Earnings Labs

Sunstone Hotel Investors, Inc. (SHO)

Q3 2017 Earnings Call· Tue, Oct 31, 2017

$9.74

+0.46%

Key Takeaways · AI generated
AI summary not yet generated for this transcript. Generation in progress for older transcripts; check back soon, or browse the full transcript below.

Same-Day

-0.25%

1 Week

-0.06%

1 Month

+1.04%

vs S&P

-1.80%

Transcript

Operator

Operator

Good morning and thank you for standing by. Welcome to the Sunstone Hotel Investors Third Quarter 2017 Earnings Conference Call. At this time all participants are in a listen-only-mode. Later we will conduct the question-and-answer session and instructions will be given at that time. I would like to remind everyone that today's conference is being recorded today, Tuesday October 31, 2017 at 09:00 AM Pacific Daylight Time. I will now turn the presentation over to Aaron Reyes, Vice President of Corporate Finance. Please go ahead, sir.

Aaron Reyes

Analyst

Thank you, Jake, and good morning everyone. By now you should have all received the copy of our third quarter earnings release and supplemental, which were made available yesterday. If you do not yet have a copy, you can access them on our website. Before we begin, I would like to remind everyone that this call contains forward-looking statements that are subject to risks and uncertainties including those described in our press release, 10-Qs, 10-Ks and other filings with the SEC, which could cause actual results to differ materially from those projected. We caution you to consider those factors in evaluating our forward-looking statements. We also note that this call may contain non-GAAP financial information including adjusted EBITDA, adjusted FFO and hotel adjusted EBITDA margins. We are providing that information as a supplement to information prepared in accordance with Generally Accepted Accounting Principles. With us on the call today are John Arabia, President and Chief Executive Officer; Bryan Giglia, Chief Financial Officer; Marc Hoffman, Chief Operating Officer; and Robert Springer, Chief Investment Officer. After our remarks, we will be available to answer your questions. With that, I would like to turn the call over to John. Please go ahead.

John Arabia

Analyst

Good morning everyone and happy Halloween. Today, I will provide a review of our third operating results including the impacts of hurricanes Harvey and Irma on our portfolio. Afterwards, Bryan will review various balance sheet highlights, provide additional color on our third quarter financial results and discuss our updated earnings guidance, which includes the impact of the recent storms. As you are likely aware by now, there were various moving pieces in our third quarter, that in some instances made more it challenging to assess the underlying performance of our business. As we look across our third quarter results, adjustment for the unanticipated hurricane impact, our portfolio performed better than we expected and our overall outlook for the business remains largely consistent with our view when we spoke in early August. Our two repositioned hotels once against delivered outsized growth while the reminder of our portfolio in aggregate continued to meet or exceed our previous expectations. Our third quarter comparable portfolio RevPAR growth of 2% came in above the high end of our guidance range, driven by a 2.4% increase in average daily rates, offset by a 40 basis points decline in occupancy. This RevPAR growth combined with stronger than anticipated ancillary revenue and a continue focus on cost containment across the organization, resulting in adjustment EBITDA and adjusted FFO per diluted share that exceeded our expectations. Our third quarter comparable portfolio property level EBITDA increased by 1.7%, as a result of a 3.3% increase in comparable hotel revenue and a 50 basis point contraction in hotel EBITDA margins. Our third quarter results were driven largely by the strong performance and continued ramp up of our two recently repositioned hotels, Boston Park Plaza and Wailea Beach Resort. For the second quarter in a row, these two hotels posted combined RevPAR…

