Earnings Labs

Black Hills Corporation (BKH)

Q4 2022 Earnings Call· Wed, Feb 8, 2023

$75.03

-0.25%

Key Takeaways · AI generated
AI summary not yet generated for this transcript. Generation in progress for older transcripts; check back soon, or browse the full transcript below.

Same-Day

-1.63%

1 Week

-1.83%

1 Month

-5.06%

vs S&P

-1.52%

Transcript

Operator

Operator

Good day and thank you for standing by. Welcome to the Fourth Quarter 2022 Black Hills Corporation's Earnings Conference Call. [Operator Instructions] Please be advised that today's conference is being recorded. I would now like to hand the conference over to your speaker today, Jerome Nichols, Director of Investor Relations.

Jerome Nichols

Analyst

Thank you. Good morning, everyone. Welcome to Black Hills Corporation's fourth quarter and full year 2022 earnings conference call. You can find our earnings release and materials for our call this morning at our website at www.blackhillscorp.com under the Investor Relations heading. Leading our quarterly earnings discussion today are Linn Evans, President and Chief Executive Officer; Rich Kinzley, Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer; and Kimberly Nooney, Vice President and Treasurer. During our earnings discussion today, some of the comments we make may contain forward-looking statements as defined by the Securities and Exchange Commission, and there are a number of uncertainties inherent in such comments. Although we believe that our expectations and beliefs are based on reasonable assumptions, actual results may differ materially. We direct you to our earnings release, Slide 2 of the investor presentation on our website and our most recent Form 10-K and Form 10-Q filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission for a list of some of the factors that could cause future results to differ materially from our expectations. I will now turn the call over to Linn Evans.

Linn Evans

Analyst

Thank you, Jerome. Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us. As we announced last quarter, Rich will be retiring mid-year, so he gets one final opportunity this morning to provide the year-end financial review. Kimberly, as our incoming CFO, will provide the financial outlook for 2023 and beyond. I'll start on Slide 4, with some key takeaways. While we successfully offset the impacts of the rapid macroeconomic shift through most of 2022, the increase carrying costs driven by natural gas prices and current interest rates are weighing on our expectations for 2023 and into 2024. I'll dive into those details shortly, but before I do that, I want to recognize our team's strong execution on what was within our control in 2022. Once again, our team delivered exceptional operational results, and we delivered earnings within our guidance range. This was no small feat considering the challenging macroeconomic and business conditions that impacted fourth quarter financial performance. I'm very proud of what our team accomplished as we executed our regulatory strategy and advance our strategic initiatives for system-wide resiliency, growth and a successful energy future. We also made strides towards strengthening our balance sheet, which remains a key focus for us in 2023. To our Black Hills team listening today, thank you for your dedication to excellence in serving our customers. I'm very proud of what we achieved together in 2022, with more wins than we can adequately cover on this call. To that point, Slide 5, highlights the excellent operational performance of our team in our electric and natural gas assets. I'm particularly pleased with the continued industry-leading electric reliability we provide our customers. All three of our electric utilities maintain top quartile for reliability for the fourth consecutive year, by the latest EEI Survey for safety, reliability.…

Rich Kinzley

Analyst

Thanks, Linn, and good morning, everyone. Since this is my last earnings update, I want to thank all the investors and analysts I've had the privilege to work with over the last eight years as CFO. It's been an honor to represent the Black Hills Corporation team. And I've appreciated the conversations and friendships developed over the many years. As I transition to retirement, I want to assure you that you're in good hands with Kimberly. I'll start my comments on Slide 11, where we've laid out earnings per share for the full year and by quarter for 2022 compared to 2021. We delivered EPS for the full year of $3.97 compared to $3.74 last year, a 6% increase and then $1.11 for the quarter, consistent with Q4 2021. Slide 12 and 13 illustrate the detailed drivers of change in net income year-over-year for the fourth quarter and full year. All amounts listed on these slides are after tax. I'll focus on the full year on Slide 13. Higher margin was driven by $32 million from new rates and investment riders, $3.8 million of increased margin from customer growth and higher usage per customer, especially at our electric utilities, and $5.9 million of wholesale energy sales. Results for the year benefited from warm summer weather and higher than normal heating degree days in early Q1 and late Q4. Compared to normal weather benefited earnings by $0.05 per share for the fourth quarter and $0.19 per share for the full year. Compared to 2021, and a record-breaking warm weather in Q4 2021, weather benefited earnings by $0.21 per share for the fourth quarter and $0.26 for the full year. O&M expenses increased 9% year-over-year, driven generally by the inflationary environment. O&M increased due to higher fuel and materials costs, and higher expenses for outside services, bad debt, labor, cloud computing and property taxes. DD&A increased due to our capital investment program. Interest expense increased due to higher short-term debt balances, which were driven by volatile natural gas prices and increased short-term rates. Additional details on quarter-over-quarter and year-over-year changes in margin and operating expenses are available in yesterday's earnings release and in our 10-K to be filed early next week. Slide 14 reflects our long-term track record. These charts show our strong rate base and earnings growth, with EPS growth being tempered by equity issuances to strengthen our balance sheet after the 2016 SourceGas acquisition. I'll now turn the call over to Kimberly for our financial outlook.

