John Olin
Analyst · Wells Fargo. Your line is open
Thanks Matt. Our second quarter financial results generally finished as expected. However, retail sales were challenged by weakness in our developed international markets. During the quarter, the EU tariff relief, that Matt noted, came later than expected and as a key factor to the reduction in our expectations for full year shipments and operating margin. We look forward to putting the burden and uncertainty of the European incremental tariffs behind us and we look forward to restoring roughly a $100 million of annualized margin which we expect to begin early in the second quarter of 2020. The summary of our Q2 results is on Slide 10. In the second quarter, motorcycle segment operating income was impacted by lower shipments, incremental tariffs and unfavorable mix, partially offset by lower year-over-year SG&A and lower restructuring charges. Financial services operating income was down 6.2%. Consolidated net income was down versus prior year due to lower operating income. Earnings per share for the quarter was a $1.23. when excluding restructuring plan costs and the impact of incremental tariffs adjusted EPS was a $1.46. In the face of ongoing retail sales headwinds, we remain focused and disciplined on tightening retail inventory, aggressively managing costs, generating cash from operations, and delivering strong shareholder returns over the long-term. On Slide 11 worldwide retail sales of new Harley Davidson motorcycles in Q2, we're down 8.4% versus prior year. Our second quarter retail sales rate was lower than the improved rate of decline, which we experienced in the first quarter. In the U.S. Q2 retail sales were down 8.0% versus prior year. Through the first six months, U.S. retail sales were down 6.5% which was an improvement over last year's rate of decline and was in line with our expectations. International markets in the second quarter were down 8.9% driven by weakness in our developed markets. Through the first six months international markets were down 6.6% which was short of our plan. We expect 2019 to be a difficult year and it is unfolding as such especially in our developed international markets. In the near term we are addressing the softness in our U.S. and developed international markets by continuing to addressabley manage inventory levels and increasing marketing investments to encourage trial and increase conversion to sale. And our exciting new 2020 motor year motor cycles are just weeks away from launching. We also continue to invest in our strategy to build the next generation of Harley-Davidson riders. Thorough 2022 our more roads in Harley-Davidson plan is aimed at stabilizing our core business in the U.S. as we grow more riders globally. We believe more roads is building the proper foundation and driving the fundamentals to help steer the U.S. industry back to growth and deliver significant growth over our international markets. Let’s take a closer look at the U.S. on Slide 12. Retail sales were down versus the prior year quarter as a result of continued headwinds within the U.S. industry and due to lower HD market share. The U.S. industry was down 4.9% in the quarter an improvement over last year's Q2 rate and sequentially in line with Q1’s improved rate of decline. While we are encouraged by the tempering of the industry decline over the last two quarters, we believe the U.S. industry for new bikes continues to be challenged by soft use bike prices. We also continue to see shifting new bike demand toward other styles of motorcycles, including the smaller displacement bikes. Second quarter of market share for new bike registrations was 46.6%, down 1.8 percentage points, driven by stronger performance in segments, which we do not currently compete, but we will enter these segments starting next year as part of our more roads plan. In the segments where we do participate the Touring and Cruiser segments, which represent approximately 70% of the 601 plus CC market, our market share was up 2.0 percentage points for the quarter. During the first quarter our retail sales were positively impacted by increased sales incentives and the execution of our stronger dealer growth initiatives as we move to jumpstart a very slow start to the selling season. In the second quarter, we increased the execution of our longer term focused stronger dealer efforts and increased equity marketing while dialing back shorter term focus sales incentives. We believe our Q1 incentives were effective and will play a role as we move forward, but expect our focus to be on more strategic and sustainable investments. Looking at used bikes second quarter prices of Harley Davidson used bikes and our dealer network rose for the eighth consecutive quarter. While we were encouraged by the firming of use bike prices over the past several quarters, used bike prices remain at low levels compared to new. We tightly manage shipments of new bikes into the dealer network in the quarter. This resulted in quarter end U.S. retail inventory decreasing approximately 1,350 motorcycles versus the prior year. We were pleased with the dealer inventory at the end of the quarter and believe inventory is in a good place as we cut over to the new model year. On slide 13, second quarter international retail sales were down 8.9% versus prior year and as I noted below our expectations. International sales were down