Barry S. Sternlicht
Analyst · Wells Fargo
Thank you, Stew. I think I should start my comments by thanking you for your amazing work these past years and since you had to print yourself out of a job by transitioning all of your reports to Miami when you're based in San Francisco, as I think our shareholder base knows. So you've been a pleasure to deal with, and the whole team and the shareholder base and the Board of Directors thank you for all your efforts these past years. And as I've told you privately and I'll say publicly, you should go into a business that we could possibly fund. We'd be delighted to be your partner going forward. So, I think we had a pretty good quarter this year -- this past quarter. I want to start by talking about the economy a little because I think, as you know, from the start, we have an overall macro view, which informs the investments we make and where we deploy shareholder capital. So our feeling of the economy is what you'll see it is to be. It's not that strong, and even though the weather impacted the quarter, for sure, I don't expect GDP growth to accelerate dramatically in the U.S., primarily because the rest of the world is not pulling its weight any longer at rapid growth. So I'd see the number between 1% and 2% GDP growth in United States, lower than that in Europe, and nobody believes the numbers coming out of China. So -- and obviously, South America, led by Brazil, is functioning at a dysfunctional rate of growth. It's not really absorbing the cost increases inherent in their labor structure. So I think we're going to see lower, longer, globally. And I think most of you and I and most every economist have been surprised that the 10-year is below 2.60% at the moment. That has to be good news for the REIT and good news for our shareholders, as our dividend and our yield globally become super valuable and super attractive. High yield continues to trade around 5%, and I'd argue that our dividend of 7.9% with secured mortgages, whether they're first or we call A2 notes because, they're first sliced in half, match funded are just far superior risk-adjusted returns for shareholders than you could find in high yield and certainly in corporate. I do think what this means, though, is with the flood of liquidity in the world, especially attracted to real estate, we see a lot of crossover capital are coming out of corporate bonds into real estate, mortgage bonds, again, and that's propelling the rise in growth in the CMBS market once again, is that spreads will continue to come in, which will absorb some increase in rates going forward if it, in fact, it happens. But I think you'll see short rates go up. We plead God they go up. It's good for us because we have LIBOR-based loans. But I don't think the curve is going to steepen, or it's going to flatten. I think the -- without growth, I don't see the 10-year racing away from you. Anything that goes to 3%, if the short end goes to 2%, you're going to see huge compression in rates or a flattening of the curve. Good for banks, good for LIBOR-based lenders, and keep that in mind as we continue to generate LIBOR-based loans and focus only on LIBOR-based loans going forward. So I really like our book. I think it's amazing, as we've said. If you've been with us, and some of our shareholders have been with us since the IPO, we said we'd build a diverse book, which we have, by asset class and by geography, which we have. We said we would focus on safety, which we have. It's pretty interesting to see the LTV of our book hovering around 66% and pretty consistent quarter-to-quarter. We've moved into Europe, as you know, and done some amazing deals. The cover of the annual report, if you haven't seen it, is Heron Tower, which is one of the finest buildings in London, and we featured it on the cover of the annual report for that reason. We have a great book. It's quite valuable. I think, if we sold it in bulk, a life company would take it down to a very attractive price compared to where we're marketing it at book or fair market value. We have, as you know, also focused on the major assets -- the major markets and the major assets. New York City is well represented in our portfolio, and that's because it is, by far, the best market in the U.S., with deep investor interest. And we see that from our equity positions at our client base, which includes -- almost 10 of the world's sovereign wealth funds are very focused on that city and will keep values high for a very long time. We're also watching, as it relates to loan-to-value, Fruchter [ph] reforms that are making their way through Congress. The biggest beneficiary of Fruchter [ph] reforms would clearly be New York City. So all the property markets in United States are pretty stable, and they are slowly improving. Even the once-dead suburban office markets are getting better, and certain markets are actually doing quite well in suburbia. You just need to pick your spots. You saw us do a deal in Minneapolis after the quarter end, which is a pretty good suburban market. Even multis, which we feared were going to be overbuilt, are still seeing rents rise, and I think -- there's a great debate about the housing market. I actually think the housing market is fine. I think the issue is more the subs, that there aren't trained subs and there isn't demand. But that doesn't mean, in certain markets, housing prices didn't run further than they should have based on galloping investor interest, which propelled these markets, like Vegas and Phoenix, far beyond where they should have been pushed. And so they're correcting. But for the balance of the company -- for the country, as you saw this morning with Tripoint's earnings, the housing market is quite good, particularly in Southern California, though they are limited to their ability to add product, nobody's going to want to spec housing there because of subs, which means that you might see some tick-up in inflation in the construction trade. And maybe some of those people will reenter the workforce, and that's good because that will propel the GDP growth higher. The lending markets, on the other hand, are super competitive. I think our -- we