Kimberly Nooney

Analyst

Thank you, Rich. Before I dive into the details, I would like to revisit what Linn said earlier. During the last three years, we've managed through some extraordinary times, including COVID, Winter Storm Uri and more recently decades high inflation, aggressive monetary policy and geopolitical turmoil, resulting in higher interest rates and volatile energy markets. The charts on Slide 16 reflect the macroeconomic environment we operate in today. Specifically, we experienced volatile and higher natural gas spot prices and basis differentials in our service territories at the end of the year. This contributed to a significant increase in working capital needs, which we fund through our commercial paper program. We had approximately $200 million more short-term debt at year-end 2022 than we had anticipate only a couple of months earlier. Our higher short-term debt balance coupled with higher short-term borrowing rates increased our interest expense in the fourth quarter. As we recover deferred gas costs and pay down these balances, we expect elevated interest expense in the near-term. Slide 17 presents the revised outlook for our 2023 earnings guidance range of $3.65 to $3.85 per share. This bridge identifies the major drivers leading to our revised guidance. Moving from left to right on this slide, we expect increased margins on new investments and ongoing customer growth, which offset non-recurring 2022 margin benefits. Although, inflation continues to impact expenses, we expect to manage O&M to a level below 2022. Additionally, as a predominantly pure play utility, higher deferred gas costs are magnifying regulatory lag within our gas cost recovery mechanism. This combined with higher short-term interest rates has resulted in rapidly increase in interest expense. We expect recovery of these deferred costs over the next 12 months to 18 months, which are impacting our financing activities this year. We now expect…

Linn Evans

Analyst

Thank you, Kimberly. Once again, I'm very pleased with what our team accomplished in 2022, including safe and reliable service for our customers, solid financial results, regulatory execution and advancing resiliency and supporting our customers' growth. We successfully adapted to overcome a variety of challenges while maintaining our long-term focus and financial discipline and we will continue to do so as we migrate through a dynamic financial landscape and leverage the long-term opportunities in front of us. With that, we'll take your questions.

Operator

Operator

[Operator Instructions] Our first question comes from Julien Dumoulin-Smith with Bank of America. You may proceed.

Julien Dumoulin-Smith

Analyst

Hi, good morning, team, thanks for the time. And congratulations again, Rich.

Linn Evans

Analyst

Good morning, Julien.

Kimberly Nooney

Analyst

Good morning, Julien.

Julien Dumoulin-Smith

Analyst

Hi, good morning. Thanks, guys. Hi, listen, just wanted to come back to the core update here if we can. Can you talk first maybe about the updated dividend payout ratio. The midpoint of the guidance implies slightly above the top-end of the new payout ratio. Why not change your target to something that aligns with the updated '23, I get that you wanted to move things, why not align at there? And then, secondly, more critical question here. How do you think about your earned returns and the structural nature of the reset lower here from 5% to 7% to 4% to 6%. Considering many the dynamics that you point to, well, obviously, interest rates are more structural, gas prices see more transient, for instance, that you can speak about, you know, how you think about the longer-dated '25, '26 earnings trajectory?

Kimberly Nooney

Analyst

Yes, good morning, Julien. This is Kimberly. So, regarding your dividend payout ratio question, we're really confident in our long-term strategy. As we noted there, we believe that our 52-year growth target is -- growth track record is pretty evident of how we think about our dividend payout ratio. We felt the increase of 55% to 65% given some of the other changes was warranted. And as we talk about and think about the longer-term vision for the company 55% to 65% made sense to us.