Bryan Giglia

Analyst

Thank you, John, and good morning everyone. I’ll start with a quick recap of the balance sheet and then provide additional color on some of the financial activity that occurred in the third quarter. And finally, I’ll finish with an update on our revised outlook for the year. Turning to the balance sheet, we ended the third quarter with nearly 467 million of unrestricted cash on hand and 1.2 billion of consolidated debt and preferred securities. While a portion of this cash will be used to complete capital investments and to fund our anticipated catch up dividend which I will discuss shortly, we estimate that we will retain between 250 million and 300 million of cash for future investment. Our current in place debt has a weighted average term to maturity of 5.4 years and a weighted average interest rate of 4.3%. Our variable rate debt as a percentage of total debt stands at 22% and 43% of our debt is unsecured. We now have 22 hotels that collectively generated approximately 247 million of the EBITDA over the trailing 12 months period and nearly 70% of our EBITDA is now unencumbered. In addition to cash on hand, we have an undrawn $400 million credit facility and no debt maturities before August 2019. During the third quarter, there were several one-time non-cash expenses and credits. While these are all items that are routinely excluded from adjusted EBITDA and adjusted FFO, we wanted to provide some additional information on each. There were two non-cash charges recorded during the quarter. First, we wrote down our two Huston assets from a net book value of approximately 72 million to a new value of approximately 38 million resulting in a 34.4 million non-cash expense during the quarter. Over the last few years and despite a…

Operator

Operator

[Operator Instruction] And we'll go first to Anthony Powell with Barclays.

Anthony Powell

Analyst

When you acquired Ocean Edge, you forecasted '18 EBITDA between 11.5 million and 13.5 million. How does Hurricane Irma change that forecast next year? And do you think it takes longer to get you to stabilize yield of 8% to 9%?

Bryan Giglia

Analyst

Hi, Anthony, it's Bryan. With Oceans Edge, we did adjust the fourth quarter EBITDA to reflect the disruption and anticipated slower ramp up to get the hotel back to its pre-strong condition. Depending on the rate at which that ramp up happens in the fourth quarter will determine if the operations next year will behind where we were or catch back up. We will need a little bit more time to determine what that rate is going to be. Please remember following the storm, the city of Key West did make a statement same for visitors to stay away until the end of October that was changed little after the storm, but the ramp up has been slow up to that point. We are entering the high season now. So, the next few weeks will be very important to understand the velocity of that ramp. And during this time there will be a business interruption claim that we are working on and will be filing, the amount to that and the timing again it's still too early to tell, but we’ll have an update on the next call.

Anthony Powell

Analyst

Thanks a lot. And in San Francisco, you’ve done a good job of booking in house group. How do you plan to alter that strategy in next year and ’19 at the citywide calendar improves in the market?

Marc Hoffman

Analyst

Yes, Anthony. I think you mean 2018 we said next year right or you also want me to talk about 2019 where the city has huge impact?

Anthony Powell

Analyst

I guess both, yes. How do you plan I guess change the booking strategy given the improvement of citywide in both years really?

Marc Hoffman

Analyst

Yes. So, currently citywide room nights for San Francisco on the books for next year of 740,000 rooms, that’s a 19% increase to 17, but it's still 20% behind 16. The number of citywide room nights that are associated with higher impact conventions that affect us, citywide is a 5,000 more rooms in a specific day are also up 22%. We are in the right place where we want to be internally in the hotel. Currently for 2018 and ’19, we’re very focused on the placement between weekday and weekend. And in 2019, the city has currently 1.15 million room nights on the books, which is the peak of any year ever in the history of the city. So, we feel that between that and compression, the one thing to remember about our hotel is and the city is we do better with transient rate than group. So if anything in 2019, we will be very, very picky about rate and placement to maximize RevPAR.

Operator

Operator

Next we’ll hear from Lukas Hartwich with Green Street Advisors.

Lukas Hartwich

Analyst

John, I was hoping you could touch on -- the economy seems to be improving, and yet we’re just not seeing an improvement in hotel demand growth. So, I’m just curious, what do you think is driving that? Why aren’t we seeing any improvement in hotels?

