Earnings Labs

Benchmark Electronics, Inc. (BHE)

Q4 2015 Earnings Call· Tue, Feb 9, 2016

$68.85

-0.60%

Key Takeaways · AI generated
AI summary not yet generated for this transcript. Generation in progress for older transcripts; check back soon, or browse the full transcript below.

Same-Day

+0.19%

1 Week

+2.49%

1 Month

+4.61%

vs S&P

-4.74%

Transcript

Operator

Operator

Good day ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the Benchmark Electronics Inc., Fourth Quarter 2015 Earnings Conference Call. At this time all participants are in a listen-only mode. Later we will conduct the question-and-answer session and instructions will follow at that time. [Operator Instructions] As a reminder, today’s call is being recorded. I’d like introduce our host for today's conference Miss Lisa Weeks, VP Strategic Planning and Investor Relations. Ma'am, you may begin.

Lisa Weeks

Analyst

Thank you, operator. Good morning everyone and thank you for joining us today for Benchmark's fourth quarter and full year 2015 earnings call. My name is Lisa Weeks and I’m Benchmark’s Vice President of Strategy and Investor Relations. With me this morning are Gayla Delly, President and CEO; and Don Adam, CFO. Gayla will provide an update on our strategic priorities and near term outlook and then Don will provide a detailed review of our financial results followed by a question-and-answer session. Earlier today, we issued our earnings release highlighting our financial performance for the fourth quarter and full year 2015 and we have prepared a presentation that we will reference on this call. The press releases and presentation are available online under the Investor Relations section of our website at www.bench.com. This call is being webcast live and a replay will be available online following the call. Please take a moment to review the forward-looking statements advised on Slide 2 in the presentation. During our call, we will discuss forward-looking information. As a reminder, any of today's remarks that are not statements of historical facts are forward-looking statements which involve risks and uncertainties described in our press release and SEC filings. Actual results may differ materially from these statements and Benchmark undertakes no obligation to update any forward-looking statement. The company has provided a reconciliation of our GAAP to non-GAAP measures in the earnings release, as well as in the appendix of the presentation. If you will turn to Slide 3, I will now turn the call over to our President and Chief Executive Officer, Gayla Delly.

Gayla Delly

Analyst

Thank you, Lisa, and good morning to everyone. I am very pleased with what our results say about the merits of our strategic plan. A few years ago, we committed to increase our efforts in our higher value markets to capitalize on the growing trend of outsourcing while balancing reduced customer spending in our traditional space. Despite the significant macroeconomic challenges in our traditional market particularly in our telecom market space our profit margins have increased. Our mix has grown in favor of higher growth and higher margin business, so despite the headwind in the top lines our profits and cash flows have continued steady. Our top priority is to expand sales and improve our mix in the higher value markets where outsourcing rates are growing, products and contract typically have longer life cycles and customers see value in our early engagements with engineering services and value added solutions which drive a richer engagement model. Our portfolio transition has enabled us to increase our margins. Previously we set forth the target of 4.5% quarterly operating margin on a non-GAAP basis. We achieved that in the fourth quarter which was a full 50 basis points higher than the comparable 2014 quarter and our highest quarterly margins since 2007. For the full year, our margin was 4.2%, as we move forward we will now establish a target to exit 2016 at a 4.8% operating margins. Recall that we are now targeting 5% as our longer term operating margin goal. A business as large and complex as Benchmark always has an opportunity for continuous improvement in areas such as production efficiency and supply chain optimization. The transformation of our portfolio to our targeted markets which are characterized by higher mix and lower volume has temporarily increased our working capital requirement as we work…