Linn Evans

Analyst

Julien, this is Linn. I would go to the latter part of your questions. We feel confident in our business strategy and the growth projects and prospects we have in front of you -- front of us. But what we've got is some of these early headwinds are going to last for a while. You mentioned the gas prices are moderating. That is true at places like Henry Hub, et cetera, but we have price differential with our basis differentials we're watching. We incurred some pretty significant gas price, costs, expenses. In December, especially during Winter Storm Elliot, the El Paso pipeline, for example, not being at full capacity, et cetera, caused some extraordinary prices that we had to absorb in December alone, which of course we did not forecast. Otherwise, things like Winter Storm Elliot will be a good thing for us in terms of gas that we sold, et cetera. But in that particular circumstance, we had to spend a lot more money than we anticipated. And now we have significant debt that we are financing. And then you think about as a predominantly pure play utility, we do have good gas cost adjustments in our states. However, when we have this extraordinary basis differential blow out, if you will, it's going to take us 12 months to 18 months before we really recoup those costs. So again that's debt that we're financing, et cetera. So these headwinds, especially that came up in December for us, are going to linger into the next year or two. And we have just general inflation that we're managing as well as I hope you know and recognize we've done a nice job of controlling O&M. And we were able to absorb general inflation, higher employee cost and things of that nature through programs that we had in place to help us with our expenses. However, after what we experienced in late fourth quarter, that just piles onto the challenge that we have before us. But I want to once again comment, you know, the structure of the business is sound, we've got some great growth opportunities, we have things crystallizing with respect to our Clean Energy Plan in Colorado, our IRP in South Dakota. So we've got some good opportunities ahead of us and are not reflected currently, for example, in our capital program.

Julien Dumoulin-Smith

Analyst

Yes, understood. I mean and maybe this becomes a little bit more of a specific state-level type of question. How do you think about the recovery of those associated costs, right, i.e., the elevated interest costs here, the elevated gas costs incurred as a function of Elliot, and then ultimately, how does that make its way through cost recovery? Understand that inflation is here to stay or at least some of them should be structural. But as you think about maybe moving beyond the near-term '23, '24 and say '25 and '26, how do you think about the specifics of going back in for recovery here, and ultimately being able to get closer to your authorized returns if you will, if these are great lag items?

Linn Evans

Analyst

Sorry to interrupt your question there, Julien, good question. Again, this is Linn. We recognized that our regulatory strategy will have to be adjusted. We've often said, we would always have two or three rate reviews going on at any one time. We still see that -- those three rate reviews per year, if not more. We'll also as we go for those rate reviews be looking very close to -- at our riders that we have, what could be amended change tweaked with respect to those. So we recognize and understand and we will be adjusting our regulatory frequency, our regulatory cadence, if you will, going forward. And of course we'll have different kinds of requests in those as we go forward. We're also very sensitive to customer bill pressures. Our customers are seeing general inflation across the economy, not just with their energy bill. So we recognize that fact, we're sensitive to that fact and we will be as innovative as we possibly can be as we strive to reduce our own expenses. I'm glad that for more than a year now, we've had our program that we call energy forward going on within our organization, as we focus on innovative and less expensive and efficient ways that we can serve our customers recognizing the bills that they have. So, to summarize, to your point, we do recognize we'll have a different cadence for regulatory reviews going forward.

Julien Dumoulin-Smith

Analyst

Excellent. Well, thank you guys very much. Appreciate the time. Good luck.

Linn Evans

Analyst

Thank you, Julien.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Our next question comes from Chris Ellinghaus with Siebert Williams Shank and Company. You may proceed.

Chris Ellinghaus

Analyst · Siebert Williams Shank and Company. You may proceed.

Hi, everybody. How are you? Rich, good luck with retirement. Hope it goes as you had hoped. The supply chain issues that you referenced, is that more on the cost side or really the supply side? And since the third quarter, have sort of cost of equipment risen faster than you anticipated?

Kimberly Nooney

Analyst · Siebert Williams Shank and Company. You may proceed.

Good morning, Chris. Yes, I would generally say that the same pressures that we're feeling, our vendors are feeling. And they are working to try to determine how to pass on some of those elevated costs to our company as well. So, yes, it's both from an availability perspective, we're starting to see some ease, but yet the timing of being able to receive the materials is still delayed, but we are continuing to see those elevated prices from our vendors being pushed through. I would say, it's trying to stabilize, but overall, it's still a real issue.

Linn Evans

Analyst · Siebert Williams Shank and Company. You may proceed.

Yes, it's a great question, Chris. And this is Linn. And I would really complement our team in how they've been on top of all of our projects, analyzing them as a bulk, analyzing them individually and we have been able to push them out, which will help us with respect to overall capital expense and the impact on our customers. So real pleased with how our team has managed through that and we'll continue to.

Chris Ellinghaus

Analyst · Siebert Williams Shank and Company. You may proceed.

