John Olin
Analyst · William Blair. Please go ahead
Thanks, Matt. Our fourth quarter financial results were impacted by first our decision to reduce shipments in an effort to lower worldwide retail inventories, as well as a result of slightly lower than expected retail sales in our international markets. Next we booked two voluntary recalls during the quarter. And finally, we recorded an additional restructuring charge in our efforts to aggressively manage the company cost. In the face of ongoing retail sales headwinds in the U.S., we remain focused and disciplined on tightening U.S. retail inventory, aggressively managing cost and driving improved cash from operations. In fact, in 2018, we increased operating cash by over $200 million, a 20% increase over prior year. Summary of our Q4 results is on slide 10. In the fourth quarter, revenue was down behind lower shipments. Motorcycle operating income was impacted by lower shipments, $19.4 million of restructuring charges, higher year-over-year SG&A, driven by two recalls, and the impact of incremental tariffs. Financial Services operating income was down slightly. Consolidated net income was largely flat to prior year due to lower operating income, offset by the benefit of a considerably lower tax. EPS for the quarter was $0.00 per share. When excluding restructuring plan cost and the impact of incremental tariffs, EPS was $0.17 per share. We remain focused on delivering strong margins and returns over the long-term. On slide 11, worldwide retail sales of new Harley-Davidson motorcycles in Q4 were down 6.7% versus prior year. In the U.S., Q4 retail sales were down versus prior year, driven by significant declines in the U. S. industry and slight market share declines. International retail sales were down modestly in Q4, driven by year-over-year declines in certain developed markets, partially offset by continued growth in emerging markets. While we expect our business to remain under pressure in 2019 driven by continuing challenges in the U.S. motorcycle industry, we intend to introduce exciting new products and add innovation that customers value in our new motorcycles. We also expect to aggressively manage supply and execute marketing efforts to encourage trial and increased conversion to sale. Through 2022, our More Roads to Harley-Davidson plan is designed to build the proper foundation, drive the right fundamentals to help steer the U.S. industry back to health, and to drive significant growth across our international markets. Let's take a closer look at the U.S. on slide 12. Retail sales were down 10.1% versus prior year quarter. While the U. S. retail sales decline is very disappointing, the decline was in line with our expectations. The U.S. industry was down 8.4% in the quarter. We believe the industry was down largely because of soft used bike prices and a relative shift and rider preferences towards smaller motorcycles. Looking at used bikes, prices remain at historically low levels compared to new. However, we are encouraged as we continue to see positive momentum in used bike pricing. During Q4, pricing services such as NADA and Black Book published higher values for Harley-Davidson motorcycles, while prices were slightly lower at auction. Additionally, the sixth consecutive quarter saw a rising prices of used Harley-Davidson bikes in our dealer network. Used Harley-Davidson motorcycle sales were up through November. Our share of the combined new and used motorcycle registrations was up through November and has been for the last nine consecutive years. We believe used sales are also an indicator of our brand health and provide prospects for future new bike sales. 2018 full year market share of new bike registrations was 49.7%, down 1.0 percentage points. Our U.S. market share reflects the adverse impact of a highly competitive marketplace and relatively strong growth in segments which we do not currently compete. In the segments where we do not compete, the Touring and the segments where we do compete, Touring and Cruisers segments, which represent approximately 70% of the 601+cc market, our market share was up 0.8 percentage points on a full year basis. During the quarter, we pulled back on shipments of new bikes in the channel. This resulted in yearend U.S. retail inventory decreasing approximately 350 motorcycles over the prior year. We believe this market discipline is important in maintaining customer and dealer value and will ultimately result in strong retail sales of new motorcycles. On slide 13, international retail sales were down 2.6% in the fourth quarter, slightly below our expectations. On a full year basis, international sales were up slightly. During Q4, emerging market retail sales were up 18.7% driven by double-digit growth in several markets including China, Brazil and India. Retail sales in developed international markets were down in the fourth quarter resulting primarily from ongoing weakness in Japan and Australia. During 2018, these two markets experienced cracking industry sales and competitive new product introductions of segments outside of are Touring and Cruising. Retail sales were also down modestly in Western Europe driven by weak consumer confidence in France and the U.K. On a full-year market - our full year market share in Europe 10.3%, up 0.5 percentage points versus prior year. As a detail on our More Roads plan reinforces, we remain confident in, committed to great potential that international markets offer to Harley-Davidson. We believe our brand, products and distribution will drive sustainable growth in international markets. On slide 14, wholesale motorcycle shipments were down in the quarter on a full year basis. We came in under our full year shipment guidance as a result of our decision to reduce retail inventory from plan levels in both the U.S. and international market on a lower-than-expected international retail sales. Compared to last year's fourth quarter Street and Sportster shipments as a percent of the total were up behind improved sales rates, offset by lower cruiser mix as we lap last year's initial selling of