Barry Sternlicht
Analyst · Credit Suisse. Please proceed with your question
Thank you, Zach. Thank you, Rina and thank you, Jeff and good morning, everyone. Welcome to our earnings call. Thanks for being with us. I usually start with the economy and those of you who have seen me on TV, I’ve been fairly aggressively trying to get the Fed to stop raising rates and let the impact of what they have done, the largest increase in rates, the fastest increase in rates in the history of the country, coupled with the balance sheet reduction, coupled with the OCC telling most of the banks to cut back lending and shrink their balance sheets, has created incredibly tight conditions. And I saw a report this morning that construction in the U.S. has dropped 27%, that’s commercial construction. Obviously, single-family homes have fallen off a cliff. And when we complete this wave of construction, I would expect many projects to get tabled. When we look back at the great financial crisis and where job losses were they were really in two categories: manufacturing and construction. And if you look at manufacturing, which is about to go negative, you will get some of the job losses in manufacturing. Construction will be a tug of war between commercial projects ending for private developers and whatever it is the government gets their act together to spend their $1 billion infrastructure budget. So that can be a little harder, which is one of the reasons I wonder where the Fed is going to be effective, knocking jobs off without actually destroying real wages and real jobs across the service economy. During ‘07, ‘08, ‘09, actually education and healthcare went up. So you can’t change that with interest rates. So the only place that really hurt the economies in the service sector which would be retail, travel, airlines and things of that such. Business services already let go 400,000 people, but you see the first and the largest dichotomy between unemployment claims and job layoffs. And it’s never happened before, but this has been a white-collar recession. All these people are getting unemployment benefits, and you’ll see these numbers show up when the unemployment benefits, which could last as long as 6 months from tech companies actually come off. I think the economy, you’re seeing the numbers from Target and grown from retailers and yet you see these retail prints. I think that was clearing of inventories in January because, obviously, everybody wants to restock for the summer. And people forget that because of inflation, when you’re getting a retail number up 3, it’s actually down 2 because prices are up 6. So you’re getting a nominal growth, but you’re not getting unit volume. And eventually, the unit volume will fall further than the price increases, and you’ll see those let up. The other thing I think about inflation, which will definitely head south, as I said, and we’re just waiting for these rent data to fall into the CPI. And that’s the single reason the government was so late raising rents, when rents were up 13% to 20% in the United States. It wasn’t in the Fed CPI numbers because of the delay in their reporting. And now that rents are falling, they are still having them rising. And it’s black and white. It’s not – it’s a fact. I don’t know why they choose to do that one category with such a lag. But eventually, we expect – I’ve said inflation could actually go negative – it will depend on other categories right now, I think, given the world complex. And the reopening of China is great. I don’t expect it to be super inflationary. Basically, it will help the supply chain and finish the when you’re building a building and you can’t get the dishwasher you need all the components of the building there. If 80% of the supply chain is fixed, you need 100% of the supply chain to be fixed to actually get things done on time and on budget. So I wouldn’t call that in and of itself necessarily inflationary, but actually, you could argue it’s deflationary. If demand comes down, the supply increases, prices will fall. And that really goes to the structure in the company, and that’s why I set it up that way. Let’s talk about the real estate landscape for a second. It is a bit of a minefield. You can’t really tell looking at companies in private or public today what’s going on exactly in these companies because many of us have floating rate debt, which is fantastic. Our earnings are going up with floating rate debt. Our borrowers, most of whom have caps in place and can pay us until the loan maturity. And also, you’ll see the key is the asset class they have, of course, and what’s happened to rents and the time we made those loans or we as an industry made loans and the banks, I’ll include the bank and the insurance companies in this. And then, of course, what could they can refinance that and where the spreads are and where rates are. So in general, this probably is as good an opportunity to put capital out as it was in 2009 when we started Starwood Property Trust in a way, I wish we had a $900 million blind pool that we had in 2009. We’ve never seen spreads like this. Construction loans, I was in Washington the other day, and I was driving near a site and driver told me that they made a loan on a hotel at SOFR plus 950, a new construction loan at 60% of cost. It’s 14% for new loans. I mean I’d love to own the hotel at $0.60 of construction costs. I back up the truck, end up empty the kids’ trust and make that loan today. Many of the companies were not – are not in a position to do that right now. We’re mostly paying defense and picking and choosing where to deploy the capital. But we can’t wait to go back on offense. And we will as soon as we see the landscape clear and the Fed basically says they are done. And what we expect to be a recession comes into place, forcing the Fed to probably lower rates. I saw a report yesterday that once they done as rates fall 200 basis points, it’s probably been pushed off a quarter or two because there is some remnants of rolling strength in the economy, but I still expect it to happen in the fourth quarter. So let’s talk about the asset classes for a second. A multifamily, which has become a bigger and bigger