John W. Conway
Analyst · Robert W
Yes, George, just a couple of things. And I know Tom and Tim will want to chime in. First of all, we don't have too much capacity in Europe, so we don't view further restructurings in the form of reducing factories and taking capacity out as appropriate. So that's that. We do think, though, of course, we can take more cost out from all of our European businesses, and that's really what the most recent restructuring is aimed at, and we'll be doing more things of that type. But we don't see any further major restructurings of our food business in Europe. There are always going to be little things here and there. When we think of the footprint, where we are, what we've done in the food can plants, we're in really good shape. We're a low-cost producer, in the context of Europe. We're going to get lower cost. As to your question about beverage, and Tim to Tom can talk about this more, but I was reflecting on it this morning, frankly, after I read your comments: We could have had the same conversation on a regional basis 15, 16 years ago in the Middle East when we were adding capacity. Initially, return on invested capital in Middle East declined. We were building new plants, or organic growth. As you fill up a beverage can plant, and I know you know the industry almost as well as I, perhaps better than I do, it takes you about 2 to 3 years to be running as well in your new plants as you are in your mature plants. Then as you add additional lines in the new plants, at times, you'll have a downturn in productivity, and then you come back up to over -- your absorbing overhead extremely well and throwing off a tremendous amount of cash. So we could have had the same conversation about your concerns about when is return on invested capital will get better in the Middle East. It's one of the best regions we have. We could have then moved on and we could have had the same conversation, and maybe we did, you and I have been talking to each other for a long time, same conversation about Brazil. We started out in Brazil somewhat early with a fairly large plant in the state of São Paulo. First couple of years were a little bit tough. It took us awhile to fill it up, took us a little while to run better. We now have 3 big plants in Brazil. We are the lowest-cost producer in Brazil. We're gaining share in Brazil. And I think we're the leading -- the industry leader from in terms of profitability and return on invested capital in Brazil. Now when we put the new plant into production, Teresina, there's going to be probably a little bit of a downturn year-on-year in ROIC, then will come back up as we fill the plant up. Now we can move over to China and Southeast Asia, I -- we could have this conversation every single time. So it's all about your conviction as to whether or not you've picked the right growth markets, that -- and do you still think that the rate of growth is strong and do you still think supply-demand's in relatively good balance. We do. So make that [ph] strong, strong belief in the strategy. But I agree, I agree, we can do an alternative strategy, George: Stop all capital investment, buy back stock. You could say that our return on invested capital is going up, and I could tell you that, in about 5 years, you'd be extremely unhappy with what was left. But maybe Tim could add to that.