Earnings Labs

Commerce.com, Inc. (CMRC)

Q2 2022 Earnings Call· Thu, Aug 4, 2022

$2.90

-1.53%

Key Takeaways · AI generated
AI summary not yet generated for this transcript. Generation in progress for older transcripts; check back soon, or browse the full transcript below.

Same-Day

+2.56%

1 Week

+8.99%

1 Month

-14.82%

vs S&P

Transcript

Operator

Operator

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for standing by, and welcome to BigCommerce Second Quarter 2022 Earnings Call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. After the speaker presentation, there will be a question-and-answer session. Please be advised that today’s conference is being recorded. I'd now like to turn the conference over to your first speaker today, Daniel Lentz, Head of Investor Relations. You may begin Sir.

Daniel Lentz

Management

Good afternoon, and welcome to BigCommerce's second quarter 2022 earnings call. We will be discussing the results announced in our press release issued after today's market close. With me are BigCommerce's President, CEO and Chairman, Brent Bellm; and CFO, Robert Alvarez. Today's call will contain forward-looking statements, which are made pursuant to the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Forward-looking statements include statements concerning financial and business trends, our expected future business and financial performance and financial condition and our guidance for the third quarter of 2022 and the full year 2022. These statements can be identified by words such as expect, anticipate, intend, plan, believe, seek, will or similar words. These statements reflect our views as of today only and should not be relied upon as representing our views at any subsequent date, and we do not undertake any duty to update these statements. Forward-looking statements, by their nature, address matters that are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from expectations. For a discussion of the material risks and other important factors that could affect our actual results, please refer to the risks and other disclosures contained in our filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. During the call, we will also discuss certain non-GAAP financial measures, which are not prepared in accordance with Generally Accepted Accounting Principles. A reconciliation of these non-GAAP financial measures to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures as well as how we define these metrics and other metrics is included in our earnings press release, which has been furnished to the SEC and is also available on our website at investors.bigcommerce.com. With that, let me turn the call over to Brent.

Brent Bellm

Management

Thanks, Daniel, and thanks, everyone, for joining us. On today's call RA and I will review our second quarter results and discuss our priorities and approach to managing through the current conditions of market turbulence. RA will also provide detail concerning our view on the back half of the year in his discussion on updated guidance. First and foremost, I'm pleased to share the second quarter was one of the best in our history, a result that encourages us given the macroeconomic climate. Our team continues to deliver on our mission to be the leading open SaaS eCommerce provider, empowering B2C and B2B merchants around the globe. Let's discuss the details. In Q2, total revenue grew to $68.2 million up 39% year-over-year. This was our 10th consecutive quarter of posting 30% or higher revenue growth, which was bolstered by strong results from the Feedonomics acquisition in Q3 of 2021. Our non-GAAP operating loss was $13.7 million, which was also ahead of our guidance last quarter. We concluded Q2 with an annual revenue run rate or ARR of $296 million up 41% from last year that represents a sequential growth in ARR of $15.5 million. This increase was driven by our continued success in the enterprise segment. Enterprise account ARR was $206.6 million up 68% year-over-year. That marks our 15th consecutive quarter of 40% or higher enterprise ARR growth. Q2 delivered the largest sequential growth in ARR in our history, excluding the quarter of the Feedonomics acquisition. It was better even than during the height of the pandemic when we saw strong transaction driven tailwinds to partner revenue, subscription upgrades and enterprise plan order adjustment. As I said, our strongest growth is coming from the enterprise segment, which now represents 70% of our total company ARR compared to 52% just before…

Robert Alvarez

Management

Thanks Brent. And thank you everyone for joining us today. During my prepared remarks. I'll walk through details on our Q2 results. In that discussion, I'll also speak to how some of our metrics are derived so that investors could more easily understand the underlying trends in revenue and bookings. In addition, I'll provide details on how current conditions are impacting the business. Efforts we are taking to optimize our spending. And finally I'll provide greater detail on our guidance on back half revenue and profit assumptions. We always strive for transparency when discussing our results and outlook. So we want to take extra steps to provide clarity in this current macroeconomic environment. In Q2, total revenue was $68.2 million up 39% year-over-year. Subscription revenue grew 51% year-over-year to $51.3 million, driven by our mix shift to enterprise accounts. Supported by strong results from our Feedonomics acquisition, we have now posted 10 consecutive quarters of 30% or higher total revenue growth and 15 consecutive quarters of 40% or higher enterprise ARR growth. Partner in Services Revenue or PSR was up 12% year-over-year to $16.9 million. Though platform transaction volumes have largely been in line with the conservative expectations we set at the beginning of the year, we saw slightly lower than expected volumes in GMV in Q2. Overall, we have been encouraged by the durability that we are seeing in transaction volumes thus far in the year, but given the economic climate, we are taking conservative approach to our PSR outlook in the back half of the year. And I'll discuss this in more detail later in the guidance section of my remarks. Revenue in the Americas was up 41% in the quarter while EMEA revenue grew 42% and APAC revenue was up 18%. Our international progress is strong as…

Operator

Operator

[Operator instructions] First question comes from Gabriela Borges, Goldman Sachs. Please go ahead.