Okay. You know, could sort of see in your interest expense guidance, the Storm Elliot impact to a degree, but was some of the increase in your interest expense expectations a change in your interest rate outlook since the third quarter?

Kimberly Nooney

Analyst · Siebert Williams Shank and Company. You may proceed.

Yes, that's a great question, Chris. So we finance all of this through our commercial paper program. If you look at the A2/P2 rates over the last couple of months, right, it elevated 100 basis points alone. And so when you think about that with the inverted curve, we're just paying more from an interest perspective, interest rate perspective on short-term rates and so that was higher than we had originally forecasted.

Chris Ellinghaus

Analyst · Siebert Williams Shank and Company. You may proceed.

Okay. So you have some things that are not in the growth guidance, the Colorado, South Dakota. Clearly, there's a lot of transmission, what you call them, events or opportunities, do you have a chance to get back into that 5% to 7% former growth rate with some of the upside opportunities?

Linn Evans

Analyst · Siebert Williams Shank and Company. You may proceed.

Good question, Chris. This is Linn. I'll be cautious, I suppose, when we put out a 4% to 6% because that's what we will achieve, can achieve. You're right, I will recognize and we recognized that the Clean Energy Plan in Colorado is crystallizing. We have a unanimous settlement that would allow our utilities to own 50% of 400 megawatts of new generation to achieve that plan of 80% reduction in our greenhouse gas emissions. So, yes, that's not in our program, our plan. But it's going to take a little bit of time for that to get done. In other words, we will issue RFPs, I believe, next quarter, and we're looking forward to getting that out there and done. So that will be an opportunity for us that, yes, we'll begin to impact our outer years. We've got the Integrated Resource Plan in South Dakota, we have been meeting with our stakeholders with respect to that one, and we're starting to crystallize around what we think we can perhaps build and own there. We're not yet ready to make that public quite yet, but issue RFPs on that this quarter. So those are both exciting. Of course, we've got the Wyoming ready and you mentioned transmission as part of our approved rate review in Wyoming this past year recently approved in January. We do have a transmission rider, that will be effective for us as well. So there are several opportunities as you indicated and intimated in your question that are beginning to crystallize for us. We're very excited about them and that's going to be some great opportunity for us in our company.

Chris Ellinghaus

Analyst · Siebert Williams Shank and Company. You may proceed.

Okay. Great. Lastly, you didn't really address dividend growth, but given the payout range, does this sort of suggest we should assume slightly lower than in a recent dividend growth rate?

Kimberly Nooney

Analyst · Siebert Williams Shank and Company. You may proceed.

So, Chris, from a dividend growth rate perspective, we view this from a long-term perspective just given our history. Obviously, we've noted here in the short-term from a 2023 and 2024 perspective, that it may be a slower growth rate. But overall, as Linn just mentioned, as we think about the long-term growth of the company, we're very confident in where we're going and we think that the dividends are crucial component of the overall return for shareholders. So that's just how we're viewing it.

Linn Evans

Analyst · Siebert Williams Shank and Company. You may proceed.

Yes. This is Linn. Kimberly did a nice job answering that. We value the dividend, we understand our shareholders' perspective on that. Increasing 52 straight years is a record that we intend to keep and to maintain, of course, subject to our Board approval. As we migrate these -- navigate these waters in front of us, flexibility for a bit might be very important to us, but we can anticipate that will continue to increase the dividend.

Chris Ellinghaus

Analyst · Siebert Williams Shank and Company. You may proceed.

Okay. Thank you so much for the color. Appreciate it, guys.

Linn Evans

Analyst · Siebert Williams Shank and Company. You may proceed.

Thank you, Chris.

Kimberly Nooney

Analyst · Siebert Williams Shank and Company. You may proceed.

Thank you.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Our next question comes from Andrew Weisel with Scotiabank. You may proceed.

Andrew Weisel

Analyst · Scotiabank. You may proceed.

Hi, good morning, everyone. I want to follow up on a couple of questions that have been asked. So, first, on the 4% to 6%, you call it, long-term, in the past you had it defined a little bit more clearly. So, I guess, my question is, given the macro headwinds going into '24, should we expect growth to accelerate in '25 plus? And you also clarified an average annual compound growth rate. Does that mean that 2024 growth might be at or below that 4%, the low end?

Linn Evans

Analyst · Scotiabank. You may proceed.

Andrew, this is Linn. Great question. Thanks for bringing it forward. We anticipate the headwinds that we're seeing in 2023 may go into 2024. We don't know that, but that's how we're planning for that. We're planning for the worst if you will with respect to what we will continue to see into next year. So I think your observation, I'll say is right. Yes, we do see more growth on the back end of this five-year plan, but we're going to focus on being sure we're growing each year including after 2023. Hopefully, that's responsive to your question, Andrew.

