Earnings Labs

Mechanics Bank (MCHB)

Q2 2019 Earnings Call· Tue, Jul 23, 2019

$15.30

-1.92%

Key Takeaways · AI generated
AI summary not yet generated for this transcript. Generation in progress for older transcripts; check back soon, or browse the full transcript below.

Same-Day

+2.18%

1 Week

+4.44%

1 Month

-5.05%

vs S&P

-2.49%

Transcript

Operator

Operator

Good day and welcome to the HomeStreet, Inc. Second Quarter 2019 Earnings Call. All participants will be in listen-only mode. [Operator Instructions] After today's presentation, there will be an opportunity to ask questions. [Operator Instructions] Please note this event is being recorded. I would now like to turn the conference over to Mark Mason, Chairman and CEO. Please go ahead.

Mark Mason

Analyst · KBW

Hello and thank you for joining us for our second quarter 2019 earnings call. Before we begin, I'd like to remind you that our detailed earnings release was furnished yesterday to the SEC on Form 8-K and is available on our website at ir.homestreet.com under the News & Events link. In addition, a recording and a transcript will be available at the same address following our call. On today's call, we will make some forward-looking statements. Any statement that isn't a description of historical fact is probably forward-looking and is subject to many risks and uncertainties. Our actual performance may fall short of our expectations, or we may take actions different than those we currently anticipate. Those factors include conditions affecting our financial performance, the actions, findings or requirements of our regulators, our ability to meet cost savings expectations or to realize those cost savings at the pace we expect and general economic conditions that affect our net interest margins, borrower credit performance, loan origination volumes and the value of mortgage servicing rights. Other factors that may cause actual results to differ from our expectations or that may cause us to deviate from our current plans are identified in our detailed earnings release and in our SEC filings, including our most recent quarterly report on Form 10-Q as well as our various other SEC filings. Additionally, information on any non-GAAP financial measures referenced in today's call, including a reconciliation of those measures to GAAP measures, may be found in our SEC filings and in the detailed earnings release available on our website. Please refer to our detailed earnings release for more discussion of our financial condition and results of operations. Joining me today is our Chief Financial Officer, Mark Ruh. In a moment, Mark will briefly discuss our financial results.…

Mark Ruh

Analyst · D. A. Davidson

Thank you, Mark. Good morning, everyone and thank you again for joining us. In the first quarter, we announced that we would sell our home loan center based mortgage banking business and retain our substantially smaller bank’s location based mortgage banking business. As a result, the historical results of our mortgage banking segment were reclassified as discontinued operations. Beginning in April 2019 and going forward, the assets, liabilities, revenues and expenses of the retained bank’s location based mortgage banking business are included in continuing operations. I will be highlighting the impact from these changes in the presentation of our financial results during the quarter. And now regarding our second quarter financial results. Our consolidated net loss, which includes the results of both continuing and discontinued operations, for the second quarter of ‘19 was $5.6 million or $0.22 per diluted share, compared to a net loss of $1.7 million or $0.06 per diluted share for the first quarter of ‘19. The share repurchase from Blue Lion Capital and affiliates on July 11, caused us to reclassify $52.7 million of our equity to temporary equity as of quarter end. This reclassification caused us to hold temporary equity for the last 10 days of the second quarter, resulting in a slightly dilutive effect to both income from continuing operations and loss per common share of approximately $0.01. One-time items include the net income for the second quarter of ‘19 worth comprised of $9.6 million restructuring charges from the exit or disposal of our home loan center based mortgage banking business, and $33,000 of acquisition related recoveries, net of tax. This compared to one-time items in the first quarter of $9.6 million of similar restructuring expenses, net of tax, and $290,000 of acquisition related expenses, net of tax. Net income was adversely impacted during…

