Peter Federico
Analyst · JMP Securities. Please go ahead
Yes. You're 100% right. I mean, obviously, the chart that we show doesn't really have any impact of the GSE's portfolio that was all prior to the Great Financial Crisis in terms of any kind of meaningful impact. But certainly, prior to that, they did have an impact on the overall valuations. And then post Great Financial Crisis, there's no doubt, starting with QE1 in 2008 or '09, whenever it was, the Fed has basically participated in this market for 11 out of 14 years or something like that, whether they're either buying mortgages or reinvesting their paydowns. So they did have an impact, and they are obviously exiting the market. On the flip side of that, you could also conclude that the Agency MBS market is forever foundational to the Fed's monetary policy, right? They're not going to stay out of the market forever, and they clearly care, and you can see that in the words that they communicated even as late as last week, where they are monitoring and paying attention to the functioning of both the U.S. agency and the U.S. treasury market. So they have had an impact. But the flip side is, when you think about the Fed's portfolio running off, it's really critical to think about the environment in which the portfolio is running off. If it's a low rate environment, then it would be much more challenging for Agency MBS because you would be facing the Fed running off its balance sheet and you'll be facing an increasing amount of supply. Frankly, that was the risk that we saw at the beginning of 2022. At mortgage rates at 7.25%, there is effectively almost no supply of mortgages. And even though the Fed is running off, I don't think that, that's going to be a material impact. So you're right that it's a factor and it's something you have to think about. But I don't think the new norm is where we are today. It may be higher than the average, the 80 basis points that I've showed on this one, on this chart. And if you looked at this chart, I call it a sort of forever, the maximum function. If you looked at this chart on Bloomberg, the average would be about 90 basis points since the 80s to now and the range would be 75 to 125 basis points. We may settle out somewhere closer to the high point of the average range of 125, but I don't think we're going to settle out here at 200 basis points. It's just too much absolute return for the same credit. I think you're going to get levered buyers and you're going to get unlevered buyers buying Agency MBS at these levels once market conditions stabilize. I know Chris wants to add something to that.