Don Adam

Analyst

Thank you, Gayla. Please turn to Slide 7 where I will provide income statement highlights. Our fourth quarter results and operating margins were within our guidance and reflect the continued execution of strategy to transition our business toward higher value markets. The fourth quarter was the fifth consecutive quarter where higher value markets exceeded 50% of our revenues. Our revenues were flat compared to the third quarter and down 12% from the fourth quarter of 2014 we continue to successfully drive operating margins to our targeted goal. In fact we exited the fourth quarter at 4.5% non-GAAP operating margin which is a 50 basis point increase year-over-year and a 20 basis point quarter-on-quarter increase. This operating margin is the highest level we have achieved since 2007. Net income on a GAAP basis was $39 million for the quarter compared to $23 million in 2014, our GAAP results include two non-recurring items; the first, the $6 million of acquisition and restructuring cost, and the second is $21 million of discrete tax benefits which primarily relates to a U.S. tax benefit from the release of an income tax valuation allowance. Our non-GAAP net income for the quarter was $23 million in 2015 and 2014. Our GAAP EPS was $0.77 for the quarter compared to $0.44 in 2014. Our non-GAAP EPS was $0.45 for the quarter compared to $0.42 in 2014. The fourth quarter 2015 non-GAAP effective income tax rate was 16% compared to 19% in 2014. The tax rate for the fourth quarter was lower than expected due to recently enacted U.S. tax legislation. We expect the tax rate for the first quarter to range from 24% to 25% based on higher expected income in the U.S. The diluted weighted average shares outstanding for the fourth quarter were $50.9 million. Now please…

Gayla Delly

Analyst

Thank you, Don. In closing, we are excited about where we’re going and we look forward to 2016 and beyond. Our team has made significant progress in transforming our portfolio through rebuilding our revenue structure and reducing customer concentration, while also enhancing profitability. Our expected new program ramps resulted in a greater technology mix with a more stable customer based. We are confidence in the trajectory of our portfolio and the anticipated expansion in our higher value market. I want to thank all of our employees for their continued focus on providing excellent service and support to our customers, while executing operational and working capital initiative. We will continue to track progress against our strategic priorities which will enable us to continue to create value for our shareholders and customers. In conclusion we are pleased with our strong performance as we evolve our portfolio and position Benchmark to driving enhanced shareholder value. We will continue to operate with discipline and execute on our initiatives throughout 2016. Now I will turn it over to the operator so that we can open the platform for questions. Operator?

Operator

Operator

Thank you. [Operator Instructions] And our first question comes from the line of Steven Fox.

Steven Fox

Analyst

First question, just a couple of things on the acquisition of Secure. Gayla you mentioned in your prepared remarks that they provide some building blocks for growth across your served markets. Can you just talk about maybe more specifically what that could mean and how long it could take to get there? And then if you could be a little more specific on the contribution from secure in terms of revenues, EPS in this quarter that would be helpful also.

Gayla Delly

Analyst

As we indicated I'll start backward, as we indicated Secure revenues were about a 100 million and consistent with all of our other acquisitions we will not be segregating the acquisition going forward, but you will see the impacts as they are included in our guidance and our margin profile going forward. And as we indicated they have had growth of about 10% per year. Of course given their size and the private nature of the company we aren't giving specific margin profiles on Secure, but with that let me speak to why we're excited about the portfolio they have and the markets that they serve. So, as I indicated they are directly aligned with our industrial markets and specifically in some of the sub sectors such as defense and aerospace providing engineered solutions and collaboratively engaging with customers from the very early stages and during the design to production with very little structure as compared to an EMS engagement where you will often the -- the customer will be further along and engage an engineering team to complete the task. And so this is really engaging much earlier and more collaboratively and some of the buildings blocks will be some of the sub-systems, some of the technologies, a catalogued, engineered approaches to problem solving which are leverageable across multiple industries. So, it will be similar to having a catalogue of a product or a widget or a gadget. There's a catalogue of engineered solutions that can be brought forth some proprietary approaches to challenges in the marketplace today and especially as those apply to taking some of the long life products and applying current technology and approaches to updating those product which enhance the lifecycle and elongate the lifecycle of those products for a much more cost efficient and effective solution versus bringing out a new product. So, that' a very meaningful and important aspect of what they're able to do that really folds very nicely into the long life products that we're targeting in a number of our industrial markets and medical as well.