Mark Mason

Analyst · KBW

Thank you, Mark. Now that we've completed most of the asset sale portion of our mortgage banking restructuring plan, we've turned our focus to improving our operating efficiency and reducing our cost structure to reflect our simplified business model and lowered growth expectations. In addition to the expense reductions to date and plan by management, Dan Davis and CBC for Profits are cost efficiency consultants, had identified a range of additional expense reduction opportunities, which involves substantial technology, organization and personnel changes. These include simplifying the organizational structure by reducing management levels and management redundancy, consolidating similar functions currently residing in multiple organizations within the company, renegotiating where possible major contracts, primarily technology, identifying and eliminating where possible all redundant or unnecessary systems and services, and adjusting staffing to recognize the significant changes in work volumes and company direction. Despite the challenges of the yield curve, and assuming our strong credit culture maintains our low level of problem assets, and assuming we realize the expense reductions currently planned by management and projected by our consultants, we expect to achieve an efficiency ratio in the low 60% range, return on average assets exceeding 1.1% and return on average tangible equity exceeding 11% within the next four quarters, with additional improvement after that time. The timing of these expense reductions will vary depending upon the nature of the expense, although a meaningful amount is expected to be realized in early 2020. These return targets are based only on expense savings without additional share repurchases, or the possible establishment of a regular quarterly dividend. Additionally, revenue enhancements, such as improvement in our cost of funds and fee income would improve these return targets. Going forward, as we implement the expense reductions identified by our consultants, we will be better able to forecast the timing of their expected impact on our financial results. In future quarters, we will be providing detailed numbers on expense reductions to date, and more specific timing of efficiency ratio, return on average assets and return on average tangible equity targets in the future. As a consequence of this change in business strategy, we are also updating our growth expectations for the near term. For the remainder of this year and next year, we will be replacing runoff in our single family loan portfolio with growth in our commercial loan portfolios, resulting in no net growth in loans held for investment over these terms. Additionally, assuming no change in the current yield curve, we expect a net interest margin consistent with our just concluded second quarter. This concludes our prepared comments. We appreciate your attention today. And Mark and I will be happy to answer any questions you have at this time.

Operator

Operator

[Operator Instructions] The first question comes from Luke Wooten of KBW.

Luke Wooten

Analyst · KBW

I just wanted to start off with just some questions on what you just touched upon on the strategic initiative and just kind of wanted to see in terms of some of the technology renegotiations and systems consolidations, does that relate a lot or heavily to the kind of information services lines. And if you could just touch on that a little bit more for the forward guidance.

Mark Mason

Analyst · KBW

Sure, it touches several categories of expenses. Of course, the technology line item, which is comprised not just of inside IT personnel and costs, but more substantially the cost of software systems that provide the backbone of our operating systems. And we have a lot of systems here, we have some very specialized loan products, and a fairly wide menu of products. And we have identified a certain amount of duplication of services among those products. We are analyzing those areas of potential duplication and consolidation, in conjunction with the need to renegotiate many of our contracts as a result of substantially reduced volumes, subsequent to our sale of the majority of our mortgage banking activities.

Luke Wooten

Analyst · KBW

And then just switching over to, what you were just touching on, on the loan growth, you said that offsetting the commercial contraction, that loan growth can be relatively flat through the end of the year, is that how I should interpret it?

Mark Mason

Analyst · KBW

Offsetting the runoff in the single family mortgage portion of our portfolio, right, understanding mortgage origination volume is going to decline pretty dramatically, those balances, particularly in this interest rate environment, are going to decline more quickly than in the past substantially. But we expect to offset that runoff with greater levels or greater composition of various commercial loans.

Luke Wooten

Analyst · KBW

And then I'll just touch one more on the margin, just trying to get a sense of, if we do get a rate cut here in the next, well, it looks like in the next couple of days, but just through the end of the year, how much of your commercial loan is floating to prime or LIBOR and given that cut, how do you see those yields trending?

Mark Mason

Analyst · KBW

A meaningful amount of our portfolio is adjustable. In rough numbers, I believe about a third of it is monthly adjusting, roughly and the remainder of the adjustable portion of the portfolio is of hybrid nature, right, short term structure and then floating.

Luke Wooten

Analyst · KBW

Okay. And then just given a cut, how do you see the yields on that? I mean, I imagine, do you have any kind of guidance for the impact to the NIM or is it kind of just to be assumed that through the end of the year, if there's a cut or two, this would be down modestly?

Mark Mason

Analyst · KBW

We're pretty balanced. And when we look at the potential for a cut at the short term of the curve, that's going to have offsetting impact in our funding costs today, given our level of loan advances and a falling deposit beta.

Operator

Operator

Our next question comes from Jeff Rulis of D. A. Davidson.