John Arabia

Analyst

It’s a great question, Lucas. I wish I had a great answer. As we’ve talked about in the past, we’re constantly looking for overall levels of details within our own business. To ascertain whether or not there is any change in the current environment of just muddling along as I think most hotels are by in large. You know there are various elements that would support the fact that we are in later stages of the cycle and acting very much in the later stage of the cycle and in terms of versus two quarters in a row where a group production has moderated not significantly but you know that’s something we’re looking at. On the other hand, there are areas such as short-term bookings in the quarter for the quarter that have been relatively strong and you know food and beverage or audio visual banquet spend has actually been pretty robust. It is unfortunately still too early to tell whether the hopes of reacceleration in our underlying business are there or not. We remain conservative in our view to operating fundamentals. I hope it happens but we've also prepared should that not be the case.

Lukas Hartwich

Analyst

That’s helpful and then just last quick one. In Huston, RevPAR was down quite a bit, but EBITDA was up quite a bit as well. So just kind curious what the disconnect was there?

Bryan Giglia

Analyst

Hi, Lucas. This is Bryan. There was a cancelation charge for one of the contract pieces of business that was in that hotel.

Lukas Hartwich

Analyst

Perfect.

John Arabia

Analyst

If you do remember, our hotel -- our two Huston hotels actually held up -- over the past several quarters have held up fairly well relative for market. And we have had a sizable piece of contract business in the hotel that business went away from us and there were certain cancelation provisions that accrued to us. So, those are actually fairly related.

Operator

Operator

Now, we will hear from Jeff Donnelly with Wells Fargo.

Jeff Donnelly

Analyst

Maybe just a first question, John. I think Marriott has been looking at transitioning I guess what you call the occupancy hurdle for award travel, reimbursement to something more of a phased hurdle. I'm just curious, how much does that influence in your opinion, pricing behavior in the market? And do you see that as beneficial to the extent it's implemented to rate integrality, to RevPAR, hotel owner profitability, all the above? I'm just curious how you're thinking about it.

John Arabia

Analyst

Jeff. I don’t think any final determination has been made. Those are discussions that are ongoing, and we have been participating in some of those conversations, for too early to tell, however we do apply Marriott and others for having these conversations and making change in terms of cancellation attrition about longer cancelation windows and making certain changes on a guest programs that remove some of the unintended negative consequences, but far too early to tell Jeff.

Jeff Donnelly

Analyst

And to switch gears maybe just back to San Francisco. I'm just curious, how are you guys thinking about San Francisco ramp as we move through 2018? We've kind gotten past the worst of Moscone. I know you're not necessary right in the heart of the convention center district, but certainly you benefit maybe from some of the over flow. I'm just curious, if kind think the back of the years materially strong than the first half. How you guys kind planning that out?

John Arabia

Analyst

On the margin we got, little bit more constructive on San Francisco for 2018. It seems that there have been incremental bookings into the city. I wouldn’t say necessary we're out of the woods yet when it comes to performance in San Francisco. We have noticed that there has been an uptick in enthusiasm towards the city from the investment community, and I think directionally that is correct. As Mark said earlier, the real win is going to come in 2019 where the city is having a banner year and there should be enormous amount of compression. But like I said and like Mark had said earlier, we do feel incrementally positive about the city moving into 2018.

Jeff Donnelly

Analyst

And just one last one. I am not sure if have they handy, but just concerning some of the bigger renovation projects you've undertaken. Can you talk a little bit about the RevPAR index of those assets have looked like sort of pre-renovation versus post renovation? I know there has been maybe a little more kind of season with Park Plaza versus LA, but I was just curious to this, you have any kind of details maybe to give us a sense of how they perform versus maybe expectation?

John Arabia

Analyst

I'll tell you what Jeff, let's get back to you with very specific numbers which we have. I would tell you for example in Wailea, our RevPAR in that versus the set has moved fairly meaningfully, as you know we have talked about buying the best house -- excuse me the worst house on the best street. And financial success for us was not replicating the rates that the Four Seasons or some of the other hotels achieved or currently achieved, but closing that gap. And in terms of RevPAR -- excuse me ADR index in roughly 2015 versus the really high end portfolio. We were less than 50% ADR in that and we moved that by over 10 points to just below 60%, so call it 48 to 59 which is a meaningful move.

Operator

Operator

Now we will hear from Bill Crow with Raymond James.