focus of our firm and our lending book is going to go through a little multifamily will be halted until not only your cap rates up because of financing is way up, the ability to get financing construction loans is gone. And you already have a 1.7 million housing shortage. So short and long-term, you’re going to see rents – they are actually – headline rents are going down, but in-place rents are going up because it’s the gap in these buildings in our portfolio alone on the loan book, Jeff tells me our rents have increased more than 20% since we started making those loans. So that they will hit their stabilized yields, we think, fairly quickly. And I would be delighted and sad, but delighted if we take the multis back because the long game for multi is excellent. There is no ChatGPT issue going to attack the residential sector. And because housing single-family home supply is going down, single-family construction costs are going up, interest rates and the cost of owning of home are going up, it makes rental homes that much more attractive. Long-term, the asset class is solid as a rock. And the values will be supported by over $250 billion of capital single-digit rate to buy multis. So the issues in other asset classes are going to help the multifamily asset class. People will run to it as a safe haven and away from things they can’t really understand or underwrite or they can’t get loans for. Multifamily sector, of course, is supported by Fannie and Freddie where spreads today are available like 200 over. Fixed rate debt is pretty cheap 130 to 150 over and that actually total cost of funds or fixed rate that is lower than floating cost at today. So if you want to park up some money away, if you’re a high net worth or in family, it’s an interesting place to invest even into the softness of the market at the moment. We make no doubt about, the Wall Street Journal, of course, writing 6 months after we talked about it, the supply has been evident. It’s coming through. It’s A class stuff. They are charging a fortune or trying to get the fortune in the B class assets will have a longer runway than the A class, which we will fight against each other and compete and probably – but will ease up because of the shortage of supply. Industrial has been a great market, going to a good market. The market is bifurcated again. The markets remain occupancies across the country remain solid big boxes are bonds. And so if you have an Amazon 15-year lease, you don’t have steps, your bond has negative convexity and the debt on industrial is not supported by a government agency. So it’s under more pressure from a cap rate perspective, but having the most solid and the strongest income growth of any asset class at the moment. You do wonder how that – if that slows down, which inevitably should and pricing has been under some strain. The office markets, you have a tale of two worlds, which is everything but the United States and the United States. Everywhere but the United States offices are leasing, I just – we have some investments in Europe, particularly in Germany. The vacancy rate in Berlin is 4%; in Munich, it’s less than that. Rents are up; in Munich, 12%. If you look at Asia, the Middle East, Korea, Japan, Australia, people have gone back to the office. It is a U.S. phenomenon probably led by the tech sector which has created this unusual situation in U.S. office. And in the U.S., you have a tale of two cities. You have newer buildings and, A, buildings leasing and everything else emptying. And it’s almost a one-for-one switch. So if you are in the A sector, you’re doing okay. You probably we were just renewing a lease in probably the worst office market in the United States is a start with Capital Group lease. We have 10 buildings to choose from A quality in San Francisco, and they are not lowering their rents, I was in credulous. I mean I can’t believe it. It’s like a 40% vacant market, and we have to pay more – much more than we’re paying today to be in the best buildings, there is very good demand for high-quality assets. And there is no demand at all for other assets. And over time, these buildings will be converted to other uses. They’ll become green silos in cities or waste lands indoor parks. I don’t know what will happen to them, but they will be removed from the stock unless people really go back to the office in a big way. I personally like being in the office. I don’t like working from home, but most of the younger generation actually likes working from Jackson Hole and Montauk. So I think that’s going to change in a recession. It has been easier for people to fire people that are not in their offices. You obviously don’t see them. You’re not attached to them, and they aren’t exactly raising the banner for the company and making it a great place to work. So I do think that will change. Having said that, the office markets are the toughest. It’s only 13% of our overall asset book, a little over 13%, as Jeff mentioned, which I think might be the lowest of any commercial mortgage REIT out there today. And we made that switch long ago. And as you know, we have almost no exposure to New York or for San Francisco to speak of in that portfolio, which has been two of the toughest markets. And interestingly, the red states, the Austins, the Nashvilles, that’s not a state; the Texas; Tennessee and Florida research triable a part those markets have performed pretty well. And continue to not only hold their occupancies better, there is fewer subletting. And they continue to attract space, and there is some net positive absorption in these cities. So you’re going city by city as you’d expect, and there is still a migration of people out of the blue states to the red states where there are no trade unions is the right to work. And obviously, there is no income taxes, and that will continue for the office markets. Hotels have been incredibly strong. One of the things you all know how much you’re paying for your hotel rooms, but you don’t pay his attention to is the hotel industry is missing almost 25% of its workers that it used to have in 2019, the rates are higher, but the workers aren’t there, so the margins are really good. And your