John A. Olin
Analyst · RBC Capital Markets
Thanks, Keith, and good morning, everyone. I'll review the financial results for the third quarter starting on Slide 11. As we anticipated, our third quarter key financial metrics were down versus prior year. This is the result of significant changes to our historical shipping patterns, driven by the launch of a new ERP system at York during the quarter. I also want to recognize that it was a critical quarter, as we put in place some of the final pieces of our manufacturing strategy, which will enable us to better meet customer demand in the future. With that as background, let's discuss our third quarter results. During the quarter, Harley-Davidson, Inc. consolidated revenue was down 10.5%, behind a 14.5% decrease in motorcycle shipments. Our third quarter income from continuing operations was $134.0 million, a decrease of $49.6 million. Similarly, diluted earnings per share were $0.59 per share, down from $0.78 in the year-ago quarter, a 24.4% decrease. Operating income from the motorcycle business was $144.8 million, down 19.9% compared to last year's third quarter. The decrease was driven by a planned reduction in motorcycle shipments, partially offset by higher gross margin and favorable restructuring spending. Operating income at Harley-Davidson Financial Services was up compared to last year's third quarter, driven by higher net interest income as we lapped a prior year loss on bond repurchases. Finally, this quarter's net income was adversely impacted by a higher tax rate as compared to last year's third quarter. Now, let's take a look at retail sales on Slide 12. Overall, worldwide retail sales of new motorcycles were down 1.3% in the third quarter and up 6.0% year-to-date. Retail sales in the quarter reflect lower production that affected product availability in the U.S. Also impacting retail sales was the retiming of the new model year launch from July to August, as well as ongoing economic challenges in many worldwide markets. Let's take a look at U.S., the U.S. market, on Slide 13. As we expected, retail sales in the U.S. in the third quarter were negatively impacted by limited product availability. During the quarter, U.S. retail sales were down 5.2%, but up 6.2% on a year-to-date basis. During the third quarter, U.S. retail inventory fell to extremely low levels, driven by 3 factors: First, planned production was down in July by about 40%, as we cut over to the new ERP system in York; second, the new model year introduction was moved out 1 month to August. Consequently, there was a longer period of time between ending model year 2012 production and shipping model year 2013 motorcycles. And third, August and early September York production was down from anticipated production rates, as our employees focused on system issues that came up during the ERP implementation. As we discussed last quarter, we entered the third quarter with 6,800 more units in the U.S. retail inventory than the prior year. And at that time, we also expected inventory would quickly fall below prior year levels and would remain below prior year levels for most of the quarter. And remember, the prior year inventory level was already lower than desired. The quarter did play out largely as expected. Inventories quickly fell below prior year levels. However, as supply of York motorcycles was restored to prior year levels, sales responded positively. As we exited the quarter, dealer inventory ended up about 3,100 units higher than a year ago and retail momentum was strong. In terms of market share, our U.S. share was down slightly, reflecting limited product availability for most of the quarter. However, our U.S. market share softened by 0.2 percentage points to 57.7% in the third quarter versus prior year. Year-to-date, U.S. market share was up 1.4 percentage points to 56.5%, which is our highest September year-to-date market share on record. On Slide 14, you'll see retail sales at international markets for the quarter grew 7.6%, driven by increased year-over-year sales in all major regions. During the third quarter, Latin America was up over 32%, driven by strong performance in Brazil and Mexico. Retail sales in the Asia-Pacific region were up 9.8%, driven by strong growth in our emerging markets and in Australia. We continue to be excited about our growing businesses in India and China. Additionally, we are pleased to see Japan was up 2.5% despite a challenging economic environment and increased competitive activity. The EMEA region was up 1.8% for the quarter compared to 2011. During the quarter, we continued to see significant softness in the U.K. and Southern European countries, especially Spain and Italy. While these markets remain down significantly, their rate of decline improved from the previous couple of quarters as they lapped the steep declines which began in Q3 2011. Northern Europe's retail sales continue to grow in the quarter behind strength in Germany and Switzerland. Through August, our market share in Europe was flat to prior year at 13.1%. We expect continued volatility and pressure on sales in the EMEA region as a result of the extremely challenging macroeconomic environment. Finally, during the quarter, Canada was up 4.9% from the prior year period. International expansion is one of our core areas of investment for future growth. During the quarter, dealerships were opened in China, India, South Africa and Oman. On Slide 15, you'll see wholesale motorcycle shipments during the quarter were down 14.5% compared to last year, behind lower production due to the implementation of the York ERP system. During the third quarter, Custom and Touring as a percent of total shipments, were 3.5 percentage points lower than prior year. This was also a result of the impact of the ERP implementation at York. International shipments as a percent of the total were up compared to last year as we allocated more motorcycles to international markets. As you may recall, in the second quarter, we temporarily diverted some international units to the U.S. to meet the strong demand in that market. On