Bill Crow

Analyst

I'll start with Key West. John, one of the big annual best of all or whatever you want to call it happen a couple of weeks ago down there. I'm just wondering, if you can get a read on the monetarism that came down for it?

John Arabia

Analyst

So, Fantasy Fest was this past weekend and we did see occupancy building from the time that we reopen hotel, occupancy started off in literally in the teams, built up to 30s. We prior to Fantasy Fest, we were in low 60s. And then for Fantasy Fest, it was lower than originally had forecasted prior to the hurricanes, but we did see more people returning to the Keys. So I would say that that was incrementally positive and we are hopeful that as the season progresses the same continues as market gets back on its feet.

Bill Crow

Analyst

It seems like there has been a couple of different narratives on the outlook for next year particularly on the supply front and I'm just wondering, if you want to give a sheer perspective of where supply is heading '18 and '19 generally?

Robert Springer

Analyst

It's Robert. I can chime in on that a bit. I think the themes that we talked about with supply remained fairly consistent. It is a market-by-market issue with certain markets just continuing to get new supply. Manhattan obviously sticks out at the market that received meaningful new supply. Other markets that we track or expecting and continuing to expect to see new supply and I think we are tracking about 6% supply growth in Manhattan. In 2018 for example, other markets that we are expecting meaningful supply growth include New Orleans, which is expecting about 4% as well as Portland, I think has been commonly refer to as a market that's got meaningful new supply. Obviously, as you look at these, it depends on where your hotel is, I'll use Philadelphia as an example. Our hotel in Philadelphia is actually really in Conshohocken, so it doesn’t really get impacted by as much as of the central business district supply. So, our supply there while Philadelphia is seeing meaningful supply growth out in Western Philadelphia in that particularly submarket, it's not as that. But if you look at it on our portfolio-wide basis, 2018 we are tracking somewhere between 2.5 and call it 2.75 to maybe slightly below 3% weighted average, supply growth. Obviously, it depends on how you slice it and dice it, but that should be directionally correct.

Bill Crow

Analyst

And Robert thanks for the color. Any markets that you think won’t peak from the supply growth perspective until after ’19?

Robert Springer

Analyst

Not that comes to mind and don’t have good, not that comes to mind.

Bill Crow

Analyst

Okay. And John finally from me, you clearly focused on long-term relevant real estate you still have some assets that I would guess you would put in the other bucket including Houston. Can you just talk about the prospects for sales over the near-term?

John Arabia

Analyst

Sure. Our strategy is very clear with to all the long-term relevant real estate and I think when you take a look at the bulk of our asset value, it would fit into those categories. However, there are still a number of hotels maybe measured in total hotels, total rooms our effort. So that would say fall short in some way shape or form to that descriptor. And we will continue to methodically sell assets after rate time to continue to concentrate the portfolio into long-term relevant real estate. We have sold rough numbers close to $800 million of assets and in the past call it 24 months and I’d anticipate that.

Operator

Operator

Now, we’ll hear from Smedes Rose from Citi.

Abhishek Kastiya

Analyst

Hi, this is Abhishek on for Smedes. Are there any markets that you consider exiting completely or any new markets that you looked to enter over or maybe next 6 to 12 months? And would those be in primary or secondary markets?

John Arabia

Analyst

You know external growth has become more difficult as evidenced by the fact that you know we’ve acquired one hotel in the past roughly three years even though Robert and team have literally kicked tires and done exhausted due diligence on well over $2 billion of assets in not so distant past. I think the likelihood of acquiring something in the near-term is let’s say relatively low, but anything we do acquire would fall in one shape or form as long-term relevant real estate and would say that predominantly those would fall into more primarily markets.

Abhishek Kastiya

Analyst

And are you seeing like lot of opportunities for more value add acquisitions? Or would it still be dependent on the market and other factors?

