William Furr
Analyst · Piper Sandler. Brad, your line is now open
Thank you, Jeremy. I'll start on page five. As Jeremy discussed, for the third quarter of 2022 Hilltop reported consolidated income attributable to common stockholders of $32 million equating to $0.50 per diluted share. Moving to page six. During the third quarter, credit quality remained solid as non-performing loans remained stable at low levels compared to the second quarter of 2022. During the quarter, the outlook for the U.S. economy improved modestly as reflected in the Moody's S7 scenario. The improvement to the economic outlook resulted in a reduction in ACL of $3.6 million in the quarter, which was largely offset by growth in the portfolio coupled with modest risk rating migration across the book. As of September 30th, the allowance for credit losses was $92 million, yielding an ACL to total loans HFI coverage ratio of 1.16%. Additionally, excluding mortgage warehouse, broker dealer and PPP loans the ACL to total bank loans HFI ratio equates to 1.25%. While we remain constructive on the current state of our credit portfolio, we continue to believe that the allowance for credit losses could be volatile and the changes in the allowance will be driven by net loan growth in the portfolio, credit migration trends and changes to the macroeconomic outlook over time. Further, certain industry provided economic forecast are reflecting an increased likelihood of economic recession in future periods. We will continue to monitor the current environment as well as a broad set of economic forecasts during the fourth quarter to determine what impacts if any updated outlook may have on the allowance for credit losses in future periods. Turning to page seven. Net interest income to third quarter equated to $123 million, including approximately $3 million of PPP related income and purchase accounting accretion. Net interest margin expanded by 44 basis points versus a second quarter of 2022 to 319 basis points driven primarily by higher yield and excess cash loans HFI and loans HFS. Further, while we continue to rigorously manage interest bearing deposit costs in the face of increasing competition and customer expectations for higher rates, the cost of interest bearing deposits rose in the quarter to 70 basis points, an increase of 42 basis points from the prior quarter. We continue to believe that through the cycle deposit beta will average 50% increasing from the current 25% to 30% level. During the third quarter, new commercial loan originations, including credit renewals at an average book yield of 6.25%, which moved higher by 177 basis points versus the second quarter levels. In addition, we retained $129 million of residential mortgages during the quarter, yielding an average interest rate of 5.26%. I'm turning to page eight. In the chart in the upper left, we highlight the assets sensitivity of Hilltop, assuming parallel and instantaneous rate shocks, which represent an asset sensitive position of approximately 7% in the up 100 basis point scenario. As we evaluate asset sensitivity and interest rate risk, we assess a number of potential scenarios. Of note, if we shift the analysis from an instantaneous parallel shift to a gradual increase over the course of the next 12 months, the F 100 basis point asset sensitivity falls to approximately 3%. One factor impacting future asset sensitivity will be our loans currently at or below their floor levels. As of September 30th, Hilltop had approximately $720 million of loans remained at their contractual floor levels. Of these loans, $151 million will reset above their floor levels over the next 12 months. In addition, $2.1 billion of variable rate loans currently above their rate floor levels are scheduled to reset over the coming 30 days. Lastly, for 2022, we expect the impact of PPP related fees and interest, which were approximately $22 million in 2021 and purchase loan accretion, which was approximately $19 million to decline by combined $25 million to $30 million versus the 2021 levels. Moving to page nine. Total non-interest income for the third quarter of 2022 equated to $207 million. Third quarter mortgage related income and fees decreased by $144 million versus third quarter of 2021, driven by the ever evolving environment in mortgage banking, which has moved quickly to being purchase focused. Versus the prior year quarter, purchase mortgage volumes decreased by 1.1 billion or 28% and refinance volumes decline more substantially decreasing 1.4 billion or 87%. During the third quarter of 2022, reported gain on sale margins declined sharply to 218 basis points down 128 basis points versus the same period in the prior year. Margins were negatively impacted by price reductions across the markets, as well as customer preference to pay more in origination fees through rate buydowns versus paying the prevailing interest rate in the market. We expect full year average margins to remain under substantial pressure during 2022 as mortgage volumes normalized from the historically high level scene over the last two years, and the competition for that lower volume drives tighter margins. Through September, gain on sale margins for loans sold to third parties has averaged 263 basis points, and we expect by the year-end, the full year average to be between 250 and 270 basis points contingent on market conditions. Additionally, we continue to execute both sales of MSRs during the third quarter. These sales resulted in realized losses in the quarter of approximately $650,000. Further, we maintain a fully hedged position against our MSR asset, and as a result had no significant net valuation mark activity in the third quarter of 2022. During the quarter, the structured finance business at HilltopSecurities benefited from two items of note. First, the lock volume increased during the quarter related to those clients that reside in states that provided additional subsidization down payment assistance through the allocation of additional government sponsored funds. Secondly, the business benefited from the outperform certain hedges in the mortgage book. Realized hedge gains equated to $13.6 million