Gabriela Borges

Analyst

Good afternoon. Thanks for taking the question. For Brent to start, I'm curious if you're seeing any change in the cadence of free platforming cycles and willingness for customers to invest in technology, putting aside the paw a services business, and really focusing on the subscription solutions business. So two questions in that; one is any change in willingness to invest in the cadence platforming cycles and two, are you seeing any change over the last quarter in the number of RFPs you're being invited to, or your win rates because of the new technology upgrades you've announced in multi hub and multi inventory.

Brent Bellm

Management

Hi Gabriela, the trends we're seeing in Q2 are consistent with the last couple of quarters, meaning a healthy continued demand in mid-market and enterprise for new and replatform decisions. This is in recent quarters of course, down from the first year of the pandemic, when there was a mad rush by companies caught flatfooted or late to adopt, but in terms of replatforming cycles, we continue to see that demand be healthy. For small business, the demand is not what it was anywhere close to the peak of the pandemic, but for mid-market and enterprise it's strong. We are noticing ourselves getting into additional and healthy RFP opportunities as a result of the strong tech analyst ratings we've been getting of late, including Forester for both B2B and B2C from Paradigm for B2B i.e. Merck in Europe for B2C. Those are seemingly getting us into additional incremental consideration cycles and it's too early to say what those win rates will be because the RFPs tend to take some time to work their way through to a decision, but we're optimistic that our win rates could be assisted by this as well. Thanks for the question.

Gabriela Borges

Analyst

That makes sense. Thank you. The follow up is for RA, would love to hear a little bit about the impact that pricing adjustments or upgrades have historically had on your business over the past two to three years. And how do we think about the potential magnitude for downside to the extent you see downgrades in your ability to manage through that?

Brent Bellm

Management

Yeah. Hey Gabriela, a lot of cases some of the upgrades like the upgrades we did in Q1 for pro plans was really just to get the merchants on the right plans. Yeah, there could be some increase in upgrades, but really is to get them the service entitlements and level of service that we feel those merchants need. So they can grow into really large enterprise merchants. I would say in hindsight, over the last two to three years, our upgrades as we move from an SMB platform to enterprise platform in large part has hasn't been material in terms of our overall revenue. It's being basically putting merchants on the right plans. And so going forward, I think our enterprise pricing is pretty well fine-tuned at this point. Our go to market is pretty fine-tuned at this point. Upgrades for us last year, obviously was impacted by the in increased transaction levels with COVID this year now we're moderating that a bit especially in the back half, but hope, hope that answers your question.

Gabriela Borges

Analyst

Appreciate the color.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Our next question will be from Clarke Jeffries, Piper Sandler. Please go ahead.

Clarke Jeffries

Analyst

Hello. Thank you for taking the question. First is maybe you could help us walk through the deal composition the quarter and maybe the occurrence of larger deals. A couple of new metrics this quarter, trying to understand what drove that big sequential growth in subscription ARR and what seems like maybe one of the lighter quarters in terms of raw net ads on the enterprise account number.

Brent Bellm

Management

Yeah, I'll start Brent, but Q2 represented a great quarter in terms our ability to win large deals on both big commerce and Feedonomics both sides closed deals north of a $1 million of ACV, which is super encouraging 12 months into the Feedonomics from the Feedonomics acquisition, I'll tell you, we just couldn't be more impressed by the team and the product, the use cases of Feedonomics back 12 months ago, versus what we're seeing today are greatly different. I think Feedonomics with BigCommerce we're able together to expand the total addressable market opportunities. When we think about just Q2, some of the notable wins for Q2 and in Feedonomics was new enterprise merchants, leveraging them for marketplace channel management, including listings on Amazon, Walmart, Target Plus, we had a very large win with a leading same-day delivery fulfillment partner in the US and in Latin America, them syncing real time local product information for millions of products. Also a large win with a global affiliate and advertising platform, transforming data at scale for millions of products. So I share that with you because I want to give everybody a sense that these use cases go well beyond just commerce. I think what we've learned with Feedonomics plus BigCommerce, there's a lot of opportunities in terms of aggregation, syndication, data transformation at scale for merchants, but also for our agencies, our channel partners, our technology -- and technology companies. So when you look at that sequential increase, a third of that increase was Feedonomics subscription and two thirds of that was BigCommerce. So both sides had a really great quarter and two several really large deals.

