Mark Costa
Analyst · Citigroup. Your line is now open. Please go ahead
Yeah. So, you know, certainly the, you know, overall Fibers business has some challenges to it. As you said, there's sort of two separate challenges. I'll start with the destocking one first. First, there's no change we've seen in the in-market growth rates. So that is not part of what's going on as far as we can tell. So market growth rates are still modest, and the one to two percent rate is as traditional cigarette markets are declining in the two to three percent range but the heat not burn cigarettes offsetting it. We've talked about that in the past. So that part is actually quite stable. You know, our contract rate for the year of this year is around 90%. Has put the prices in place for the year. So we're in very solid shape on a pricing point. As you said, you know, it's really a question of, you know, what's driving the volume decline, markets are stable, then by definition, you know, it's a dynamic around customer destocking. As the principal driver of what's going on. You know, as I said before, TOW is incredibly small. Percent of the final price of a cigarette about 2%. So the cost of it is not a high priority when you're selling cigarettes that are greater than 60% gross margins. You know, the focus always starts with security of supply. And when the market got incredibly tight, in that 2021, 2022 time frame, customers were building inventory. And as we've now discovered, building a lot more inventory than we fully understood. One of the challenges with customers when you're in situations like a very tight market is no one wants to tell you how much inventory they have because they're afraid you will not supply material to them. You know, as much as they might need going forward. So you get this dislocation of, you know, inventory. And we certainly lived through that in the 2022, 2023 time frame. Where we discovered just how much inventory people had built over time. And so the destocking is going a bit longer than we expected. And the reason the destocking started, I should have mentioned, is the market has loosened up a little bit. So there's some capacity that's been added in China. If you look at it from a 2023 to 2025 point of view, that capacity is around 5%. Of the, you know, ex-China market. So the capacity utilizations have now moved down into that lower, you know, 90% range. 90, 95% range. And with that room, the customers feel safe destocking. And that's what we see going on in what we're gonna see in the second quarter is something similar to the first quarter. I've learned my lesson around predicting how long destocking is gonna last. Certainly, we expect some of it to continue in the back half of the year. And we're still working with our customers to truly understand exactly where, you know, where this all sits. But the good news is the fundamentals are there. The capacity utilization is still, you know, in the 90s. You know, the markets are not declining in some significant way. And I think that gives us stability. The contracts, as you asked, are about 80% for next year. You know, most of those are multiyear contracts, some are annual. They generally include pricing. A lot of it's CPT pricing that actually gives customer protection on, you know, making sure the margins are tracking with, you know, raw materials. So overall, I'd say we feel like the market is certainly facing that challenge, and it's gonna continue a bit more than we expected. It's good to remember there are a couple other dynamics driving earnings down. We had a discontinue product from customers with about $10 million and energy is a bit of a headwind this year relative to last year and how it flows in. The second part of this discussion, of course, is around the impact on the tariffs with China. We do have two products that go into China. One is the textiles, the Naya product, which has been a great growth story for us and half of the Naya that we sell is in China, the other half's outside of China. It's a huge market. So it's a time-based issue for us to if these tariffs last for a period of time, of just winning market share in mills outside of China to replace do in China. So that one is manageable and we have some inventory in place. I'm gonna get some of those issues now. When it comes to the flake, this is, you know, cellulose flake that you spin into fiber, and we do this with the Chinese national tobacco company. Obviously, the rates are, you know, pretty high. There, and so we'll have to just see how those tariffs evolve over time. So that's a more specific thing around, you know, what's going on with the tariffs. And what is to see how long the tariffs last with this China. When you put them together, obviously, creates a bit of more challenge for this year. It's still extraordinary earnings compared to our past. And great cash flow that comes out of this business.