John Corbett
Analyst · DA Davidson. Your line is open, Kevin
Yes, Kevin, and I share your frustration with the inability to predict that and it's obviously a function of the Cecil model, and the impact of changes and economic forecasts on that. So maybe, sort of unpack that just a little bit. So as I said in my comments, for this quarter, we used a 50/50 weighting of two scenarios, the baseline scenario, which is Moody's sort of middle of the road forecasts where they assume there's a 50% chance of things being better or worse than that. And now we also weighed 50%, their S3 scenario, which is their recessionary scenario, and that on the probability curve is in their lingo, is a 90% chance that things are better than that than S3 and a 10% chance things are worse. And so at a 50/50 weighting of those two, essentially, you're at 70%on that if you if you pictured a straight line, horizontal line, between zero being the happy days are here again and 100 million economic event, we're at 70% by one 50% of 90 % and 50% of 50%. And we use weightings between 50/50 and two-thirds based on one-third over the last number of quarters. So we've been an effectively weighted average range of 63 to 70. Just to keep that mental image the horizontal line is the example. If we have gone 100% baseline, so just stick with whatever you think going happen and not wait in another scenario with more pessimism. It would have told us to have a reserve about 40 basis points below where we were at the end of the quarter. And if we go with 100%, S3 would have had about 40 basis points higher. Now the thing that I'll caution you is that change is quarter-by-quarter as those forecasts and the underlying economic metrics and their last drivers in the Cecil model change. So it could be that in a worst time, S3 is a lot worse, and baseline is a lot worse. So those are not static amount there. So anyway, that's sort of the underlying thing. It could go lower if their forecasts continue to improve, they could also get worse. And as we all know, as Cecil, if the projections are moved to predict worsening economic outlook quickly, then you'll see a quick reaction through the provisions for credit loss to build a backup just based on the variability that Cecil imposes.