George Makris
Analyst · Raymond James. Your line is now open
Thank you, David and welcome to our third quarter earnings conference call. In our press release issued earlier today, we reported net income of $81.8 million for the third quarter of 2019, an increase of $26.6 million or 48.3% compared to the same quarter last year. Diluted earnings per share were $0.84 for the quarter.Included in the third quarter earnings were $2.1 million in net after-tax non-core items. We had merger-related costs of $1.9 million, early retirement program expenses of $131,000 and branch right-sizing cost of $119,000.Excluding the impact of these items, the Company's core earnings were $84 million for the third quarter and core diluted earnings per share were $0.87, increases of $27.5 million and $0.26 respectively over the same quarter last year.I would like to mention that we've been consistent with our inclusion of, among other things, securities gains and losses along with charitable contributions and provision expense in our core results, while excluding items such as merger-related costs and branch right-sizing expenses from the core results. We've done so again this quarter. However, this quarter we experienced several notable events that further impacted our results and never worth additional discussion.First, as is public record, Simmons Bank as a result of its merger with Bank SNB, was a participant in a shared national credit to White Star Petroleum, LLC. White Star became subject of bankruptcy proceedings earlier this year and on September 30, 2019 bankruptcy court authorized the sale of White Star assets through the Section 363 proceed.Our portion of the shared national credit was $19.1 million. Based on the anticipated net proceeds from the pending bankruptcy sale, our loss recognized in the third quarter was $14.7 million. As a result of the loss, we made a special provision of $15 million increased the allowance to an appropriate level consistent with our historical ratios.Second, during the quarter, we recorded the sale of our Visa Class B common stock. The gain on the sale of the shares was $42.9 million pre-tax. It's been our intention to fund our Simmons First Foundation with part of the proceeds from the sale of the Visa stock.We have previously contributed over $6 million for the foundation as an advance on that commitment. This quarter, we contributed another $4 million for the foundation to bring our total contribution over $10 million since its inception in 2014.Third, we've previously mentioned our efforts to reduce our CRE portfolio by selling some non-relationship loans. During the quarter, we sold $114 million of loans and recognized the $5.1 million loss, including sales fleets. Included in the loan balance was $82 million from the Reliance Bank portfolio and classified loans to $32 million primarily from the acquired portfolios of Bank SNB, Heartland Bank and Southwest Bank.In summary, the net after-tax effect of these notable items is an increase to net income of $13.8 million for the quarter. I'll speak more on the White Star loan later. Our total assets were $17.8 billion at September 30. Our return on average assets for the third quarter was 1.83%, while core return on average assets was 1.88%. Our efficiency ratio was 43.8%.Our loan balance at the end of the quarter was $13 billion, a decrease of $124.1 million from last quarter. We were successful in reducing our real estate portfolio by $165 million.Our loan pipeline, which we define as loans approved and ready to close, was $639 million at the end of the quarter, compared to $419 million at the end of the second quarter of 2019. The projected weighted average rate of the loans in the pipeline is 5.43%.On a consolidated basis, our concentration of construction and development loans was 108%, and our concentration of CRE loans was 321% at the end of the quarter. Total deposits at September 30 were $13.5 billion, which was flat compared to last quarter and an increase of $1.1 billion from the year-end 2018. Our non-time deposits were up $200 million, while our time deposits were down the same amount.Our net interest income for the quarter was $150.2 million. Included in interest income was the yield accretion recognized on loans acquired of $9.3 million, which is down from $10.2 million last quarter. Of this amount, $4.4 million or 48%, was accretable credit mark related and $4.9 million or 52% was interest mark related.Our net interest margin for the quarter was 3.81%, compared to 3.92% at June 30. The Company's core net interest margin, which excludes all accretion, was 3.58% for the third quarter of 2019, compared to 3.66% for the previous quarter.The 23 basis point difference between GAAP and core net interest margin included 11 basis points of credit mark accretion and 12 basis points of interest mark accretion. The rate decreased in the variable rate loan portfolio preceded our ability to manage deposit repricing, which contributed to the decrease in our net interest margin.Our non-interest income for the quarter was $83.8 million, an increase of approximately $50 million compared to the same period last year. This increase was mainly the result of the gain on the sale of Visa stock previously discussed.In addition, we recorded the gain on the sale of securities of $7.3 million related to the sale of approximately $89 million of bonds as part of a plan to reduce wholesale funding and rebalance portfolio. We also had an increase in mortgage lending income of $3 million, compared to the same period in prior year.Non-interest expense for the third quarter was $106.9 million, an increase of $6.6 million over the same quarter last year. Core non-interest expense for the quarter was $104 million, which represented an increase of $5.5 million, when compared to the third quarter 2018. $4 million of this increase was related to the Simmons First Foundation donation mentioned earlier. We also had incremental increases in several operating areas related to our recent acquisition of Reliance Bank.Software and technology costs increased approximately $2.2 million over the same period in the prior year, related to our next-generation banking technology initiative that we have previously discussed. Our incremental IT expenditures during the third quarter were primarily related to this initiative.I am pleased to report that we're beginning to see real change associated with our NGB investment. Major milestone was accomplished during the third quarter when we successfully completed the migration of our core banking platform to our vendor-hosted environment. This