Rich Williams
Analyst · Sameet Sinha from B. Riley FBR
Sure. So there's a lot there, Sameet. Thanks for those questions. Our marketing spend, as we've discussed it in the past, all of it is tied with the same fundamental philosophy of return on our marketing investment in terms of incremental gross profit generation over time. So our 12- to 18-month ROI thresholds apply to offline as well as every other really category and channel we work in. So when we move some things down or move some things up, which happens constantly in our spend, it's largely because of performance. Now in the case of offline here, recently, we've been doing some 2 things really specifically. One is some market mix model-testing that's really based on improving the total performance and productivity from our market investment. And the second piece is exactly what you mentioned, which we really need to continue to scale the product and merchandising pieces before we start to lean really heavily into more brand reeducation, at least more so than what we're doing. And you can see that in our offline campaign. They're still very much rooted in savings in the classic Groupon with a little sprinkling of new product experience. That one is going to -- you're going to see us continue to spend and optimize along those campaigns. They work well. But before we really lean hard into the rest of it, we need to see broader reach and exposure of our core new experiences around bookability, card-linked, voucherless, et cetera. So we have some work to do on that. It's why we're leaning so hard into accelerating those in the first half in particular. And I would expect you're going to see more of our marketing start to tilt towards education and brand development as we move into the second half. As far as the desktop and app experiences, when you should see those, there's like one -- so depending on what browser you're going to use and if you clear your cookies, you may -- if you go to mobile web as an example, you may already start to see some pretty dramatic version -- changes to versions of the mobile web experience. And you're seeing everything from automatic rotating slots to horizontal scroll and a lot of different merchandising slots coming in just to improve search and browse discovery. So we have pretty significant changes that are already rotating in market and they're live. Just whether you're in a test-sell or not, it's hard to say. But you're starting to see those already. But what you should think about there is that we don't -- unless we -- one of those pieces that we're testing is just an outright winner, I would not expect a big bang change. In general, I think you've seen historically, when brands that have significant consumer populations decide to make big bang changes, even if it's generally good and for the right reasons, it takes consumers a while to get used to it. And those can be pretty cold starts for consumers that are well trained in your existing UI. Instead, I would expect us not to do that. I wouldn't expect us not to do the big bang but more to feather in our winning elements that we see consumers are interacting really productively with. And you're already seeing some of that happen in our core app. We have new filters. We have additional filter metrics and a bunch of other things that are making it easier to -- for consumers to find what they're looking for. But we're feathering those in as they win and as we go. And I think that's just a healthier way for us to move. Unless we see just something that blow us away and consumers adopt it really aggressively and immediately. But it's just not our experience there historically, especially not at scale. As far as Groupon Select, it's not something that we've discussed broadly, and I think that's just because it's very much in an experimental stage. It's very early. There's still a lot of folks who haven't been exposed to it, haven't seen it on the site or in our apps. We're very excited about that program. I think it has a lot of potential. But again, it's a membership-oriented program. So it's a little too early to start discussing what the potential of it is ultimately, financially, for the company and for customer accounts because as you know, in membership, it's really about continuity. And that's where it counts, not just how many folks you can get in the program initially. So I'd say, stay tuned on that one. We're watching it really closely. We are excited about it as an early-stage initiative, but we have a lot of wood to chop on that one.