Michael Porcelain
Analyst · Citigroup
Thanks, Fred, and good morning, everyone. In almost every respect, Q4 was terrific and a perfect finish to a very successful fiscal 2018. Consolidated net sales for Q4 were $167.4 million, of which approximately 39.3% were generated from U.S. government end customers, 27.3% from international end customers and 33.4% from domestic commercial end customers. We did expect slightly higher revenues in Q4, but we did see a few things slip into our fiscal 2019. Otherwise, our revenues, we would have reported in Q4, would've been even higher.
As you can see with our level of bookings, demand for our solutions remains very strong. During Q4, we achieved bookings of $214.4 million with strong order flow across almost all of our product lines. Our bookings exceeded our own expectations. We achieved a consolidated book-to-bill ratio of 1.28, with both of our segments achieving a book-to-bill ratio in excess of 1. As Fred mentioned, our consolidated backlog of $630.7 million, which was higher than what we finished Q3 at, is at a record high for the company. As I mentioned during our last few conference calls, when you think about the strength of our reported backlog, you should be mindful that the total contracts that we have in-house are actually higher than the $630.7 million amount. If you download our Q4 investor presentation from our website, we have, once again, included a table that shows a summary of certain contracts that we have been awarded and which indicates that we have additional visibility to approximately $500 million of potential orders from existing contracts. Alternatively stated, between backlog and contracts in place, we have approximately $1 billion of visibility into future revenue.
Because we are the sole provider for many of these contracts, funding and orders are generally assured and likely to occur. As you know, although timing of receipt for new orders and funding is always difficult to predict, I believe that our overall visibility has never been higher and clearly shows we are positioned for growth in fiscal 2019 and beyond.
Let me now turn back to sales and give you a sense by segment of what is happening. Net sales in our Commercial Solutions segment for Q4 were $93.2 million, in line, when compared to Q4 of last year. Sales in this segment represented approximately 55.7% of consolidated net sales. This was a solid quarter for bookings for our Commercial Solutions segment, which achieved a book-to-bill ratio of 1.15. Net sales of our satellite earth station products, which include our HEIGHTS product line, our SCPC satellite modems and solid-state power amplifiers, were higher this quarter as compared to Q4 of last year and Q3 of fiscal 2018. This was the third quarter in a row of sequential growth for our satellite earth station product line after several years of difficult end marketing conditions and challenges, and although international market conditions have become more volatile of late, we do believe that fiscal 2019 will be another year of growth.
As Fred will discuss in a bit, our HEIGHTS product line continues to pick up traction, and our business outlook for fiscal 2019 assumes that related sales of our HEIGHTS solutions will grow significantly in fiscal 2019 as compared to the level we achieved in fiscal 2018. Given market dynamics, we are optimistic that we are experiencing a period of multiyear revenue growth for this product line.
Turning to our Enterprise Technologies solutions and Safety & Security Technologies solutions. Net sales in Q4 2018 were similar to Q4 of 2017. We have healthy backlog in each of these product groups, and end market conditions remain healthy. We are responding to a number of active proposals, but as we have seen, sales cycles, especially for Next-Gen 911 solutions alone.
In Q4, we did make a decision to wind down our VirtuMedix product line and go into a mode where we intend to focus on maintaining customer support, but not chase new sales. Ultimately, we gave it a try, but we feel our future efforts are best spent growing our location-based and Safety & Security products lines here.
Now let me turn to our Government Solutions segment where you can demonstratively see the benefit of our strategy we implemented a year or so ago. Here, net sales were $74.2 million as compared to $54.6 million in Q4 of fiscal 2017. This represents an increase of approximately 36%. Sales in this segment represented approximately 44.3% of total net sales. Bookings for this segment were at the highest level in 2 years and reflect continued strength in almost all of our Government Solutions product lines. During Q4, we achieved a book-to-bill ratio of 1.44, the sixth quarter in a row that our book-to-bill ratio in our Government Solutions segment exceeded 1. Backlog for our Government Solutions segment is the highest it has been since our acquisition of TCS back on February 23, 2016. This remains quite an accomplishment, and we are optimistic about the future.
Now let me give you some color on our operating metrics. Our gross profit in Q4 of fiscal 2018 as a percentage of consolidated net sales was 37.6%, as compared to 40.9% in Q4 of fiscal 2017. During Q4, as described in our 10-K, we did record a favorable adjustment of approximately $1 million to cost of sales. Excluding this adjustment, our Q4 gross margin was actually 37%. As a reminder, our gross margins are influenced by products -- product mix changes. For example, our Government Solutions segment has lower margins than our Commercial Solutions segment, so when sales in this segment pick up, it does impact our consolidated gross margin percentage.