Steven Fox

Analyst

And then just as a follow-up, if I understood correctly, of a really good growth on medical, you're expecting even better growth this year and even better growth on top of that in '17. So, could you just talk, obviously you have new win momentum but specifically where the new wins are maybe benefitting from certain trends or what drives the confidence in the accelerating growth?

Gayla Delly

Analyst

I believe that Medical has accelerated their pace to outsourcing in my mind for two reasons. One is that they are seeing cost pressure that they may not have heretofore seen at the same pace or intensity that they do today. And the second reason being that in addition to their ongoing investment in R&D a number of medical equipment organizations have invested through M&A. And as they had invested through M&A they have manufacturing locations that may not align directly with their goals and objectives and therefore outsourcing whether they originally as an organization outsourced or whether they are looking at it to further align their footprint, becomes a valid solution and opportunity for them to look at more efficient ways to get products to their customers. So we see that as a great opportunity. And of course as you know part of the reason we see some growth going forward in medical with probably greater visibility than you might generally see in other markets is because of the long time to market with the FDA approval and the period of launch as we said it's I believe last quarter we had two programs that were delayed and this -- actually last time it was three programs and this time was two programs that were delayed. And so it becomes very difficult on a quarter-by-quarter basis to anticipate the level of revenues and throughput especially with new product introduction, but we can see how many are on the roadmap that have not yet been launched into the full production levels anticipated.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. Our next question comes from Andrew Huang of B. Riley Company. Your line is now open.

Andrew Huang

Analyst

Thanks for taking my questions and congratulations on the operating margin improvement. When I think about your longer term operating margin targets of over 5%, will we see some improvement in the gross margin, or will that be entirely driven by operating leverage?

Gayla Delly

Analyst

That’s a good question, I think you will see a little bit of both, but as you can see no doubt in the model we have some clear opportunity on the SG&A line, the operating expenses to drive efficiency back but we would expect there would be contribution both in the gross margin and the operating margin.

Andrew Huang

Analyst

And then I think in your press release you talked about targeting 15% to 20% reduction in cash cycle days, exiting 2016. So could you give us a feel for where most of that’s coming from, is it going to be inventory or receivables, or payables?

Don Adam

Analyst

I think we’ll get a contributions from all three, but the majority of that increase will come from inventory, and then the corresponding impact on payables.

Andrew Huang

Analyst

And then if I could squeeze in one last question on Secure Technology, when I look at 2016 are there going to be opportunities to optimize SG&A for that business?

Gayla Delly

Analyst

Again specifically for Secure, we are integrating, so we would expect for some of the normal business systems and tools to enhance the engineering toolsets, enhance some of the back office operations that we would probably have some cost in front of the savings but yes we would get those savings through that area.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. And our next question comes from Mitch Stephens from RBC Capital Markets. Your line is now open.

Mitch Steves

Analyst

So I guess I’m going to start on the Telco side of the business. Could you just walk us through what’s happening for the Q-over-Q, is that still a single customer specific issue? And then secondly, I know you can’t talk about this or name of the customer. But can you talk about product lines are doing better or worse than others within Telco?

Don Adam

Analyst

Mitch I think sequentially I think, I would say most of the customers in our sector saw continuing declines from Q3 levels, much the same as we experienced from Q2 to Q3. So, the declines that we’ve seen are very long broad based. We serve a number of customers in the Telco sector, there is not one specific product line, it’s across the board.