John Arabia

Analyst

It will be above. I believe that we have the deep expertise to do deep dive repositioning as evidenced by the fact that we did, but we completed successfully Wailea Beach Resort, Boston Park Plaza. At the same time, I think both of those projects have been very successful. So I believe that we have the expertise in house. However, I would say that, that will not be our only investment type. And when you take a look at Oceans Edge, that was a property that just opened up and other than meeting some operational enhancements, really requires almost no capital. So it really will depend.

Operator

Operator

And next you will hear from Chris Woronka with Deutsche Bank.

Chris Woronka

Analyst

Apologize, if I missed it earlier. Can you guys give out a group -- overall group pace for 2018?

John Arabia

Analyst

Chris, it's John. Unfortunately, we've not provided guidance yet on 2018 or provided 2019 pace, however, I would tell you as we stand today the group pace for our portfolio is positive, moving into 2018.

Chris Woronka

Analyst

Okay great. Then second question is, you guys sold by efficient a two few years ago, I guess to Avendra, now Avendra itself is just getting a new owner. Do you guys anticipate any changes with the new owner?

John Arabia

Analyst

That you would have to ask BuyEfficient or Avendra, Marriott has made public comments about the benefits that should nor to the existing owners but other than that, we don’t have any incremental lends on that, other than happy clients of Avendra.

Chris Woronka

Analyst

Okay fair enough. And just on Huston, I noticed, it looks like those hotel are not in the held for sale bucket on the balance sheet as of September 30th. Is there a point they would have to move into that, if they were being marketed? Or could something theoretically happen outside of that?

Bryan Giglia

Analyst

Hi Chris, it's Bryan. There are several criteria by actually to determine whether or not something goods put into held for sale. You have to be marketing and you have to have a likelihood of it transacting within a certain time frame and so, whenever something is taken out to market or may be loosely shopped in the market we evaluate that in a quarterly basis and if we meet those criteria we would then move in into held for sale.

Operator

Operator

Now we will hear from Shaun Kelley with Bank of America.

Shaun Kelley

Analyst

John, first of all thanks for the comments on kind of all the personal stuff up front, I think sometimes it's easy in our ivory towers to lose track of all that, all the hard work that’s been done to. So thanks for the reminder there. And then -- and look just one question because you guys have covered plenty of ground. But when we led off earnings season here across the lodging REIT sectors that there is some concern around, CBD performance and how that stacked up relative to the overall kind of broader markets. I think when we look at your core portfolio I mean clearly we look at it in two buckets. You got the renovated properties that are continuing to ramp extremely well above your underwriting and then you kind got the core. As we think about the core, your markets are little bit different and portfolio is little different then may be just having kind CBD level drivers. So, I'm kind curious like, how do you stack up or think about the core performance? And in this operating environment whether it's kind now or 4Q or whatever like just can you help us think about how you would expect us to stack up versus the broader baseline RevPAR numbers that we are seeing out there for the industry right now?

John Arabia

Analyst

Yes, Shaun, I think you’re hitting on an important point, and that is just stated very clearly without the significant growth Boston of late or Wailea, which are real and meaningful to our company. The rest of portfolio is just as I said earlier just kind of modeling along and not so dissimilar pound for pound from maybe what some of the other hotel REITs are generally reporting. And in generally modestly on performing what the industry is doing as some urban concentration seem to be underperforming notably Chicago for example, New York had its well publicized difficulties. So, I can't disagree whatsoever with the comment you made, Shaun.

Shaun Kelley

Analyst

Any reason San Fran's portfolio looks a little different and performs little differently in '18? I mean we've exhausted San Francisco, so you can kind of leave that one out, but whether it's Chicago or company specific initiatives on the renovation side or anything you are looking forward to in '18 that you'd highlight out of your geographic mix that investors maybe are looking?

John Arabia

Analyst

Yes, we do have a sizable asset in San Diego that appears that it will have a pretty good year next year. We continue to believe that the best is yet to come for Wailea and while Boston appears to have a little bit more gas in the tank to so to speak into '18. We believe that the ramp on Wailea should be positive. And then finally despite the fact that unfortunately the hurricane hit us few weeks after we acquired it, Oceans Edge will deliver and will provide incremental earnings to the company overtime. So that’s generally I would highlight.

