Jose Luis Laparte
Analyst · Roth Capital
Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us today. Net warehouse sales in the quarter grew 1.3% to $686.4 million, and comparable sales ended with a decrease of minus 1.2%. Sales in our non-Colombia market, Central America and Caribbean in aggregate grew 2.2%. We saw good sales -- good growth in sales in excess of 5% in Honduras, Jamaica and Guatemala as well as Panama, which benefited from having an additional warehouse club for some portion of the quarter compared to Q4 of fiscal 2015.
For Colombia, comp warehouse sales decreased 6% when translated to U.S. dollars at the average rate for the period of COP 2,970 to the dollar. As I mentioned in past earning calls, our goal has been to have positive local currency sales growth. And in this quarter, we saw a comp sales increase of 1.5% with an improving comp trend for each month during the quarter when measuring Colombian pesos.
When we look at the results for Colombia with more detail, sales of locally acquired merchandise increased 19.2%, which reflects the results of our effort to convert items from imports to locally sourced. We are not sacrificing quality of those items, and we're able to realize a reduction in prices versus some of the imports. And we're glad to see the acceptance of our members on the items that have been converted.
Sales of imported merchandise had a decrease of minus 12.6% for the quarter. The stabilization of the Colombian peso in recent months at around COP 3,000 to the dollar has provided an environment where we are seeing an increase in the spending by our Colombian members.
Some of the sales trends in the specific markets that we saw in the third quarter continued in the fourth quarter. Soft demand and flat to slightly down year-on-year sales occurred in Costa Rica, Dominican Republic and Barbados. Economic weakness and government policy are making things difficult for our business in Trinidad that began in Q3 when the government expanded the number of products subject to VAT in February. Q4 sales declined in that market 5% from a year ago, although they were essentially flat when measured in local currency. I will spoke more about Trinidad later in my remarks.
In terms of merchandise categories for the quarter, with some mid-single-digit increases year-over-year in pets, health and beauty, oils and condiments in the food area. In fresh, produce, deli and gourmet deli showed also single-digit increases. For non-foods, we saw softer sales in most of the categories. The standouts with single-digit increases were automobile, home furniture and fashion apparel.
Warehouse margins in the quarter were 14.7%, flat with last year. As some of you may recall, Q3 wasn't a good quarter for margin, given the level of markdowns we did in that period as well as underperforming our end cap and vendor support areas. Margins in Q4 were 100 basis points higher than Q3. This sequential improvements in margin occurred in both our Colombian and non-Colombian markets. Margins in Colombia are stabilizing after many quarters of year-on-year reductions. Merchandise margins in Colombia this quarter were only 20 basis points below Q4 of last year.
Membership income increased 0.7% for the quarter to $11.6 million. We finished the quarter with more than 1,490,000 membership accounts and a 12-month renewal rate of 80% compared to 86% last year. If we exclude Colombia, the 12-month renewal rate was 87%, which is consistent with our renewal rate in the past few years. If we look at the Colombia renewal rate, the overall 12-month rate is still affected by the large number of nonrenewals experienced in Q2 due to the anniversary of the opening of the 3 warehouse clubs in the fall of 2014, which will continue to impact the 12-month renewal calculation in Q1.
On a monthly basis, however, we have seen a steady improvement in renewal rates in Colombia, particularly the last few months of the fiscal year. We are encouraged by the trends and see this as an evidence that with a stabilizing currency, coupled with the efforts of our operations and by the team, members are increasingly seeing the value that a hike on membership provide. In addition to the improving renewal rates, we continue to see strong sign-ups, especially in our Bogota and Medellin markets. I will add a few things about membership in Colombia when I talk about our Chia opening.
Moving on, operating income for the quarter was $32.8 million compared to $34.9 million in Q4 of last year. Despite some of the improving trends we have been seeing in local currency sales in recent membership renewals, Colombia recorded an operating loss for the quarter of $1.3 million, which included $802,000 of preopening expense associated with our Chia warehouse club, which opened in September. This loss compares to a small profit a year ago, resulting in a year-on-year difference of $1.6 million. This was the largest contributor to the $2 million year-on-year reduction in operating income for the total company.