Clarke Jeffries

Analyst

Excellent, helpful color. Sounds like Feedonomics is really executing. Second follow-up is just tightening the range on the profitability guidance, but roughly holding the midpoint. Sounds like there was some commentary about a flowing of hiring $6 million to $8 million. I'm just wondering if there were any investments that are actually going up and offsetting the slowing and hiring to get to you to sort of keep that in line of operating income guidance.

Brent Bellm

Management

No, thankfully I think we, we really got ahead of it, Clark. I mean, we went into the year knowing that it was an investment year for big commerce. We feel great about our execution in terms of staffing up our key strategic initiatives, but we also went in the year knowing that next year we needed to show leverage, because we've always had a goal to get to break even by mid 2024. So I feel great about how we staffed up. We executed really well when we look at the five strategic initiatives that we covered at our analyst day. I think we've we we've executed extremely well across all five. And so if I take a step back and think about our progress, as Brent mentioned we believe we are the most modern e-commerce platform in the market today in our goal is that we want to be a clear leader in the enterprise category over the five years over the next five years. And these are these investments that we're making are how we're going to get there. So, make no mistake we're investing for the future, but with the changing macro environment, we're also taking a hard look at the entire business. We're making sure that our spend is focused on the highest ROI areas. And then we're also looking at optimizing our cost structures to make sure that our unit economics improve over time. And our profitability also improves, but we went into the year knowing that we were going to drive leverage, starting to drive leverage in the back half. So I feel pretty, really, really good on our ability to kind of get ahead of it. And we don't feel like we got ahead of our skis, so really proud of the team.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Next question from Terry Tillman of Truist. Please go ahead.

UnidentifiedAnalyst

Analyst

Hey guys, this is actually Connor [ph] on for Terry. Thanks for taking my question. First one for me just on international expansion. So congrats on growing your presence in Europe to Nordic [ph] I know international expansion is one of your key investment areas this year. Could you maybe just remind us what you look for in terms of ROI entering new geography and have these regions been mostly consistent with the US in terms of enterprise merchant demands? Or is there maybe a little bit more slow down there? Yeah, go ahead. Brent,

Brent Bellm

Management

Why don't you take the ROI part of it RA and I'll answer the second part.

Robert Alvarez

Management

Yeah. Connor, we covered this on the analyst day, but you know, we're basically we know that we're going to invest in the first year. We look for a, a payback anywhere from 18 to 24 months. Sometimes when we make heavy heavy investments, it could be up to 30, but on average, you know, we're kind of make, want to make sure that these expansion costs, we get paid back in kind of 18-24 months and the markets that we enter into we, we test and learn a lot before we make these investments. We know they're strong product market fit. We've identified agency partners, tech partners, to make sure that our product can be ready in those markets. And so much like the markets that we've seen such great success in, we try to replicate that model. And I could say that that holds true for the markets that we entered into in Q2.

Brent Bellm

Management

Yeah. And in terms of performance in market to market, none of them should be benchmarked against native English speaking countries like the us, which by the way, was our second market, not our first Australia was our first way back when or the UK. I mean the UK just was a rocket ship, but even when we formally entered the UK, we already had more than 3000 stores there. We just didn't have a marketing website or employees. It's very new to enter foreign language countries, Italy, France, Spain, Germany. What we're seeing Netherlands, what we're seeing in general is that our markets are in line with our, sort of first year, second year performance, but there's variability from country to country that can have a lot to do with the early traction or lack thereof that we get with local agency partners and just how strong they are and how heavy they go in with us. An example of a market that's off to spectacular success is Italy. And if every new launch country where like Italy, then we'd be way ahead of all of our targets. But in general, we're on track and that's true in Europe. It's on, it's true in Mexico as well. Thanks for the question.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Next question comes from Daniel Reagan, Canaccord Genuity. Please go ahead.

Daniel Reagan

Analyst

…forecast for the business, just given the macro backdrop, which verticals or cohort types were you seeing the most risk in, and then also as volumes come under pressure, how should we be seeing about risk of downgrades? Any color there would be great.