Slide 16, you'll see revenue for Motorcycles and Related Products segment was down 11.6%, driven by lower shipments in motorcycles during the third quarter. Parts and Accessory revenue was down 0.8%, behind a 1.3% decrease in worldwide retail motorcycle sales. General Merchandise revenue was up 9.1%, driven by our sportswear and leathers categories, which included the new 110th Anniversary products. Average motorcycle revenue per unit decreased $279 compared to last year, largely as a result of unfavorable currency translation in the quarter. On average, our major foreign currencies were weaker by approximately 9% between the third quarter of 2011 and the third quarter of 2012. During the quarter, we increased our global average prices for the 2013 model year motorcycles by approximately 0.75%. We believe our ability to increase prices for the second consecutive year reflects the strength of our brand and appeal of our new motorcycles. Slide 17 provides the cadence and impact of our restructuring activities. The big news for the quarter was the York ERP implementation, a crucial milestone in our manufacturing transformation. While we are very pleased overall, we did experience some minor systems disruptions after we cut over in July. In fact, we lowered production in August and early September as we focused on resolving these system issues. While there were no major complications, the slower production compounded the already limited product availability during the quarter. By the end of the quarter, we were caught up on the lost production. However, we utilized overtime to catch up. Today, the York production line is largely running at speed, and we have shifted our focus to system optimization. We incurred approximately $11 million in temporary inefficiencies during the quarter. We were toward the high end of our range, partially due to the overtime we accumulated as we made up for the slower-than-planned production during the ERP implementation at York. As a result, we now expect $32 million to $35 million in temporary inefficiencies for the full year. We are very pleased with the new system and look forward to the benefits it brings to our future. The next step at York is to prepare for the execution of our flexible manufacturing strategy, which will allow us to produce motorcycles closer to customer demand, starting in the first quarter of next year. Turning to the restructuring cost and savings on Slide 18. We incurred $9.2 million in restructuring expenses during the quarter. We also moved $5 million of expected spending from 2013 -- 2012 to 2013. We now expect between $35 million to $45 million for the full year 2012, and $5 million to $10 million for 2013. We continue to expect total cost to be $490 million to $510 million. We also continue to expect total ongoing annual savings of between $315 million and $335 million upon completion of our restructuring activities. We are very pleased with our progress as we enter into the final stages of restructuring. On Slide 19, you'll see gross margin in the quarter fell $37.5 million behind lower shipment volumes and unfavorable mix, which both were the result of the ERP implementation at York. Gross margin benefited from lower manufacturing cost as a result of restructuring savings. Gross margin also benefited from the model year 2013 motorcycle price increases and lower raw material costs. Foreign exchange positively impacted gross margin by $1.2 million. However, revenue was $28 million lower as a result of the devaluation we experienced in most key currencies versus last year, offset by favorable hedge positions and the positive impact of lapping year ago foreign currency losses. Over the next several quarters, we expect downward pressure on gross margins as a result of the devaluation we are experiencing in most key currencies. The adverse financial impact of devaluation will be somewhat tempered in the near term by our currency hedges. As a percent of revenue, gross margin increased to 34.7% or up 1.0 percentage points versus last year's third quarter. We are very pleased with our gross margin performance during the quarter and the first 9 months. However, we expect fourth quarter gross margin percent to be roughly in line with last year's fourth quarter. We expect fourth quarter gross margin percent will include productivity gains and improved mix, but will be offset by unfavorable foreign currency and significantly lower production levels as compared to last year. Operating margin for the quarter fell by $35.9 million, driven by lower gross margin as a result of lower shipments. As a percent of revenue, operating margin fell 1.4 points during the quarter on lower revenues, with largely flat SG&A and restructuring spending. On a year-to-date basis, operating margin is up 26% to $662 million. And as a percent of revenue, operating margin was up 2.3 points versus prior year. SG&A was $224.0 million or 0.8% higher during the quarter compared to quarter last year. For the fourth quarter, we expect SG&A to be modestly below prior year spending of $266 million. Q4 SG&A will reflect the impact of 5 fewer calendar days in the quarter, which equates to roughly $8 million in lower expenses and reflects the lapping of last year's recall expense of $12 million. Favorability from these items will be partially offset by a moderate increase in spending in the fourth quarter to support our growth initiatives. We continue to expect full year SG&A spending will increase over last year as we invest in growth, but will decrease as a percent of revenue. Now moving on to our Financial Services segment on Slide 21. HDFS operating profit was $72.4 million, up 16.7% compared to last year's third quarter. I would like to highlight 2 items on the year-over-year comparison. First, the provision for wholesale loan losses was unfavorable at $4.8 million, driven by a reserve release for last year's third quarter. Second, the key driver of HDFS' operating growth of $10.4 million in the quarter was an improvement in net interest income. This was largely driven by the lapping of prior year