William C. Cobb
Analyst · Gil Luria
Thanks, Colby, and good afternoon, everyone. Earlier today, we announced our results for fiscal year 2013, which ended April 30. As many of you know, this was a challenging season for the industry as a whole, and while we're continuing to analyze some of the details, there are 3 important takeaways from the season. First, the challenges faced by the U.S. tax industry this year were unprecedented, resulting from late tax legislation, filing delays and an overall decrease in returns filed with the IRS. I'm proud that as an organization, we showed a tremendous ability to adapt to this unique environment and to execute on our plans in the U.S. Globally, I'm pleased that we again served more than 25 million clients worldwide. As the leader in the tax industry for over 58 years, H&R Block has become the largest tax preparer in the world, and our unmatched presence and expertise gives us an advantage as we look to 2014 and beyond. Second, although we executed well on many of our initiatives this tax season, we have room for improvement. Difficult decisions were made this tax season, with a focus on growing the business profitably. And we delivered better financial results in fiscal 2013, achieving our margin expansion goals. I'm also pleased that we grew and took share from Intuit for the third consecutive year in the digital online category, which is the largest and fastest-growing category for do-it-yourself filers. And finally, though there's still plenty of work ahead, we remain confident in our long-term strategy to be a global year-round tax-plus company. We continue to see growth opportunities in digital, financial services and international. And while some of these opportunities may take a few years to develop, I am optimistic about our ability to expand our business profitably and serve our clients better. In our core Assisted category, the value our tax professionals provide is only getting stronger as changes in legislation and economic conditions continue to add complexity to Americans' tax situations. The percentage of filers who choose to seek assistance has remained at close to 60% for the last 12 years, and growth in the digital do-it-yourself category continues to moderate as a number of pen-and-paper filers declines. Our strong industry position and financial strength continues to give us a competitive edge as we look to 2014 and beyond. With that summary, I'd like to take a few minutes to provide our thoughts on the U.S. tax industry. As I mentioned earlier, this was a challenging tax season for the entire industry as significant legislative changes in early January prompted the IRS to delay the opening of e-file to January 30. Additionally, certain forms issued by federal, state and various other taxing jurisdictions were unable to be filed as late as early March. With little time to react to these changes, these delays presented challenges to our industry to update systems and plan for operational needs throughout the season. Similarly, the delays confused and frustrated many taxpayers and significantly impacted the timing of filings during the season. You will remember from our previous earnings call in March, we expected that these delays would impact the timing of filings, but that ultimately, the season would normalize to historical growth rates of 1% to 2% by the end of April. Nonfarm employment, which has historically been the best leading indicator for tax filing growth, was up 1.7% in calendar year 2012. Based on this indicator and other information we had at that time, we had little reason to believe that growth levels this year would be different than average historical levels. Instead, at season's end, IRS returns were down approximately 1%, a result no one was expecting. So what drove the decline and does this mean we've set a new expectation for future growth in IRS filings? At this point, we're still analyzing IRS and other industry data to understand many of the details. And it's likely going to take a few months before we have a complete picture of the 2013 tax season. There are, however, a few possible factors that we can point to. First, the delays I mentioned earlier may have created confusion for certain taxpayers or a delayed sense of urgency to file for others. The IRS has not reported extensions yet, but it's possible there could be more return files in the upcoming off-season than in years past. We also know that taxpayers on average received lower refunds this year, and that more tax returns had tax balances due. It's hard to say whether this changed taxpayer obligations, but nonetheless, it may have created less incentive for some Americans to file by the middle of April. Finally, the IRS has applied more rigorous procedures in processing returns in an effort to curb inaccurate or fraudulent filings. Certain credits, such as the Earned Income Tax Credit, also known as the EITC, are rightfully receiving considerable focus. According to the IRS, the rate of improper EITC payments has remained high and had estimate that the EITC improper payment rate was 21% to 25% in 2012, which equates to $12 billion to $14 billion of improper payments. To address this, the IRS has become more vigilant in processing the 27 million returns that contain the EITC, evidenced by additional due diligence requirements put into place in 2012 for paid preparers who prepare returns with EITC claims, as well as a number of other changes. Additionally, Congress increased penalties for preparers who file fraudulent EITC forms, and the IRS has begun aggressively assessing these penalties. We believe that these efforts have contributed to the decrease of the number of EITC filings as a percent of total IRS filings over the past 2 years. Reducing fraud through such targeted efforts by the IRS and Congress benefits the country, our clients and our company. In particular, reducing the abuse of the EITC protects the benefit for all citizens, including our clients who legitimately qualify for it. We expect the IRS and Congress to continue focusing on ways to reduce fraud, and we fully support their efforts in applying consistent rigor for all returns filed. That said, considering long-term trends in IRS filings, there isn't enough evidence to suggest this was anything more than just an abnormal season. The IRS' annual growth in tax filings of 1% to 2% is supported by 50 years of data. And as such, this year's results do not cause us to change our expectations for future tax filing growth. Taxes are here to stay, and I'm confident that H&R Block will continue to play a significant role in improving and simplifying our clients' lives. With that context, let's turn to our performance