Earnings Labs

Live Oak Bancshares, Inc. (LOB)

Q3 2018 Earnings Call· Thu, Oct 25, 2018

$38.74

Key Takeaways · AI generated
AI summary not yet generated for this transcript. Generation in progress for older transcripts; check back soon, or browse the full transcript below.

Same-Day

-2.85%

1 Week

+0.93%

1 Month

-5.09%

vs S&P

-4.46%

Transcript

Operator

Operator

Good day ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the Q3 2018 Live Oak Bancshares Inc. earnings conference call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. Later we will conduct a question and answer session and instructions will follow at that time. If anyone should require operator assistance, please press star then zero on your touchtone telephone. As a reminder, this call is being recorded. I would now like to introduce your host for today’s conference, Greg Seward, General Counsel, Live Oak Bancshares. Please go ahead.

Greg Seward

Management

Thank you and good morning everyone. Welcome to Live Oak’s third quarter 2018 earnings conference call. We are webcasting live over the internet and this call is being recorded. To access the call over the internet and review the presentation materials and commentary that we will reference on the call, please visit our website at investor.liveoakbank.com and go to today’s call on our event calendar for supporting materials. Our third quarter earnings release is also available on our website. Before we get started, I would like to caution you that we may make forward-looking statements during today’s call that are subject to risks and uncertainties. Factors that may cause actual results to differ materially from our expectations are detailed in the materials accompanying this call and in our SEC filings. We do not undertake to update the forward-looking statements to reflect the impact of circumstances or events that may arise after the date of today’s call. Information about any non-GAAP financial measures references, including reconciliation of those measures to GAAP measures, can also be found in our SEC filings. I will now turn the call over to Chip Mahan, our Chairman and Chief Executive Officer.

Chip Mahan

Management

Greg, thanks, and good morning. I am now on Slide 3, today’s agenda. We’re going to talk a little bit about a hurricane that hit Wilmington, I’m going to give you a brief tech update - we’re very happy that SunTrust has made an investment in Apiture. We’ve been getting questions recently about concentration risk, so sticking with our standard of soundness, profitability and growth, in that order, we’re going to talk a little bit about that. I’m going to give you my view of a rather interesting quarter, and then proud to introduce our new partner, Huntley Garriott, and he will give you his thoughts on our business. Moving on to Slide 4, Hurricane Matthew came through here two years ago, 2016. Our IT team led by Thomas Hill said enough is enough. We spent the last 24 months moving to a cloud only infrastructure and thankfully completed that effort on the 18th of July this year, and then it was game time as Hurricane Florence hit on the 14th of September. Greg, I’m moving to Slide 5. One of our guiding principles here, if you have followed us over the years, is we treat every customer like the only customer in the bank. I rather think that some of our customers in Alaska or Hawaii may not have known that there was a hurricane in North Carolina, but for almost two weeks we were in disaster recovery mode. Over 300 of our folks evacuated. We took 700 customer calls, fulfilled 360 support tickets, we approved $94 million in loans and close 39 of those. Sadly maybe, August was the best lead month we’ve ever had and then the hurricane hit and we were down 9% year over year, but we’re making a comeback. Moving on to Slide 6…

Huntley Garriott

Management

Thanks Chip. After listening to a couple dozen earnings calls each quarter for the last two decades, it’s strange to be on this side of the microphone, but I’ve been at the bank for a little over a month now, joining just as the hurricane arrived, and I have to say it was really inspiring to see the people here at Live Oak and how they stepped up in the face of that storm. I thought I’d start with a few initial observations about Live Oak and then address a couple of specific topics that we’ve been focused on here at the bank. My initial thoughts here at Live Oak are consistent with what attracted me here in the first place - it’s a remarkable franchise and I think one that’s really unique in my experience in banking. It’s an incredibly talented group of folks with a real culture of innovation and the proven ability to leverage technology. As you can see on Slide 12, Live Oak started largely as a mono line SBA 7 lender utilizing the SBA guarantee program to fund the majority of the loan production and a model based on vertical domain expertise and efficient workflow technology. Ten years later, as Chip mentioned, we’re proud to report we finished the SBA fiscal year in the number one position for lending. As we look ahead, we’ll continue to build out new industry verticals where we see opportunities, and continue to augment that team with the best general small business lenders in the country. The folks that we’ve brought on board already are world class and have meaningful pipelines that will help drive originations in 2019 and beyond. Diversifying the business was the next phase in the company’s evolution, building out expertise in conventional lending. Across ABL, CRE…

Chip Mahan

Management

Let’s do that.