as a result of lower sales in developed markets, partially offset by higher emerging markets sales which were up 7.6%. Retail sales increases in emerging markets were driven by double digit growth in various markets including China and our ASEAN markets. However, Q2 retail sales in developed international markets were down 13.6%. Retail sales were down across most markets in Western Europe as we lapped strong initial sales of our new Softail motorcycles. Weakness in Japan and Australia continued behind contracting industry sales and competitive new product introductions in segments outside of Touring and Cruising. We expanding our stronger dealer efforts internationally and will continue to support our dealers in these markets with programs and a strong focus on test ride campaigns. Our year-to-date market share in Europe was 8.8% down 1.6 percentage points versus the prior year adversely impacted by lapping last year's strong Softail results and by lower sales of our Street motorcycles due to the impact of implementing the Street recall. As a detail on our more – plan reinforces, we remain confident in and committed to the great potential that international markets offer to Harley-Davidson. On Slide 14, wholesale motorcycle shipments in Q2 were down 5.3% and roughly at the midpoint of our guidance. Overall, family mix shifted slightly to Touring versus last year’s second quarter. On Slide 15, revenue for the Motorcycles segment was down 6.0% in the second quarter behind a 5.3% decrease in year-over-year motorcycle shipments. Revenue during the quarter was adversely impacted by a $144 decrease in the average motorcycle revenue per bike. This decrease was largely driven by unfavorable currency exchange, which adversely impacted Q2 revenue by 1.6%, partially offset by higher year-over-year pricing and decrease sales support. Both P&A and general merchandise sales outperformed retail motorcycle sales growth in the second quarter. On Slide 16, gross margin in Q2 was down as a result of lower shipments, higher manufacturing expense and unfavorable mix, partially offset by higher pricing. Product mix was unfavorable by $14.3 million in the quarter driven by unfavorable model mix within families and unfavorable P&A and general merchandise mix. In Q2, manufacturing was unfavorable versus prior year driven largely by $34.4 million of incremental EU and China tariff costs. Manufacturing was also adversely impacted by lower absorption on reduced production and shipments and temporary inefficiencies related to our manufacturing optimization initiative. On Slide 17, operating margin as a percent of revenue for Q2 was lower compared to last year, driven by lower gross margin, partially offset by lower SG&A and restructuring expenses. SG&A continued to benefit from aggressive expense management, partially offset by higher marketing and increase More Roads investment. Restructuring charges for manufacturing optimization totaled $10.4 million in the second quarter down $1.9 million from prior year financial. Financial Services segment’s second quarter operating income shown on Slide 18 was $75.5 million down 6.2% compared to the prior year. Net interest income was up $7.7 million due to higher year-over-year receivables and strong interest rate yields on the portfolio. The provision for retail motorcycle loan losses was $6.9 million unfavorable in the quarter, driven by higher credit losses. Operating expenses were up versus prior year as a result of a reporting change in which Harley-Davidson Dealer Systems business moved from the motorcycle segment to the financial services segment and due to higher depreciation as a result of our investment in the new loan management system, which was implemented in January of 2019. HDFS' operational results are on Slide 19. Q2 retail originations were down 1.8% versus prior year driven by lower motorcycles sales partially offset by higher HDFS market share. HDFS market share was 65.9% up a strong 1.9 percentage points during the quarter. At the end of the quarter, there was $364.2 million of cash and cash equivalents at HDFS and $1.93 billion of liquidity available through bank credit and conduit facilities. During Q2, HDFS pay dividends of $45 million to Harley-Davidson Inc. and also completed two asset-backed securitization transactions totaling just over $1 billion. On Slide 20, both our 30-day plus delinquency and credit losses were adversely impacted by startup inefficiencies resulting from the implementation of our new loan management system in the first quarter. The operational issues are largely behind us; however, we will continue to work through higher delinquencies that occurred during the system implementation. We expect key metrics to be impacted through the third quarter. The 30-day delinquency rate for retail motorcycle loan receivables on our balance sheet in Q2 was 3.33% or 24 basis points higher than last year’s Q2 rate, but sequentially improved from Q1 2019 which was up 42 basis points. The annualized retail credit loss rate for receivables on balance sheet was 1.82%. Q2’s loss rate increase of 26 basis points was above Q1 2019 which was up seven basis points as it takes time for the increased delinquent loans to roll through to credit losses. The remaining Harley-Davidson Inc. financial results are summarized on Slide 21. Our quarter end cash and cash equivalents balance was $924.6 million