Evangelos Perros
Analyst · Jefferies. Please go ahead
Thank you, Sanjiv. 2024 was a solid year for Pagaya from a financial perspective as we turn the corner to a new chapter in our company's history. In the beginning of 2024, we set out two aspirational goals to become cashflow positive and to set ourselves up to become GAAP net income positive in 2025. And while the journey to get there has been very challenging, the team readily embraced it and successfully executed towards achieving these goals. We are ready to leverage all of the hard work, tough decisions, instructive learnings from our disappointing past performance and deep management experience to truly demonstrate the earnings power of our business in 2025 and beyond. Throughout 2024, we were enlightened by our experience dealing with legacy issues and the adverse impact from our 2021 to 2023 performance, but still remained laser focused on building a disruptive business that can withstand all cycles and create long term shareholder value. Pagaya has been tested as has our sector, U.S. consumers and our lending partners. And we have persevered and emerged from a series of macro and other factors with a strong fee generating engine, improved capital structure and liquidity profile and significant operating leverage. I'm very pleased to be here today and provide our inaugural launch of positive GAAP profitability guidance, which we expect in the second quarter of this year, while executing on a business plan that is self-funded. This is no small feat for a company of our size and short history. Our results for the fourth quarter were better than our guidance, demonstrating strong monetization of robust network volume and continued operating leverage, leading to 88% EBITDA growth. We are publicly guiding to GAAP net income profitability for the first time, which I will discuss in more detail later. Before turning to detailed results, I'd like to highlight several achievements, which reflect consistent execution of our financial strategy. FRLPC as a percent of volume at a record 4.5% increased 25 basis points-quarter-over quarter and 130 basis points year-over-year, the truest measure of the value we provide to our network partners. Core operating expenses were 49% of our FRLPC, the lowest in our public history, a testament to the operating leverage in our model and the trend, which will persist going forward. Our funding program has been further optimized with diverse funding sources such as the recent forward flow from Blue Owl and improvement within our ABS program. Net cash required to fund our volume has declined to 2% to 3% for personal loans and 1.5% to 2.5% for all network volume. This is a step function improvement in our risk exposure in absolute terms as well as cash flow characteristics. Our interest expense and access to liquidity improved meaningfully as we completed our previously announced balance sheet restructuring and refinancing. Lastly and importantly, we no longer expect to face material headwinds to profitability from securities on our balance sheet associated with 2021 through 2023 vintages. This allows us to demonstrate the true earnings power of our operating model as stable recurring growth in revenue is expected to drive profitability. Turning to network volume, we saw 9% growth in the fourth quarter to $2.6 billion of which we funded under 1% of the flow through our network, relatively in line with the trend over the last several quarters. Part of the increase was attributable to CRM and higher than expected conversion versus what we expected with our previous guidance. Personal loans remained the largest contributor to volume, up 24% year-over-year, organically at approximately 60% of total. Total revenue and other income of $279 million grew by 28% from the year ago quarter with fee revenue up 31% primarily due to personal loans. FRLPC grew 55% to a record $117 million in the quarter and was a record 4.5% of network volume. This was at the high end of the 3.5% to 4.5% range we provided for the second half of 2024 and was up 130 basis points from the year ago quarter. Once again lending product fees made up the majority or 71% of total FRLPC up from 63% one year ago and 32% two years ago. This is an important and purposeful shift toward more sustainable and predictable revenue growth through the cycle. Our adjusted EBITDA grew 88% year over year to a record 64 million with margins up 730 basis points to 23%. Incremental margins of 49% in the quarter reflected strong operating leverage, a trend we expect to continue going forward. Net income attributable to Pagaya was a loss of 238 million and was primarily impacted by fair value adjustments a risk that we had highlighted during our third quarter earnings. The losses ended up higher than we expected. Overall fair value adjustments net in our overall portfolio were a loss of $156 million versus $101 million in the prior quarter. Approximately 90% was attributable to 2023 vintages. In addition, previously recorded market driven losses of $79 million in other comprehensive income on our balance sheet were reversed and reported as other expenses net on our P&L. This reversal is attributable to our fair value estimate, assuming we will exercise our optional redemption rights on several of our investments as the most likely scenario compared with prior estimates. We believe we have taken the majority of our losses related to historical vintages in the last quarter, and we do not expect them to have a material impact, if any, to our performance in the future. I want to highlight a few things and emphasize what I mentioned before. Losses in any consumer lending business are to be expected, but the outcome of our execution over the challenging 2021 to 2023 period is still deeply disappointing. Throughout 2024, we have taken significant actions to effectively navigate similar outcomes in the future. Select examples include our scale and expanded