Barry R. Sloane
Analyst · KBW
Thank you very much, and welcome to our Q1 2026 Financial Results Conference Call. My name is Barry Sloane, President, CEO, and founder of NewtekOne. Also presenting today is Frank DeMaria, Chief Financial Officer of NEWT, the financial holding company that's publicly traded, and Frank is also Chief Financial Officer of Newtek Bank, National Association. Those who want to follow today's presentation along, please go to newtekone.com, N-E-W-T-E-K-O-N-E.com. Go to the Investor Relations section and the Presentations section. We appreciate everyone's attending today, given that this is our 25th year as a publicly traded company and our 13th quarter reporting as a bank holding company after acquiring National Bank of New York City. We've accomplished quite a lot, from $180 million of total assets in National Bank of New York City to over $2 billion, the financial holding company is approximately $2.9 billion of assets, and the bank has over $2 billion of deposits, up from $140 million at the time we acquired it approximately 3.25 years ago. We want to make sure in today's presentation, one of the biggest concerns I think people have, particularly in the current volatile market, is credit quality. I want to point everyone towards Slide 21, where we're able to demonstrate that the bank clearly has stabilized credit. NPLs are down as a percentage when we typically take out the government guarantees for both the numerator and the denominator. With that said, let's go to Slide #2 under forward-looking statements. Let's absorb that. And then let's go to Slide #3. Important always to note when you look at NewtekOne as its purpose: our mission hasn't changed since it was founded in 1998 at 120 West 18th Street, Apartment 4B, with 3 founders. The focus of NewtekOne is to provide small- to medium-sized businesses, small- to medium-sized enterprises, and independent business owners all across the United States to have financial and business solutions that are state-of-the-art. We help our clients become more successful by growing their revenues, reducing their expense, and reducing their risk. I think more importantly, we're very much involved in the concept of real-time payments. We'll talk about that quite a bit today, moving money, and giving businesses the analytics that they really desire and require, apart from what they typically get from the top 4 large financial institutions in the United States, regional banks, and community banks. On Slide #4. How do we do this? NewtekOne uses technology to tackle its mission statement. I think it's important to point out that although we've taken many different sizes and shapes as a publicly traded company, we started off as a 1933 Act company, converted in November of 2011 to a 1940 Act BDC company, and then converted back into a financial holding company. We acquired National Bank of New York City primarily for the purpose of improving our client experiences historically. We believe that by using technology, we have solved the 3 primary challenges that the banking industry needs to overcome to be able to help the customer base. One, the high cost of infrastructure with too many branches and expensive traditional bankers. We are traditional bankerless and branchless. If you take a look at the efficiency ratio at Newtek Bank, National Association for this particular quarter, it was 40%. Insufficient lending margins from riskless loans. We think this particular industry, when they're lending, generally is avoiding risk. They're not managing risk, and we think that there's very little margin in their business. And frankly, if they aren't able to acquire deposits materially below the risk-free rate, there's not a lot of margin in their business. Lastly, from a deposit perspective, basically taking in deposits with 0 interest paid or noninterest-bearing deposits and charging excessive fees for the business client is not in the domain of NewtekOne or Newtek Bank, National Association. We have an extremely attractive platform that pays for business clients: 1% on checking, 3.5% on business savings, and a true, no asterisk, 0 fee bank account. Important to note, we're a major adopter of real-time payments. We can announce today that we are now -- have FedNow for receiving payments for our client base. We've been approved by the Federal Reserve's FedNow program and The Clearing House RTP. So we're fully approved, this is live, and we're able to benefit our clients today with real-time payments appearing in their account. On Slide #5, obviously, these are things I think many of you are already aware of in terms of our structure. NewtekOne is considered a bank holding company regulated by the Fed Board of Governors. Newtek Bank, National Association, which used to be called National Bank of New York City, is a depository offering great solutions, real-time payments, obviously, it's a lender to the business community. Through its holding company, investment in Newtek Merchant Solutions provides payment processing solutions, payroll solutions, and insurance solutions that support independent business owners all across the United States. We've utilized our own proprietary and patented technological solutions to acquire customers cost effectively. We receive 600 to 800 unique business referrals a day through our NewTracker trademark client acquisition tool, and we give customers through the Newtek Advantage, a far-advanced business portal to help them manage their business, move money on a real-time basis, as well as get the types of historic data and analytics that they so rightly deserve. NewtekOne provides a full menu of best-in-class on-demand business and financial solutions to independent business owners. Importantly, we don't leave clients to just software. We have staff, over 300, that are available on demand, on camera. So in addition to great software and great