Gayla Delly

Analyst

And in fact we serve a number of different technologies within Telco and we’ve seen demand there remain lackluster and I believe some of it’s with carrier spend, some it's associated with the M&A activity that has been undertaken and then of course in other cases I believe it's associated with inventory corrections that are taking place. And last that I think we pointed to is there are some new technologies, some innovation that’s coming to market and normal delays there I would say on getting those engineered solutions dialed in. So it really seems to be a challenged marketplace as they are looking at the appropriate type of products to into the infrastructure to support all of the conversions, the Internet of Things, there is a lot of moving parts there and what we’re excited about is specifically some of the new technologies that we’re supporting. But we don’t expect that those are going to, as I said in my prepared remarks that that revenue size will outpace or meet what we saw in 2014. If you recall part of the reason we’re seeing the follow-up is just because the impact really outsized performances in 2014 and early 2015 and I would say and I was going say that is going what we're comparing to and I don’t see that type of marketplace and I would say some of that probably had to do with emerging market infrastructure built out, although I don’t have all the details around that, that’s what I truly believe was taking place that allowed for such significant increase in 2014.

Mitch Steves

Analyst

Yeah, that makes sense. And secondly if I could ask another on the end markets. You guys are talking about the growth essentially for 2016 for the combined company is there any sector that’s going to be better than season particularly in the back half of the year, I am not looking for your guidance, just looking for rough essentially seasonality or uptake on the specific end markets.

Gayla Delly

Analyst

I would say I don’t see anything in the overall marketplace where we see conditions changing dramatically in the second half at this point. We see mixed signals from customers and again the excitement seems to be conversion around new technologies, but I don’t see anyone pointing to global economic changing to the macro environment supporting increased or enhance performance overall. I don’t see any one industry, our excitement is primarily around the new products and new customers versus volume of production improvements expected.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. [Operator Instructions] Our next question comes from Jim Suva of Citi. Your line is now open.

Jim Suva

Analyst

Thanks very much. If we look at your full year outlook for 2016 and we roll up the different segments and we pull out the Secure Technology. Does that means that you are looking for relatively flat organic growth, or is my math wrong there because flat organic growth in this [indiscernible] actually seeing is quite encouraging or maybe my math is wrong there. I am just kind of thinking about organic growth for this year.

Gayla Delly

Analyst

I think it’d be flat to slightly up overall and again as you pointed out, we feel that that is strong given the current marketplace. But again we are not giving guidance for the full year but knowing the overall environment and soft demand environment that our customers see, there is growth from new product and it’s a matter of trying to identify what your belief is about the longer term macro-environment and again I'll point that we have maintained customer relationship, it’s not the departure of a customers, it’s the departure of volume for customers that will drive whether the -- and macro-environment that will drive whether that is substantial, moderate, or no or slow growth in our core base of business.

Jim Suva

Analyst

And then as a follow up, you mentioned the March quarter outlook is relatively seasonal. Is that when you also include, you added in I believe your acquisition in the December quarter and it may have likely only have impact for the December quarter, so you get a little bit of a boost. Are you excluding that in your comment about seasonal or how should we think about your comment for seasonal? Does it include that in a really organic and macro conditions are a little bit sub seasonal where margin and acquisitions helps?

Gayla Delly

Analyst

Let me take it the other way, and see if this helps answer. And if you go back a couple of years when we had a greater portion of our businesses associated with Telco and in concluding you would see kind a stronger boost in Q4 and then as follow up that was more substantial in Q1. So, I believe it was two year ago we saw about a 16% quarter-on-quarter decline. A couple of year -- last year it was like a 12 and this year it’s about 8. So, that’s an all in number, so all of our business and all of our guidance. So, it does have the season impact in there, it also has the shift in business.

Jim Suva

Analyst

And my final question is on the telecom softness you've mentioned. When you go back and talk to your market intelligence people, is it just the overall market, is it your geographic exposure to where the products is going, is it your customer concentration or do you just expect that entire market to face those challenges? Thank you.

Gayla Delly

Analyst

It’s what we see across our customer base which is as you said it’s product, it’s geography, it’s customers. So we don’t see it isolated to a specific sub-segment and I believe some of that again is probably timing related and some of it probably is related to geographic.

Jim Suva

Analyst

Great. Thank you very much and congratulations on the good results.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. And our next question comes from Sean Hannan of Needham. Your line is now open.