for the year. Our estimates on market share are largely unchanged from our end-of-season volume results announced in late April. Though we won't have final data from the IRS until the fall, we estimate that total returns at the IRS were down about 1%, and our preliminary analysis suggest that we maintained our share of the overall U.S. market. At the end of last year, we talked with you about our client and market share gains, which are important, given the challenging competitive environment we are in after discontinuing our RAL offering. I also explain, however, that to grow the business long term, we would have to rationalize our cost structure, invest prudently to grow the business and focus on a better balance of client acquisition and profitability. In line with that long-term strategy, there are a number of decisions we made to improve the overall profitability on returns filed with the company this year. First, in Assisted, we shortened the timeframe for our Free Federal 1040EZ promotion and made various other systematic changes to optimize the rebate and referral programs in our offices. In digital, we exited certain unprofitable desktop software retailers and focused on optimizing our online offerings. Excluding the impact of these efforts, total desktop returns would have been down about 4% compared to the 7% we reported. In financial services, we discontinued the Free Refund Anticipation Check, or Free RAC promotion, which resulted in revenue growth, though it did negatively impact the number of Emerald Cards issued. And in Canada and Australia, similar to our U.S. strategy, we enhanced our promotional offerings to focus on high-value clients, and were able to exceed our revenue growth expectations in these markets. Heading into the season, we knew these actions would create headwinds for client count, but as you know, not all clients generate the same economics for our business. While our past focus on client volume and related market share gains was necessary for competitive reasons, we are in a new stage of growth for this business, with a focus on improving mix and profits over time. It's important that we balance our initiatives to gain market share with the associated cost. And the actions we took in fiscal 2013 do just that, positioning us well for long-term sustainable growth. With these actions in mind, let's take a look at our overall 2013 performance in each market category. In Assisted, the number of returns prepared by the company declined just under 3%. We believe the overall Assisted category was down about 1% in filings, and that we lost approximately 30 basis points of share. We obviously would have liked to perform better here. However, as I mentioned earlier, it's not just about increasing clients, it's about growing the business profitably. In the off-season, we'll be evaluating a number of things to continue our focus on driving a better mix of high-value clients. We'll also be taking a look at how we can continue integrating our adjacent financial products and deliver more value for our clients year round. That said, we set aggressive targets in client satisfaction and exceeded those targets, and we continue to retain clients at a significantly higher rate than our nationally branded Assisted competitors. Service must remain at the core of what we do, and metrics like these are usually good indicators of future health of our business. It's also important to note that our Assisted volume was not materially impacted by our decision to exit Sears. We're pleased that the clients we previously served in Sears locations were retained at levels in line with our expectations. Now consistent with our focus on growing profitably, we've also decided not to renew our relationship with Wal-Mart in the United States. At the end of the day, this was an economic and operational decision for us. Unfortunately, results in this channel did not meet our expectations, and we're confident that we can serve our clients better in our other 10,000-plus convenient neighborhood locations. We have offices minutes away from most Americans, and our tax professionals have lasting relationships with our clients. Importantly, we do not expect our decision to exit Wal-Mart locations to have a material impact on our results going forward. Turning to the do-it-yourself category. Total H&R Block At Home returns increased 232,000 over last year. In the key online category, returns grew approximately 11%, leading to a 50-basis-point gain in online share. Our marketing strategy was well designed and executed, and we believe our investments were better timed and more efficient than our competitors. Overall, the increase in online returns was offset slightly by the decline in desktop filings and Free File Alliance returns. Our mix of do-it-yourself clients continued to improve, which positions us well going forward as we continue to gain momentum in this category. In financial services, the discontinuation of our Free RAC promotion did result in an increase in fees earned from RACs, offset by lower RAC volume. However, it also resulted in the issuance of fewer Emerald Cards, with 2.5 million cards issued and $8.7 billion in total deposits. While we issued fewer cards compared to last year, this still represents a 9% increase over 2011, the last comparable year in which we similarly did not offer the Free RAC promotion. Though we've seen strong initial progress in efforts launched this year to increase card usage, we realize this was the first season for many of these initiatives. And it's going to take time before we can assess our true performance in this area. Finally, on the international front, I'm very pleased that we're continuing to see solid growth as revenues grew 7% to $249 million. Canada and Australia have strong management teams and have executed well to drive consistent profitable growth over the past few years. We remain under-penetrated in these markets when compared to the U.S., and I'm excited about the opportunities to broaden our global presence. Overall, we are making progress in our long-term strategy, and this year provided important lessons that we'll take into the off-season as we prepare for next year. Facing an array of challenges, our tax professionals and other associates remain focused on serving our clients, and they went the extra mile to finish the year strong. I want to thank all of our tax professionals, our other associates and our franchisees for demonstrating the strong values that truly set H&R Block apart. Now I'll talk for a few minutes about where we're headed in 2014 and beyond. But before doing so, I want to turn it over for Greg to discuss our financial results for fiscal 2013.