Fran Horowitz-Bonadies
Analyst · JJK Research
Thank you, Arthur, and good morning, everyone. First of all, it is an honor to lead the company's effort to revise the A&F brand and reignite growth across our business.
I am confident in our strategic direction and in our ability to execute on our plan to create more customer-centric brands with clear identities that resonate with consumers and to generate sustainable growth and profit for our shareholders.
As Arthur mentioned, our results for the quarter reflect an environment that was and remains challenging and highly promotional. In spite of that environment, Hollister achieved positive comp sales during the quarter and international markets improved measurably from last quarter.
But we did not make as much progress at A&F as we wanted, we have made important changes under the new brand President's leadership to enhance the performance of the brand. We continue to listen to our customers as we refine and promote our brand positioning, and we are confident in the team and the plan for the brand's revitalization.
Overall, we have made significant progress on our strategic initiatives across both brands that have proven to increase customer engagement and provide a better customer experience. This includes the development of new store prototypes and loyalty programs, as well as the continued rollout of our omnichannel capabilities.
Starting into the fourth quarter performance by brand. Hollister continued to perform despite the strong headwinds in the markets. Calling out a few key items of note, in Hollister guys, we saw continued strength in categories where we've added innovation and stretch. We have strong performance in denims, key item knit tops and outerwear, partially offset by underperformance in fleece bottoms.
On the Hollister growth side, cozy fabrics and trend details on top fashion and innovation denim performed well. Our emerging Internet category highlighted by the reintroduction of the Gilly Hicks brand did well, partially offsetting overall underperformance in woven and basic jeans.
Going to the Abercrombie brand, the challenging external environment, coupled with several specific issues we identified during the quarter contributed to the slower-than-expected progress in our brand revitalization plan.
Our flagship and tourist stores continue to weigh particularly heavily on results and traffic remains a headwind despite an improvement from last quarter.
In addition, notwithstanding strength in categories where we introduced newness and innovation, it is fair to say we did not achieve the expected improvement in the more seasonally appropriate assortment particularly in outerwear, which lack the signature A&F details necessary to create differentiation. Our designers are now aligned on a singular brand esthetic and attuned to differentiation we need to engage and inspire our Abercrombie customers.
In addition, our overall assortment architecture lacks size and color depth in key items, such as fleece, to support the top line and ended this season 2 [ph] in certain brand out categories. This is a function of staffing and process issues we identified during the quarter. The teams have been strengthened with new senior talent in both planning and merchandising. They've worked quickly to improve processes and make the necessary adjustments to the assortment going forward, such as increased depth of buy in top 30 items and reducing number of SKUs to get assortment more focus.
There is always a time lag required to work through this type of issue and we expect the impact to continue into the first quarter of 2017, however, this will not happen again.
During the quarter, we began to communicate and evolve identity to the A&F brand in conjunction with a major marketing campaign. While the campaign generated over 1 billion media impressions, it did not convey separate brand identity to our customer who did not make meaningful impact. Based on our learnings, we understand that we need to sharpen the brand identity, create invitational message and involve the creative. To be clear though, the brand positioning we shared previously remains the same.
The Abercrombie & Fitch brand embodies American casual luxury with an updated attitude that reflects the character, charisma and confidence of today's 20-something consumer. We know and understand that customer and third-party research confirms that more than 80% of U.S. sales come from customers over the age of 18. However, we do need to sharpen how we communicate and express that brand identity. As such, we have engaged an external creative agency and hired a new Chief Marketing Officer, Will Smith, who will help us enhance the power and clarity of our brand identity and strengthen the connections we have with our customers.
We continue to acquire success and learnings from our experience with Hollister to the A&F brand, and we are confident that with the right people and processes now in place, we will see greater traction on our revitalization plan for the brand.
Despite disappointment with the overall results, as we've mentioned, 2016 was a year of significant progress on our strategic priority. We converted 65 additional Hollister stores to the new prototype format during the year and we've been pleased with the positive feedback we consistently received from customers following each and every new store rollout.
Based on our learnings in these prototypes, extensive research and conversations with more than 1.5 million customers, we developed a new prototype concept store for A&F, the first in 15 years and the first of which was unveiled last month. We have been pleased with the initial customer reaction.
Also, after a successful rollout of the Hollister Club Cali loyalty program in the U.S., which now have 5 million members, we are on track to launch the A&F club loyalty program next week.
In addition to providing valuable, timely insights into our customer's preferences, at Hollister, we saw a direct correlation between program membership and stronger customer engagement as evidenced by increased spend per transaction. We are excited to roll out and replicate the success of this program at Abercrombie this year.
We continue to enhance our robust omnichannel capabilities, which our customers are increasingly utilizing. Our POPIN, which our purchase online and pickup in-store, has rolled out across stores in the U.S. and Canada following a successful rollout in the U.K. It accounts for 7% of total DTC orders in a combined markets to which it is available. As we had anticipated, this also drives attachment purchases from picking up in the store. We've also made it possible for customers to cross navigate and transact both the Abercrombie adult and kids brands through a single website.
