Chris Marr
Analyst · Bank of America Merrill Lynch. Please go ahead
Yes, Jana I will take that question and expand a little bit even beyond New York city if that's okay with you so again when we think about New York and our supplemental package we provide MFA disclosures so we are showing the 48 assets in the same pool that are in the Burroughs like North Jersey, Long Island. Specifically of those 48 assets, 23 of them are in the Burroughs we currently operate in Staten Island, Queens, Brooklyn and Bronx. Their performance was extremely solid in Q1, those 23 assets 8.4% revenue growth minus 4.3% expense growth, 13.2% growth so a market perspective, the Atlantic Coast, New York, Philadelphia and Boston continue to perform quite strong. From a supply perspective then, if you start to look at supply in our seven major markets and so that would be the New York, North Jersey, Long Island market broadly, Greater Chicago land from Baltimore Maryland all the way through Northern Virginia, Arlington, counties Dallas fort worth, Houston, Miami, fort Lauderdale, our work tells us that thus far in 2016 in those markets there have been 28 new store openings not controlled by Cube and of those 28, 8 compete with an existing CubeSmart asset. The primary market for supply would be the Dallas Fort Worth area that 8 new stores open, 3 of which compete with us. Then when we roll forward and we look at what we define as in development and so when we think about in development we think about assets that are under construction that have received all of their approvals but not begun construction yet. 4 have received permits but have not received their approvals yet. What we see in those 7 broadly defined markets at this point are 96 non Cube controlled assets that meet that definition. 33% of those are in Dallas Fort Worth. The next most significant market would be the broad New York, New Jersey, Long Island but when you break that down because of the very highly populated area and you look at the Burroughs specifically, we currently see 14 assets non-Cube controlled in the Burroughs; 2 in Queens, 8 in Brooklyn, 1 in the Bronx and 3 in Staten Island and then of those 14 4 will directly compete with an existing Cube so from a supply perspective again we remain very comfortable with the overall supply in those 7 markets. I think when you look at where things appear to be moving in volume the quickest is the Dallas Fort Worth area. I think we have a large competitor who has 6 projects just on their balance sheet going in Dallas, Fresno, Plano and Louisville and I would put Houston right behind that. So not worried at all about Burroughs or New York, New Jersey, Long Island. Again when you think about those markets and you think about square foot per capita again we remind folks, if you look at all the storage in the Bronx 2.2 square feet per capita, Brooklyn 1.47, Queens 1.6. If you look at our stores in the Bronx, we have one Cube to rent for every 82 households, in Brooklyn one Cube to rent for every 97 households and in Queens on Cube for every 57 households. So continues to be an under supply market, there would have to be a significant new supply way beyond what we see today to get that market to be of any concern and again I will remind folks about the national average of 7.35 of square foot per person and the two highest are Dallas at 7.9 and Houston at 7.6 so that's where we are seeing most of the new supplies. Hopefully that not only answered your question Jana but answered our question from the supply perspective.