flow access, improved credit underwriting and risk management overlay, funding optimization and diversification, cost of capital improvement, all of which have been validated by third parties such as rating agencies, corporate funding partners, and institutional investors looking to gain access to our production. In addition, introducing GAAP net income guidance is one step towards driving visibility and accountability. Continuing with our results, interest expense was 26 million in the quarter while share based compensation expense of 16 million was toward the lower end of our expected range of 15 million to 20 million per quarter. Adjusted net income was positive for the six consecutive quarter at 13 million, excluding share-based compensation and other non-cash items such as fair value adjustments. Our credit performance remains strong with continued improvement over the past two years, driven by enhancement of our underwriting models. Our personal loan cumulative net losses for first and third quarter 2023 vintages are 20% to 35% lower than peak losses in late 2021 at the same month on book. Auto cumulative net losses for first and third quarter 2023 vintages are trending approximately 30% to 50% lower than peak 2022 vintages at the same month on book. Turning to funding, the team has driven meaningful improvement in diversification and efficiency of our funding channels. In our ABS program, as of the end of 2024, we have issued $26 billion across 64 transactions with more than 130 partners, including our sixth AAA rated transaction, which closed in the fourth quarter. We expect net risk retention levers in our personal loan paid ABS program to remain in the 4% to 5% range of notional size of the deals. Last week, we announced our second large forward flow agreement with funds managed by Blue Owl Capital to purchase up to $2.4 billion in consumer loans through the Pagaya network over a 24-month period. This is a clear testament to the attractiveness and demand of consumer credit originated across Pagaya's platform and our focus on funding loan origination in a capital efficient manner. We have further diversified on the back of our third pass through securitization of the year in December for $100 million. As a reminder, pass-through transactions not only help to diversify our funding sources, but the net risk retention requirement is at a minimal 1% of the notional size of the deal. We will continue to leverage strong demand from investors for this product. We currently expect all non-ABS funding channels to represent 25% to 50% of our 2025 funding sources. This will lead to continued reduction in required risk retention, and we will continue to consider holding more securities when and if it makes economic sense. Before turning to guidance, I want to review our balance sheet and provide more details on fair value adjustments for the quarter. We ended the year with $227 million in cash and cash equivalents and $764 million in investments in loan and securities. In the fourth quarter, the fair value of the overall investment portfolio of net of non-controlling interest and prior to any new additions in the quarter was adjusted downward by $156 million versus $101 million last quarter. 90% of those adjustments were driven by the 2023 vintages as a result of the meaningfully higher cost of capital at which these transactions were executed, leaving minimal to no cushion against changes in initial loss assumptions, which still ended up being higher than expected at the time of pricing. Additionally, we reversed the previous loss of $79 million in other comprehensive income in our shareholders equity, which was a reclassification to other expense as I explained earlier. Our 2025 guidance, which includes positive GAAP profitability in 2025, reflects multiple illustrative scenarios related to future impairments, if any, as laid out in our earnings supplement. In the fourth quarter, we also added $17 million of new investments in loan and securities, net of pay downs from prior investments, inclusive of an $8 million gain on sale. As of year-end, the mix of our investments was 31% notes and 68% certificates versus 13% notes and 87% certificates a year ago. The improvement in mix and quality of our assets is an additional source of potential liquidity for Pagaya as we head into 2025. Turning to our outlook. Our full year 2025 and Q1, 2025 outlook reflects the current momentum and resilience in our business, and while we see improvement in the macro environment, we remain cautious. The focus remains on profitable growth and we expect to generate positive GAAP net income profitability in the second quarter of the year. We expect continued growth across personal loan auto and POS products while FRLPC reflects the full year impact of the improvement in fees in 2024 and the change in funding mix. Given the investments to-date in operating efficiencies, we do not expect any material investment in the business in 2025. GAAP net income profitability will be driven by these factors along with lower fair value adjustments, if any, as well as lower interest expense. All the result of our relentless execution in 2024 to get the Company to be cash flow and GAAP net income positive. For the first quarter of 2025, we expect network volume in the range of $2.5 billion to $2.7 billion, total revenue and other income in the range of 280 million to 295 million, and adjusted EBITDA in the range of 65 million to 75 million. We expect first quarter GAAP net income in the range of negative $20 million to breakeven. For the full year, we expect network volume in the range of $10.25 billion to $11.75 billion total revenue and other income of $1.15 billion to $1.275 billion and adjusted EBITDA in the range of $265 million to $315 million. We are guiding to GAAP net income for the year in the range of negative $10 million to positive $14 million. With that, let me turn it back to the operator for Q&A.