technology in a frictionless manner, they can also get somebody on camera when they need them. On Slide #6, we talk about our target market. I think the relevance of our target market is the SMB, SME, or independent business owner market is quite large and quite lucrative. It's estimated that there's 36 million independent business owners in the United States that identify themselves in this category. According to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, it's 43% of U.S. GDP. And frankly, we've been tremendously supportive of this particular asset class. And according to the SBA, we have stabilized and supported over 110,000 jobs over the last 5 years, the second highest amongst all SBA lenders. The independent business owner is a huge economic demographic that, frankly, the existing industry has taken advantage of by basically taking their deposits, not really providing them attractive lending solutions to enable them to grow their business, or for that matter, the ability to move money on a real-time basis. It's important to point out that in recent SBA data, NewtekOne is the largest SBA lender by units and is top 2 or 3 by loan volume. Also important to note that even though the bank's balance sheet is a little over $2.1 billion, when we make an SBA loan, 75% is government guaranteed, we typically sell it. So even though the bank is $2 billion, we basically -- when you look at the government guarantees and the fact that we're servicing them, it's a much bigger infrastructure. I would guess over our history, if we kept all the government guarantees on the balance sheet rather than selling them, it would be approximately $4 billion of total assets. On Slide #7, we're going to focus on the really attractive quarter that we just reported. Really good start to 2026, EPS of $0.43, beating Street consensus by about $0.01, reflected 19% and 23% growth over Q1 '25 basic and diluted EPS, and was within our $0.37 to $0.47 guidance range. We want to reconfirm our 2026 guidance of $2.35 at the midpoint and establish a $2.60 midpoint for 2027. The current Street consensus for 2027, $2.35, $2.40, $2.45, and $2.50 from 4 of the 6 analysts to blend to $2.43. Also, for those that follow our stock closely, you're familiar that we've done a very nice job in growing book value and tangible book value. So book value per share ended Q1 2026 at $12.35 and tangible book at $11.84. We started off at a tangible book at $6.92 in Q1 2023, quite a substantial growth over the course of time. It's the technological advancements that are supporting a record number of originated loans and tremendous year-over-year growth. In the first quarter of 2026, we originated 961 loan units, up 40% year-over-year, with 500 loan units alone originated in March versus 287. In dollar terms, $391 million of loans, versus $366 million of loans for Q1 2025. And March's momentum has continued in April with approximately 10% year-over-year growth. In addition, we were able to capture the operating leverage. Q1 2026 operating expense was just over -- up over 7.5% on year-over-year asset growth of 35%, and a return on average assets of 1.96%, very favorable to the industry, but also important for those of you that follow the company, the first quarter is clearly our weakest from an earnings perspective. I think it's important to note, using technology on a loan under $350,000, we're using AI to read tax returns, read lease agreements, read operating agreements, as well as alternative valuation methods. So by being able to do this, we're able to really fund small business loans quite quickly. As a matter of fact, we talked about, which we'll do in future slides, the 7-day loan. Once a loan application is completed, we can clearly fund that particular application under $350,000 within 7 days. Slide #8, deposit growth, extremely important for banks. We had 2 consecutive quarters of record number of deposit accounts. We ended Q1 2026 with 37,000 deposit accounts, more than doubling year-over-year. In 13 quarters, we've grown deposits from $142 million to $1.9 billion. Business deposits, which come in at a lower cost, increased Q-over-Q and year-over-year by $37 million and $173 million, respectively. Consumer deposits also climbing quarter-over-quarter and year-over-year by $392 million and $668 million. Since the acquisition of Newtek Bank in 2023, 54% of our lending clients have opened up a business deposit account. And since February of 2024, when we initiated key man life to Newtek Bank business lending clients, 25% of those clients have purchased key man life and do so in an automatic, frictionless basis where they apply once and they can get a bank account, key man life, they can currently get flood insurance in the menu, in the very near future, we're also going to be able to offer property and casualty, all automated, one app, frictionless, and get that client their funds as quickly as possible for those that qualify. We just started in January originating C&I long am loans, nicknamed C&I LA. We used to call them ALP loans, and these are being originated at the bank. The C&I LA originations approximated $85.7 million versus $68.5 million in the same quarter a year earlier. We are now funding these, obviously, with bank deposits, where historically, in 2025 and earlier than that, we funded them up at the holding company with warehouse facilities. The cost of those facilities were approximately SOFR plus 325 basis points, but the bigger cost, which I'll describe in a second, has been not using a warehouse facility, but the bank funding. We have historically securitized C&I LA loans on a regular basis, and we may do so from the bank's balance sheet. Once again, let's take an example of, say, a $500 million portfolio. So a $500 million portfolio, which historically was originated at the holding company with a 70% advance rate from a street warehouse line -- and we