for the third quarter. Further, the structured finance business reflected a $4 million unrealized positive valuation mark as of September 30th. It remains important to recognize that both fixed income services and the structured finance businesses can be volatile from period to period as they are impacted by interest rates, overall market liquidity, volatility and production trends. Turning to page 10. Non-interest expenses decrease from the same period in the prior year by $67 million to $289 million. The decline in expenses versus the prior year was driven by decreases in variable compensation of approximately $55 million, largely driven by PrimeLending, which was linked to substantially lower fee revenue generation in the quarter compared to the prior year period. Additionally, non-compensation variable expenses, particularly mortgage production related expenses, declined as volumes declined versus the prior year. Lastly, Hilltop recorded $1.3 million in severance in the quarter, which was principally incurred in our Mortgage segment. Looking forward into the fourth quarter of 2022, we continue -- we will continue the work of repositioning our mortgage business to reflect the ongoing market dynamics that are currently present, while continuing to focus on investing in the business for future growth once this portion of the cycle begins to ease. As Jeremy mentioned, we've taken definitive steps to reduce the cost of originating loans over the last few years, and that work is proving beneficial as we continue to focus on our target productivity levels over the coming quarters. While we remain committed to the mortgage business as it is core to our franchise, we do expect that the headwinds facing this business will continue in the 2023. Further, we expect that inflation will continue to impact compensation, occupancy, and software expenses resulting in elevated fixed costs within the businesses compared to prior periods. To help mitigate some of these headwinds, we remain focused on continuous improvement, leveraging the investments we've made over the last few years to aggressively manage increased productivity across our front, middle, and back offices. And while these inflationary pressures do exist, we are continuing to further streamline our businesses and accelerate the adoption of our digital capabilities to support client acquisition and overall business productivity. Moving to page 11. Average HFI loans equated to $7.9 billion in the third quarter, increasing by approximately $397 million from the prior levels. During the third quarter, commercial lending, in particular commercial real estate was solid as both closed production and our forward pipelines remain robust. While commercial loan growth has improved over the last few quarters, we expect that the full year average loan HFI growth, excluding mortgage loans retained and PPP loans during 2022 will be in the 1% to 3% range as competition remains very intense for newly funded loans and mortgage warehouse lending. Outstanding balances have continued to move lower throughout the year. Further, given our current liquidity position, we expect to continue to retain one to four family mortgages originated PrimeLending at a pace of between $25 million and $75 million per month for the remainder of 2022. Mortgage marketplace has shifted towards hybrid adjustable rate products, and we prefer holding these versus the longer duration fixed rate mortgages that made up the preponderance of the loans retained in prior periods. Turning to page 12. In the graph in the upper right, we showed the ongoing progress made in reducing NPAs as overall credit quality remained stable across the portfolio. During the third quarter, annualized net charge-offs to total loans was elevated at 15 basis points versus the prior periods, but remained well below nor normalized run rate loss expectations. The charge-offs in the period were not related, and we currently do not expect any systemic exposure emerging across the portfolio at this time. As is shown on the graph on the bottom right of the page, the allowance for credit loss coverage at the bank into the second quarter or into third quarter of 2022 at 1.21%. Turning to page 13. Third quarter average total deposits were approximately $11.7 billion and have decreased by approximately $243 million or 2% versus the third quarter of 2021. As was provided in earlier outlook, we have expected that deposits would trend lower throughout the year, and that has been the case. Overall, deposit flows are in line with our expectations and reflect certain client movement to achieve higher rates, while other clients are putting their capital to work in projects, which are requiring more equity now than in past periods. Further, we are seeing movement of deposits internally into treasury or laddered bond funds offered a HilltopSecurities and within the private bank and PlainsCapital. We continue to monitor the in and outflows and anticipate adjusting our pricing in the future to remain competitive, but not market leading from a deposit yield perspective. As noted earlier, given the expectation of additional rate changes from the Federal Reserve, we do expect to see deposit costs continuing to rise later in 2022 and into 2023. While deposit levels remain elevated, it should be noted that we remain focused on growing our client base and deepening wallet share through our treasury products and services. These efforts have been successful in 2022, and we expect that they will continue to accelerate in the 2023. Moving to page 14. We are updating our 2022 outlook to reflect current market conditions, expectations for future performance and actions we will be taking to support profitable growth over the coming quarters. It should be noted that we expect ongoing volatility in the capital markets and the overall economy, and that this volatility could materially impact our results and change our expectations in the future. As such, we will provide updated outlook where appropriate during our quarterly calls. Operator, that concludes our prepared comments and we'll turn the call back to you for the Q&A section of the call.