Paul Brody
Analyst · Piper Sandler. Your line is now open
Thank you, Nancy. Thanks everyone for joining the call. As usual, we will review the quarterly operating results, the non-core items, factors that drove those numbers, and then we will open it up for questions. Starting with the operating data, progressively stronger trading levels and record margin borrowing throughout the quarter drove robust operating metrics, albeit below the unusual spike in the first quarter, with the tailwind of rising world markets on positive vaccination and economic news and low interest rates. Continued global interest in financial markets, amid the search for higher yield, led to industry trading volumes that are still above the activity level of 2020 in most products. Mean stock trading volume came down from the extreme highs of the first quarter, which impacted industry volumes, mainly on stock. So, over the course of the second quarter, trading by our active trader customer base rose from April lows. Volatility, as measured by the average VIX, fell from the unusually high levels it reached early last year at the beginning of the first phase of the coronavirus pandemic, a time of great uncertainty amid rising case numbers worldwide. The average VIX fell from 35 in the second quarter last year to 18 this quarter. And while it has come down recently, the VIX is still stronger than pre-pandemic levels, reflecting perhaps the unevenness of the reopening of economies worldwide. Compared to the second quarter of 2020, our quarterly total DARTs rose 32% to $2.3 million, second only to the unusually active first quarter. Our customer trade volumes rose year-on-year in several product classes, led by increases of 34% and 160% in options and stock volumes respectively. Stock volume was inflated by trading in low-priced stocks though even after removing those from our calculation, our share volume still rose 36%. Again, these volumes are second only to those of the first quarter. Futures volume declined 19% year-on-year, but remained modestly higher than the pre-pandemic level. FX dollar volumes this quarter were lower, a trend we have seen since the explosion of volume in early 2020 and now are about even with pre-pandemic levels. Total accounts reached a record $1.414 million, up 61% over the prior year, contributing to customer equity, growing 79% from the second quarter of 2020 to $363.5 billion. Our overall average commission per cleared commissionable order declined 15% versus last year to $2.38. So, it rose 3% versus the first quarter. Factors impacting this decline included product mix that featured smaller average trade sizes in options and ForEx and our continued success in capturing liquidity rebates, some or all of which are passed through to our clients. Capturing these rebates reduces the overall commission our clients pay, decreasing the average commission per DART, but also reduces the exchange fees we pay on the expense side, making their net impact neutral to our bottom line. Moving to our net interest margin table, our net interest margin rose from 0.99% to 1.15% year-over-year, driven by margin lending and securities lending. Quarter-over-quarter, our NIM declined from 1.26% to 1.15%, partially impacted by a decrease in the average effective U.S. benchmark Fed funds rate from 8 to 7 basis points with a further impact from most other rates worldwide remaining at or below zero. Securities lending and margin loans were the largest contributors to our net interest income. Securities lending was particularly strong this quarter, though down from a spike in the first quarter when several stocks presented us opportunities to lend at high rate. Utilizing our in-house developed system, our team executed on opportunities to lend hard-to-borrow names that investors were looking to short. Net interest income from securities lending reached $136 million this quarter, up 70% year-over-year. Average margin loan balances rose 94% versus last year as investors continue to grow more comfortable taking on risk and leverage. Higher year-over-year balances led to a 97% increase in margin loan interest income to $128 million. In light of the flat yield curve, we kept the duration of our portfolio relatively short and recorded an immaterial mark-to-market loss on our holdings of U.S. Treasury. Outside the U.S., notably in Europe, where we have grown accounts at 55% and client equity by 70%, negative benchmark interest rates in some currencies have affected our ability to achieve acceptable yields on our segregated cash in this region. This has led to a couple of unusual factors. Over the past few quarters, we have earned interest on our customer credit balances as we pass through negative rate costs on large balances in these currencies. Our aggregate yield on segregated cash in this quarter was immaterial, but slightly negative. This was driven by increased customer cash balances and negative rate currencies although offset by the pass-through of costs I just mentioned. Aggregate segregated cash balances fell 13% as clients used more cash to invest in the financial markets and more cash was used to fund margin lending in the U.S. This overall decline along with inflows in negative rate currencies led to a drop in our segregated cash net interest to minus $2 million, including the pass-through of $8 million of the negative rate interest to customers. The net interest earned on segregated cash balances was $6 million for the quarter. Note that for accounting purposes, our FDIC sweep program, which was $2.7 billion in the second quarter, removes funds that would otherwise be included in segregated cash balances on our balance sheet. Now for our estimate of the impact of the next 25 basis point increase in rates, and calculating the impact of rate changes, we understand that as the possibility of a future rate increase becomes more certain this expectation is typically already reflected in the yields of the instruments in which we invest. Therefore, we attempt to isolate the impact of an unexpected rise in falling rate separate from the impact of rate hikes or cuts that have already been baked into the prices of these instruments. With that assumption, we would expect the next 25 basis point unanticipated rise in rates to produce an additional $99 million in net interest income over the next four