Following initial success at Hollister, we've added ratings and reviews in social content to all our website resulting in closer customer engagement and valuable feedback. We've also augmented our fulfillment capabilities to the West Coast, we upgraded our apps for loyalty and omnichannel integration for mobile devices, which now accounts for over 40% of online sales. A common theme here is ensuring that we meet our customers’ needs regardless of when, where or how they are looking to purchase.
We further added to our payment capabilities with Recheck pay and Apple Pay and are now leveraging Facebook Messenger as another point of communication with our customer. We continue to work with our key social media partners to help drive innovative customer engagement and ensure we are at the forefront of exploring new ways in which our customers may want to engage with our brand. Hollister was the first retailer to have a sponsored Snapchat lens and both our brands are among a select group to be part of Instagram test of a new e-commerce feature.
In addition, we continue to find new ways to expand our reach in wholesale, franchise and licensing. This year, we doubled our hotel business with the addition of our newest partner, Zalando. And we see further opportunity for future growth, both with existing and new partners. We entered into a franchise partnership in the Middle East but we expect to open 4 stores in each of Qatar and Saudi Arabia in 2017. And our fragrance licensing partner, Inter Parfums, developed and launched 2 new fragrances. First, Instinct by A&F; and Wave by Hollister, which have performed well and are additive to our already successful fragrance business.
We talked about having made progress on our key strategic initiatives in maintaining our focus on executing against them. As we move forward, our success comes down to 3 simple but critical points of focus. First, we must consistently inspire our customers by creating emotional connections through rich brand experiences. We must intimately understand our customers to create these brand experiences wherever, whenever and however they choose to shop and to deliver trend-right, brand right products that never compromises on superior quality, fit or softness.
In order to inspire our customer, we have to know them and there's no substitute for being in stores, in their environment and engaging with them and that's what we have done and continue to do. We know who they are, what they value and aspire to, how they shop and behave and how they feel about the brand.
We'll also continue to improve our research in CRM capabilities, as well as leverage our voice on the customer data, which allows us to continuously receive and respond to customer feedback and measure our performance. This type of insight and feedback is helping us adapt and execute better and faster be it in product design, associate training or store layout.
Second, we must innovate relentlessly. This means we challenge ourselves to improve every day from our style, to our stores, with new retail experiences, to our systems and omnichannel expansion.
This year, we are introducing innovative styles in existing categories. For example, after seeing a strong customer response to the addition of stretch in key Hollister guys’ categories, we recently introduced a new line of advanced stretch jeans for both guys and girls that integrates performance fibers for added comfort. In addition, we are expanding emerging categories, such as swim and Gilly Hicks.
Gilly Hicks was recently relaunched in Hollister stores and online around the world and includes bras, bralettes, swim, lounge and sleepwear. The initial decisions on swimwear and the reintroduction of the Gilly Hicks brands were in direct response to customer insight gleaned from conversations with and the closest to our customer that we value as customer-centric brands.
As I mentioned earlier, we have rolled out our successful new store prototype. This is another example of our focus on innovation, coupled with our focus on inspiring our customers through rich brand experiences.
Our new A&F store prototype here in Columbus at Polaris Fashion Place was imagined with the best customer experience in mind, and formed by research and customer interaction. We put particular emphasis on technology and a sitting room experience with each fitting room suite having thoughtful amenities, such as control over lighting and music. This is the first of 7 new prototypes that we will open this year and we are excited about what this new customer experience will bring to the brand. While the store has only been open a few weeks, we have been encouraged and excited by its early progress.
Lastly, we must develop leaders. Inspiration and innovation require us to attract, retain and develop the best talent. We require leaders that are committed to our vision for the business and can inspire their teams to deliver on that vision with a singular focus and flawless execution.
We have such a team in place now. We also continued to invest in our teams through training and development programs to elevate our service and attract the types of leaders who will thrive in this new environment and have a desire to succeed and realize our objective.
That investment in training is working and in addition to the inherent cost and morale benefit and the lower associate turnover we are experiencing at all levels of our sales organization, it has had a direct and measurable impact on customer engagement and the overall customer experience. We've seen this clearly in our voice of customer data and customer Net Promoter Scores.
On the home office front, we've seen similar improvements in associate engagement and morale.
In addition, our new brand Presidents, Stacia Andersen and Kristin Scott, have made significant changes to their teams with additions in key areas, such as merchandising and planning. We now have the right people in the right places and every one aligned on vision and execution.
We believe we have the right foundations in place to continue to drive forward the Abercrombie brand revitalization and to accelerate our progress with Hollister.
As we look ahead the rest of 2017, it is likely to remain a challenging environment but we are confident that we have taken the right steps to support a strong, standout portfolio of differentiated, aspirational brands and sustainable long-term growth.
I would like to thank all our teams for their continued energy, passion and dedication to moving our brands forward in the coming year.
And with that, I will hand it over to Joanne.