Ben Palmer
Analyst · Stifel
Thanks, Mike, and thank you for joining our call this morning.
Before we get started, I'd like to take a moment to share some unfortunate and sad news. Our long-time Head of Investor Relations and Vice President of Corporate Services, Jim Landers, passed away a few weeks ago after a long and courageous battle with cancer.
I worked closely with Jim here at RPC for more than 20 years, and he was a tremendous contributor to the company in so many ways. I'm sure those of you listening today who are lucky enough to work with him over the years know he was also a great friend and colleague. He will truly be missed by all of us.
Shifting to the quarter. As you can see from our earnings release, the first quarter was a soft start to the year in what feels like a muted oilfield services market. So we did not give explicit financial guidance for the first quarter. We did expect more stable EBITDA. Our activity level in pressure pumping was down modestly on a sequential basis compared to the fourth quarter of 2023, contributing to our overall results finishing below our original expectations.
Unlike some recent quarters where we have seen more volatility in pressure pumping compared to other service lines, revenue performance was generally consistent throughout the business. Our total revenues declined about 4%, with pressure pumping down 5%; and other service lines in aggregate, down 3%.
The frac market remains highly competitive. We have seen some fleets moving into the Permian from gassy plays, adding capacity to an already crowded basin. In addition, ongoing operating efficiency gains have created additional pump hour capacity.
Regarding pricing, motivation to keep assets utilized and absorb fixed cost has certainly impacted industry pricing compared to year-ago levels. We are working vigorously to control costs to be as competitive as possible in this environment. We are also balancing our interest in putting our assets to work with our preference to not burn them out on low-return projects.
Our Tier 4 DGB fleets are highly sought-after and generally serve semi-dedicated customers. Regarding our new Tier 4 dual-fuel fleet, we eagerly await bringing those assets into service around midyear and expect to have solid utilization for this new fleet for the remainder of 2024.
We highlight that our operational performance on existing Tier 4 DGB assets has been quite strong. For example, our gas substitution efficiency has sustained an average of above or about 65% over the past few quarters. We believe this efficiency metric is among the best in the pumping industry and demonstrates our ability to effectively operate these high-quality assets and drive value for our customers. As we have said before, we intend to continue to invest in fleet upgrades.
To reiterate, when we place the new Tier 4 DGB fleet in service in a few months, we will be pulling a Tier 2 diesel fleet out of service, so we do not add to industry capacity, likely repurposing those assets in other parts of our business or keeping them as spare parts and equipment.
We continue to monitor the market for electric fleets. While we do see the benefits of this evolving technology, we also see some potential shifts around the ideal long-term technical and power source solutions. We will continue to invest in our fleet with a strong focus on upgrading to Tier 4 dual fuel. In our view, dual-fuel assets have a long demand runway and we will focus our efforts and capital in this direction until we feel the risk-return profile on investments in electric fleets is further in our favor.
Regarding how we see the next few quarters playing out, visibility remains limited, but we are certainly encouraged by the recent increase in oil prices, with WTI reaching above $80 a barrel recently. The rally is in part attributed to geopolitical events, which can be, of course, unpredictable and reverse quickly, but also supported by a strong U.S. economy. If this level is sustained, we are cautiously optimistic that many of the smaller private E&Ps that make up the spot and semi-dedicated pressure pumping market will steadily increase activity while the larger E&Ps stick to budgeted expenditures and exercise capital discipline.
Mike will now discuss the quarter's financial results.