Sean Hannan

Analyst

[Audio Gap] If I were to consider the tone and what appeared to be ambiguity of your outlook for '16 coming out of the last quarter call, it appears that there seems to be an improved feel that you folks have in the opportunity for growth this year. Of course Secure is helping that, but again you do the math and it suggests, you've got 58% of your business that in aggregate should do over 10% growth and the rest of it’s kind of a GDP-ish macro related kind of decline, I mean net-net that should be up for the year. So it seems like that perspective has changed and improved, can you help to just make sure we -- to validate this and make sure I'm thinking about this the right way?

Don Adam

Analyst

Let me answer it this way, I think if you look at our higher values versus our traditional side as we've stated in our comments we believe the higher value portion of our business will have about 10% growth. Now flipping that over to your traditional side, the one -- sort of the wild card in there is how well is Telco is going to perform. I mean certainly Q4 was a low point of the year, we’re expecting further declines into Q1. So, it's how fast do the new programs that Gayla alluded to earlier do those ramps in the Telco sector is really going to drive what 2016 looks like.

Gayla Delly

Analyst

And then Sean, one thing that I might add to what Don indicated that make no mistake, we don't see this through rose colored glasses. This is -- we don't see a different overall macro-environment than what others see. I truly believe that it's rough and rocky times out there across a lot of the markets we serve, if not all of them. And so the end market softness and how that impacts us, will be what it is, but what we are excited about in a positive tone you hear in our voicing and hear in our comments is that we feel probably better by than ever about what we are doing and the team and the actions we have in place to manage through this and once again we're positioned for solid growth, we have focused attack plans for each of our segments and importantly we have diversified. So we have behind us some of the challenges that concentration or some of the technology that is not as leading edge may have in the marketplace. Those are in the rear-view mirror and that gives us a positive look going forward.

Sean Hannan

Analyst

A couple of more technical modeling questions, unless I missed it, did you state a share count that you're expecting for March?

Don Adam

Analyst

It will be modestly down for the quarter, we finished that 50.9 probably couple of hundred thousand's lower than that.

Sean Hannan

Analyst

So, like a 50.5?

Don Adam

Analyst

50.5-50.7 yes.

Sean Hannan

Analyst

And in terms of the taxes, pretty material change versus my last model. It would signal that there's probably per annum 8% -- I mean I'm sorry $0.08 headwinds with this higher tax rate and I'd expect that 24-25 [ph] is the midpoint is probably your expectation for the year. Can you comment a little bit around that and how we should be thinking about taxes and that impact?

Don Adam

Analyst

First the rates is going to be driven by the geographic mix of where the profits are generated. You couple that with the fact that we just added Secure which is exclusively in United States, that's going to have increasing impact on the tax rate.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. And so we have a follow-up question from the line of Andrew Huang of B. Riley Company. Your line is now open.

Andrew Huang

Analyst

In light of the weakening macro some people say that slow-end markets caused OEMs to pump the brakes and back off the outsourcing and then others maybe opposite that OEMs want to actually step up the outsourcing. So, I'm wondering if you’re willing to share what you're actually experiencing when you're out there pounding the pavement.

Gayla Delly

Analyst

I think again we see probably a mixture of both, I don't think it’s one size fits all. It really is based on the scenario that each OEM has and in their own environment. So, I would say any of us in our industry would be wrong to say that we only see one or the other, but clearly what allows OEMs to take fixed costs out of their model is to outsource, and so while there may be a stepping stone where a number of OEMs may collect a certain amount of their manufacturing and bring it under one or a few operating units that exist that’s generally a stepping stone and if they have further or additional need for improvement then that’s when they consider outsourcing. So I don’t ever consider it to be a final decision but it made logical decision for some OEMs to take a step function improvement in consolidating some of their manufacturing.

Operator

Operator

Thank you. And at this time, I am showing there are no further participants in the queue. Any final comments from management?

Gayla Delly

Analyst

No, we want to thank everyone for joining us on the call today. And look forward to speaking with any of you with follow up calls and appreciate your time. Have a great day.