Jon Bortz
Analyst · Evercore. Please proceed with question
Thanks, Ray. So let me begin with the macro. Most economic statistics continue to improve and have been improving since last fall. These include employment growth, corporate profits and consumer confidence, among others. GDP growth estimates for the world have also increased for 2017 and 2018, supported by stronger synchronized growth in most regions around the world. This year, business investment, which had been a lagger, has also begun to show better growth again. Despite these stronger economic statistics, our quandary is that our industry is yet to see any meaningful improvements in demand despite historical correlations, suggesting we would have benefited by now. Nevertheless, the economy continues to maintain modest annual growth, with healthy employment gains and our industry continues to experience modest growth in overall demand. On an equally positive note for the intermediate term future, though not a benefit for next year, construction starts in the US have slowed due to a combination of a more challenging environment for obtaining construction financing, significant increases in construction and development costs, and certainly an overall softening in the underlying operating business as RevPAR gains have moderated across the industry to roughly inflationary gains. And a growing number of major metropolitan markets are experiencing RevPAR declines. In fact, nine of the top 25 markets as defined by Smith Travel, suffered RevPAR declines year to date, with 13 of the top 25 markets declining in the third quarter. As it relates to supply growth, we currently expect the rate of supply growth to top out in the urban markets in 2018 in general. And for the industry, we expect supply growth to peak in 2019. One other positive that's occurred, which if it continues should help our industry and our business, is that the dollar is falling significantly from its peak earlier this year following the election. The dollar is currently down a little over 8% this year. This should lead, all things being equal, to more international inbound travel in the future, as we saw declines in international inbound travel last year as a result of the dollar's previous run up. Unfortunately, while we continue to see increased global travel due to stronger economies around the world, all things aren't equal and the US has not been participating as much as it should be, due to non-economic political factors that are acting as headwinds to increased international inbound travel. We hope these abate. As for our industries performance in the quarter, it was mostly as expected, but for the pluses and minuses from the hurricanes in Texas and Florida. Industry demand was better than supply growth in Q3, primarily due to a better than expected September, which was likely a result of the benefits in Houston and Texas following the hurricane. In fact, Houston's robust growth following Hurricane Harvey added over 60 basis points to the industry's 3.3% demand growth for September. For the quarter, demand was up 2.4%, a deceleration compared to Q1’s 2.8%, but up slightly to Q2’s 2.3%, even with the shift of the Jewish holidays into September this year from October last year. Industry supply growth in the third quarter ticked up marginally to 1.9% as compared to the first half’s 1.8%. This roughly flat trend of industry supply growth continues to surprise us and is likely a result of construction schedules stretching out even more due to both shortages of construction labor and overwhelmed city building and inspection departments. And as a result of the two major hurricanes, we expect that demand for construction labor will increase further and exacerbate the already longer construction schedules. With occupancy increasing 0.5% and ADR rising 1.4%, RevPAR for the industry increased 1.9% in the quarter, down from the first half’s 3% growth and last quarter's 2.7%. The other notable observations from the quarter were that business demand growth remained modest, but relatively stable, though slightly lower due to the holiday shift in September. And leisure travel remained healthy in the quarter. Transient outperformed group overall for the industry in the third quarter and has outperformed for the whole year so far. For Pebblebrook, the trends were similar. So we had some additional headwinds in the quarter, most but not all of which were previously communicated in detail. What was unexpected in the quarter were the hurricanes, wildfires and even a hepatitis outbreak that all had a negative impact on our demand, not only in the directly affected markets like South Florida, the Columbia River Gorge and San Diego, but throughout the country at our properties due to cancellations and no shows from people and businesses directly affected by the events, including as a result of their inability to travel out of their affected regions. In total, we estimate that we lost $900,000 in room revenues or roughly 30 basis points in same property hotel RevPAR growth in the quarter, another $800,000 in other revenues, including food and beverage and just shy of $1 million in EBITDA. As expected, our performance in San Francisco in Q3 was not as bad as Q2, as was also the case for the city. The biggest negative impact came from the slow ramp up of Hotel Zoe due to the delays in the completion of the renovation late last quarter. Hotel Zoe’s RevPAR in Q3 declined 21.6%, with the majority of it coming from declines in occupancy. The hotel has been very well received by our customers, so we fully expect to see significant improvement next year. We also had significant under-performance at Sir Francis Drake and (Oregon) Fisherman's Wharf, though we expected these challenges and took them into account in our outlook. Both properties suffered from an inability to build a group base further out, and therefore they underperformed their concepting in the market. We're working hard at both properties with our operators to right these ships. In general, the San Francisco market performed a little better than we thought, as the strength of the underlying economy locally helped offset the negative effect of the Moscone closures. The good news about the impact from Moscone this year, as well as our renovations, particularly at Hotel Zoe, is that they make for much easier comparisons next year and in 2019. And citywide bookings in San Francisco are positive for 2018. While still way down from 2016 due to the ongoing renovation and expansion that is