Martin A. Nisenholtz
Analyst
This is Martin. Let me just give you a couple of points on that, three, really. The first is that from a broad-based perspective, the industry itself has trended down a little bit coming in to this year. E-marketer, which is one of the sources that we use, has reduced its forecast by about 5 points down to 19%. John, you may have seen the Yahoo! results yesterday, so I think we have seen in general a bit of a slowdown in the business overall. With respect to our properties, about.com, as Janet said, grew 24% in the quarter, which is pretty good but off a little bit from last year when the volume at About was going through the roof. That is related to principally the CPC side of the business. The display side of About is doing much better this year than it was doing last year, but the CPC side is dragging it down a little bit because of that governor on volume. We have many programs and plans in place to increase volume throughout the year but given that we do not want to over-promise, we felt that it was prudent to send a signal that volume was abating somewhat. With respect to your question about this display, and this sort of relates to my first point, yes, there has been a slight slowdown in the display line at nytimes.com, but some of that has to do in the first quarter with a single extraordinary item that I am not going to get into, but the point is if that had not happened, we would have performed much better. And then finally, because the businesses are still significantly -- not dependent on but weighted towards in some respects the classified area, we have seen a slowdown in the real estate business overall. I think while the online side is trending very well, the upsells obviously are affected somewhat by that. I might end by simply saying that as I think we all know, the base at the Times company overall is quite large. It is much larger than many of the other companies and so off of the bigger base, the growth rates are obviously harder to attain. Overall, that’s the story. It is early in the year. The business is, as you know, quite volatile, so there could be some significant change as we go forward.