was the single largest conversion we have ever done. The seamless transition was very successful and has increased the security and the reliability of our systems.In addition, on October 16, we had an extremely successful launch of our new mobile banking app. Our new app makes us a formidable competitor in mobile banking and customer response has been phenomenal as evidenced by the 4.9 star rating from our users. We will continue to expand customer offerings through our digital channel.At September 30, the allowance for loan losses legacy loans was $66 million with an additional $600,000 allowance for acquired loan. Loan discount mark was $60.4 million, for a total coverage of $127 million.At the end of the third quarter, non-performing assets were $93 million, an increase of $5.4 million from the second quarter. This balance is primarily made up of $72.9 million non-performing loans and $20.1 million in other non-performing assets, which include $5.9 million in closed bank branches held for sale.Our annualized year-to-date net charge-offs to total loans were 38 basis points and the provision for loan loss for the third quarter was $22 million. The White Star loss is embarrassing and contrary to the credit culture here at Simmons. Because we were only a participant in the credit, we were limited both in our ability to act unilaterally and in our access to timely information.We've learned some valuable lessons from this experience. We have changed the approval authority of any energy loan to a bank-wide committee. All loan participations must also be approved by the bank-wide committee. And we are evaluating our whole limits on any single loan and on total borrower data.We will work to exit all purchased syndicated energy credits. Currently, we have $197 million in syndicated energy loans in which Simmons is not the lead bank. We expect to exit at least $120 million of these credits by the second quarter of 2020.Our energy portfolio currently includes two credits, totaling $17.3 million, which are all non-accrual. Both loans are acquired loans from the Bank SNB portfolio. We've recently done a deep dive in our energy book and while things can obviously change, we're confident we have accounted for all classified credits as of September 30, 2019 and have reserved for them accordingly.In summary, we have balances of $426 million in energy credits or 3.33% of our total loan portfolio. During 2019, we have booked $87 million in new commitments, all of which are Simmons Bank control. We have booked no additional energy loans since the second quarter. 72% of the energy portfolio is upstream and only 7% is service related.In the future, we will emphasize that energy loans we make should be to customers with deep banking relationships with Simmons. I'd also mention that losses like this impact not only the bank itself, but also inappropriately it's manageable. And I expect the White Star loss have a substantial impact on the compensation payable under the incentive plans for over 80 company executives.Our capital position remains very strong. As of September 30 common stockholders' equity was $2.5 billion. Our book value per share was $26.36, an increase of 11.4% from last year, while our tangible book value per share was $15.73, an increase of 16.7% from the same period. Ratio of tangible common equity to tangible assets was 9.1% at September 30. Our total risk-based capital ratio was 13.2%, while our Tier 1 leverage ratio was 9.1%.In our press release, earlier today, we shared our initial projection for the expected increase in the allowance for credit losses that will occur as adoption of new accounting standard. Based on current work completed to-date, we estimate that the ACL will increase by approximately 130% to 170% over the allowance based on June 30, 2019 loan loss. However, when purchase discounts are considered, our ACL will increase by 10% to 30% over the June 30, 2019 total credit coverage ratio.The estimated increase is driven by changes within the new standard and approaches used in modeling, not due to perceived increase in risk within the portfolio. This projection is simply an estimate as a point in time, modeled under fairly stable economic conditions and does not include the impact of our pending merger with The Landrum Company.We will continue to refine our methodology and assumptions in any adjustment to future reserve levels will be based upon the forecast of economic conditions at that time and the composition of our portfolio among other factors that will be subject to change.While we expect significant changes related to season, we do look forward to a single line item representing the entire allowance or the total loan portfolio. The double accounting will still require some explaining with the current shift from acquired to legacy loan approvals and the related provision expense can go away.We're excited to announce that we're still on target to complete our previously announced acquisition with The Landrum Company on October 31 with an expected system conversion during the first quarter of 2020. We're really excited about the expanded market presence in several states as a result of this merger.Last week, our Board approved a new stock buyback program up to $60 million. We look forward to using this mechanism as market conditions warrant as a method to increase shareholder value. Over the past five plus years, we've acquired 10 new banking partners. During that period, we've adopted new associates, products, services, processes, and certainly new markets.Over the next few months, we will evaluate our new organization and make adjustments consistent with our longer-term strategy. We will continue to build the Simmons brand throughout the states we serve by investing in those communities. We will examine our lineup of products and services.We will view the makeup of our loan and deposit portfolios. We will plan for the optimization of our physical locations. We will increase our efforts behind digital offerings to our current and future customers and we will work to make sure we achieved the efficiencies we expect from our investment in technology.Future M&A activity will be strategic and will be prioritized to provide additional scale and market share in our current footprint similar to our expectations regarding our newest partnership with Landmark Bank.This concludes our prepared comments. We'll now take questions from our research analysts and institutional investors. I'll ask the operator to please come back on the line and review the instructions and open the call for questions.