Sharon John
Analyst · SCC Research
Good morning, and thank you for joining us today. As fiscal 2021 came to a close, we were thrilled to kick off our year-long celebration of Build-A-Bear's milestone 25th anniversary on the heels of the most profitable year in the company's history. Today, we will reflect on the record-breaking results from 2021, which were achieved while navigating through the challenges, volatility and uncertainty of a global pandemic and provide an update on the strategy that contributed to our positive outcome. We will also share a few details about newer initiatives that we're working on for 2022.
First, it's important to note that the advancements this company made in 2021 reflects the successful execution of a multifaceted strategy that has required years of planning and investment. The model was primarily envisioned to elevate and monetize our iconic brand while evolving the company into a digitally driven, diversified, omnichannel entity, enhanced by dynamic and efficient vertical retailtainment presence. With many of the building blocks now in place, we believe Build-A-Bear is fundamentally different than it was when we began this process or even prior to COVID. In fact, many of the necessary changes in transformative initiatives actually accelerated during the pandemic.
Additionally, we believe these efforts have provided the company with a platform for a compelling future as we continue to leverage and build on these new capabilities with the goal of creating ongoing shareholder value. To achieve this transformation, this leadership team initiated and led wide-scale, long-horizon efforts designed to evolve the company, both during and in response to a variety of external pressures, included changes in consumer shopping habits, resulting in the rapid rise of the digital economy and shifting mall traffic patterns.
We systematically invested in and executed plans to improve operations and profitability, including an organizational restructure and acquisition of new talent aligned with the strategic objectives and IT infrastructure and systems overhaul, sweeping supply chain improvements with sourcing diversification, the addition of a new warehouse management system, a relaunch and expansion of the e-commerce side and back end to include omnichannel capabilities, a relaunch of our valued loyalty program, a significant shift to digital marketing and content as consumer communication tool and rationalization, renegotiation and evolution of the store fleet, resulting in a significantly improved 4-wall contribution.
While we have acknowledged that there is likely some accretive impact from the pent-up demand and government stimulus, we believe the majority of our positive results this year are due to the cumulative effect of the strategic advances that we were just noting. With that in mind, our fiscal 2021 financial highlights include: total revenues of $411.5 million, an increase of over 60% compared to fiscal 2020 and more than 20% versus fiscal 2019; growth in digital demand to a record level of $73 million with a penetration of nearly 20% of net retail sales; pretax income of $50.7 million, exceeding the upper end of the range of our most recent guidance. As noted, this is the highest pretax income in our company's nearly 25-year history and compares to a pretax loss of $20.2 million in fiscal 2020 and a pretax income of $1.6 million in fiscal 2019. And we ended the year with cash and cash equivalents of $32.8 million, putting us in a strong position to continue to fund strategic capital investments.
Note that this position is reflective of the fourth quarter $20 million special cash dividend paid to our shareholders and the repurchase of over $4 million of our shares associated with the recently announced stock buyback program. With this proven strategy and continued momentum in 2022 quarter-to-date, we intend to remain focused on accelerating and expanding our key initiatives while we leverage the excitement that comes with our 25th anniversary celebration plan.
Build-A-Bear is beloved and well-known with earned multigenerational appeal. Since the company was launched, we have sold over 200 million furry friends and have remained relevant by capturing many popular interests of a broad range of today's consumers, including a desire for collectibility, experience, personalization and DIY or through collaborations with other powerful brands to broaden our popularity beyond the core consumer.
Additionally, we are proud that Build-A-Bear is importantly also recognized as an authentic and trusted brand that is elevated to pop-culture status, and we believe our brand power and successful strategy coupled with an accomplished and proven team, along with our passionate and dedicated organization, provide a strong model for delivering sustained profitable growth with a combination of an efficient core business, driven by continued enhancements, diversification and innovation, including newer initiatives such as the Bear Cave, which is an age-gated section of our website, designed to expand our addressable market by offering what could be considered a somewhat surprising selection of adult-targeted furry friends collectibles and licensed products for older consumers, such as the recent launch of our Matrix bear or our fan-favorite Deadpool bear as well as romantic gift and the instantly popular Van Gogh museum collection.