service is probably not as good as it was. You should bring your own sheets to a hotel today because we’re not going to change them for you. That may change in January, half of the jobs added were in the hospitality industry. There is 250,000 jobs in the hospitality industry which went away – a long way back to hiring the people that they couldn’t hire. But the debt markets are a mess. Nobody wants to lend against hotels, which we would be delighted to step into that vacuum. It’s an asset class we obviously know very well. I’m not sure anyone has made more loans or bought more hotels than Starwood Capital Group in the last 30 years. And those are really the major groups. Data centers continue to be strong. We have credit issues you have to watch. And I think the key is that this is probably the best lending environment we’ve seen since 2009. Lease up 3 or 4x during the last 12 years of our existence. Like – are we 13 yet or still – 13.5. We’ve moaned and grown about too much competition or this is not an issue of that today because the lenders, the banks are on the sidelines, insurance companies are actually filling the void, but playing at low leverage. Given our background and credit, our knowledge of the markets, our real-time data from $120 billion asset base, we feel we could deploy capital extremely well and incredible spread in this market. But we’ve always not issued equity below book value. And if we were above book value, we love, we think we can make extraordinary loans today with a credible risk reward characteristics. But at the moment, we’re going to play defense and make sure we have the liquidity to handle anything that comes our way as we navigate through this unusual situation that the world finds itself in. What we’re doing here is really running multiple scenarios, which is we do nothing. And virtually nothing, we can earn our dividend earnings doing almost nothing, which is phenomenal and probably shocking, we have surprising to me at least. But it’s primarily because the floating rate book is carrying the firm and the loans. We always got repaid and not getting repaid is actually a good thing because we don’t have the downtime, the money doesn’t go into cash and we’re earning the coupon and they get paid currently. The other thing we’re doing is how do we get focus on turning the asset base over faster to look at things that are not earning their keep, and we’re earning, I would say, a 7 on the situation can be deployed at 14, maybe we sell the 7 take whatever small loss or might be to redeploy that capital in 14. The Last thing, of course, is to get the, as Jeff mentioned, the unproductive assets from our book out, whether it’s the buildings in Houston or the Tower in Los Angeles or the Chatsworth apartment, they are not contributing anything. They tie up capital in them. Their source of equity for us. And of course, we could sell additional liquid – we can create additional liquidity by selling additional interest in the Woodstar portfolio, our multifamily assets if we wanted to. We’ve not really wanted to do that. We have lots of ways to create liquidity for the firm on top of the $1.1 billion of liquidity we sit on today. So I think we’re excited about the opportunities. We’re cautious about the environment. It’s nice to have a special servicer, they are the largest in the country that will continue to perform and is a hell of a hedge against everything else going on in the world. They have unparalleled knowledge both in the CMBS markets and of the loan book. We employ something inside the firm, something like 16 people in IT who run the databases that power the LNR service business. We have information that is mind-boggling, and it’s been accumulated over 30 years. Actually, the head of servicing has been here 30 years and he’s one of the original employees of our company. They do an amazing job. And I think it will be an amazing opportunity for him to grow and add additional earnings to the company in the foreseeable future. The worse it gets, the better their life will be and the more they’ll learned. And today, we are roughly, I think, third of what we earned in the peak in ‘07, ‘08, something like that. So there is good upside, hopefully, for that business, which is not – is a pure ROE business. It doesn’t deploy any capital, raises the ROE of the firm and hopefully, we will see positive things. So that we don’t want to get too good because obviously it’s probably bad for the loan book if it’s too good. So I think we’re positioned to take advantage and what we’re looking for is to signal from the Fed that they are done. And I think the first thing that happens is spreads come in. AAA is the 200-plus over is an anomaly. It should not be that way. That fear in the market, there is tons of capital out there, it runs the equity market. I do think the equity markets are a bit ahead of themselves. You can see the speculation creep back in with AMC and Bed Bath & Beyond and all these companies they get rated by the guys I thought were dead. Immune stocks show up again, that is not healthy. We want these markets to settle down and be driven on fundamentals on a growth potential and really a fundamental analysis of the future and the cost of capital of equity and debt normalizing. I do think we can get back to 3% inflation. I’m not sure we can get to 2%. I don’t know how he could actually try to hold the number like that and you’re really going to just crush the economy and then try to balance to the 2% inflation that would be the visitor couldn’t do that. I am not even sure the lords themselves could actually make that happen. So their own power better be the lord because we’re going to need him and his team to actually do something that I think is virtually impossible. We have a great balance sheet today, a great fortress balance sheet. We’ve worked hard over the past decade to on outside our CLOs and our balance sheet debt, not repo debt. So we’ve done pretty much what we could do to sit in a really excellent position to prosper into the future. We’re all hands on deck. Everyone’s committed. We’ve got a great team, a great Board and a great shareholder base, and thank you. We will take questions.