continue to rely on our speed, our knowledge, our relationships, the fully fixed acquisition guys we have in Starwood Capital Group, to amend the [indiscernible] are dedicated to the REIT, as well as the 74 asset management people in the various functions of the firm also can look for opportunities for us. I would have liked to have seen more loans from Europe in the quarter, and we continue to press our European team. There, too, spreads have come in dramatically over the last 12 months. And even on the equity side, we're able to refinance loans that were LIBOR plus 450 or LIBOR plus 275, and those spreads will continue to come in as Europe recovers. Probably the most important statistic I look at when I look at what's happening in the world, I know how sanguine investors are becoming, is the 10-year in Spain and Italy, which has hovered for years above 4%, 5.5% and 6% and 7%, and then crashed this year, falling from 4% to like 3.18% and actually getting very close to U.S. 10-year treasury rates, which is quite something, given the moribund economies of both countries, though they're both mending. So we are looking at other geographies today and other product lines to add to our business lines. We have many business lines. We don't have the one. And the special service is interesting. At $222 million, that's less than 5%, I think it's 4%, of our book, but a very small part of our overall business. And in fact, our small loan conduit business; the CMBS investment and trading business; the B-piece business; the servicer, Hatfield Philips, which is our servicing business run by the REIT in Europe; all those are contributing meaningful to our growth and take us away from being a book value company and towards a global finance company, which is what my goal is for our firm. We also made a key hire to run Hatfield Philips in Blair Lewis, and he joined us in January. I'm really excited about the future growth and potential of that business. Also, I'll point out in the quarter or prior -- early in the quarter, it was announced that Google took an interest -- put $50 million investment into Auction.com at a $1.2 billion strike price. I'll point out, in our book, in our earnings, that is a 0 value. It clearly has value, and Google wouldn't invest and Google Capital in something they thought couldn't be the leader in its field. So that's a free option for shareholders on something that could have significant value down the road. Also, I'll point out the assets like 701 Seventh Avenue in New York City, which was a retail base deal where we financed the project for developer, Steve Witkoff, in partnership with Vornado, who we sold a piece to, to secure our -- to make sure our position was safe, then signed a deal with -- to put a Marriott on top of the box, and Marriott provided a put on the hotel, which gave us the ability to significantly increase the construction loan, and then we split it in half and sold it to another investor. So we wouldn't assume this exposure to that, but we do have a 10% equity kicker in the transaction, which we believe is worth tens of millions of dollars, and that's 0 in our book. And also, we did not accept an offer to sell it. And I'll also point out that we believe our CMBS book is quite valuable, and though it's marked at fair value, we would suggest it might be worth more than that. And the sales that we made in the quarter, you should expect us to continue to look at individual securities, some of which they recently bought or are just trading around, very high IRRs, but we think that's an interesting business. We have an unlevel playing field because we have very good information on all the CMBS legacy securities. We'll continue to mine those opportunities going forward, and every day, I seem to get a wire transfer of $22 million or $5 million or $8 million as they buy and sell these positions. We sold the ones we sold because the yields to maturities fell below 5%. And there are others that, when we see stuff like that, we must take advantage of the marketplace and sell these positions. So we'll continue to do that. It should be viewed as a recurring, nonrecurring because they will recur overall going forward. I also will reiterate how Stew's comments about the accomplishments of Rina and Stew and Cory and the teams in integrating the Starwood systems in with the LNR platform. We had -- I don’t know how many people we have in accounting before, half a dozen, and now we have 60. We had an IT platform of, I don't know, none, and today, we have like 40 people doing IT. So one of the other projects we have here is working on our database and making it usable across the company and across all our entities so that we have unbelievable information on loans and on assets and on our performance, which will help us underwrite. And Stew raised that in the year-end discussion with me that we're not taking full advantage of the extraordinary skill of our enterprise, which, today, I think, is a $38 billion asset manager. So I think we'll keep working on the market opportunities that are afforded to us. We want to drive the earnings growth to create a full-fledged finance company, and that will create continued growth in our dividend. The key for me has always been the diversity of our book and the ability to not face rollover risk. The construction loans we made will fully -- pretty much fully match the expected maturity to prepayments and repayments of our loan book in the near couple of years, which means the cash that we get back that we couldn't deploy, and don't forget, it's earning close to between 7% and 11%, then goes to 10 basis points. That's a problem for us, so if we can fund these construction loans, they will absorb those repayments. And because of the nature of borrowers and the quality of the projects, we're very comfortable that these are really good assets. And for example, we have a construction loan on an apartment deal in the Upper East Side where our basis is -- our breakeven is $850 a foot. If you know anything about Manhattan real estate, that's about 1/3 of what it's probably selling for. In fact, I think that project is sold out or close to being sold out.