Brent Bellm

Management

I got most of the question. I don't think, I got the beginning, but, I think I got the gist of it. So, what we've seen in our aggregate GMV volume, in the first 18 months to 24 months of COVID, we saw a sizeable step up in our aggregate GMB. We have not seen a deterioration of that. We've seen growth rates that have come down a little bit. But in terms of aggregate GV volume, pretty much across every major category we've seen growth and we continue to see growth. There's some categories growing faster than others, but overall they're all growing off of a much larger base than they were, you know, 12 or 18 months ago. When we think about the back half, we AC, obviously have to factor in GMV assumptions for same store sales. We also have to factor in the launch of new accounts and I'm really excited about the back half because we're actually launching one of our largest accounts ever in, in hi in our history. And it's going to once fully launched, it'll be north of a billion dollars on our platform. So when we think about and look at the GMV by category, we're seeing growth across most categories. We're also factoring in the launch of new accounts with much higher GMV. And just like in Q2, as we sign larger and larger merchants, we're going to be able to add that GMV on top of the aggregate GMV. That's been stepped up over the last, 12 to 24 months. So as I think about the back half of the year, you know, we're looking at same store sales assumptions discounting that slightly, and then adding the impact of, you know, large accounts that you know, we're really excited to launch.

Daniel Reagan

Analyst

Got you. Super helpful.

Robert Alvarez

Management

1 thing I'll also add there as our mix is now 70% enterprise these are businesses, often national brands. These are companies with a wide product catalog that have kind of the durability, I think that will allow, their GMV to continue to increase on big commerce. So as that mix continues to shift even further and further to enterprise as, and then you add on top of that large enterprise, accounts that are a million dollar in ACV and accounts that have a $1 billion running through the platform. That's definitely going to help us, I think navigate any fluctuations in same store sales or near term economic uncertainty.

Daniel Reagan

Analyst

Got you. Super helpful. And just as a follow up and circling back to the replatform cycle, as we think about the Magento displacement opportunity with sun-setting of M1, can you just talk a little bit about how your approach acquiring these customers has evolved now that you have probably a little bit better way of the land? And then secondly, what levers can you pull to accelerate? Any agency efforts here? Thank you.

Brent Bellm

Management

Yeah, with time, we keep trying to get better both at the core demand generation tactics that we're already good at, which I will highlight as well as add new tricks that have higher ROI. So the things that we already are well experienced at digital marketing outbound and inbound sales development rep sort of lead cultivation account targeting, and especially one of the things I think we're best in the industry at is working with our agency partners. We're very good at co-selling with agencies building joint value proposition with agencies, but one of the big opportunities we have is to expand our agency network, both within established markets and new markets. And particularly at the high end, if you go to the very high end of large enterprise, you know, historically we were competing in mid-market in the lower end of large enterprise and the types of agencies that were doing the multi-million dollar installs and implementations, weren't working with us, they were working with in years past the Oracle ATGs and IBM WebSphere of the world, even though those aren't sold anymore or at Magento enterprise, maybe Salesforce SAP, and now that many of the tech analysts are actually rating us ahead of those platforms. And far ahead of our more SMB centric platforms, we're entering the consideration set. And in fact, the priority set of, of many of these top agencies. And so we're trying to compete for the full spectrum of opportunities. And some of these sales can be very big and needle moving for us if and when we win them, there are also a bunch of other technology partner tricks and you know, working with our existing merchant base to expand our opportunity, set that our new tricks for us, we're trying to work on. And you know, and finally we want to increase our presence at events eCommerce events, industry events. We want the word to get out that we are the world's most modern enterprise eCommerce platform and be in the consideration set for every relevant decision that big companies and small companies are making

Robert Alvarez

Management

The only that's great. Brent, the only thing I would add to that point is we launched an omnichannel certified agency partner program. That's getting a lot of great interest in traction and essentially that allows our agency partners to help merchants on their omnichannel initiatives regardless of what platform they're using. So regardless if they're on Magento or anything on other platform they're able to work with, Feedonomics it's a great example of how big commerce and Feedonomics are working together. They call Feedonomics leveraging our ecosystem of amazing partners, our partners, being able to leverage their technology to transform millions of skews of data and syndicate that to a lot of feeds at a scale that they just couldn't do on their existing platform. So I think feed Andos and our omnichannel initiatives in this partner program could be a really good way to incentivize merchants to start working with Feedonomics and then, hopefully migrate over to big commerce sooner rather than later.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. The next question will be from Josh Beck with KeyBanc. Please go ahead.

UnidentifiedAnalyst

Analyst

Hey guys, this is Mattie on for Josh. Thanks for taking my question. My first question for you is what are going to be the key factors bridging what today's 15% to 20% organic growth outlook is here to your long term model expectations. Thanks.

Brent Bellm

Management

Yeah, so I'm happy to take that. I I'll just point to enterprise. So even with Feedonomics in our base period in Q3 we still feel like we could grow our enterprise ARR potentially over 40%. Enterprise and Feedonomics, as we've mentioned before, we expect both segments to grow at a pretty high clip at a very comparable clip. Knowing we've got some lapping effects this year it still gives us a ton of confidence that with the large mix of our revenue tied to subscription that large mix tied to enterprise the deals that we're winning today and that we have great pipeline to win in the second half we still stand pretty confident that, over the next five years, this is a business that, will deliver a 25% to 30% CAGR.