scheduled to be completed at the end of next year, they're up roughly 20% in room nights, along with 11 more compression days with 5,000 or more citywide room nights on the books. In 2019, citywide room nights on the books are up another 62% from what's currently on the books for 2018. With compression days of 5,000 or more room nights up by a whopping 102% were up from n41 days in 2018 to 83 days in 2019. These are all record numbers and materially surpass the strongest prior years in San Francisco's history. For Pebblebrook, we should also see continued market share gains due to recent renovations in San Francisco at Hotel Zoe, Hotel Zeppelin and Hotel Zephyr, as well as improved relative performance at Hotel Zelos due to better management. In addition to the recently transformed hotels Zoe, Zeppelin and Zephyr in San Francisco, the completion of our other transformations at Hotel Revere Boston Common and Hotel Palomar Beverly Hills and the upcoming completion of the renovation of the Gulf Tower at LaPlaya in Naples early next year, should drive significant upside and relative performance over the next few years. Continuing ramp up from the completion of similar renovations and transformations at W Los Angeles West Beverly Hills, Vintage Portland, Union Station Nashville, Monaco DC and Hotel Colonnade Coral Gables, should also enhance our performance in the next couple of years. At the four transformational redevelopments completed in 2016, Hotel Zeppelin San Francisco, Union Station Nashville, Monaco DC, including Dirty Habit, and Hotel Colonnade Coral Gables, EBITDA rose by $2 million in the third quarter. That brings the total EBITDA increase for 2016 redevelopments to $5.7 million, already above our outlook provided at the beginning of the year of $5.5 million. While these are very encouraging numbers, there is more to come. When we look at the portfolio by coast, RevPAR at our West Coast hotels experienced a RevPAR decline of 3.6%, while RevPAR at our East Coast hotels, excluding LaPlaya in Naples, declined by 5%. We outperformed in five of our markets when comparing to the urban RevPAR performance of each particular market, and underperformed in seven markets. Notable outperformance was in Portland, Coral Gables, Nashville and Boston. Notable under-performance occurred in San Francisco as described, Seattle where our Kimptons are struggling, Washington DC also at Kimpton, West LA, particularly the Palomar and the Mondrian and in Buckhead at our Intercontinental where we've recently changed out the key leadership at the hotel. As of the Intercon, we have made changes or are in the process of making leadership changes at many of our hotels that have been underperforming. The industry's third quarter RevPAR performance does not change our industry RevPAR growth forecast of 2.3 - 2% to 3% for the year and we continue to believe it will likely end the year towards the middle of the range. RevPAR growth for the urban markets has underperformed the industry year to date by 150 basis points and it underperformed in Q3 by 230 basis points, all as we expected. Interestingly, if you remove both San Francisco urban and Manhattan from the third quarter numbers, urban would have been almost 53 basis points better. So you can see that those two markets, because of their large sizes and high octane season rates, have a disproportionate impact on the overall urban statistics reported by Smith Travel. The difficult comparisons in Cleveland and Philadelphia in the third quarter due to the political conventions last year, also worsened the performance of the star urban markets. For Pebblebrook, our outlook for same hotel RevPAR and EBITDA, takes into account the removal of LaPlaya from both Q3 and Q4 due to the hotel's closure beginning in early September due to hurricane Irma. LaPlaya’s operating numbers are now taken into account in the overall corporate performance. Our adjusted EBITDA and adjusted FFO numbers, reflect the company's performance without the negative impact to the balance sheet and without the loss from the deductible related to the physical property, but do include the decline in EBITDA due to LaPlaya being closed during the quarter. Accounting for the exclusion of LaPlaya from our outlook, for our same hotel EBITDA numbers, our outlook range for Q4 remains the same as our previous implied outlook, and the upper end of our outlook for the entire year increases by the amount of the beat in Q3, which equaled $800,000 and the lower end increases by $3.8 million. Then taking into account the reduction of $5 million EBITDA in Q4 at LaPlaya due to the property’s closure and delay in the completion of the renovation and reopening of the Gulf Tower rooms due to the hurricane, our outlook range for adjusted EBITDA is reduced by the $5 million impact at LaPlaya in Q4, then partially offset by the Q3 beat of $3.5 million at the top of the range, and more than offset by the $6.5 million Q3 beat at the bottom of the range. Our outlook for adjusted FFO goes through the same machinations, with the upper end of the range increasing by the amount of the $0.06 beat in the third quarter, subsequently reduced by $0.07 for the fourth quarter impact at LaPlaya. Our outlook range for same hotel RevPAR for the year remains the same at minus 1% to minus 2%. However, we now expect to be at the bottom of the range. This is due to the negative impact of the lost revenues due to the various natural disasters, including the ongoing wildfires outside of San Francisco in October, as well as the removal of LaPlaya from the comparable numbers where we've been forecasting strong RevPAR growth in Q4 following the originally planned completion of LaPlaya’s renovation at the end of the third quarter and the easy comparison to last year's fourth quarter when the resort was also under renovation. For Q4, our RevPAR range is now minus 0.5% to growth of 1.5%. Before we complete our prepared remarks, I'd like to make a special mention of our operating teams at both LaPlaya in Naples and Hotel Colonnade in Coral Gables and the incredible efforts they made beyond the call of duty, to ensure the safety of our guests and our associates, protect the value of our hotels and get back up and running as quickly as possible. So again, thank you. Finally, despite all of the natural disasters we've been facing recently, as the R.E.M. song says, we still feel fine. That completes our prepared remarks. We’d now be happy to answer whatever questions you may have. Michelle, please proceed with the Q&A.