Jeff Rulis

Analyst · D. A. Davidson

A question on the income statement and trying to get into an okay approach to rightsizing what things look like post Q2, is it a good place to start, maybe fair to back out the 10.4 and 7.6 in fee income and expenses from the discontinued ops. Understand, going forward and then understanding efforts made to build that fee income and reduced cost. Is that a fair start point?

Mark Ruh

Analyst · D. A. Davidson

No, actually the reverse. The change in the quarter was reclassifying that portion of mortgage origination and servicing that will be continuing out of discontinued operations in the prior quarter into continued operations. And so, you should expect to, going forward, see those higher levels of revenue and expense.

Jeff Rulis

Analyst · D. A. Davidson

Okay. And then on the stranded costs, I think you identified 8.3 previously. One of those has been captured as of the 2Q run rate and I suppose what's left?

Mark Ruh

Analyst · D. A. Davidson

Yeah. And I apologize for not calling that out. But if you look on page 25 of our earnings release under the non-GAAP financial measures, at the end of the first page, it shows second to last line on that page, the stranded cost numbers for the quarters, historical and most recent, and the 8.3 million has declined to 6.2 million in the second quarter and still falling, of course.

Jeff Rulis

Analyst · D. A. Davidson

And are the exit and disposal cost, is that complete, i.e., no further charges anticipated in future quarters.

Mark Ruh

Analyst · D. A. Davidson

In terms of restructuring type charges, that's substantially correct. We may have some miscellaneous items that come through, however, we will still have some operating loss in discontinued operations in the third quarter, as we finish closing the pipeline of lock loans that existed when we transferred the offices and personnel. Those loans are being closed with the assistance of that personnel that will be transferred under a transition services agreement with HomeBridge. And while the economics of that agreement, we think are favorable for the company, we are not anticipating net income, probably some smaller net loss in discontinued operations.

Jeff Rulis

Analyst · D. A. Davidson

Okay, and additional balance sheet adjustments post second quarter, you spoke about 133 million in deposits set to transfer to the mortgage buyer and then, you had an elevated loans held for sale, could you talk about just structured deposits and loans that are planned to go away.

Mark Ruh

Analyst · D. A. Davidson

So, right, including the expected reduction in deposits, loans held for sale should fall ultimately to less than $100 million. Two things driving that. One, of course, the completion of the closing of the discontinued pipeline and then ultimate sale of those loans, but also the sale of our interest in mortgage services, which provides currently $70 million, $75 million a month in originations to us, maybe larger past month. So all of those will create a decline, ultimately in loans held for sale over the next six to nine months. The most -- the largest part of that being in the third quarter. The deposit number that we previously discussed, and of course, this temporary equity number that is existing temporarily at the end of this quarter.

Operator

Operator

The next question comes from Steve Moss of B. Riley.

Steve Moss

Analyst · B. Riley

I want to start on the mortgage making side, assuming the sale of WMS here? I guess it's kind of fair to think about originations on an annual basis probably in something like the $750 million to $1 billion range annually.

Mark Ruh

Analyst · B. Riley

That's fair. It's seasonal still.

Steve Moss

Analyst · B. Riley

Okay. And then just in terms of, as you're thinking about expenses here, about how long do you think it will take to implement the bulk of the consultants and your own plans, recommendations? Should we think of that over the next six months or is it really longer over a 12-month plus period.

Mark Mason

Analyst · B. Riley

Well, I just stated in my comments that we're expecting to realize the lion's share of this over the next four quarters with a meaningful amount in early 2020. Right now, it's a little hazy, right. I mean, we are just investigating the potentials and beginning planning. And so it's a little hard to be more specific, but we feel good enough to make, to provide this guidance. And unfortunately, right now, it's kind of as good as we can provide. But beyond the first half or the first three quarters of next year, there's still more to come, right. Additionally, if you think about limiting loan growth, but continuing deposit growth, we are planning on improvement in our cost of funds as well, but these numbers don't include any of that.

Steve Moss

Analyst · B. Riley

And then, I guess, on the CD special that you guys ran, just kind of wondering, where was that? And where are your CD rates today versus perhaps the current cost of funds [indiscernible]?

Mark Mason

Analyst · B. Riley

Well, they’re down substantially. We had a hole to fill, right, a very temporary one to plan for, with the transfer servicing deposit. And relative to advances and with liquidity considerations, we felt the right thing for us to do was to float a certain amount of short term CDs and raise that money quickly past life premium. But over time, those costs are down very substantially. Yeah, 40 basis points. Right.

