Michael Rechin
Analyst · Sandler O'Neill
Great. Thank you, Dan, and thanks to everyone for taking time out of their afternoon to get caught up on our progress at First Merchants. The comments I'll be making are from our press release issued earlier today, January 27, released about 9:45 a.m., and directions in that press release point you to a webcast that will contain the slides that my co-host John Martin, our Chief Credit Officer, and Mark Hardwick, our Chief Financial Officer will cite in their remarks.
So the press release covered what I feel is a very strong year of progress for the company in many regards, as you'll hear from other management today. And Slide 4 starts out with full year highlights at the top where we talk about record net income of $60.2 million, $18 million of net income in excess of our 2013 full year results of $42 million, translates to a 17% increase in earnings per share of $1.65 over the level achieved in 2013 of $1.41. And the results then produced, on the bullet points directly beneath it, an elevation in our returns in average assets to 1.08%, in return on tangible common equity of 12.94%. So we like our ascent towards truly high performing returns and feel it's indicative of the progress we've been making for several years now.
The last full year highlight is around Citizens Financial. And throughout this call, I know we're going to get a chance to talk about Community Bank of Noblesville and towards the end of the call about Cooper State Bank. But when I think about actual accomplishment, what's forefront for me is the progress we made with Citizens Financial, which we refer at this point as our Lakeshore division. And the progress there for a $1.1 billion bank that closed in the fourth quarter of 2013 was significant for us. I described it, at that time, as our entrance into a third growth market to complement other markets we're currently in. And when I think about that full year acclamation, I think of it in the context of leadership, first and foremost, and a couple of key people from that company leading our efforts in the northwest corner of the state and just across the state line into Illinois and some of the out markets of Chicago. Some of the cultural acclamation that, that management team has lead: the retention of key clients, key folks on their team. And the work in front of us is to take advantage of that momentum and to build on our branding across a really large, dense, competitive marketplace. So we're pleased with the way that, that went for us in year one. We look forward to 2015.
The bottom half of Slide 4 talks a little bit more close in time to our fourth quarter highlights just wrapped up. Again, another strong quarter. We had $0.41 or $15.3 million in earnings after absorbing acquisition expenses associated with the Community Bank of Noblesville work of $0.03 a share in the fourth quarter, to ready us for the closing that took place in that period of time and ultimately the integration that will take place here in a couple of months. I thought, while our fair value accretion was light in the quarter relative to prior periods, the core net interest margin holding in pretty well and actually an overall set of performance that I thought was strong and you'll hear a little bit more about that from Mark.
Moving to Slide 5. A little bit of detail on Noblesville. It's a modest sized bank at $270 million, a nice additive to a marketplace that we're already significant in. And on Page 5, just a couple of reminders of what actually closed into our company on the 7th of November. So we brought over $145 million in fair value marked loans that I think at year-end were right at about $140 million, deposits of $228 million. It really did a nice job for our liquidity moving into 2015. Transaction value at $49.2 million that wound up with about the desired -- after final election considerations split of 71% stock and 29% cash. So the work relative to Community right in front of us is to work through the integration as we have with other companies joining us and all of that work is on track. Key management from Community Bank of Noblesville, just like the Citizens folks, have joined us and taken slots on our team in a leadership way, and they'll be helping us lead that cultural integration that works side by side with the actual data integration plan for the last week of April of this year.
Looking back with some moving away from approximations to what actually joins us. With Community are 9 full service banking centers -- and I'm on Slide 6 at this point, with the deposits that I referenced earlier, very additive to our business plan, while it's not so sizable that it brings undue risk into what is already a significant amount of momentum for us in the central Indianapolis marketplace. So 7 of the 9 locations in Hamilton County, not only the fastest-growing Indiana market but right at the top of the state in terms of income per capita. As such, it increases our market share position in Hamilton County from 8 to 4. And so the work ahead of us, beyond the data integration, is just having the banking centers get laid out in the most efficient way for our shareholders and for the marketplaces that we serve. And so on a couple of bullet points in the middle of the page alludes to the fact that we'll have some 2015 consolidation opportunities on at least 3 overlapping locations in markets that First Merchants had historically operated in.
So as the press release states, it's accretive to our earnings per share this year. So capture the first 12 months of operations. Additive to our business plan as I said. Our finalization of our credit work came in with the $11.6 million of marks on a combined basis between interest rates, OREO and credit. So that's exactly what we thought, if not a little bit better, because on the last bullet point -- and Mark will show you a specific slide on our tangible book value growth over time. But I would describe it all as better than we originally shared, because at the time of the announcement, I think, we had talked about tangible book value earn back of 4 years or just under 4. Based on the finalization of our work, it will turn out to be 3 and the result of that you'll see in Mark's slides, which I'm going to let him move to right now.