Andrew Weisel

Analyst · Scotiabank. You may proceed.

Yes. And you said it's the five-year plan, so that goes through '27?

Linn Evans

Analyst · Scotiabank. You may proceed.

Yes.

Andrew Weisel

Analyst · Scotiabank. You may proceed.

Okay, great. Next question on the gas price recovery, how often do you reset your rates in your biggest jurisdictions? Obviously, the volatility up and down means you're always kind of playing catch up, but how often are they reset and is this one of the potential changes you might pursue in some states?

Linn Evans

Analyst · Scotiabank. You may proceed.

Yes, thank you for that question. Andrew, this is Linn again. It varies by state, that's where I'll start. Some states, we get fairly quick immediate recovery; some states, we have a full-year lag, some are more than that. Sometimes we are based off of a forecast and frankly some of our recent gas cost adjustments were based on forecast that turned out not to be accurate in the hindsight. So it varies by state and that's what we will evaluate as we go forward is what is the most fair to customers and fair to shareholders with respect to timeliness, so that we're sending price signals appropriately and things of that nature. So again probably for the third time, it really varies by state.

Andrew Weisel

Analyst · Scotiabank. You may proceed.

Okay. Fair enough. Then lastly, you mentioned potentially accelerating the regulatory calendar, where specifically might we see the next filings? Is it beyond what's currently underway?

Linn Evans

Analyst · Scotiabank. You may proceed.

Yes. Thank you for that question. Andrew, this is Linn again. We're not quite prepared to announce that. We will probably do that relatively soon, maybe next quarter. Our regulatory team does a fantastic job of managing relationships and expectations. And of course we want to make sure we're sitting down and talking to our stakeholders in that regard before we make public announcements. And we're just not quite ready to do that, but you can anticipate, we will probably still have the three typical rate reviews in 2023 that we will file.

Andrew Weisel

Analyst · Scotiabank. You may proceed.

Very good. Thank you very much and congratulations again to Kimberly and Rich. Rich, enjoy the time with your grandkids.

Rich Kinzley

Analyst · Scotiabank. You may proceed.

Thanks, Andrew.

Kimberly Nooney

Analyst · Scotiabank. You may proceed.

Thank you.

Linn Evans

Analyst · Scotiabank. You may proceed.

Thank you for your questions, Andrew.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Our next question comes from Brandon Lee with Mizuho. You may proceed.

Brandon Lee

Analyst · Mizuho. You may proceed.

Hi, Linn, hi Rich, hi Kimberly. Quick question, for your 4% to 6% range, I guess, where does the capital plan currently puts you there, are you in the middle and what gets you to 6% and what gets you to 4%?

Linn Evans

Analyst · Mizuho. You may proceed.

Thank you for that question, Brandon. This is Linn again. We'll stay silent on that. It's important that we just know that, that EPS growth rate is out there. And it will -- our capital program is going to be a foundation fundamental part of that. And then I also -- we've got other growth opportunities with respect to continuing to serve our expanding hyperscale, datacenters, blockchain mining. Our first blockchain miner turns on here very soon. We're very excited about that. We've got incoming migration into our service territories, more business is coming. So all those fundamentals are strong. So with the combination of all the things that we have in our current plan and in our current forecast that put us in that growth range target.

Brandon Lee

Analyst · Mizuho. You may proceed.

Okay, great. That's all I had. All my other questions were asked. Thanks a lot.

Linn Evans

Analyst · Mizuho. You may proceed.

Brandon, thank you for your question. We appreciate it.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. And this concludes the Q&A session. I'd now like to turn it back to Linn Evans for any closing remarks.

Linn Evans

Analyst

Thank you very much. Well, we look forward to providing our customers and shareholders value. As we migrate through these current interest rate and macro environment, I'm more confident than ever in our team, and what we can do. And these headwinds that we're facing today are going to make us a better and stronger company. I hope you hear the optimism in our voices about the future, despite the short-term and near-term challenges that we will migrate through and we'll migrate through successfully in. In closing, I again extend my sincere gratitude to each one of my co-workers for their dedication to safety, their dedication to serving our customers. I'm very privileged to work alongside each of you every day. So best wishes to all of you for a Black Hills Energy Safe Day, and a very productive day and we appreciate the questions this morning. Thank you.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. This concludes today's conference call. Thank you for participating. You may now disconnect.