Steve Moss

Analyst · B. Riley

And then, I guess as the balance sheet here is more or less stable, how should we think about, you talked about commercial loan growth? How should we think about that underlying mix between C&I, CRE and construction?

Mark Mason

Analyst · B. Riley

If you look at past volumes, I would expect a consistent relationship generally, though, our C&I lending has been increasing quarter-over-quarter, if you look at the trend over the last five quarters or so. Residential construction lending has declined somewhat, consistent with a slowdown in that market. And so I think you'll see that construction volume decline somewhat. Commercial real estate, general commercial real estate lending, we expect to be very strong, perhaps grow slightly during this period. We will not be holding all that on our balance sheet though. While originations have grown, sales are growing as well. And we effectively use that product type to balance our balance sheet needs these days. And we continue to work on growing our C&I business as I previously stated.

Steve Moss

Analyst · B. Riley

Okay. And I guess more of like a, little more, I guess, housekeeping, if you will, it looks like you guys disclose proxy expenses and some severance and looks like that came through continuing operations. I was wondering if you could quantify those items.

Mark Mason

Analyst · B. Riley

We haven't, specifically. But the delta between the items that we have described, primarily not exclusively, relates to those items. We did have severance in continuing operations, because as we've been discussing, we've been paring down corporate services and personnel. And, in total, those numbers have been meaningful and salaries and related costs for the quarter, about $1 million of that delta, if that helps.

Operator

Operator

The next question comes from Tim O'Brien of Sandler O'Neil and Partners.

Tim O'Brien

Analyst · Sandler O'Neil and Partners

First question I have for you guys. Can you talk a little bit about capital management plans and needs here going forward, obviously, with slower loan growth planned. That's a factor in this, but -- and also where you see capital ratios, key capital ratios kind of settling out with the share buyback pending and stuff.

Mark Mason

Analyst · Sandler O'Neil and Partners

Sure, all of our current buyback activities have been concluded, right. We first suspended and will soon terminate the $75 million board authorized repurchase plan, given we filled that and a little more with the repurchase of the Blue Lion shares. We, by strategy, quickly authorized after the end of the first quarter, and the completion of our servicing sales, our $75 million buyback with the intention of completing the home loan center sales and then after second quarter, assuming the completion of the sales, re-evaluating our capital needs going forward, and it is our expectation that the board will authorize additional future share repurchases, and ultimately, a regular quarterly dividend. We're very early in the stabilization of the company. If you think about what we just went through in the first and second quarters, and what we will be going through for the next several quarters in efficiency improvement, I don't expect that we will wait too long before the board authorizes additional adjustments to our capital. But I don't want to front run their decisioning. But I expect that that will happen.

Tim O'Brien

Analyst · Sandler O'Neil and Partners

And then sticking my turn on with another expense question. So on that page, it looked like about 6.2 million or thereabouts, on page 25, for shared cost reduction. So $2 million reduction if I'm reading it, right.

Mark Mason

Analyst · Sandler O'Neil and Partners

Yeah.

Tim O'Brien

Analyst · Sandler O'Neil and Partners

And then the work that Mr. Davis has done and the consultants and stuff, are the cost savings that they've -- those opportunities been identified and quantified? And are they separate from these shared costs, targeted share cost reductions?

Mark Mason

Analyst · Sandler O'Neil and Partners

I wouldn't say they are necessarily separate, in that the classes of potential savings, cross many aspects of the company, which would include corporate services.

Tim O'Brien

Analyst · Sandler O'Neil and Partners

And then I guess a different way to look at where you guys ended up, finishing the second quarter from an expense standpoint, and kind of on a go forward basis. Do you have a sense of ballpark range of where total non-interest expense might foot, ex-one timers and extraneous costs and things like that, the core number here in the third quarter? Is that going to be north/south of 60 million do you think?

Mark Ruh

Analyst · Sandler O'Neil and Partners

Well, this last quarter’s total expense was 58 million. So, I don't expect it will be higher than that number. Right. If you think about the things that went on at the company, including continuing reductions in personnel, and the fact that the second quarter is really a peak quarter for mortgage loan originations, even in our ongoing business, that we would expect the number generally not to exceed that number. I warn you, we could have non-recurring write offs, restructuring, severance, and we will, right, related to some of these cost savings initiatives. I am speaking to core numbers.

