Andrew LaBenne
Analyst · KBW
Thanks, Scott, and good afternoon, everyone. 2026 is certainly off to a dynamic start. Let's get into the details of our first quarter. . Turning to Page 11 of our earnings presentation. Loan originations grew by 31% to $2.7 billion, above the high end of our guidance range. All of our consumer businesses showed strong growth, supported by the compelling experience and value we deliver. Our industry-leading credit performance remains a key differentiator where we have continued our outperformance across 5 years of quarterly vintages. This is a key reason we were able to sell loans without any need to provide credit enhancements or loss protection. Now let's turn to revenue on Page 12. Net interest income increased 18% to $176 million, another all-time high, supported by a larger portfolio of interest-earning assets and continued funding cost optimization. Turning to noninterest income. As a reminder, with our move to fair value option for all newly originated held for investment loans, noninterest income now includes the loan origination fees, which were previously deferred under CECL and have a positive benefit to revenue. Conversely, the impact of loan sales prices in credit now reduces noninterest income in the fair value adjustments line. Impacts from credit previously would have been captured as provision expense under CECL. As we previewed last quarter, total fair value adjustments were approximately double fourth quarter 2025 levels driven by 4 factors. First, more volume receiving a day 1 fair value adjustment as we transition 100% of all newly held for investment originations to fair value option at the start of the year. Second, a greater mix of longer duration major purchase finance loans, which carry a higher discount rate and therefore, a higher day 1 fair value adjustment. Third, larger date to fair value adjustments, driven by a higher average balance of loans carried under fair value during the quarter. Lastly, the higher benchmark rates observed later in the quarter also increased fair value adjustments which were not expected when we provided our outlook in January. These higher benchmark rates increased the discount rate on our held-for-sale portfolio to 7.3% from 7.1% at year-end. For the held for investment portfolio, the discount rate was 7%, reflecting the specific product composition of that portfolio. With all this in mind, noninterest income was $76 million, up 12% year-over-year and down sequentially due to the move to fair value option despite marketplace sales prices improving and solid credit performance. The sequential reduction was more than offset by lower provision, which I will cover later. A useful way to evaluate revenue performance under this accounting transition is risk-adjusted revenue or revenue less provision for credit losses which grew 58% to $252 million due to the revenue growth I just described and the materially lower provision for credit losses under fair value options. For net interest margin on Page 14, I will refer to the sequential changes which provide better context on the quarter. The net interest margin expanded to 6.3%, up 30 basis points over the prior quarter primarily driven by 2 factors: first, lower interest expense contributed approximately 20 basis points, reflecting a 13 basis point benefit from lower deposit costs plus an additional 7 basis points from a lower day count this quarter. Second, we aligned our interest income recognition on the previously purchased held for investment fair value portfolio to the same methodology as the newly originated loans under fair value. Previously, credit impact was coming through the average yield and will now come through fair value adjustments. This benefit was approximately 14 basis points of net interest margin and explains the sequential yield increase in our loans held for investment at fair value. With the market now predicting no additional fed rate cuts this year, we expect our net interest margin on a go-forward basis to return to around 6% as we progress through 2026. Now let's move on to credit where performance remains excellent. As Scott mentioned, we continue to outperform the industry with delinquency rates well below our competitive set. Provision for credit losses was less than $1 million, reflecting the impact of our move to fair value option accounting for newly originated held for investment loans, combined with strong credit performance on the remaining legacy portfolio under CECL accounting. Our net charge-off ratio for the total held for investment portfolio improved meaningfully to 3.5%, down from 6.1% driven by continued strong performance as well as portfolio aging dynamics, which will normalize over time. It is important to note that these charge-offs and delinquency metrics now include all held for investment loans on the balance sheet, inclusive of both fair value and CECL portfolios for all reported periods. We're continuing to improve the profitability of the company, and that is allowing us to invest in critical initiatives to drive future growth. These include developing new marketing channels, supporting the rebrand and building out home improvement. Overall, expenses on Page 15 were $185 million, up 28% year-over-year. The majority of the increase was due to higher marketing spend reflecting both our continued investment in paid acquisition channels to drive originations growth as well as the impact of fair value option under which marketing expense for held for investment loans is now fully recognized at origination rather than deferred and amortized. Of the $10 million sequential increase in marketing spend, the impact of the accounting change was approximately $7 million. Compensation and benefits expense was up 12% year-over-year, reelecting headcount growth to support new business verticals, including home improvement and continued expansion in our core businesses. Other noninterest expense also increased 13% year-over-year. Our pretax profit margin reached a new high of 27%, reflecting a strong pull-through of revenue growth to the bottom line. We're excited about our step-up in profitability and our capacity to reinvest in the future growth initiatives while growing profit margin. Overall, pretax net income was $67 million, which more than quadrupled compared to a year ago and reflects a new high watermark for the company. Diluted earnings per share was $0.44 above the high end of our guidance range and more than quadrupled from the prior year. Our return on tangible common equity was 14.5% and our tangible book value per share increased to $12.49. Turning to the balance sheet. Total assets grew to $11.9 billion, up 14% year-over-year. We ended the quarter at $10.2 billion in deposits, which was also an increase of 14% compared to the prior year, and we continue to see healthy deposit trends across our product offerings. Our balance sheet remains a competitive strength, allowing us to generate recurring revenue through retained loans while maintaining the flexibility to scale marketplace volume as loan investor demand grows. We ended the quarter well capitalized with strong liquidity and positioned to fund future growth. I'd also like to provide a brief update on the $100 million share repurchase and acquisition program we announced at our Investor Day in November. Since inception and through the first quarter, we have utilized $38 million and reduced our average diluted share count by 1.5 million shares compared to the previous quarter. Now let's turn to our outlook. We entered 2026 with a tremendous amount of momentum. Even considering the new rate outlook, our outperformance to date gives us confidence to maintain our full year guidance with the assumption of a stable consumer and rate environment. As a reminder, we were assuming 75 basis points in cuts when we entered the year, which was a tailwind for both loan sales prices and net interest margin, which we no longer expect to benefit from. For the full year, we continue to expect originations of $11.6 billion to $12.6 billion and diluted EPS of $1.65 to $1.80 consistent with the 13% to 15% near-term return on tangible common equity target we shared at Investor Day. For Q2 2026, we expect to deliver loan originations of $3.0 billion to $3.1 billion, representing 23% to 27% year-over-year growth. On earnings for Q2 2026, we expect to deliver diluted earnings per share of $0.40 to $0.45. We're pleased with our execution. Our strategy is working, and we remain encouraged by the underlying fundamentals of the business. With that, we'll open it up for Q&A.