our new Softail motorcycles. On slide 15, revenue for the motorcycle segment was down 8.7% in the fourth quarter and a 7.9% decrease in year-over-year motorcycle shipments. Revenue during the quarter benefited from $230 increase in the average motorcycle revenue per bike, this increase was driven by higher year-over-year pricing and favorable mix, partially offset by unfavorable foreign currency exchange. Both P&A and general merchandise sales lagged, retail motorcycle sales growth in the fourth quarter due in large part the timing of our fiscal calendar that had one less week versus last year’s calendar. In addition, general merchandise was down as it lapped strong sell-in of our 115th anniversary products. Full year revenue was [up 1.1%, bike] shipments being down 5.3%. We believe this demonstrates a resilience of our company and brand in the face [Technical Difficulty]. On slide 16, gross margin in Q4 was down as a result of lower shipments, unfavorable manufacturing expense and higher raw material cost partially offset by higher pricing and favorable currency. Financial impact of currency was favorable by $4.0 million during the fourth quarter. Q4 foreign currency exchange gains were partially offset by a stronger U.S. dollar, which adversely impacted revenue by 1.5%. Raw material costs were higher during the quarter behind increased steel and aluminum pricing. Finally, manufacturing was unfavorable versus prior year driven by the impact of incremental tariffs, lower absorption on reduced production and shipments and temporary inefficiencies related to our manufacturing optimization. Q4 tariff costs increased by $13.4 million driven by higher EU and China tariffs, the full year impact of incremental tariffs $23.7 million. On slide 17, operating margin as a percent of revenue for Q4 was lower compared to last year, driven by lower gross margin, higher SG&A and restructuring expense. SG&A was adversely impacted by two voluntary recalls booked in the fourth quarter. The first was a $35 million clutch recall on certain Touring and Softail bikes which we discussed last quarter. The second was a brake recall on our street motorcycles for which we recorded a $20 million charge. We believe that limited parts availability for referring our street motorcycles will adversely impacted for Q1 2019 retail sales by approximately 2500 motorcycles, primarily in our international market. We do not believe that these recalls will have a meaningful impact on our full year retail sales. Restructuring charges totaled $19.4 million in the fourth quarter including ongoing manufacturing optimization of $15.5 million and an additional $3.9 million restructuring charge related to cost-reduction efforts. Profitability and strong cash flow remain a key focus. It is our objective to further leverage our established capabilities to drive profit, cash flow, top quartile ROIC into the future. Financial Services Q4 operating income shown on slide 18 was slightly lower compared to prior year. Net interest income was up $4.4 million due to higher year-over-year receivables. In Q4, there was a reporting change in which Harley-Davidson dealer systems business moved from the motorcycle segment to the Financial Services segment, Harley-Davidson dealer systems by its dealer management system software and services to the majority of our U.S. dealers. Under the leadership of HDFS, this business will leverage HDFS e-competencies related to managing dealer facing systems and servicing the U.S. dealer network. During 2019, we expect the reporting change will increase both financial services revenue and operating expense by between $10 million to $13 million, while having only a modest impact on operating income. HDFS's operational results are on slide 19. Q4 originations were up 8.0% versus prior year, driven by increased used motorcycle sales in the dealer network and a higher HDFS market share of new motorcycle sales. Market share was 69.5%, up a very strong 9.6 percentage points during the quarter, driven by competitive U.S. sales rates and HDFS continued commitment to full credits from lending. At the end of - quarter's end there were $609.2 million of cash, cash equivalents at HDFS and $1.0 billion of liquidity available through bank credit and conduit facility. During 2018, HDFS paid dividends of $235 million to Harley-Davidson. On slide 20, 30 day delinquency rate for retail motorcycle loan receivables on our yearend balance sheet was 4.12% or 9 basis points lower than Q4 2017. The annual retail credit loss rate for receivables on a balance sheet was 1.76% or 14 basis points lower than 2017. HDFS continues to maintain a robust liquidity position, contributed strong profitability to the company. The remaining Harley-Davidson Inc. financial results are summarized on slide 21. Our yearend cash and marketable securities balance of $526.3 over prior year and anticipation of paying off a $600 million MTN matured on January 15. Year-to-date operating cash flow was up over $200 million or 20% from last year driven by lower working capital as we remain pretty focused and diligent on our use-of-operating cash. Our effective tax rate was 22.6% in 2018 was considerably lower than last year driven by - driven due to the impact of the Tax Cuts and Job Act. In addition, fourth quarter of 2018 benefited from lapping last year's write-down of $53 million of deferred tax assets related to the 2017 Act. And finally, starting liquidity company has and intends to continue maintain a minimum of 12 months of effective liquidity needs in cash and/or committed credit facilities. Harley-Davidson's full year financial results are summarized on slide 22. Revenue net income earnings per share were all up in 2018 despite lower shipments $106.3 million charges related to our restructuring plan cost, $23.7 million due to the impact of [Technical Difficulty] an increased in SG&A and [higher recall] cost. EPS for the year was $3.19 and when excluding restructuring plan cost the impact of incremental tariffs EPS was $3.78. We believe the charts on slide 23 demonstrate that we benchmarked very well