Bear Cave may have recently hit your radar screen this Valentine's with the broad interest in our After Dark marketing campaign, which alone generated over 1 billion global media impressions. HeartBox, a new gift box collection that offers a tasteful curated assortment of theme products, including a custom Build-A-Bear furry friend, sweets from Sugarfina and drinkware from Swig to provide an upscale convenient online solution for a wide range of adult-to-adult gift-giving occasions with the goal of participating in the expansive gifting market.
Build-A-Bear 3D Workshop, a fun e-commerce experience and creative shopping option, designed so guests can interactively engage in a reimagined virtual Build-A-Bear Workshop. They see their new furry friends come to life as they select sounds and clothing with a unique digital Make-Your-Own animated process that ultimately directs the final product to our site's checkout cart.
Our new Automatic Teddy Machines or ATMs are innovative interactive teddy bear vending machines designed as a tool to efficiently expand the brand's presence into a variety of new locations. They have successfully debuted in airports in conjunction with our partners at Hudson's as well as in children hospitals. Klarna has been added to our online checkout process to provide guests with a convenient extended payment plan for purchases with the goal of improving conversion and increasing average order value. In fact, the average order value of our fourth quarter Klarna transactions was over 50% higher than non-Klarna orders.
Buy online pick up in store, buy online ship from store and same-day delivery through ships lowers common purchasing hurdles by providing important last-mile options for our guests while improving our efficiency by using our retail workforce and store fleet as fulfillment centers. Because this approach also shortens delivery time, it extends the shopping window for holidays and occasion gifting. And our ongoing evolution of digital marketing capabilities and consumer service tools is expected to continue to drive both e-commerce and physical store traffic and sales.
As a reminder, these recently launched programs are all aligned with our strategic pillars of: one, further driving our digital transformation; two, continuing to evolve our retail experience and leverage our expanded omnichannel capabilities; and three, optimizing our solid financial position to invest in growth while generating sustained profitability.
With that, I would also like to share some additional efforts that are expected to launch in 2022 to support these 3 strategies, including: first, as it relates to leveraging our ongoing digital transformation, we have plans in place to improve repeat purchase and enhance engagement with the 12 million opted in first-party data contacts, including over 10 million active Build-A-Bear Bonus Club loyalty members by implementing a new advanced loyalty module with Salesforce, to better leverage the improvements that have already been made in the digital marketing area and by utilizing this module to access a single view of our individual Bonus Club members, to engage with them using relevant guest specific and personalized experiences and sales messaging, as this approach has been shown to deliver higher click-through rate and conversion metrics, which contributes to incremental purchases.
In addition to optimizing our current first-party data with add-on purchases, we also have programs aimed to extend our addressable market by reaching beyond the core kid base to acquire new teen, tween and adult consumers with unique affinity offerings and expanded purchasing occasions. We have over 75 licensed relationships in place, ranging from Star Wars to Harry Potter to Pokemon to the NFL and have added properties such as the recently launched and already popular Elvis furry friend and the new Rebel Girls collection that launched on Tuesday in honor of International Women's Day.
We have shown a consistent ability to leverage the affinity that consumers have for other brands to fuel new guest acquisition through the use of our dynamic digital marketing tools, resulting in additive sales and significant increase in Google search data for our brand, yet another proof point of its relevance. Also, we plan to continue to utilize digital media, content and entertainment as marketing and brand-building tools to engage consumers and create value.
We have a variety of Build-A-Bear created intellectual properties, including Honey Girls, the popular product line that inspired the music-driven live-action film starring Grammy Award winner, Ashanti, that was released last fall in conjunction with Sony. We are delighted that the movie was recently added to the quality selection of Netflix entertainment viewing options, expanding the potential audience for Honey Girls by millions of target consumers.
Next, we expect to continue to leverage our expanded omnichannel capabilities while further evolving retail experiences and purchase occasions. With 97% of North American stores profitable with an average contribution margin of over 25% in fiscal 2021, we believe there is an opportunity to strategically add new locations. Specifically, in addition to a number of nontraditional locations that were opened in 2021, which were shared in our third quarter call, we expect to add between 15 and 20 new store locations in North America through a combination of corporate and third-party retail with an emphasis on tourist sites over the next 2 to 3 years.