On the operating expense side, SG&A expenses were $27.8 million in Q4 of fiscal 2018 or 16.6% of consolidated net sales, which is lower than the 17.9% last year. For the year, SG&A expenses as a percentage of revenue were 20%, lower than the 21.1% we achieved in fiscal 2017.
Research and development expenses were $13.9 million in Q4 of fiscal 2018 or 8.3% of consolidated net sales. We continue to believe that R&D spending is paying off, and our spending is contributing to the recent contract awards we have announced. And of course, we continue to invest significantly in new technologies across our entire product line.
Total stock-based compensation expense was $5.6 million for Q4 of fiscal 2018 as compared to $5.5 million for Q4 of fiscal 2017. As we did last year, we paid fiscal 2018 bonus awards to most of our employees and all of our senior executive management in the form of fully vested, but restricted share units. These share units must be held for a 1-year period before they are allowed to be sold. And in simple terms, they reflect the confidence that we have in our future.
Amortization of intangibles was $5.3 million in Q4 of fiscal 2018 and we expect the run rate to be lower for fiscal 2019, as certain assets related to the 2008 Radyne acquisition became fully amortized towards the end of fiscal 2018. On a GAAP basis, our consolidated operating income was $16 million or 9.6% of net sales in Q4 of fiscal 2018. For the year, we achieved operating income as a percentage of consolidated net sales of 6.2%. Excluding favorable adjustments described in our 10-K, our operating income would've been 5.9% of consolidated net sales. This 5.9% compares favorably to the 3.3% of consolidated net sales we achieved in fiscal 2017, excluding the $18.7 million of adjustments described in our 10-K. As a reminder, operating income includes all of the amortization associated with the TCS acquisition. As such, we believe, adjusted EBITDA is an important metric. And in this regard, our adjusted EBITDA was $30.7 million in Q4 of fiscal 2018 or 18.3% of consolidated net sales. Adjusted EBITDA on our Commercial Solutions segment was $20.5 million or 22% of related net sales and in our Government Solutions segment, was $8 million or 10.8% of related net sales.
Let me now talk about our interest expense, taxes and balance sheet. Here, interest expense was $2.6 million in the fourth quarter and primarily reflects interest on our secured credit facility. Our effective tax rate was 27% for fiscal 2018. And on the bottom line, GAAP net income was $7.5 million or $0.31 per diluted share in Q4. We did take a $2.3 million or $0.09 per diluted EPS charge for discrete tax items, primarily associated with updated estimates of the impact of tax reform. GAAP net income excluding this charge would've been $9.7 million or $0.40 per diluted share.
On the balance sheet side, at July 31, 2018, we had $43.5 million of cash and cash equivalents. This was another strong quarter for cash flow generation. We continue to achieve operating and working capital efficiencies and in Q4 of fiscal 2018, we generated cash flows from operating activities of $19.7 million and reduced our total indebtedness by approximately $15 million.
As of July 31, 2018, we had total debt, excluding unamortized deferred financing cost of $171.3 million. Our leverage ratio was 2.19x adjusted EBITDA as compared to a maximum allowable of 3x adjusted EBITDA under our current facility. So today, we have pretty good balance sheet flexibility and given our future outlook, we anticipate being in compliance with our credit facility covenants for the foreseeable future.
As I mentioned during our last conference call, given our improved balance sheet and the strength of our operating results and our expectations on the future, we are looking at ways to reduce our current facility cost and obtain additional flexibility or even look at other debt structures. In short, we think we can reduce cost and obtain better terms than we have today. If we are successful in achieving such results or make changes, we will report it back to you.
At the end of the day, it was a really good quarter for Comtech and a solid finish to what was a very successful year for Comtech. Let me give you a quick recap on the year, and I'll interweave some comments on our fiscal 2019 guidance. First, fiscal 2018 was our third consecutive year of revenue growth. We finished the year with $570.6 million of revenue or 3.7% higher than fiscal 2017. Our Commercial Solutions segment represented 60.5% of fiscal 2018 net sales and our Government Solutions segment represented 39.5%.
Looking forward, as Fred stated, we are setting our fiscal 2018 revenue target to a range of $600 million to $625 million. This revenue growth target reflects an annual growth rate of approximately 5% to 9.5%. We think that is impressive, it may also be conservative. We have a large number of programs that we are pursuing. And if some of them come in earlier than we currently expect, our actual revenues could even be higher than our targets. Although both segments are expected to achieve revenue growth in fiscal 2019 as compared to the amounts achieved in fiscal 2018, we do expect our Government Solutions segment to significantly increase and to account for a higher percentage of our consolidated net sales in 2019 as compared to 2018. We will likely burn off some of our backlog for the next few quarters until some of these large opportunities are secured.