Operator

Operator

And next we will hear from Thomas Allen with Morgan Stanley.

Thomas Allen

Analyst

In the press release, you highlight that the New York City, San Francisco and Portland markets outperformed your expectation. Can you just give us a little bit more color on what you think drove that? Thanks.

John Arabia

Analyst

Yes, a whole host of different things. And remember, going into this quarter, we had fairly low expectations for the quarter in general other than our reposition hotels. And for those hotels in particular, we had assumed fairly negative RevPAR growth and they just happen to come in slightly better although in couple of cases still negative to slightly better than our expectations, and those expectations underlying our guidance and our forecast. With that all -- for some of the more details, I'll turn it over to Marc.

Marc Hoffman

Analyst

Yes, in San Francisco, the hotel benefited from short-term pick up of group that performed better particularly on weekends. And then also the over the Jewish holiday which were softer, we did much better. In Portland, it was again while that hotel is small with better group plus market benefits from solar eclipse to be honest with you. In New York, the market has had some short-term demand that helped to absorb five and its city based demand. And then the Houston hotel benefited from the business that came through as the market resulted from the hurricanes.

Thomas Allen

Analyst

And then is there actually a way to -- do you think there is a way to quantify the hurricane displacement business in Houston?

Bryan Giglia

Analyst

It’s Bryan. In the third quarter, we think that from the two Houston hotels combined, we picked up about $0.5 million of EBITDA in business. Looking into the fourth quarter, that business is the hurricane related business whether it'd be construction crews, other crews some teams of business. That is very short term in nature and so while we have some of that and we’ve had some of that in October, it's yet to see whether that will continue for the rest of the quarter but for the third quarter we had about 500,000 of additional EBITDA. That is obviously offset by what we had at Oceans Edge and then in the rest of the portfolio the week of the hurricane some of our group boxes, Orlando being one which actually lost some group business but then built with transient, did lose food and beverage. And then San Diego had because of the difficult travel time, had some loss revenue during that time period also.

Thomas Allen

Analyst

So should we read into it that you call out that the Oceans Edge impact, but the rest of the Orlando, the San Diego, Houston, kind of the impact of the hurricane that kind of net neutral?

Bryan Giglia

Analyst

For the third quarter, it's slightly negative due to the group loss, but we’re talking a couple of hundred thousand dollars. Fourth quarter, we don’t know yet what the impact of Houston, if it will result in positive pick up or not.

Operator

Operator

Now moving onto Floris van Dijkum with Boenning. Go ahead please.

Floris van Dijkum

Analyst

Could you maybe comment on -- the last quarter again there was a significant difference in performance between your Marriott and Hilton branded hotels. If there is any -- I know you don’t have as many Hilton hotels as your Marriott hotels, but if you could talk about some of the specifics around that?

John Arabia

Analyst

No, I wouldn’t take it that performance have anything to do with the specifics brands. I would say it was more driven by hotel specific factors.

Floris van Dijkum

Analyst

Anyone that sticks up in your mind?

John Arabia

Analyst

Well, no, for example the two Houston hotels did fairly poorly although better than expectations. Orlando had a -- Orlando Renaissance had a difficult comp to just a phenomenal third quarter of last year from memory. I think our RevPAR was up something like 24% in the third quarter of last year with great food and beverage. In our Philly hotel in West Conshohocken, we had a tough comp because of the D&C. So, I would say it's just a more market specific than anything that the brands were doing.

Floris van Dijkum

Analyst

Right, but the Conshohocken hotel was a Marriott right, and your Marriott outperformed Hilton significantly I think by about 6%, if I’m not mistaken in terms of RevPAR?

John Arabia

Analyst

Yes, the real outperformance between Marriott and Hilton is really driven heavily on Wailea and on the DC Renaissance, but Wailea…

Floris van Dijkum

Analyst

Got it.

John Arabia

Analyst

Over a 90% RevPAR growth through the quarter.