Tim O'Brien

Analyst · Sandler O'Neil and Partners

In that second quarter number, the 59 million core number, that did include retention of the mortgage business of those -- that personnel and stuff, their compensation is reflected in that number in the second quarter, that 59 million, correct?

Mark Ruh

Analyst · Sandler O'Neil and Partners

That is correct.

Tim O'Brien

Analyst · Sandler O'Neil and Partners

And can you quantify what the savings are from that severance here going forward.

Mark Ruh

Analyst · Sandler O'Neil and Partners

In continuing operations, I think I just mentioned that we had about $1 million of personnel. [indiscernible] But I don't think I can give guidance on forward similar numbers yet.

Operator

Operator

The next question comes from Tim Coffey of Janney.

Tim Coffey

Analyst · Janney

As we look at kind of the forward run rate for the gain on sale line, with the composition, would you anticipate the composition will look a lot like it has the last two quarters where mortgage banking is a sizable portion of that component, followed up by commercial real estate?

Mark Mason

Analyst · Janney

I think that's going to be true in terms of the size of the numbers. The efficiency of those two operations is dramatically different. Right? If you think about the relationship between the revenues and expenses, right, our efficiency ratio in commercial real estate is in the mid to high 30% range, right. But single family retail mortgage is running in probably mid-70 range, right? So, remember, and remember, there is seasonality still in mortgage revenue, second quarter being relatively high point for the year. So the relationship or the composition of that non-interest income will change during the year, perhaps meaningfully. Additionally, commercial real estate loan sales and in turn gain is historically higher in the second half of the year than the first half of the year, in particular, Fannie Mae does loans sales are typically higher in the second half of the year. And so you can see a material change in the composition of that revenue line through the year.

Tim Coffey

Analyst · Janney

What about the absolute dollars falling to that line?

Mark Mason

Analyst · Janney

Not sure I understand the question.

Tim Coffey

Analyst · Janney

Will we expect the gain on sale line item to come down?

Mark Mason

Analyst · Janney

I would expect it to be seasonal with respect to each of the operations. And I think it's a little unclear at this point how much will be offset versus a decline.

Tim Coffey

Analyst · Janney

And then kind of flipping over to the mix of earning assets, if the loans, the commentary on the loan portfolio going forward, will combine with your expectations to grow deposits? Would you anticipate that securities would become a bigger part of that earning asset mix or do you think it can stay kind of in this low teens on an average basis?

Mark Mason

Analyst · Janney

We carry a securities for liquidity and collateral purposes. And so, they will vary. Generally, around 15% of assets, roughly less if we can, right, but you should generally see that balances vary in relation to the size of the balance sheet around those numbers, say 13% to 15%, roughly.

Tim Coffey

Analyst · Janney

And then with the exit from a substantial portion of the mortgage business, would it be correct to start thinking that your average borrowings will start to decline.

Mark Mason

Analyst · Janney

Yes, as the balance sheet stabilizes. We do expect deposit to continue to grow. If you assume that our loan portfolio stabilizes around this number for the near term, and deposits continue to grow, those will create a reduced need for home loan advances and other borrowings. And so you should see the composition of funding change.

Operator

Operator

[Operator Instructions] Our next question comes from Jeff Rulis of D.A. Davidson.

Jeff Rulis

Analyst · D.A. Davidson

Just a couple of housekeeping follow-ups, maybe for Mark Ruh. The expected tax rate going forward, do you have an estimate on that?

Mark Ruh

Analyst · D.A. Davidson

Yeah. It looks like it's going to be closer to what we report as a combined federal and statutory tax rate. So it was a little bit low this quarter. But as we have larger income basically, the portion that we attribute to tax free securities will be less, so it's going to climb higher. And we typically have seen in the past it's around 20% to 21%. I mean, when we started having quarters where we start earning again, on a net basis, you're going to see it, you're going to see converge towards that -- towards that combined federal and state tax statutory rate. But again, we've worked typically, we were running 20, 21 is what you'll see. This was an odd quarter because net income is so low.