Operator

Operator

[Operator instructions] Our first question comes from the line of Jennifer Demba with SunTrust. Your line is now open.

Jennifer Demba

Analyst

Thank you, good morning.

Chip Mahan

Management

Morning, Jennifer.

Jennifer Demba

Analyst

Huntley, welcome to the company.

Huntley Garriott

Management

Thank you.

Jennifer Demba

Analyst

Look forward to working with you. Question first of all on the competition you’re seeing in small business lending and probably other conventional lending as well. Can you give us a little bit more color on where you’re seeing the most intensity there?

Huntley Garriott

Management

Yes, I think it’s broad based, right - you’ve got the large banks that are playing in various spaces or verticals, and largely they tend to be some of the more established customers with track records where they’re willing to compete on price more than on structure and term, so there are credits where we just look at it and say from a return perspective, people are starting to do some things that don’t make sense for us and we’ll draw lines there. I think maybe Steve, you can jump in too.

Chip Mahan

Management

And Steve, I know that--Steve Smits is with us here, our Chief Credit Officer, and I know that our lending officers are making a lot of proposals and a lot of times losing and kind of spinning, so you may want to comment on some of that.

Steve Smits

Analyst

Correct. This is Steve Smits, Chief Credit Officer. We do see competition coming from across all of our verticals, but what sticks out to me is healthcare is always a very competitive space. Competition comes from conventional lenders that are offering pricing and leverage that we don’t think are sound decisions for the long term, so we’re going to be very disciplined about not following that down, so that is certainly an area that we see a great deal of competition. In addition, some of our--you know, self storage, for example, will see some challenges with the cost of the projects escalating due to cost of materials, for example, that may be impacted - steel impacted by tariffs, for example, makes the projects less feasible right now until pricing comes down to make that more sensitive. Some of that is delayed projects due to costs prohibiting feasibility.

Jennifer Demba

Analyst

Okay. With this lower production expectation, what is the NIM outlook over the next few quarters? Are you still expecting NIM expansion?

Brett Cains

Analyst

Hi Jennifer, this is Brett. I would say just in short, when we think about NIM at least going into next quarter, I’d say flat to up would be the best estimate right now. As Huntley and Chip both mentioned, looking more strategically at holding higher volumes of loans on balance sheet, and of course that means additional funding through deposits as we rely less on funding through those loan sales.

Jennifer Demba

Analyst

What about a tax rate? You already gave some guidance for ’18, but what about next year, Brett? What are you thinking about?

Brett Cains

Analyst

I think we’re in a better position at this point to comment on 2019 than we were last year at this time commenting on 2018 with the impending or the potential back the for tax reform, so where we sit now in 2018, we have the ability to better predict and fine tune what we think our effective tax rate will be. I would say that it certainly would not be a negative effective tax rate like we saw in Q3 and sort of what we’re expecting to happen for the full year of 2018, so I would say just thinking about 2019, targeting somewhere in the high single or low double digits would be most appropriate.

Jennifer Demba

Analyst

I’m assuming Neil’s there. Can we just talk about Apiture so far, where you are, what inning you’re in, and how everything is going versus expectations?

Chip Mahan

Management

Neil just got back last night late from the first ever [indiscernible] Apiture user group meeting.

Neil Underwood

Analyst

I did. Hey Jennifer. I think trending positive. You know, the biggest thing that the SunTrust investment does is validate Apiture and its API-based solution to larger FIs. If you take a look at other players in the market, some of which that are public, their largest customer is around the $50 billion mark, and we think the solution set spans large FI all the way down to some of the smaller sub-billion dollar ones. I think that’s--when you think of scale, much of which we get from great platforms from Amazon Web Services, you think of scale and bookings and revenue certainly could change the trajectory of the value of Apiture over time. More importantly from our perspective, it allows us greater investment in R&D and innovation, and given we’re the first user of the new open platform, we’re the benefactor of that.