UnidentifiedAnalyst

Analyst

Awesome. And for my follow up, I'm curious if you guys could give an update on how B2B Ninja and B2B Bundle acquisitions are tracking and then just overall B2B momentum. Thanks.

Brent Bellm

Management

Yeah, they're tracking consistent with their trend line pre acquisition, which is a very healthy trend line. And we shared some of those B2B growth rates in our analyst day in Q1. I should say in in May, the most important thing to note is with bundle B2B. There's a fair amount of work that we do to now bring that product native into the platform and improve the architecting and the compatibility of it with all themes with multi-store front additional geographies. So there's refactoring of the product that they have to make it more usable with the best capabilities, both and both functionality and openness at big commerce. And we are fixated on that in the short term, continuing to sell it very successfully. And then, maybe after a year after acquisition, we'll start turning our attention to the addition of additional functionality in this. We're just very pleased though, with where we are at B2B in general. For paradigm that it's mid-market and B2B combines to recognize us as an award winner in 22, out of 24 categories, that shows that the product is quite well rounded and mature as it is, and it's only going to get better.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Next question will be from Koji Ikeda of Bank of America. Please go ahead.

Koji Ikeda

Analyst

Yeah. Hey. Hey, thanks guys. Thanks for taking the questions. Just a couple from me. I wanted to ask the first question on the guidance and RA appreciate all of the color on the call regarding the guidance and the way to think about it. I guess my question is really about PSR regs, really thinking about how we should be thinking about this segment's growth in the second half. I clearly understand the factors that were driving the guidance there, but real short question is, could PSR revenue growth be flat or even down in the second half?

Robert Alvarez

Management

No, we don't think so. Koji. When I think about the second half you know, we do start with our same store sales assumptions. And then we add on the impact of, you know, the large accounts that we launch and the impact to PSR. We do expect that impact in the kind of part of Q3, most of Q4. So Q4, I suspect PSR kind of in the mid to high teens based on that remember we also have a mix of non GMV related revenue items in PSR. But when I think about Q4, I can see that kind of in the mid to high chains. When I think about Q3, we do have to lap a deal, couple of partnership deals that we signed Q2 of last year that could put Q3 in the single digits, but overall for the back half. No, I don't, I don't see that being negative. If anything, I see it slightly down in Q3 just for the lapping effect of those deals from last year and then outpacing based on the large merchant launches in Q4.

Koji Ikeda

Analyst

Okay. Got it. Thanks RA. And then just, one follow up there. So thinking about the subscription side of that, that equation, the little bit of a slower growth rate there just that's the subscription component for potential downgrades, affected by the GMB with the commentary that you said earlier in the call, is that the right way, right way to kind of think about the growth algorithm here.

Brent Bellm

Management

You got it. Yeah because the GMB assumptions affect PSR obviously, but definitely touches on assumptions around upgrades, downgrades and potential churn. The good news is, you know, with our large mix of enterprise, our retention metrics still look really good. But again, when you're kind of scenario planning and what if planning around that it does touch on churn a little bit, but since our mix is so heavily weighted to large enterprise merchants, we feel pretty good about that, but it does affect upgrades and downgrades.

Koji Ikeda

Analyst

Got it. Thanks guys. Thanks for taking the questions.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Our next question will be from Parker Lane with Stifel. Please go ahead.

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst

Hey, it's Max on for Parker, just staying right there on the potential churn, thinking about this strong enterprise traction and kind of the way you're shifting away from some S and B free trials and stuff. What do you think the churn will be for those smaller customers or is, is it just a matter of new small customers not coming on? And is there an idea of what you think the overall percentage of enterprise should be in the long run?

Brent Bellm

Management

Yeah, it wasn't so long ago that we were saying that enterprise could be 70% and we're here already. I think in our analyst day I mentioned that I think there is a clear path to 80 potentially 90% of our revenue could be enterprise on the small business side. I don't want anyone to think that we're not still winning small business merchants or not seeing revenue from small business merchants, that promotion what we found when we dug into it was, a lot of signups, but really low conversion after the promo period. So in terms of effective kind of P&L management, didn't make a lot of sense to have that hanging out there where you have gross new signups that don't convert to revenue. What we're seeing now is we're getting signups and they're converting and they're paying and the revenue from the signups that we're getting now for small businesses are, is actually much greater than the revenue we were getting when the promos were in place. So I think with the promos we attracted probably small businesses that, you know weren't real businesses or weren't serious about e-commerce what we're seeing now is small businesses that, you know, are serious, have real businesses and you know, are growing on our platform. So I think overall I would characterize it as a win in terms of attracting small business merchants that, you know, do drive revenue. And we expect that that two to one LTB to C will get better. Now that we're doing a better job of identifying those merchants, signing up those merchants and not spending too much money on acquiring merchants that won't convert.