should note, we just paid 2 of those down to 0, one from Capital One, one from Deutsche Bank -- had a 30% equity haircut. So on $500 million worth of loans, you need $150 million of capital from the holdco. Once you securitize with a 15% OC, or owner certificate, meaning that you had 3 classes of bonds above it -- single A bond, a BBB bond, and a BB bond -- to give you an 85% advance rate. An 85% advance rate on $500 million of collateral is $75 million. All would have to be contributed from the holding company. In the event that we securitize off the bank's balance sheet, it's dramatically less. You're funding it with core deposits at approximately a 10-to-1 leverage, much more efficient and much more profitable. On Slide #9, tangible book value per share, one of my favorite slides. So real simple for those people that like to invest based upon tangible book value growing. If you look at this slide, it's a little dizzying to a certain degree: $6.92 in Q1 2023. It's currently $11.84. Frank DeMaria will talk about where we think we'll be at the end of the year, and it'll be $13.50 approximately. And then on top of that, you look at the dividends that we paid. So $2.43 of cumulative common dividends declared, $4.92 of tangible book value growth since the conversion, we've delivered $7.35 of value to shareholders, more than double the Q1 tangible book value of $6.92, something we're really proud of. On Slide #10, we touched upon this a little earlier, the technological advances that are supporting increased loan volume. Those advances have also helped us with deposit growth. I think once again, it's important to note, we had tremendous unit and dollar growth in the first quarter. We talked about the 7-day business loan. We talked about our AI that we use for smaller balance loans with respect to using it to read tax returns, which are very important to spreading financials and actually calculating debt service coverage. Some of our competitors in the marketplace, frankly, that have been scoring [ going ] some of these loans, they can't do it. They've got to change their technology. It's creating friction. We've had several of our competitors in the space reporting problems with their fintech originators that aren't able to actually deliver the solution. Not a problem for NewtekOne or Newtek Bank. We've been using the 5 Cs of credit lending in our entire history. We're doing that on the $350,000 loans to basically get liens, get appraisals, read operating agreements, and lease agreements. Importantly, when you compare our business loans, which are structured to amortize over 10 to 25 years with no balloon payments, these are commercially viable rates. Compare it to merchant cash advance, or the daily debit type loans, we can create monthly payments that are 7% lower than a borrower would experience with alternative financing options that are structured with shorter maturities. So our business model, whether it's 7(a), C&I LA, or loans that go into the bank, I think it's important: we have been long amortizing lenders since 2003. We have that expertise. Our loans give the borrower a lot of flexibility. There's no covenant, so it allows them to distribute all the income. It allows them to borrow more without asking. It allows them to do an acquisition. What's the trade-off? We get a personal guarantee. We get a lien on all business assets, and in many cases, personal assets. We would trade that off all day long. We have the knowledge and experience making loans over 2 decades to have a very good feel for the full frequency and severity. We know these businesses. We know these markets. We do know how to manage, making these types of loans, get greater net returns after provisions, after allowance for credit losses, which are almost 5%, very, very strong risk management within the walls of Newtek Bank. We're very proud of what we've been able to do here. And now when you add technology, there's no need for a business owner to borrow money from an MCA or a daily debit loan at [ huge risk weightings ]. They might have to wait a couple of more days, but they get a long am, they get an adult payment, and they actually get an adult loan. Those technological advances that we have created for ourselves internally have also been very valuable to our digital account opening and deposit growth on Slide #11. Take a look at the graphs. They're very attractive. You can see we've grown business deposits. We've grown total deposits. We've grown depository accounts. We're just doing very, very well in this particular area. Importantly, these are insured deposits, 78% insured. These deposits are not going anywhere. They're insured. They're small. You're not going to have a Silicon Valley Bank-type problem because the customers weren't paid any interest. They had millions or tens of millions or hundreds of millions of dollars that just flew at a moment's notice. We're very, very happy about paying market rates of interest. We get good margins on our loans, net of write-offs. It's a real good, smart business model. Slide #12. This is our nonbank lender, held over from the days when we didn't own a bank, and we had to fund our business with warehouse lines and securitization at the holding company. So Newtek Small Business Finance is winding down. I think it's also important to note that this portfolio has really experienced what we consider the Great Financial Crisis for small business, where rates went up 3% to 5% in a short period of time and inflation really made it difficult for businesses. So when you look at net increase in nonaccruals, shrinking. The accruing portfolio, shrinking. Nonaccruals at fair value, shrinking. The outstanding securitization notes, down to $113 million. That's really important because the loans that are in the securitizations, all the cash flow is being used to pay down the debt in the securitization. So once you hit