Floris van Dijkum

Analyst

Got it. And one other question I had for your 7 million tax gain, on asset previous sold. Is that --was there earned out with that part of the reason that, that was -- that dissipated?

John Arabia

Analyst

No, there is no earn out would have a cash implication, so it was a non-cash, but it was with the differed gain based on a potential exposure to a liability that is now deemed to be remote. And so that’s why at the time of sale, a piece of the gain from a gap prospective was differed.

Operator

Operator

And we will take questions from Stephen Grambling with Goldman Sachs.

Stephen Grambling

Analyst

I realize it's still early, but are there any expectations for kind of core expense inflation on the horizon? Any reason that number could move up or down on the coming year? And maybe as related follow-up some of your peers have alluded to limited contributions from the Marriott Starwood merger to-date. So what are you seeing and what are your expectations? Thanks.

John Arabia

Analyst

I think the question was on the cost side. As we mentioned in prepared remarks, all we've seen is we've seen inflation on wages and benefits. Particularly in certain markets, Chicago comes to mind, New York comes to mind, just particularly some of those markets where there is incremental supply growth. And competition for associates and managers has been on the rise, but overall I would say that it seems later cycle type of events where we're seeing pick up in wages and benefits. And then I think the question -- the second question was in result to benefits from Marriott Starwood, I think a little bit too early to tell, we're anticipating benefits that's still too early to tell.

Operator

Operator

And Patrick Scholes with SunTrust. Go ahead please.

Patrick Scholes

Analyst

John, a number of your fellow peers have called out in this earning season, weakness in inbound international. Are you seeing similar weakness? And if so, are you able to quantify that weakness?

John Arabia

Analyst

Not really, the markets that we generally have our international travel would be New York, a little bit in San Francisco. And then believe it or not, now it is actually 90% roughly 90% a domestic market, unlike Oahu. So and there, we've seen a slight up take, I believe in Canadian tourism, so noting significant that stands up for our portfolio.

Patrick Scholes

Analyst

Okay, thank you. And then just on the business that you have the Key West hotel. How much of that is sort of long-term contract, say, government relief or redevelopment contractors?

John Arabia

Analyst

Zero.

Operator

Operator

And our next question will come from Bryan Maher with FBR Capital Markets.

Bryan Maher

Analyst

Just kind of a follow-up to Thomas' questions earlier on Huston. Couple of the people have reported already have really highlighted strong RevPAR gain come out of Houston with the potential for a long tail on that. It doesn't sound like you guys are leaning that way. Is there something at your properties specifically they don’t give you that level of confidence that tail will be there for you?

John Arabia

Analyst

Yes, we think the tail will be there. Again, as we mentioned in prepared remarks, Houston actually did better than we expected. Keep in mind we were bullied last year by a fairly sizable piece of contract business at our two hotels there that business wins away in various quarters of this year. And we actually anticipated even more difficult tropes knowing in the third quarter. So as I believe we outperformed I believe from my collection we outperformed I last year we have taken couple of more launch this year.

Operator

Operator

Looks like, we have a follow-up for Anthony Powell with Barclays.

Anthony Powell

Analyst

Just one for me. How does Chicago fit into your long-term relevant real estate strategy? EBITDA is down roughly 21% year-to-date difficult market with high supplied growth and cost inflation. How do you view that market long term? And what can you do there in the interim to stop the bleeding?

John Arabia

Analyst

It’s a great debate, Anthony. It is a phenomenal city however it is one city that the taxation issues and other issues within the city and a number of folks who continue to develop in that city make it -- had made it a little bit more challenging. Long-term, we are happy with Chicago particularly where we sit. Our Embassy Suites at State and Ohio is just a little engine that could ton after ton tone you know doesn’t mean that can be cyclical. But I do think that’s a very good question. That’s something will be debated internally.

Operator

Operator

And that does conclude our question and answer session. I'll turn the call back over to John Arabia for closing remarks.

John Arabia

Analyst

Thank you very much everybody and have a wonderful and very safe Halloween. Take care.