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst

Got it. That makes a lot of sense. And then thinking back to the strength you mentioned in Feedonomics and how well it's performing, are you still intending on investing around $5 million to $6 million that you mentioned during the analyst day, or is that potentially going to be lower as you look to cut some costs or is it potentially going to be higher given the success?

Brent Bellm

Management

It wouldn't be higher. Feedonomics is now part of our omnichannel strategy. I mean, they just came off a quarter where they signed the three largest deals in their history. So that no reason for us not to continue to invest in Feedonomics and in our omnichannel initiatives, omnichannel in a lot of ways, if you think about a potential tightening spending environment we believe BigCommerce provides an excellent ROI total cost of ownership advantage for merchants around eCommerce. We also believe Feedonomics is super attractive for merchants who want to increase in their return on ad spend increase in conversion. And so both of our Feedonomics business and big commerce business, I think that there is some really, really strong advantages to what we offer for merchants. If they're taking a hard look at mission critical investments that they need to make,

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst

I appreciate the color. Thanks.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Our next question will be from Samad Samana of Jefferies. Please go ahead.

Samad Samana

Analyst

Hi. Great. Thanks for squeezing me. Hi, RA. Hi, Brent. Maybe just first question just with your existing larger merchants, you know, they're usually planning for multiple years, even if things are maybe a little bit slower in the, in the short term So I guess, Brent, I'm curious when you think about multi-store, are you seeing customers still adopted and at least still launching new stores with the eye that is a transitory change in behavior, and that e-commerce is still going gain share over time, or just, how are you seeing the behavior of existing customers, even as they're thinking beyond let's call it the next couple of quarters and as they're -- as they're building their business for long term?

Brent Bellm

Management

After the pandemic, every business views online and eCommerce as strategically essential to their future, what's so powerful about multi-store is it lets businesses add brands and or customer segments like B2B and or geographies in a far easier and more seamless way than they ever could before because they can do it all within one account and leveraging a common set of tools and backend integrations. When we first went into general availability at the end of Q1, it was available only to new stores and therefore our existing customers were sort of salivating for when it would be ready for them. And then last quarter we launched it now for existing enterprise stores and we're seeing very healthy demand for this among them. It's too early to say, like at what point, what percentage of our customers will have multiple stores using multi-store front? You could, many of them already had multiple stores that were redundant or, or sort of independent accounts, but now having single account multiple storefronts, we don't know what long term maturity will be in terms of penetration and number per, but I think it will be quite large because most of our mid-market enterprise customers are big. They are complex, they do have multiple brands, geographies and or segments to sell into. And, and so we think we're early days of a long term adoption trend there.

Samad Samana

Analyst

Great, appreciate that. Thank you.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. The next question comes from Emil [ph] of Barclays. Please go ahead.

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst

Hey thanks. Well for me to, for squeezing me and more bigger picture question if you think about the things going on in the industry and we just saw the big news at Shopify. How do you think it from an industry perspective now? Are we still on the kind of the hangover to some degree from the pandemic and the big boom in eCommerce and we kind of everyone kind of scaled up too quickly and now kind of suffering from that or are we kind of be way beyond that and this is now more getting ready for what's going to happen to the economy? Like, could you just kind of see how you frame it in your mind?

Brent Bellm

Management

Thank you. Yeah. And, I've received this question probably more than any other question over the last couple of years and my answer's pretty consistent. If you look at the data and just take the us the best official slash public data source is the us census, which comes out with its quarterly eCommerce estimates for B2C in 2020, the year of the pandemic B2C grew 32% in the us if trendline growth rate had been 13% to 15%. All right. Let's just say that average is 14%. Well, 32% isn't even one and a half years of accelerated growth. Then when you got to 2221, so, alright, you've accelerated by about a year and a half in terms of eCommerce adoption and the height of the pandemic. Q1 continued to have growth rates north of 40% because they were overlapping some months pre pandemic. But then by the end of the year, you dropped down to 10% growth rates in the last couple of quarters of last year and the year average 14%, which was smack dab, normal pre pandemic. So you're already back to pre-pandemic levels. You've only booked about a year and a half worth of acceleration. And you're now growing at a rate lower than you were pre pandemic as you lapse the highs, Q1 was 6.6%. Q2 is not yet reported. My point is that the net of all of this is that B2C has accelerated by about a year through these two plus years of pandemic. It's our expectation by the end of this year, that the laughing of the peaks from a year ago and the return to store will be done, will hopefully be back to normal growth rates in that, you know, call it 12 to 15% range at the end…

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst

Okay. Yeah, it makes total sense. Thank you. And then Robert, like one quick, last question for me, like, as we go into macro downturn and like, obviously you talked about like some of the enterprise contracts that might not hit the volumes, et cetera. Can you and, and hence then kind of get, get stepped down, et cetera. Can you remind us, like how tightly are these contracts negotiated? Was there a lot of buffer in there or are they kind of close to where they are, they kind of relatively realistically negotiated in? He there's a, you know, there's quite a few step downs. Like how should we think about that?

