the strength of the strategy, the strength of our execution, strength of our service levels, the strength of our product technologies, all governance starts as I see it with new win rates, which continue for us to be very, very high, I think, kind of low to mid-teens rate as a percentage of revenue. So that's going to, I think, continue in earnest. And so couple of the variances that we expect to potentially play out a little bit differently in 2025. So number one, I mean, if the market, I would love it if the market would just be flat in Europe and North America. I'm not asking for a lot, just when it's down 2%, 3%, though, that's a little bit of a headwind. So my expectation is these markets in North America and Europe, our two largest markets would be largely flat. There would potentially be upside to the market growth of LatAm and of course, in Asia. And as much as you hear talk out of China, we still see growth in China, perhaps it's not as strong as it has been in the past, but it's still solid, strong growth for us. So I think that will be a positive. One of the things we saw during COVID, you heard a lot of companies talking about SKU rationalization, right? It's like, hey, we can't even get our core products on the shelf, forget product number 300, that drives a very small part of our revenue. And so many of our customers, many CPG companies commissioned programs around SKU rationalization, which takes time and they can be complex. And so some of the discontinuations that we have seen in the market in 2023 and in 2024, I believe, and I think we could say that across most of our businesses, I would point to a lot of these initiatives around SKU rationalization, I'd like to think that, that could moderate in 2025, but my crystal ball is a little foggy on that one. But if discontinuation rates subside a little bit, that could be another touch of upside. To your point about the portfolio optimization, we remain on track there. I think that's going to go very, very well. We expect to have very, very strong savings from that program. As you recall, we estimated $8 million to $10 million of savings. We remain on track there. We expect on the cost side of that, the $40 million of charges. We're still right about in that ballpark with, again, the vast majority of that being non-cash related. So the timing of those, some of that is 2024. Some that is 2025. Some of that is 2026. So I think that would certainly give further credence to our operating leverage projections and our improvements in operating profit growth. But I think the big thing and the question that folks have is like, hey, guys, the EBITDA growth looks good and the profit looks good. Why is that not translating to EPS growth? And there's two words, tax and interest. That's why. And so you look at 17% OP growth in Q3, and you're like, why is it 8% EPS, tax and interest, and those are the single biggest headwinds to EPS growth and why we're not getting that flow through. So you'll start to see us lapping some of that here in Q4. You heard Tobin estimate substantially higher growth rates on EPS. And so tax, we expect that not to be a headwind in 2025. So that's an important flow through to EPS. And interest rates, you saw a headwind there. I think that's somewhere around the order about $0.08 for the year in terms of EPS headwind interest. So I'd like to think that, that will also not be a headwind and possibly could be a slight tailwind with less debt and potentially actions from the Fed. So those are some of the variances that we would, at this point, as I'm sitting here in late October, we could reasonably project for 2025.