the cleanup call, and there's 3 securitizations left -- we started off with 13 -- and you hit the cleanup call, which we're going to start to hit those in the next 6 to 24 months, probably on all 3, then those loans and the monthly P&I flows through, and we're able to use that cash flow for a lot of nice things up at the holding company. Also, when you look at NSBF on a total consolidated basis, at the beginning of 2025, it was 21%. On 3/31/2025, it's down to 13%. So it continues to shrink. We're happy about that. The remaining portfolio is fairly seasoned. The weighted average life is about 66 months. So we think we're through the worst part of the curve. And we certainly appreciate the opportunity to participate in the program as a nonbank lender. And we've been participating as a bank lender pretty much for 3.25 -- actually about 3 years. Slide #13, the C&I LA program, extremely additive. I want to really emphasize how additive it is. The average loan size on C&I LA is about $4 million to $5 million. Let's use $5 million because it's a nice round number. So on 100 units, you've got $500 million. On 200 units, it's $1 billion. To do $1 billion of 7(a) loans, you almost have to do 3,000 units. So the ability to grow with our pipeline in a quality manner exists, it's there without reaching for bad credits. Importantly, the C&I LA program is not a 7(a) type program with a 7(a) borrower. The borrowers are seasoned, will go through the metric profile. You'll see these are very strong credits. So this is going to help us diversify. As a matter of fact, at the end of March, the 7(a) portfolio at the bank, I think, was down to about 41% of the total portfolio. So diversification is an extremely important part of risk management at the bank. We plan on doing more CRE at the bank, more short am C&I, as well as the C&I LA program, which has the great margins, and we've developed a 6- to 7-year expertise in. Once again, the size of the loans are extremely important. It will enable us to grow the balance sheet in a better quality manner without having to reach. In January of 2026, we successfully launched our fourth C&I LA securitization. There was $295 million of securitized notes sold, backed by $342 million of loans. It was our 17th securitization in our history. The deal was 10x oversubscribed with 32 institutions purchasing the notes. Slide #14, very important. I think you need to absorb this. These businesses, on a weighted average basis, have been around for about 10 years. That is not an SBA borrower. Weighted average LTV, 47%; weighted average debt service coverage, over 3. That is not an SBA borrower. When you look at the coupon, you say, "Well, gee, how are they getting a coupon?" If you give an entrepreneur the flexibility of not dealing with intrusive covenants, letting them distribute their income, but they're willing to personally guarantee, lien all business assets, and some personal assets so that you're covered, this is a good loan program. We have repositioned the value of early amortizing a C&I loan, or putting a 3- or a 5-year balloon payment on a loan, of requiring certain financials, 45 days in arrears after the quarter. I would much rather look into their bank account, see what they're doing, who they're paying, what they're paying, seeing the revenues coming into the bank account, than have those financials all day long. That's once again the advantage of being technologically on top of this particular business and this particular industry. Once again, limiting state concentrations, limiting industry concentrations, diversification, diversification, and more diversification. This is a program which is stronger credit than 7(a) with really good margins, and we have an expertise in it. Slide #15 just gives you an idea of how successful we've been in this particular marketplace. I'd like to point out a recent deal we did, 2026-1. So the gross spread before we deduct the servicing fee was 6.6%. That's the coupon on the collateral versus the yield on the securities, net of the servicing fee, 5.66%. Now securitization interest expense is higher than bank deposits, but also it's match-funded, which is extremely important. So you get the duration benefit. Now the other thing about securitization costs, you set it and forget it. And when I say that, I'm not talking about what we're doing on the servicing side, because we're fairly active on the servicing side with our borrowers. But think about a 566 bps spread after servicing. So if you went to a bank and said, "Oh, by the way, I can give you and make loans at a 5.66% spread, and there's no cost to run the bank. You don't need FDIC insurance. You don't need people managing depository accounts. You don't need branches. You don't need bankers. You just put the loans in a special purpose vehicle, you click the coupon, you service the loans, and you pay the bondholders." That's a winning business. And when you look at the valuations on the owner certificates, we're slightly over 2:1 on the value, but look at that spread and you're probably 5x to 5.5x cash flow, very reasonable. That's after the markup. So we love this business. We have an expertise in this business. We have a track record in this business. We're good at this business. Slide #16. So when you look at the active securitizations, because the first one is already paid off and wound up, look at the 2024 deal and look at how the overcollateralization grows because you've got all that excess cash flow that goes to pay down the senior notes. So the OC went from $36.2 million to $50 million. That shows you that the book value will ultimately get to the fair value in about 3 to 3.5 years. So because you've got all that excess cash flow flowing into the securitizations, into the special purpose vehicles, it really hyperamortizes the bonds. I would now like to turn the rest of the presentation over to Frank DeMaria.