Mark Costa
Analyst · Jefferies
Yes. So it's a great question. So from an end market point of view, obviously, the end markets have been challenged, and we've been in a version of stagflation since 2022, right, that has not had any improvement. And I think that as you look at the auto market, obviously, it's impacted by interest rates, the price of gas and everything else going on this year. But the challenge in demand has been in place for quite some time. We expected at the beginning of the year, autos would have been similar to last year. It turns out they're going to be from a sales point of view, probably down 3% to 4%, and that's a function of interest rates and gas prices, which I think all connect to, to some degree, the Iran war. And I think when you look at building construction, it's been down 20% on total home sales in the U.S. starting in '23, and it stayed there and it continues to be weak, also true about the same percent or 20% down in Europe and obviously, China being worse. And consumer durables are, to some degree, connected to home sales as a transaction moment and just overall affordability. So those also remain somewhat challenged. And I'd say, at least in the back half, are going to be a bit down relative to last year. But overall, if you look at it, it's been down, but it hasn't gotten a lot worse this year. It's just not gotten better, right? In the beginning of '25 before the trade war, it was -- the economy was recovering and then the trade war hammered it down. Things I think were stabilizing with consumers and it was getting a bit better in the first quarter of this, the Iran war hammered it down. So unfortunately, those 2 events have prevented some market recovery. But underneath it, what it tells you is consumers are resilient because everyone still has a job. And that's the key difference between other sort of recessionary moments where a lot of people lose their job and really cut back on spending, people have their job. They're just moderating how they spend money to manage that affordability. So that's the good news. And then if you actually add up the area of the curve of things they've not bought since 2020 to now, there's a lot of pent-up demand if we could just get to some stability and where they feel safe. And in this context, we're demonstrating our innovation still delivers a lot of growth as we said it would and improving year-over-year. So when you've got mid-single-digit growth in consumer durables in a down market, when you've got autos flat in a down market, you've got all this Renew growth creating new markets for us to sort of grow in and expand our corporate addressable markets, accessing the packaging market in a profitable way, et cetera. We feel good about how we're delivering growth this year in this context. And in this context, which is very challenged continues into next year, that will -- we're confident we can keep delivering that revenue growth in this context. So that's one context. It could stabilize if the Iran conflict gets resolved. I think that will be a big stimulus in consumer behavior, feeling safer about the future. So that could happen, but that would be upside in how we plan for next year. But the revenue part feels like we're in a good shape to drive growth in revenue. And as we mentioned, we have ways to stabilize fibers. I don't think CI is going to be a big headwind despite the drama we're in here in Q4. And then we've got tailwinds in spread, tailwinds in asset utilization. So it all lines up to being a pretty good year with that volume. And importantly, when you think about that and that working capital can be released a much better cash flow year next year.