loss of $8.7 million on the early repurchase of a portion of our 6.8% medium-term notes in Q3 of 2011. Based on continued strong credit loss performance and a more favorable cost of funds, we now believe HDFS' full year operating profit will improve slightly over last year. Now, I will provide more detail on HDFS' operations on Slide 22. During the third quarter, HDFS retail motorcycle loan originations increased 2.5% or $15.6 million compared to the same period last year. The increase was driven by growth in used motorcycle loan originations, partially offset by a decline in new motorcycle loan originations, consistent with lower retail sales in the U.S. During the quarter, our market share of new retail motorcycle lending was up slightly at 52.3%. Originations in Q3 were approximately 80% prime. Total finance receivables outstanding decreased 0.2% compared to a year ago, primarily due to a declining retail portfolio. Retail finance receivables outstanding decreased 1.5% compared to a year ago, partially offset by wholesale finance receivables, which were up 9.5% compared to last year. We are very pleased with the improved retail delinquency rate and the credit loss -- retail credit losses compared to last year, which you will see on Slide 23. The 30-day delinquency rate for retail motorcycle loans at the end of the third quarter was 3.24% or 49 basis points better than the same date last year. Annualized retail credit losses were at their lowest level in over 10 years. For the third quarter, retail credit losses came in at 65 basis points, considerably lower than prior year of 111 basis points. This favorable credit loss performance was driven by our continued strong underwriting, collection and loss mitigation efforts, as well as consumer behavior in managing their credit in the U.S. While we continue to be disciplined in how we manage the loan portfolio and the overall business, we have no assurance that the current consumer behavior will continue. In fact, we expect retail credit losses to increase over time, due to customers taking on additional debt, HDFS' efforts to find more prudently structured loan approvals in the near prime and subprime lending, and lower recoveries resulting from lower charge-offs than prior periods. We remain focused on enabling sales of Harley-Davidson motorcycles and prudently managing the business, while providing an attractive return to Harley-Davidson, Inc. Now let's take a look at cash and liquidity on Slide 24. You will see that at the end of the quarter, we had $1.93 billion of cash and marketable securities. In addition, HDFS had $1.55 billion of available liquidity through bank credit and conduit facilities. We currently have, and intend to continue to maintain, a minimum of 12 months of projected liquidity needs in cash and/or committed credit facilities. We ended the quarter with higher than typical cash balances. This was due to the timing of our funding activities. During the quarter, we took advantage of the very favorable debt markets and completed 2 transactions, both which represent all-time low interest rates -- interest cost to HDFS. First, in July, HDFS completed a $675 million asset-backed securitization at a weighted average interest rate of 0.81%. And second, in September, HDFS completed the sale of $600 million of 3-year notes with an interest rate of 1.15%. Through the fourth quarter, we expect our cash balance to come down and be in line with our cash strategy to hold 12 months of projected liquidity in cash or committed credit facilities. Additionally, we established a $200 million Canadian conduit facility to more efficiently finance Canadian retail receivables, and we renewed our $600 million U.S. conduit facility. During the third quarter, we repurchased 1.9 million shares of Harley-Davidson stock for $85 million. As we have stated, returning value to our shareholders through increasing dividends and share repurchases is a top priority. We will continue to evaluate opportunities to enhance value for our shareholders. Now I'd like to highlight 2 items on Slide 25, which provide the remaining Harley-Davidson, Inc. financials. First, the company provided operating cash of $712.5 million during the first 9 months, compared to $901.6 million provided in 2011. The decrease in operating cash flow was primarily driven by an increase in working capital and an increase in HDFS wholesale receivables due to the timing of shipments in the third quarter. The motorcycle business generated year-to-date operating cash of $496 million. Second, the effective tax rate was higher this quarter versus last year's third quarter, which included a favorable settlement of an IRS audit, as well as a favorable change in the Wisconsin income tax law associated with certain net operating losses. On Slide 26, you'll see that for 2012, we continue to expect motorcycle shipments to be 245,000 to 250,000 motorcycles on a worldwide basis, up 5% to 7% from 2011. During the third quarter (sic) [fourth quarter], we expect to ship 44,500 to 49,500 units, which is down 2% to 12% compared to last year, as we move production closer to seasonal demand. We expect fourth quarter gross margin percent to be roughly in line with last year's fourth quarter gross margin. As we expect Q4 gross margin percent will include productivity gains and improved mix, which will be offset by unfavorable foreign currency and significantly lower production levels as compared to last year. We expect Q4 production to be down versus prior year for the following reasons: First, we plan to implement flexible production at York in the first quarter of 2013; second, we will not repeat the build of 7,000 additional motorcycles in the fourth quarter of 2011 to support the ERP launch; and third, because there will be 5 fewer days in the fiscal Q4 calendar compared to last year's fourth quarter. We continue to expect full year 2012 gross margin of 34.75% to 35.75%. Finally, we continue to expect 2012 capital expenditures to be $190 million to $210 million, which includes approximately $35 million of capital related restructuring.