Brent Bellm

Management

Thank you. Yeah. I would characterize it as we try to build in kind of a good estimate as we negotiate them in the of what they expect, what we expect in the first 12 months in terms of number of orders. Remember our enterprise contracts are based, are order based. Now if they're, if volumes are elevated, they could get there faster. And again, we're using kind of a trailing 12 month view to kind of moderate or, or, or temper down any kind swings in the near term. In terms of like the next tier of orders, it's really based off the first tier that we negotiate. So some of our contracts are, low average order value high, average order value. So you really have to do it. It's merchant specific, and it's really working with the merchants in terms of what they're expecting to sell and what their history of sales have been.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Next question will be from Matt Pfau of William Blair. Please go ahead.

Matt Pfau

Analyst

Thanks Brent for fitting me in guys appreciate it. Wanted to just follow up RA and your comments around competition. Was there any changes in competition that drove those comments and then if there are any changes, are they specific to any of your segments? Thanks.

Robert Alvarez

Management

Yeah, I don't think the usual suspects are still the same. I think what we're finding with the omnichannel, you know, partner program that we've launched is we're finding ways to allow merchants and our partners to leverage our omnichannel capabilities, that's platform agnostic. So you don't even have to be on big commerce to take advantage of that. And I think it's for us, what we're seeing is there's a high demand. If you're a, if you're on an old legacy e-commerce platform if you're on a platform that doesn't have the capabilities to optimize feeds and drive great transaction flow through all the different channels you're very frustrated because you need to grow your business and you want to look for ways to do that. And Feedonomics is I think a clear leader in their ability to help merchants with that. And so our ability to work with them, our ability to open up our ecosystem, have our partners sell Feedonomics into their base of merchants is I think for us just a really pleasant surprise. It's not something that we thought we would have an opportunity to do 12 months ago, but we have a strong opportunity to do that today.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Next question will come from Keith Weiss - Morgan Stanley. Please go ahead.

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst

Hi, this is actually Ryan [ph] for Keith Weiss. Thanks for taking my question. Maybe just first you've talked before about that cross-selling feed doo's into your install base provides an average lift of 20 to 40%. And then at the time of the acquisition you had maybe 1000 customers overlapping how has this trended since and where could this go over time now? You've got a better view in the business.

Brent Bellm

Management

Yeah, we still feel really good about those stats. I would say that the teams have really leaned in are, couldn't be more proud of our big commerce team leaning in with Feedonomics I'll tell you, you know, 12 months after the acquisition, it's pretty rare that the teams are intact, are excited, are motivated. The culture at Feedonomics is real, super strong. The excitement within big commerce to self EDOs is incredibly high and merchants, our enterprise merchants are, are, are really interested. So we're seeing good pipeline, we're seeing good adoption but we had to build the cross sell motions. So operationally, we had to get that motion in place, the system in place. And, once we did that, I feel like we're seeing some, really good demand signals to stand behind those stats that you mentioned.

Robert Alvarez

Management

I'd add to that. I'd add that the other big opportunity is when we release selfer versions of Feedonomics, which are targeted at small and mid-market merchants, but frankly, even a larger merchant could start taking advantage of a subset of Feedonomics capabilities at reasonable initial cost. Once we have that version out. So when we have self-serve for Feedonomics. we'll target a few initial channels to be announced, probably advertising channels that are most popular and most widely used, and that could drive the count of adoption up very substantially once it's released.

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst

Oh, thank you. And maybe on that kind of same line of thought, have you kind of evaluated what the average uplift is for cross selling multi-store front omnichannel B2B in those other areas you talked about that could drive growth of 10% of revenue over time?

Brent Bellm

Management

I don't think we have a number off the top of our heads to share or even if we've thought about it exactly that way but…

Robert Alvarez

Management

No, nothing, no, no specifics to share there on that front. What we are seeing is continued strong pipeline in B2B. We often see merchants that come to big commerce for B2B and they realize how strong our B2C offering is, and they can run everything on one platform. So, we still see a large number of opportunities that, that fit that use case. I thought we've talked a lot about omnichannel headless typically is a new deal, new sale, new opportunity when we respond to RFPs or when merchants really want a headless solution. But I'd say overall across kind of all those initiatives, we're, we're really seeing, you know, strong demand and signals that, that give us a confidence that those are areas we'll, we'll need to continue to invest in.