Jeff Rulis

Analyst · D.A. Davidson

And then, just to peg on the Q3 average diluted share count, just some moving pieces there. We could do the math on what's coming out. But do you have a number? There's some averaging in there?

Mark Ruh

Analyst · D.A. Davidson

Yeah, I don't have -- that really small effect that we talked about that happened again in the second quarter, if there may be a very, very immaterial effect due to that in the first 11 days of the third quarter, but it'll be tiny. I mean, you guys really won't even see it. I mean, I think as far as the diluted share count, you can expect that the only shares we're going to be bringing on is due to shares that would be issued due to employee grants, which is generally a pretty small number. But you do have to remember that we're losing the 1.7 million shares that were repurchased to Blue Lion. So those will drop off after the first 11 days of July. And then so our diluted share count will change due to that.

Jeff Rulis

Analyst · D.A. Davidson

As well as the open market purchases, repurchases.

Mark Ruh

Analyst · D.A. Davidson

Well, those are -- you see those already. Those are down. Yeah. We finished that up in June, we're done with that.

Jeff Rulis

Analyst · D.A. Davidson

There was no tale of buyback in July.

Mark Ruh

Analyst · D.A. Davidson

No. All done in June.

Jeff Rulis

Analyst · D.A. Davidson

Great. And then maybe last one Mark Mason, just to confirm, those financial numbers you rolled out as 60% efficiency ratio or low range, ROA 1%, ROTC 11%, your expectation is to get to those numbers by this time next year. So when reporting, is that -- am I reading that right?

Mark Mason

Analyst · D.A. Davidson

Yeah, it was actually in excess of 1.1% on assets, in excess of 11% return on tangible common, just to be specific. Our expectation is that we would be able to get to that run rate a year from now, right, meaning in the third quarter.

Jeff Rulis

Analyst · D.A. Davidson

Okay, third quarter of 2020 is your expectation on those estimates? Okay.

Mark Mason

Analyst · D.A. Davidson

Right. So it's sort of a lag when you accomplish the cut or you take the action, right?

Jeff Rulis

Analyst · D.A. Davidson

I didn't catch that last bit.

Mark Mason

Analyst · D.A. Davidson

There's a lag between taking the action, right, and getting the benefit in the P&L. Right. So all these things happening to get the sort of annualized benefit of all those things. That is what we are currently targeting.

Operator

Operator

Our next question comes from Jordan Hymowitz of Philadelphia Financial.

Jordan Hymowitz

Analyst · Philadelphia Financial

If just your loan portfolio stabilizes here, and securities are about 15%, would you say your total assets are bottom around 6.5, 6.7 billion? Is that a good number?

Mark Mason

Analyst · Philadelphia Financial

They're going to decline slightly, 6.5, I believe is low. I think that, a higher number is more reasonable. We should be quite similar to where we are now.

Jordan Hymowitz

Analyst · Philadelphia Financial

So what you're saying that you got 200 million of available for sale [indiscernible], let's just say it's 6.7 billion, which maybe it’s higher. And you said 1.1% on assets. That's 73 million without any additional buybacks, that's about a 2.80 in EPS number. Is that math right?

Mark Mason

Analyst · Philadelphia Financial

The math is the math, right.

Jordan Hymowitz

Analyst · Philadelphia Financial

Okay. And is there a possibility [indiscernible]

Mark Mason

Analyst · Philadelphia Financial

I'm sorry, not to be snotty. That's just the revenue. Right. That's the math.

Jordan Hymowitz

Analyst · Philadelphia Financial

So, there's a possibility for additional buybacks, a possibility, correct?

Mark Mason

Analyst · Philadelphia Financial

Yes.

Jordan Hymowitz

Analyst · Philadelphia Financial

And would you say it's a fair statement that now that you've got rid of the mortgage business and you’re probably in the hottest market in the country, you would be more of a desirable candidate to sell or it could be bought rather?

Mark Mason

Analyst · Philadelphia Financial

I would assume that’s true.

Operator

Operator

This concludes our question-and-answer session. I would like to turn the conference back over to Mark Mason for any closing remarks.

Mark Mason

Analyst · KBW

We appreciate all the great questions and your patience on the call today. Look forward to talking to you at the end of the next quarter. Thank you.

Operator

Operator

The conference has now concluded. Thank you for attending today’s presentation. You may now disconnect.