Peter R. Huntsman
Analyst · Mike Sison with Wells Fargo
No, I think that as you look at it, we always like to go back and look at past cycles and say that we're repeating -- we certainly can repeat the cycles, but the reasoning that goes behind the cycles, whether it's an active war, whether it's energy volatility, whether it's an implosion or an explosion, 2 different things in the housing market, the number of unsold homes today are almost where they were in 2007 and '08, but for completely different reasons. And therefore, I think that the outcome of this cycle will -- the timing of it and the reasoning behind that outcome will be completely different. As you look at the other thing that's unique about this cycle is that we've got kind of 3 major economic blocks in the world, and all 3 of those are being hit for different reasons. The U.S. around, in my opinion, at least as it relates to this segment of the chemical industry, it's largely around interest rates and affordable housing. And I believe that, that is something that will be addressed, can be addressed. And it could happen very -- I'm not going to say overnight, but if interest rates -- if you saw a meaningful change in interest rates, something that economists, "the experts" have now been talking about for what, 3, 4 years, I think you could see quite a rapid recovery in North America. And that would, I think, take us to normalized levels of MDI, again, not over the course of a quarter, but certainly over the course of a year or something where you're getting much closer to a normalized rate. As I look to China, in the excess capacity that they have in China and the ability to stimulate consumer spending in China, largely from the rebound of an implosion that took place in their housing markets, again, for completely different reasons than what we saw in the United States and what we're seeing in the United States. They're now in probably their fourth going to their fifth year of what I would consider to be a lack of consumer confidence being driven largely by the implosion that you saw in housing value and overcapacity that was built to some degree to try to counteract the economic benefits of that housing issue. I think longer term, China is going to continue to be a very competitive place. I have a very competitive energy. They've got a vibrant work, well-educated workforce. And I think that China recovers. Europe is going to continue to be in an area of volatility, but it will find -- look, Europe is just not going to disappear. It will find its areas of competitiveness, whether it's in aerospace, whether it's in electronics, whether it's in renewable energy and so forth. And they'll continue to benefit. There'll be a lot of economic dislocation from Europe as they de-industrialize. A lot of that will end up in North America, the Middle East or in China. And so there'll be this reselling, but I don't see the tide coming back at the same -- for the same reason at the same time in all regions. But of course, you will see a recovery, and you will see for new capacity to be built in this industry to feed future demand, you're going to have to see higher prices, higher margins, and that will precipitate a cycle and a cyclical return. And that element of recovery has always been the same in past recoveries as to the reason why you see the recovery. So sorry, that was a long rambling answer. But yes, I believe that there will be a recovery. I think that we get back to those normalized levels probably in the U.S. and in China sooner than in Europe. And I see no reason why we wouldn't be able to do that. And then when we do that, we'll have an even more competitive cost structure, that will return even more to the bottom line. We've learned how to operate the company at a lower cost and lower inventory, stronger working capital discipline. We've got further downstream capacities that are filling out in Geismar, Louisiana, new capacities and catalysts and so forth that have been built and completed and now going into market in Performance Products and chip cleaning technology and so forth and Performance Products coming into the market. So not only will we see the recovery, but we'll also see some new opportunities from past investments to capitalize on that.