Jennifer Demba

Analyst

Okay, one more question before I jump off. The provision was negative because you changed the methodology for the family entertainment sector. Do you have any other sectors that are maturing to the point where that will happen in 2019 before CECL is enacted in ’20?

Steve Smits

Analyst

Jennifer, this is Steve Smits again. No, we do not, so our model dictates that once we have our own historical data after several years, we flip from using industry data to our own internal data, so that was the result of what happened with family entertainment, because we have very strong performance in that area. We do not have verticals scheduled to have that same encounter before CECL is enacted in 2020.

Jennifer Demba

Analyst

And how is the CECL prep going?

Steve Smits

Analyst

CECL is going very well. We’ve been very proactive in working on our modeling and with the expectation to run tandem models throughout 2019 to be well ready for January 2020.

Jennifer Demba

Analyst

Thanks so much.

Chip Mahan

Management

Thanks Jennifer.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Our next question comes from the line of Aaron Deer with Sandler O’Neill + Partners. Your line is now open.

Aaron Deer

Analyst

Hi, good morning everybody.

Chip Mahan

Management

Morning, Aaron.

Aaron Deer

Analyst

Chip, kudos to your team for getting through that hurricane so successfully; and Huntley, may I also say congratulations on your new gig with Live Oak.

Huntley Garriott

Management

Thanks.

Aaron Deer

Analyst

I guess starting with the--well maybe let’s start with the growth outlook. I obviously hear as we head into year-end you’ve kind of dialed back the expectations, which makes sense given the environment; but with all the new verticals that you have added over the past year or two, as we look out to 2019, are you comfortable at this point giving any sort of guidance in terms of what sort of origination volumes we should expect next year?

Chip Mahan

Management

Aaron, the answer to that would be no. That said, though, I will say that from the credit guys to the sales guys, we are really excited about the eight what we call general lenders that we have brought on board in the last six months or so. In addition to that, we have a couple of unnamed verticals that we’re working on that look like they could be really, really exciting. But you know, as we look back at some of our more mature verticals, it is disappointing to see the level of competition, and I think what is happening here is that, frankly, other banks see us go to a vertical and they follow us, and then they go to trade shows and they follow us around. I guess that should be an indirect compliment. But you know, I’m excited about next year. I think over the next 60 days as we drill down with the 22 verticals or whatever we have within the GMs and that group, we’ll come up with a number, and as we have every year since we’ve been public, we’ll probably let you know what that is in the next 90 days.

Aaron Deer

Analyst

Okay. Then with respect to gain on sale, first maybe if you could give us the percentage of sales this quarter versus in the second quarter that were USDA versus SBA, if you have that?

Huntley Garriott

Management

Yes, USDA in the third quarter was a very small percentage of our total sales. We sold about $298 million in the secondary market. Around 40 of that was USDA, I’d say 10 to 13%, and Q3 USDA was a much more substantial portion of what we sold. As you know, [indiscernible] has that seasonality where we see the drop-off in originations in the third quarter and then that will tick back up in Q4.

Aaron Deer

Analyst

Okay. It sounds like your internal analysis with Bob Judge and such is suggesting that--or at least you guys are taking the approach that we’re not going to get any sort of snap-back in the premiums, and if that’s the case, as you kind of re-think what you hold versus sell, if things do stay the same, can you give us a sense of what your outlook would be for loan sales over the next several quarters?

Huntley Garriott

Management

Yes Aaron, I think it’s hard to put a number on it. I will tell you that as we look at it, the 10-year sector has been a little more depressed than the 25-year, so we may be more likely to sell some of the longer paper or price just a little better from a risk management perspective as well and more likely to hold the shorter paper. But it ends up being--you know, it will be a little bit of a loan by loan, week by week analysis. I do think that we’re going to watch prepayment speeds really carefully and then watch how investors price those in. The interest rate environment and the curve shape will affect that some too, and then we just have a supply-demand imbalance and a bit of technicals that we’re going to watch. I think it’s safe to say it’s going to be more, significantly more on balance sheet, but I think it’s really hard to put a number on it as we sit here right now.