against various peer groups in our ability to generate and return cash to shareholders period of 2015 to 2017. One of the five objectives guiding our business strategy and execution through 2027 is to deliver superior return on invested capital measured by Motor Company ROIC being in the top quartile of the S&P 500 and by a best-in-class return on equity at HDFS. Harley-Davidson is a leader in ROIC at the Motor Company and ROE at HDFS is a clear leader in our ability to generate and return cash to our shareholders. Slide 24 illustrates our recent history of returning cash to shareholder. In the fourth quarter of 2018 we paid a quarterly dividend of $0.37 per share, repurchased $194.2 million of our stock. Driving superior value for stakeholders is a top priority. After investing in our business, we intend to return excess cash to our shareholders in the form of increasing dividends, share repurchase. Slide 25 is a summary of our multi-year manufacturing optimization initiative. We now expect total program costs to be between $152 million to $162 million versus our most recent estimate of $155 million to $185 million. We are also lowering our capital estimates at $65 million versus our most recent estimate of $75 million. We continue to expect our manufacturing optimization to yield ongoing cash savings of $65 million, $75 million. In Q1, we expect manufacturing optimization cost of approximately $20 million. We believe these investments have very attractive return. When completed we expect this initiative will simplify our manufacturing footprint, provide focus in our operational investments and improve gross margin by roughly 1.25 percentage. Moving on to 2019 guidance on slide 26, we expect the declines in the U.S. industry to continue into 2019, albeit at a more temperate pace than in 2018 and we expect international sales grow - as a result in 2019 we expect to ship between 2017 222,000 motorcycles which is down approximately 3% to 5% versus prior year. During 2019 we expect retail sales to be positively impacted by, focused investment in our strategy to increase global ridership, model year 2019 and 2020 motorcycles and continued expansion of our international dealer network. However, we expect these positives to be more than offset by strong headwinds including, the weak U.S. new bike industry, a relative shift in U.S. rider preference towards smaller motorcycles and a marketplace crowd with highly competitive promotions incentives and discounts. In 2019 we will continue to aggressively manage supply in line with demand and plan for U.S. yearend inventory to be down versus 2018. We expect gross margin as a percent of revenue to be lower than prior year driven by significant increase in incremental tariffs lower volumes and unfavorable mix, partially offset by aggressive cost reductions including the benefit of $25 million to $30 million of manufacturing optimization sales. During 2019, we expect incremental tariff cost to be approximately $100 million to $120 million. These costs include EU, China tariffs on our products shipped from the U.S., as well as U.S. tariffs on certain items coming back coming from international market. This estimate excludes metals costs, belting from U.S. steel and aluminum tariffs, but we do expect for metals costs that are included in our gross margin guidance. We intend to mitigate the impact of incremental EU and China tariffs by year end. Our plant in Thailand came online in Q3, 2018. As we explained when we announced this project in 2017 we intend to utilize it to make more of our products accessible to customers and targeted international market, including our China and ASEAN market. As our operations in Thailand ramp up the fact that realize manufacturing efficiencies and to lower our cost of motorcycles produced there through other international markets. Looking at SG&A we expect SG&A to be lower in 2019 behind aggressive cost management and lapping 2018 recall cost. For 2019 we have relocated substantial amount of our SG&A spending to invest in our more roads plan to drive future growth. For 2019 the motorcycle segment operating income is expected to be between 8.0% or 9.0%. Excluding the impact of incremental tariffs, manufacturing optimization cost, we expect operating margin as a percent of revenue to be largely flat to 2018. We are very focused on improving operating margin, in line with are plans we expect motorcycle segment operating income in 2022 improve by approximately $170 million to $200 million versus 2019 as we complete for manufacturing optimization and continue to address tariff impacts on our business. We expect Financial Services operating income in 2019 to be down compared to 2018 driven by higher cost of debt and higher depreciation on our investment, a new loan management system which went live on January 1st. Capital expenditures in 2019 are expected to be between $225 million to $245 million, which includes approximately $20 million deferred manufacturing optimization. We expect our full year effective tax rate will be approximately 24% to 25%. As we look forward to the first quarter we expect 53,000 to 58,000 motorcycles which is down approximately 9% to 17%. Segment operating margin as a percent of revenue is expected to be down approximately 6 percentage points from Q1, 2018. We expect first quarter will be adversely affected by incremental tariffs, unfavorable mix, lost absorption on lower shipments and unfavorable currency, partially offset by lower year-over-year restructuring costs. Despite the challenges we faced in 2018, Harley-Davidson's demonstrated its incredible resilience by growing revenue and profits, delivering significant higher year-over-year operating cash and returning $628 million to our shareholders through dividends and share repurchases. As we look beyond 2018, we are prepared for an extremely dynamic and highly competitive global market motorcycle market. We will continue to focus our investments, deliver strong returns to our shareholders and drive growth for the company over the long-term. Thank you. And now let's take your questions.