slightly lower than last year. Year-to-date operating cash flow was $496.2 million, which was down versus last year, driven by higher working capital and lower net income. Regarding liquidity, the company has and intends to continue to maintain a minimum of 12 months of projected liquidity needs in cash and/or committed credit facilities. We believe the charts on Slide 22 demonstrate that we are a leader in ROIC at the motor company and ROE at HDFS, and we are a clear leader in our ability to generate and return cash to our shareholders. One of the five objectives guiding our business strategies and execution through 2027 is to deliver superior return on invested capital as measured by motor company ROIC in the top quartile of the S&P 500 and by best-in-class return on equity at HDFS. Slide 23 illustrates our recent history of returning cash to our shareholders. In the second quarter of 2019, we paid a quarterly dividend of $0.375 per share and repurchased $42.9 million of our stock. Driving superior value for all our stakeholders is a top priority. After investing in our business, we intend to return excess cash to our shareholders in the form of increasing dividends and share repurchases. Slide 24 is a summary of our multiyear manufacturing optimization initiative. Key milestones in this initiative were successfully completed in the second quarter. We continue to expect $25 million to $30 million in savings for 2019. As Matt noted, annual ongoing cash savings are expected to be $65 million to $75 million after 2020. Manufacturing optimization costs were $14.4 million in Q2 and we expect costs of approximately $10 million in Q3. For the full year, we expect to incur $40 million to $50 million of operating expense, which is a $10 million reduction over our most recent guidance. We believe these investments have very attractive returns. They simplify our manufacturing footprint, provide focus in our operational investments and improve gross margin by roughly one and a quarter percentage points. Moving on to 2019 guidance on Slide 25. As Matt discussed, we recently obtained favorable EU tariff treatment for our Softail and Sportster motorcycles produced at our Thailand facility reducing tariffs on these bikes from 31% to 6%. We expect a similar approval for nontrite terrain motorcycles later this year. We expect to begin production for EU market in Thailand in late October. After shipping and inventory flow through, we expect motorcycles at the lower tariff rates to reach our European dealers in early Q2 2020. The approval process took considerably longer than we had anticipated and the delay has had an adverse impact on our shipment and operating income guidance. With regards to our shipments, the original plan was for sales of low tariff bikes to begin in the EU in early Q4 versus the revised timing of early Q2 2020. Our transition plan included a significant reduction in high-tariff inventory prior to the receipt of low-tariff replenishment, temporarily constraining supply in Q3 of 2019. The delayed start-up production shifts the inventory de-load of high tariff inventory to the end of the year. As a result, we expect to ship fewer bikes into Europe in Q4 than we originally planned. We expect the combination of company and dealer inventory in Europe to be down approximately 3,200 motorcycles due to the shift in timing of our approval. With regards to our operating margin, our 2019 operating income will not benefit from lower tariff rates in 2019 as originally anticipated. In addition, we have experienced a cost of idle manufacturing capacity in Thailand as we awaited approval as well as increased costs resulting from a dual-path approach in the event of a denial. Consequently with the delay of these approvals and softer than expected European retail sales as key drivers, we are lowering our 2019 full year shipment guidance by 5,000 units to 212,000 to 217,000 units. In addition, we are reducing our 2019 full year operating income margin guidance to 6% to 7% from the original guidance of 8% to 9%. Full year 2019 incremental tariff costs are expected to be approximately $100 million from our previous expectation of $100 million to $120 million. Tariff costs have been reduced behind lower expected European shipments as we de-load high tariff motorcycle inventory and lower demand in Europe. Other expectations for full year 2019 are largely unchanged. In the third quarter, we expect to ship approximately 43,000 motorcycles to 48,000 motorcycles. We also expect third quarter operating margin to be down approximately three percentage points versus last year, driven by lower planned shipments, continuing impact of tariffs and higher SG&A behind increased marketing investment. We continue to make the right decisions and investments to drive long-term sustainable growth and to provide long-term value to our shareholders. We continue to proactively manage through various and often significant global market headwinds, while continuing to invest in our future through our More Roads plan. As we look forward, we are excited to put the uncertainty of the European incremental tariffs behind us and look forward to restoring roughly a $100 million of annualized margin. We are prepared to face the challenges ahead and committed to driving long-term growth for the company and strong returns for our shareholders. Thank you. And now let's take your questions.