Aaron Deer

Analyst

Okay. Brett, given that 75% of your loans re-price monthly or quarterly, I was surprised that we didn’t see a more material increase in the loan yields given the rate hikes that should have pulled through from March and June. Can you talk about your expectations for loan yields going forward?

Brett Cains

Analyst

Yes, the loan yield from Q2 to Q3 was somewhat depressed from what you would expect, given that 75 to 80% of our portfolio will re-price on a quarterly basis. That was depressed primarily as a result of some unguaranteed loan sales that we did for concentration reasons, and those unguaranteed sales when they occurred, any deferred calls associated with those loans hit--were deducted from yield immediately, so that led to that depressed growth there. That’s not an expectation for Q4 that we would see that type of depression on the normal adjustment that occurred at the beginning of October as a result of the September rate increase.

Aaron Deer

Analyst

Okay, so that’s why, I guess, you have confidence that you expect loan yields to outpace your deposit re-pricing. I guess you guys still have a fair bit of liquidity on the balance sheet. Your guidance heading into the fourth quarter, it sounds like you said flattish to up a little, but might we not see a more material increase in the margin just given some of those favorable trends?

Brett Cains

Analyst

I would say I would approach it probably a little more cautiously, harkening back to the response to Jennifer’s question, in that as we evaluate what volume of loans we’re going to hold in Q4, that will impact what liquidity we need to go out and raise. In your modeling, I would say approach it a little more cautiously than a substantial increase.

Aaron Deer

Analyst

Okay. Then lastly, if we can just explore the expense subject a little bit, I guess with the Reltco costs kind of dropping out of the--

Chip Mahan

Management

Did we lose everybody?

Aaron Deer

Analyst

--for both compensation and non-interest expense, and then how might that transpire through next year as you guys continue to make investments, but then have some offsetting savings from the new core processor?

Chip Mahan

Management

Let me tee you up on that just real quick, Huntley. Aaron, I think what you’re going to see is we always talk about four verticals a year and hiring other platform lenders. Given the fact that some of our historic verticals are off year over year, we will have the ability to continue to grow those areas and repurpose people without hiring net new folks, and I know Huntley has got a lot of things that he wants to say about that as well.

Huntley Garriott

Management

Thanks Chip. I mean, if you rewind the clock and you said that we thought we were going to be plus or minus $2 billion origination this year, and as Chip mentioned, we’re coming in $1.7 billion to $1.8 billion, part of that is that the market’s competitive, and to Chip’s point we bid on and missed some deals, but we also have people that can do some other things. We’ve got a platform built to do $2 billion of origination, we come in short of that, we don’t think we need more people to go out and do that again next year. I think that’s--and then as you layer on those recurring revenues, the model starts to look really interesting. The rest of it, I think is really just a much sort of careful line by line discussion and being really thoughtful about what we spend where. It’s nothing glamorous, but it’s just a lot of blocking and tackling and being really thoughtful about it.

Aaron Deer

Analyst

Okay, so in terms of a run rate to build off of in the fourth quarter, we’re maybe looking at something around the $39 million level and then it sounds like maybe not a whole of additional investment needed in 2019?

Brett Cains

Analyst

Yes, this is Brett. I would agree with that - 39 or 40, and then as you model out the future, not seeing the non-interest expense base grow as it has in the past, really focusing just on scaling the model at this point.

Aaron Deer

Analyst

Okay, terrific. Thanks for taking my questions.

Chip Mahan

Management

Thanks Aaron.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. We have no further questions at this time. I would now like to turn the call back to Chip Mahan for closing remarks.

Chip Mahan

Management

I thank you for that, and I thank everyone for dialing in, and we shall see you at year end.

Operator

Operator

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for participating in today’s conference. This does conclude today’s program. You may all disconnect. Everyone have a great day.