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst

Thank you. Helpful. Appreciate your time.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Next question will be coming from Brian Peterson, Raymond James. Please go ahead.

Brian Peterson

Analyst

Hi, thanks for taking the question. This is John on for Brian. Just a follow up on the international expansion question asked earlier, given you've officially expanded into call it 11 plus nations over the last year, as we think about 2023 and beyond. How should we think about the pace of international expansion and the investments there? And then just as a quick follow up, maybe clarify a bit of the comments from earlier on longer sales cycles thus far, are you seeing any length fitting in sales cycles? And if so, are they tied to any specific geos? Thank you.

Brent Bellm

Management

In 2023, I think the balance of our emphasis and investment will be growth in the markets that we have already expanded into building out personnel potentially in language customer support in, in select countries and building our marketing and sales effectiveness in those countries. We have a weight model that we call test and learn, which can involve putting up a marketing website that doesn't involve the same investment in actual people and infrastructure in market. And I think we will ramp more of that up relative to big full country launches in 2023. So the rate of announcing countries will determine as we finalize our plan, but I'm looking at geographies like Asia and Africa, where we don't have many flags planted and still see a lot of long term opportunity there. All right. You want to take the second question?

Robert Alvarez

Management

Yeah. In terms of our sales cycles, we look at it with our mid-market team and our enterprise team. We're not seeing a lengthening of cycles. Some of the deals that we are now working on are just much larger deals. So the nature of those deals likely take a little longer, but when we kind of take a step back and think about alright, if we are going to have to face that headwind, could there be a little bit longer sales cycles potentially. But, if that happens, if those sales cycles lengthen for those reasons, then there's also reasons where our TCO advantage is really going to shine. So I think what we're hearing and what we're seeing from our agency partners and the merchants that we're working with that, that TCO advantage is, is really, really powerful in a tight spinning environment. Like I know at BigCommerce, we're looking at our, our spend on software and the mission critical software. And if you can provide me software that is 30, 50% cheaper and is better and more flexible and more modern than, you got my attention. So I think who knows what, how it's going to play out, but I think any lengthening of sales cycles could be balanced out with, maybe even higher pipeline.

Brian Peterson

Analyst

Perfect. Thank you very much.

Operator

Operator

The next question will be from Ken Wong of Oppenheimer. Please go ahead.

UnidentifiedAnalyst

Analyst

Hi, this is Nancy [ph] on for Ken. Thanks for squeezing me in here at the end. Just one quick test question from me. You highlighted it Analyst Day that had list sales through 34% last year and accounted for about 9% of new sales MRR in the year. Can you give us a little color on how headless is trending in 2022 and our new sales for headless still growing around three times faster than other use cases?

Robert Alvarez

Management

That was a one-time disclosure. I'm not sure we'll update it on a quarterly basis, but I can absolutely confirm that headless demand stays very strong at BigCommerce and it's at all sizes. It's both at the low end of the market. Maybe customers are creating a front end on WordPress to the high end of the market where they're using leading CMSs like content stack content, full bloom reach, or sort of custom frameworks in react. And next. It's really fantastic. The user experiences that businesses are creating. And it's our belief that this approach to composable or headless is viewed as sort of the leading edge and the most modern approach for companies that are capable of pulling it off. And certainly the tech analysts are saying the same thing. So, demand is strong and I'll leave it to RA when we next provide formal data updates on that. Thanks for the question.

Operator

Operator

That concludes our question-and-answer session. I would now like to turn to call back over to Mr. Brent Bellm, President, CEO and Chairman for closing remarks.

Brent Bellm

Management

Great, thanks everybody who listened in. I want to conclude with three quick takeaways worth emphasizing. The first is Q2 again was our largest and best ever quarter of subscription ARR growth and we did that in a market environment that's not the most favorable. I think that's a great indication of just how strong our core business momentum is. We also now have posted two quarters where we're so far this year where we've beat on the top line and bottom line guidance while holding firm to our full year guidance to the street. This is in a context where many other eCommerce players have disappointed or seen their own trend lines fall behind. And so we're really confidence in the underlying strength of our business and the things we have done to adapt to it, to stay true to our full year guidance because we certainly see headwinds in parts of our P&L as we outlined in the prepared remarks. And then the third thing is we're really excited about the increasing recognition we're getting from tech analysts and experts that BigCommerce is today, the world's most modern enterprise eCommerce platform. We're hoping that increasingly leads to ever more consideration and adoption in the quarters ahead. So thanks again everybody for joining in. we thought it was a good quarter and we look forward to talking to you again in three months.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. The conference has now concluded. Thank you for attending today's presentation. You may now disconnect.