As a part of this initiative, we recently opened a new retail format called Build-A-Bear Adventure in our home market in St. Louis, featuring party rooms and an arcade in addition to the classic bear-building process. This concept is designed to build on and extend the strong connection consumers have with the brand in association with birthdays and parties by offering a next-level experience for gift, while also providing expanded omnichannel fulfillment support.
Speaking of parties, after a nearly 2-year pandemic-driven hiatus, we are expecting to relaunch our beloved Build-A-Party business and stores in the coming weeks, historically generating up to 5% of sales. Our party business has long been a staple of memory making for guests and has served as a rite of passage for millions of children. We could not be more pleased to bring parties back to the workshop in conjunction with our own 25th anniversary celebration.
Separately, while we have shared that the pandemic disrupted some of our international franchise operations, we continue to believe in the broader opportunity of the brand globally. With that in mind, we recently partnered with Global-e, which offers a platform to enable and accelerate direct-to-consumer cross-border e-commerce as we roll out the capabilities in the upcoming months, international shoppers will be able to more efficiently access our digital product offerings, starting with Canada and Mexico.
As noted, we plan to capitalize on Build-A-Bear's 25th anniversary to create interest, leverage nostalgia and drive incremental visits and sales. We have activities planned throughout the year, including for the first time in our history, a special collection of fan-favorite furry friends inspired from the past being launched with new releases planned intermittently throughout the year.
Our Valentine's Day classic Hearts Fur You Pup sold out quickly, and we have seen positive consumer reaction on social media in anticipation of upcoming releases. We have also developed a number of exclusive limited-edition collaborations with a selection of our powerful portfolio of licensed partners, which is expected to create buzz and drive demand and a new celebratory marketing campaign was [ recently ] introduced on January 25, encouraging our millions of fans and guests to engage with us, while recalling their own personal memories related to the millions of furry friends that have been made leading up to this milestone anniversary of Build-A-Bear Workshop.
With respect to the final strategic pillar of continuing to optimize our solid financial position to invest in growth while generating sustained profitability, we plan to maintain disciplined [indiscernible] management particularly in light of the inflationary pressures, wage increases and supply chain challenges. We also remain focused on ongoing post-pandemic lease negotiations and continuing to evolve real estate portfolio to new locations, formats and business models, and we expect to continue to strategically manage capital to support key initiatives and innovative development designed to deliver long-term profitable growth and return value to our shareholders.
As we kick off our fiscal 2022, following the close of a remarkable year of challenge and change that ultimately delivered record profitability, it feels appropriate to take a quick look back on the winding road this team and company has navigated to arrive at this juncture. One way to highlight the significant progress is by comparing our fiscal 2021 results with those of 2012, the last fiscal year before the broader strategic plan was put in place.
Total 2021 revenues were over $411 million compared to $384 million in fiscal 2012. 2021 digital demand reached over $70 million with a penetration of nearly 20% of net retail compared to e-commerce sales of approximately $14 million in 2012 or 4% of net retail sales. 2021 merchandise margin increased over 950 basis points compared to 2012, even with pandemic-driven challenges and supply chain disruptions. 97% of North American stores were profitable in fiscal 2021 with an average contribution margin of over 25% compared to 20% of all locations being unprofitable with less than an average 10% margin in 2012 and reflecting our efforts to diversify our retail footprint at year-end in 2021, less than 65% of our stores were in traditional malls versus over 85% in 2012.
Finally, in 2021, we delivered over $50 million in pretax income, again resulting in the most profitable year in our history compared to a pretax loss of $47 million in 2012.
In closing, as noted, thus far, we have continued to experience positive momentum in the first quarter of 2022. I would also like to note that our company was recently named to the Forbes list of America's Best Employers for the third consecutive time. With that, I would like to thank everyone at Build-A-Bear for delivering these record-breaking results in fiscal 2021.
Our passionate and dedicated team is the beating heart of our company and brand. We are also grateful to our valued guests, suppliers and other partners who have played a part in delivering this business expansion. We believe we have strong plans in place to continue the positive start of our 25th anniversary year, assuming no further negative COVID impacts or effects from other external disruptions. And we intend to remain focused on leveraging our broadened capabilities and innovative programs with the goal of driving further profitable growth and shareholder return.
Now I would like to turn the call over to Voin to discuss our financial results in more detail.