For the full year fiscal 2018, we achieved bookings of approximately $755.1 million, which translates into a full year book-to-bill ratio of 1.32. Our book-to-bill ratio was really fantastic. And at first glance, it may be difficult to repeat a 1.32 ratio in fiscal 2019. But then again, we have a number of large opportunities out there. So it might be possible to repeat. And at the moment, we are shooting for a book-to-bill over 1x in fiscal 2019, and we will update you as we report our numbers.
Our gross profit for fiscal 2018 as a percentage of consolidated net sales was 39.2%. In fiscal 2019, we will be working through a number of large programs that we have in-house, including our new over-the-horizon troposcatter system contracts, which are in the early stages, and we continue to successfully migrate our large wireless customer to our 911 network. In addition, we anticipate more HEIGHTS sales, which, today, have lower gross margins than our SCPC products. Adding it all up though, we believe that our gross margin percentage in fiscal 2019 will be comparable to the 39.2% we achieved in 2018.
Our R&D as a percentage of consolidated fiscal 2018 net sales was 9.4%, and we expect to continue such investment levels in 2019. As such, we expect the amount of our spending in dollars to be higher, but as a percentage to be comparable.
Our SG&A as a percentage of consolidated fiscal 2018 net sales was 20%. We continue to make investments in this area and based on current spending plans, we do expect SG&A as a -- as -- in dollars to be higher, but as a percentage in fiscal 2019, to be comparable to fiscal 2018.
Amortization in fiscal 2018 was $21.1 million and we do expect it to decline to approximately $17.2 million with all of the decline occurring in the Commercial Solutions segment.
Our operating income as a percentage of consolidated net sales, excluding the favorable adjustments, were 5.9% in fiscal 2018, as I mentioned earlier. We believe, we -- that we can improve this margin in fiscal 2019. And given our current expected product mix and other spending changes, it will likely come in under 7%.
Our total interest expense, which excludes -- which includes amortization of deferred financing cost is expected to range from 6% to 6.4% in fiscal 2019. Our actual cash borrowing rate currently approximates 4.5%.
If you look at adjusted EBITDA
[Audio Gap]
segment, we achieved 19.7% in the Commercial Solutions segment and 7.7% in the Government Solutions segment in fiscal 2018. On a consolidated basis, it was 13.7%.
Given all of the puts and takes I described earlier, as product mixes, changes and other spending changes, we are still focusing our adjusted EBITDA as a percentage of revenue in fiscal 2019 to be about the same that we achieved in fiscal 2018.
In fiscal 2019, before any discrete items, we expect our effective tax rate to approximate 23.25%, which reflects a full year of tax reform compared to the 27% in fiscal 2018. On the bottom line, GAAP net income was $29.8 million or $1.25 -- $1.24 per diluted share. Excluding the benefit of tax reform for the year, net income would have been $18 million or $0.75 per diluted share. As such, on a GAAP basis, given the growth we are expecting, we are setting our GAAP diluted EPS target to a range of $0.89 to $1.10.
As everyone knows, Comtech's financial quarters have some unevenness or lumpiness to them. In this regard, similar to Comtech's business cycles for the last several years, financial performance in the second half of fiscal 2019 is expected to be higher than the first half. In addition, given the straight-line amortization expense associated with intangible lives, we expect to report GAAP operating income slightly above breakeven in the first quarter of fiscal 2019 with each of the remaining fiscal 2019 quarters achieving higher GAAP operating income. We expect our GAAP operating income and our adjusted EBITDA in the first quarter of fiscal 2019 to be a bit better than the amount we achieved in the first quarter of fiscal 2018. Considering the impact and level of interest and taxes like we had in Q1 of fiscal 2018, we do expect to report a slight GAAP net loss in the first quarter of fiscal 2019 with significant improvement thereafter.
In addition, based on the anticipated timing of shipments and performance related to orders currently in our record backlog and the timing of expected new orders, net sales and adjusted EBITDA for each of our first 3 quarters of fiscal 2019 are expected to be a bit better when compared to the respective quarters of fiscal 2018. Our fourth quarter of fiscal 2019, like last year, is expected to be the peak quarter, by far, for both net sales, operating income and adjusted EBITDA. In addition, we believe that in fiscal 2019, we will continue to generate a significant amount of cash flows from operations on a GAAP basis. In the past 2 years, we have generated over $100 million of cash flows, which truly is a testament to the strength of our business. Given our growth, it is reasonable to think we can generate somewhere around $50 million of cash flows from operating activities in fiscal 2019.
In summary, fiscal 2019 is expected to be another terrific year for Comtech. And as we sit here today, our business outlook looks bright.
Finally, before turning it over to Fred, I just want to mention that our Board of Directors declared a dividend for the fourth quarter of fiscal 2018 of $0.10 per common share payable on November 16, 2018, to shareholders of record at the close of business on October 17, 2018. Future dividends remain subject to board approval as well as compliance with financial covenants under our secured credit facility.
Now let me turn it back to Fred, who will discuss our business in further detail. Fred?