quarters and $102 million as the yearly run rate based on our current balance sheet. Our net interest income is highly sensitive to small rate increases due to the impact of low benchmark rates on the spread between what we earn on our segregated cash and what we pay to our customers. As U.S. rates fell below 50 basis points, our spread compressed as we earn less on our segregated cash. However, the converse is also true that as rates move back up towards 50 basis points, the spread rise. The $102 million run rate includes the reinvestment of all of our present holdings at the new assumed rate, but does not take into account any change in how we may manage our segregated cash. A 25 basis point unanticipated fall in rates would produce a decline in net interest income of $32 million over the next four quarters and $32 million as well for the yearly run rate. As a reminder, about quarter of our customer credit balances are not in U.S. dollars, and so changes in rates that occur in the U.S. do not apply to all of our balance. Turning to the income statement. We define non-core items as those not part of our fundamental operating results. Non-core adjusting items versus the year ago quarter are as follows: our currency diversification strategy swung from a gain of $16 million a year ago to a loss of $9 million this quarter for a comparative decrease in income of $25 million. Investment gains and losses rose from a gain of $13 million to a gain of $113 million this quarter for a comparative increase of $100 million. And mark-to-market on U.S. government securities went from a $13 million loss to about zero this quarter, a comparative increase of $13 million. The net effect of these items increased pre-tax income by $104 million this quarter, a positive shift of $88 million over last year’s quarter. Net revenues were – they reported $754 million for the quarter, up 40% versus last year’s second quarter. Excluding non-core items, net revenues were up 24% to $650 million. Commission revenue rose 11% on higher volumes year-on-year, particularly in stocks and options. Net interest income rose 40% to $274 million despite continued low benchmark interest rates, thanks to growth in our balance sheet, higher margin loan balances and our successful securities lending efforts, our growth in net interest was robust. Other fees and services revenues, which include market data, exposure, account activity, FDIC bank sweep program and IPO facilitation fees as well as order flow income from options exchange mandated programs rose 38% to $55 million. The top three contributors were risk exposure fees, which were up $6 million, market data fees, which were up $5 million, and liquidity payments from options exchanges, which rose $2 million. Other income, which includes gains and losses on our investments and currency diversification strategy, as well as principal transaction showed a gain of $118 million, up from a gain of $27 million in last year’s quarter. Ex non-core items, other income increased 27% to $14 million. Non-interest expenses were $213 million for the quarter, down 33% from last year’s quarter. Larger exchange liquidity rebate, lower futures volume and a $6 million clearing fee rebate drove a 29% reduction in execution clearing and distribution fees to $54 million despite the higher stock and options volume. As mentioned, a portion of exchange liquidity rebates are passed through to our clients and are reflected in reduced commission. Fixed expenses were $158 million, down 34%, driven by a 73% decrease in G&A expense. Last year’s G&A included a $103 million in costs associated with the WTI oil futures event. At quarter end, our total head count stood at 2,429, a 34% increase over last year. We continue to hire aggressively in client services to support the influx of new accounts as well as in software development. Note, too, that Brexit requires that we open offices in Europe, which are now fully operational in Hungary as well as in Ireland. Customer bad debt expense was $1 million, well contained for a highly active trading period. Reported pre-tax income more than doubled from last year’s quarter to $541 million or a 72% pre-tax margin. And excluding non-core items, pre-tax income rose 41% to $437 million, 67% pre-tax margin. Diluted earnings per share were $1 for the quarter versus $0.40 for the same period in 2020. And ex non-core items, diluted earnings per share were $0.82 versus $0.57 as adjusted last year. Now to help investors better understand our earnings, taxes and the split between public shareholders and the non-controlling interest, the second quarter numbers are as follows. Starting with our pre-tax income of $541 million, we removed $1 million income at the holding company, then we deduct $12 million for income taxes paid by our operating companies, which are mostly foreign tax. This leaves $528 million, of which 78.1% or that $414 million reported on our income statement is attributable to non-controlling interests. The remaining 21.9% or $114 million is available for the public company shareholders. As this is a non-GAAP measure, it is not reported on our income statement. After we expense remaining taxes owed by the public company of $23 million on that $114 million, the net income available for common stockholders is the $92 million you see reported on our income statement. Note that the public company’s tax is proportionately higher than last year, primarily because IBG Inc’s. ownership rose from 18.6% to 21.9%. Our total income tax expense of $35 million consists of this $23 million plus the $12 million of taxes paid by the operating company. Turning to the balance sheet, with $9.9 billion in consolidated equity at June 30, 2021, we’re well capitalized from a regulatory standpoint. We deploy our strong capital base toward opportunities to grow our business and investment opportunities worldwide as well as to emphasize the strength and depth of our balance sheet to current and prospective clients and partners. Our capital is deployed across 14 registered broker-dealer type entities around the world, supporting regulatory capital requirements, liquidity needs, margin lending, and other financing opportunities in our growing brokerage business. And we continue to carry no long-term debt. Now I’ll turn the call back over to the moderator, and we will take questions.