Net income for the quarter was $22.3 million or $0.70 -- $0.74 per diluted share, $0.01 below the fourth quarter of last year. The net income in the current period contains a beneficial effect of certain tax-related items, reducing our effective tax rate and favorably contributing approximately $0.06 per diluted share to our results in the quarter. John will provide some additional information about this in his remarks.
Now let me go to a quick update on the work we're doing to grow sales in some of our warehouse clubs by expanding the sales floor and adding parking spaces. In Q4, we completed the expansion of our Barranquilla club, and we're nearing completion of the expansion of our Santa Elena club in El Salvador. In both cases, we're adding about 8,000 square feet of sales floors and 30% more parking spaces, just in time to improve our members' shopping experience for the upcoming holiday season. We have a number of additional clubs that are candidates for similar expansion, and we're proceeding with permitting process for them.
We continue to push forward a number of other sites for additional warehouse clubs in a few of our markets. As you have heard me say before, the time lines to obtain all of the approvals and permits necessary for us to construct and operate a successful warehouse club can be long. Having said that, let me tell you about the warehouse club we just opened. In September, we successfully opened our seventh warehouse club in Colombia in Chia, a municipality just north of Bogota. Our grand opening on September 1 was an exciting day, and we had sales during the first 3 days in excess of $1 million.
Our shoppers on those days were both new members who signed up in the few -- in the weeks leading up to our opening along with existing members who have been shopping with us in our Salitre, Bogota club or even our Barranquilla club. We even had more than 500 numbers that have purchased a membership at our Salitre club but have never shopped at any PriceSmart. They made their first purchase at our Chia club. As such, we believe that this new location will not only add new members to our existing base in Colombia, but it will also allow a more convenient location for some existing members, particularly in the northern part of Bogota.
We expect to see those members increase the frequency of visits and shop more with us, which will also contribute to an improving renewal rate. The construction activity associated with the building of a facility that would be the future home of our Miami distribution center is proceeding, and reports are that it is even slightly schedule ahead. We currently expect to take possession sometime during our second fiscal quarter and begin operation soon afterward.
I would like to come back to Trinidad, which I mentioned earlier in my remarks. Trinidad is providing a somewhat unique challenge, as we and other businesses are experiencing a very liquid market with respect to sourcing hard currency in that country. We are currently unable to exchange TT dollars for U.S. dollars or other tradable currencies at the level needed to settle payments owed to PriceSmart Inc. by our Trinidad subsidiary for the shipments we are sending to Trinidad. This reduces our ability to deploy that cash for corporate purposes and also exposes us to the financial risk of a devaluation of the TT dollar. We're doing everything we can to source tradable currencies with our banks. However, until such time that, that certain state of tradable currency is resolved, we plan to take a step to limit our exposure. We have made the difficult decision to restrict future shipments of merchandise to Trinidad from our distribution center in Miami to levels that generally align with our Trinidad subsidiary's ability to source and pay for the merchandise in U.S. dollars. Although the situation is dynamic, based on recent levels of tradable currency availability, we anticipate reducing planned U.S. shipments to Trinidad by approximately 20% over the next 3 months. This is likely to result in our Trinidad warehouse clubs running out of certain merchandise, negatively impacting sales in Trinidad, which we estimate to be in the $8 million to $12 million range for the fiscal second -- for the second fiscal quarter.
These actions do not impact merchandise on hand or currently en route from our Miami distribution center to Trinidad. So Q1 of this year will not be impacted nor do they impact our plans to purchase and stock merchandise we obtain locally in Trinidad. We will increase or decrease shipments from the U.S. in line with our ability to exchange TT dollars for other hard currencies, and we will continue to seek to maximize the level of tradable currency our Trinidad subsidiary can obtain. Trinidad has historically been a very good market for us with good sales and very loyal members, but we may be dealing with this difficulties for several more quarters.
One final comment as we finish the month of October and prepare our PriceSmart clubs for the upcoming holiday season. In most cases, the exciting merchandise we have for our members is already either in the clubs or almost there. The initial reaction to our seasonal items appears to be good. Across our company, we're ready for the busy season of the year, and we will continue to seek opportunities to improve our results even with the challenges that exist in the markets either because of soft economies or other factors. We always recognize that we can do better and show the members that we're there for them to help -- we're there for them to help them save money.
Thanks again for joining us today. After John's remarks, we will take your questions